Always a great experience with them! The food is great, service is wonderful and overall everything is always perfect

I went here after moving into town alittle over 2 months ago, and was looking for a good place to eat since I didn't know what food was good around here. Their food is fresh, cooked amazingly and their curly fries are my personal favorite. Their service when I walked in surprised me at first because they took my order as soon as I walked in and told me how long it would wait and the prices for their food is better then any place around I've seen, the place is clean and kept up it's amazing. read more

Great deals for lunch specials! The two slices of pizza and a drink will fill anyone up -- it's like eating a half of a medium pizza. Solid thin crust pizza. Super friendly staff. read more

Works if you're in a hurry. Nothing exceptional but nothing mediocre. They'll make any sub a grinder, that's a plus. read more

On Tuesday, 11/28, I ordered a pizza from this business. My order was taken, I paid for the delivery, but it never came! I contacted the delivery service, and after two phone calls, I found out that the place was CLOSED! No warning, no one answered the phones! No way to run a business. I even sent them an email to discuss the situation, but as of this writing, I've received no response. A former customer! read more

Was an ok experience. its was uncomfortably hot in the place. I order an cold sub and it was really dry but didn't feel like driving back. hardly any mayo on it and they forgot the oils. I will try the place one more time for pizza but definitely won't eat in the place because of it being so hot read more

Pretty decent American-style pies with fair prices, good service and they'll have your pies ready wicked fast. Their wings are legit freshly deep-fried goodness and the broccoli bacon pizza here is a must-try. Recommended. read more

See all

third time now that the lady at the counter has been beyond rude on the phone seems anytime you ask a question it is a huge inconvenience for her to answer it I understand people are short staffed and frustrated due to covid I myself am a manager at a restaurant and but having this type of customer service is horrible you are willing doing this job but this was the bottom of a box that was thrown into our bag not to mention clearly clarified I would like a wrap it was off the menu & I was given a sub instead normally I'd let this slide but with the horrible service I could not. Such a shame when the food is extremely good .... if you don't like the industry then you should leave .... you make this a horrible place to call because it seems as if people are bothering you I've always tipped well here but this place will now get less of my service unless things change read more

Papa's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Joy, Pennsylvania

See all

Okay. Papa's Pizza doesn't have the best pizza in the area. BUT! They *do* make some pretty damn good wings. My favorite is the sweet chili wings. Today we also tried their Bacon Cheddar Fries and we all enjoyed them. We got our order to-go and the fries were piping hot. One of the nice things about Papa's is that they deliver. Not many (if any) deliver in Mount Joy so it's definitely good to have that option sometimes. On my first visit, the staff was friendly and helpful. The owner (I think it was anyway) knew it was my first time and gave me some suggestions and info. I highly recommend you try their sweet chili wings. Try them on Tuesdays when they're on special. I'm giving 4 stars because of the wings. read more

See all

Today I tried a Steak Sub here, cost about $10, now my favorite for a great and filling steak sub. Ordered by phone and picked up 15 minutes late. Delicious!! read more

Worst pizza i've had in a long time. Sauce had no flavor . it was cheap though . they need to brighten up there pizza I don't recommend this place for pizza. That is all I ordered. read more

Mount Joy is a tiny little town and it literally has a half dozen pizza places. None are terrible, but this one doesn't stand out. My kids love coming here, so I go, but I never go without them. Adequate, inexpensive and fast food - but if you want great pizza - keep driving down the street. read more

I had company last night and raved about the cheese steaks..so we ordered some. I was just praising the flavor And the size. I took mine out of the bag and gave my company the bag with their sandwich in. They said "did you get me a small?" I said they only come in one size. It was at least 4" smaller then mine. If you're giving sandwiches in the same order they should ALL BE THE SAME SIZE. read more

Food was terrific! Had the wings and cheesesteak stromboli. Amazing service and super positive atmosphere! read more

Papa's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Joy, Pennsylvania

I've only had pizza and stromboli from Papa's in the half dozen times I've been there, but it's been great. What I most appreciate is that, unlike other pizza shops in the area, they don't skimp on the toppings. Too many times at other places, you get a pizza that has one or two mushrooms, pepperoni, etc on a slice. With Papa's pizza, you get topping in pretty much every bite! read more

I grew up in NJ where the worst independent pizza you can get is better than most of the stuff you can get out here in Lancaster. After a year of trying all the local places, Papa's delivers! The whole slice was the right combo of crisp and chewy, without any grease leaking thru the crust. Sauce was tasty, cheese tasted good. I was thrilled with the pie we got and will definitely be back for more. The only feedback would be to start accepting chip and Apple Pay because it's way more secure than swiping my card, but I'll pay however they want as long as they keep selling delicious pizza that meets NJ standards. read more

They have THE best French fries I have ever tasted...and believe me I've tasted a lot of fries! They have quick and friendly service. Food was excellent! I look forward to dining there again read more

We had cheese steaks tonight and they tasted good. But they were quite small for the price you pay. I usually can't eat a whole cheesesteak in one seating but this one was no problem. I'll go to the other pizza places in town in the future where you get a comparable tasting steak sandwich which will fill you up and make you feel like you got your moneys worth. read more

Absolutely awesome pizza and customer service . Love it . My new go to pizza in Mount Joy .

I've definitely had better pizza, but not bad considering it was $8.99 for a large cheese pie. The staff is friendly and the service was quick. read more

Papa's Pizza - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Joy, Pennsylvania

Living in Mount Joy, we have our choice of numerous pizza locations but we keep going back to Papa's because their prices and service is second to none. The fact they delievy and are fast is great!! They finally opened up on Sundays so I look forward having them taking care of our wing fix all season read more

Best pizza in the area by far! I have also had their wraps and chicken Caesar salad and they were great as well.

I do not mean to be disrespectful in any manner. However, why would you eat at Papa's Pizza when Two Cousins Pizza is just down the road? I most certainly support Kurt's claim that great pizza is located down the road. read more

The food here is decent, but nothing out of this world. Their wings are the only thing that have stood out to me, they beat two cousins wings easily. Decent pricing. They deliver to homes, and are the only pizza shop located on Mount Joy that does so. The last time I stopped by for a pick up order, the girl behind the counter was extremely cold and rude to me for no appearant reason. Like I had inconvenienced her with my presence. Did not say hello, did not thank me, just stared at me. In the past I've had much better experiences with their customer service, but the rude counter girl left me with a bad taste in my mouth. Will probably not be returning anytime in the near future. read more

I placed an online order for 2 large cheese pizzas to pick up about an hour and a half later. Upon arrival, my order wasn't ready. It was not ready for another 45 minutes. Never in my life lol, and never again. I should've been pushed to the top of the list but I waited there while several other customers, most of them regulars, received their food. read more

I bought a roast beef sub for almost $8 it left me not feeling full and satisfied hardly any meat on the sub if I went to Subway I would have paid $3 for a 6 inch packed with me and veggies won't buy gold sub there again read more

My wife and I have been coming here for three years. We have always enjoyed there food and they have NEVER messed up our order. The staff there are very sweet as well. Papas is the definition of what a pizza shop should look like. read more

I have ordered a pineapple and bacon pizza on two different occasions and have unfortunately run into issues with the business over common sense customer service etiquette. Each time we received a ham/pineapple pizza. The mistake I understand. It happens. On both accounts, however, the representatives of the business complained about having to return the correct pizza to us. On the second occasion instead of trying to accommodate to the customers needs the employee stated "You ordered a pineapple/ham pizza, I remember! If you want your pineapple/bacon pizza you have to come pick it up because I know you didn't order a pineapple/bacon pizza" She voided the credit card transaction. I then thought to myself "Wow! Kids are starting work early these days! Eight years old?" I then realized she wasn't in fact eight. At least I think I'm right about that but perhaps I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt... It is under my belief, and I'm sure to 90% of the populous, that any decent business providing services are to be accommodating and understanding to their customers during mishaps. Right? Papas pizza is a unique business in that they find it a sufficient practice to turn the cheek during moments when they have made a mistake. I'm not one to believe that the customer is always right all the time. It's a collaborative effort and mistakes happen; but you can't tell me it's a worthy business practice when the childlike presence on the phone is getting paid to show off how much they don't really care about you. read more

Gregory, Kurt and josh...you obviously don't know a good pizza place! Papas is wonderful, and my personal favorite in Mount Joy! We dine in and order out, every time meals are dead on and service is great! Pizza is awesome, Papa's has been a family favorite for years. Broccoli cheese bites are great, just ordered them tonight with a party pizza, which for the size is a great price. I'll always recommend it! read more

Pretty dang good pizza.. have had better, but can't complain. Wings were delicious, but seemed a bit overdone and quite small. Prices are reasonable. Best thing is it's within walking distance to my house. Had some issues with the online ordering, but it worked out. read more

I was pleasantly surprised with the pizza quality at this place (ordered a Margarita Pizza). The staff was also extremely nice. Will be going back again. read more

We order Papa's Pizza a couple of Thursdays a month. Their pizza is awesome. Today was my boyfriend's birthday and I requested for them to make the pizza in a heart shape half pepperoni half cheese. They said yes without hesitation. They are amazing, their employees are so friendly, and best of all their deliveries are super fast! One time I ordered pizza and it was at my door in less than 15 minutes! Keep up the great work at Papa's! We will keep comin' back! read more

I grew up in Philly, New York and I have never had better Pizza that at Papa's pizza. Great prices great food and outstanding service. If you get it delivered service is outstanding all the time. read more

I have been going here for months and always had a good experience...today I tried to call in and order a pizza. The young girl who answered the phone was rude ... Extremely rude !!!!! She put me on hold, then came back on the phone, started to take my order, then interrupted me for my phone number.. Then started over again to take my order, and interrupted again.. Then she asked me what I wanted...so I asked her if she was ready to take my order this time,,, next thing she hunga up on me...like her rudeness was my fault...Well news flash Papas Pizza, you just lost a very good loyal customer...as long as that rude young lady is waiting on customers, I will NEVER order anything in your Pizza Place.. In fact I will let Everyone I know how my experience was. I will go order a pizza at some other place read more