We had the all meat Stromboli and it's one of the best I've ever had. Their tomato sauce that they give you with the Stromboli is very good. Highly recommend this place. read more

The food is consistently delicious, service is spot on. Ambiance... like stepping into a true Italian pizza shop! It's where all the locals gos read more

Good food. Didn't take long and clean restaurant. It isn't far from town. It is next to the ice cream parlor.

Both of my daughters have a gluten allergy we tried their pizza and it was amazing,they have the best in the area!!

SHOCK! We stumbled upon this place after doing the train nearby and we were HUNGRY. At first look at the menu, we were surprised at how inexpensive the prices were - we actually did a double-take. And inside is real mom and pop, nothing fancy. My friend is visiting from Ireland, and he was craving real American style pizza. I told him I'd split whatever he wanted to order and so he went for a medium pizza with mushrooms and onions. The crust was amazing - fluffy and a bit sweet. I like it cheesy, and the right amount of cheese was on it for me. The only minor disappointment was that it didn't look like the mushrooms were fresh, maybe canned? Other than that, we shoved in as much as our stomachs could possibly hold - for him, that was three giant slices and for me, two. We just loved it. read more

Pizza City - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Great pizza and incredible prices. Steak and cheese sandwich was really good as well! Highly recommend if looking for pizza, subs and a beer. Very informal. read more

The owner is excellent. His outstanding customer service, and the way he handles his customer. The food tastes excellent, and the prices are such that he's not greedy. read more

We were at Cherry Crest and stumbled upon this in need of quick dinner. Local place. Great customer service. Pizza as great!

Pizza and wings were NOT good. Pizza was sub-par. Bone in wings are tiny and looked like chicken nuggets. Couldn't even tell which part I was eating. Wings had no sauce or flavor. I didn't even finish them. No idea how this place has 4 stars. read more

Pizza City - Mild Bone-in Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

This is an average family run friendly pizza place in the charming town of Strasburg, PA. Despite other reviews claiming it was NY style, I found the crust to be more similar to Pennsylvania -Marlyland styles, not long and thin crust like New York pies. It is greasy with good cheese but the NY comparison ends there. The sauce cheese combo is above average and better than chain delivery pizza. The avg crust and toppings hold it back though from being more than average vs other mid Atlantic Italian family run pizza shops. The menus are paper photocopies. Parking consists of 3 angled spots in front with others nearby. You order at a counter. read more

See all

We were in town for a show at Sight & Sound with a gaggle (the official term for "lots") of children and teens; after the show, despite gorging ourselves on roasted almonds, pretzels, and nachos at the theater, everybody was getting hangry. I thought we could drive the 1 1/2 hour trip home and then eat, but my wife and family informed me that I was dead wrong. To my surprise, just a few miles up the road on Main St was Pizza City and they were so hospitable and more than willing to provide my family with the sustenance we needed to survive the rest of our journey. Okay, I'm being sarcastic and salty about how hungry everyone was, but I'm very genuinely grateful for the food and hospitality! This place seems like a local favorite as I watched the lone chef, manager, cashier, (probably owner) greet numerous customers by name and remember their orders or suggest something they'd like based on previous orders. That's impressive! We ordered a couple large pizzas and he suggested we consider the Sicilian style which offers more bang for the buck. Each pizza was huge, very delicious, and very reasonably priced. For our group of 12, we ordered two pizzas, some fries and mozzarella sticks and we ended up taking home a whole leftover pizza. We ate and enjoyed for a fraction of the price I've previously payed at other establishments when we had more time to kill. Now I know the smorgasbords and family restaurants are the thing to do when you visit Lancaster, but if you want to really be treated like family, stop by this pizza joint and enjoy! (Sorry no pics this time. I had my hands full!) read more

Really like their pizza. Thin, crispy, and nice cheese mixture. Yelp said I need more characters.

Wonderful service, pizza was fabulous and the prices are amazing. First time visitor but I would not hesitate to go back. You will not be disapointed With their pizza. read more

Pizza was good, but i've had better. Service was also good. Food was not to my liking, but the crust was yummy and veggies seemed tasty.

Very courteous to customers and great value. Highly recommended if you are looking for a place to eat near Sight and Sound

Food is awesome. Cheeseburgers, cheesesteaks, pizza and fries were perfect. Just a perfect little no frills pizza and sandwich shop.

just went there for the first time. the pizza is great, and I'm from Boston, and am use to thin crust

Pizza was really really great! To me it was New York style with a crispy outside texture that was delicious. We picked it up and when we did the gentlemen there were so kind and helpful! read more

Gotta say I'm picky and if this pizza city wasn't delicious I would never gave it 5 stars but I did so to me I was impressed.. first I live in new York home of the greatest pizza places in the world but I gotta say I loved pizza city just as much as my favorites .OK now walking into the place it's clean clean clean I like that we ordered a special pie which was loaded with tons of meats the medium pie was enough for 3 or 4 people I'm stuffed on 2 slices and all those toppings worked together the pie was cooked to perfection and the sauce was amazing so if your on yelp and want a real delicious and clean spot definitely go there! there were two guys working there who were both really friendly also so in closing this new yorker gives pizza city two thumbs up thanks guys!! read more

Pizza City - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Real NY Pizza. If you're looking for a low key pizza and sandwich place this is it. Locals come here because it's inexpensive and the food is good. Best pizza I've had in ages. Authentic New York taste. read more

Another visit to Pizza City! I try to come here whenever I am in the Lancaster area. The pizza was hot, ready on time for takeout and so damn good. I'm a fan of simple. Extra cheese or pepperoni. Both are very good. The crust is airy and substantial, but not too thick. The sauce...it's New York through and through. Tangy and zesty with a hint of sweet. The cheese...I could eat just the cheese and be happy. While there are better pizzas in the world, I am confident this is the best pizza you'll find in this part of PA. read more

I purchased a 14 inch pizza today. It was very good. The pizzeria reminds me of the show Cheers, everyone knew each others name.The person who made the pizza was a nice person. I recommend this restaurant and calling the order in. Not many parking spots. read more

This is a decent restaurant with very good prices! It's definitely high on the value scale. The staff were very friendly and polite, which I really appreciated. :) My husband and I both ordered subs, which we weren't crazy about, but judging from the other reviews, maybe we should have gone with the pizza. I'd be willing to come back to try the pizza, but this wouldn't be my go-to place for subs. My other problem with the visit was the bathrooms. :/ My bathroom was out of paper towels, and my husband said there was no soap in the men's bathroom. That kind of inconvenience is always a let-down at any business - someone should be checking in on that. The upsides of this place are: friendly staff, great prices, quick service (you order at the counter), and you can buy beer to take home, if you want. read more

Pizza City - Turkey sub - strange presentation - Pizza Near Me - Strasburg, Pennsylvania

Pizza was super greasy and made my wife sick. Do not recommend. Order was completed in a timely manner and was reasonably priced.

This is my favorite pizza shop around!! The owner is hilarious he always tells a joke when my friends and I come in, and the. Pizza is out of this world!!! I would highly recommend this place if you are looking for a good new your slice of pizza this is the place to go!! The service is quick and the environment is awesome, the prices are good and I bet you you will come out if the shop satisfied and full,! They do offer take out and it is not extra so if you want to eat out home or your hotel go for it! read more

Great pepperoni pizza! It has the right amount of cheese and sauce, the crust is just right, and the pepperoni has the perfect zip. We have also ordered the chicken parmigiana platter and it was very good as well. Nice portion of chicken with pasta and a salad. read more

This is our first visit to Pizza City, thought we've driven by several times before. Today, we were in the mood for something different...and, that's just what we got. From the humorous greeting by the counter guy to the quality of the food. Very impressive. The neat thing was that the rest of the clients were very low-key. So, while they asked intelligent questions about my service dog, the folks were also respectful enough not to distract her from her job. As we got ready to leave, we were presented with a couple pieces of lunch meat and cheese...so that the service dog may enoy a snack, too. This is a definite, "We'll be coming back to this place in the near future." read more

This was our first time to the Lancaster area. We saw some reviews and sounded good to go. We were not disappointed. The staff was very friendly, the salad was fresh, and pep pie was cooked to perfection. My boy is a tough critic. He had a 2 thumbs up appoval, not to mention the price was better than what I am used to coming from NH. If I make my way back near by, I will make this a mandatory stop. read more

Stopped by here for lunch after the railroad meusum. Pizza was good and the staggering was helpful. I would return if ever in the area again read more

The absolute best pizza outside of NYC. It is exactly the same each time we come here and it's always fabulous. It's a real gem.

Very simply, if you live within 100 miles of Strasburg, PA you have the best NY pizza in your backyard. It's worth the drive and worth fasting before you arrive. The pizza is ridiculously good and you'll be able to snub your nose at your NY friends who swear you've lost your mind! I remember coming to Pizza City as a teenager since my grandparents lived down the street. Ever since then, regardless of where I lived, I made the pilgrimage to Pizza City where the family-owned business always knew me. Even though the owner just passed last year, the family has not changed the recipe. read more

While I am loathe to badmouth a small locally-owned business I feel the need to weigh in because of the 5-star reviews. We ordered the house Special and found it to be nearly tasteless aside from the ultra-thin coldcut-type meats. No flavor from the thin, dry crust, sauce or cheese. I requested extra sauce to dip my slice in and, while it was provided at no additional charge by one of the friendly employees, it was chilled and extremely bland, surely from a can. The restaurant was doing a fairly brisk Sunday lunch business, was clean and comfortable and the staff were very pleasant and efficient but we won't be back. My advice: try a slice before ordering a whole pie. read more

Lancaster is not a particularly good pizza town. To me, it's kind of ponderous. Proximity to NY, plenty of New Yorkers moving here, and a bustling food scene should mean there's some great spots. Sadly, that's not the reality. Pizza City is one of the three we return to. (The others are Espinos and Luca.) Pizza City is consistently good, the guy cares about serving up a nice pie, it's very inexpensive, and I'm 8 for 8 on having a solid experience. For a neighborhood pizza shop, what more can you ask for? read more

Terrible customer service experience today..... Been a LONG LONG time customer for years. But after being talked to the way I was today. You lost not only me but my wife and my family's business for life. Was not ok to yell at me and have a bad attitude when I asked how much sodas were and I didn't hear you the 2 times you said it. He sounded muffled and sounded like 2 for 2.50 but it was actually 2.50 EACH. Which it was ok that's fine but why the attitude. Not the first time he's nasty and it will be the last. I guarantee we won't be back. So disappointing. read more

Stopped in at lunchtime while visiting the railroad museum. My two slices and a local beer were good value for money,

Price is right at this place. Plenty of food for a reasonable price. The service is very friendly. The pizza is good, but not great. The crust is very doughy and I prefer crispy. read more

This pizza is the real deal. My family and I were running around Lancaster County and just needed a quick bite and WOW, for a little pizzeria in a little town, it was true NY style, on par with Rays on Prince street (not kidding!). Don't overlook. read more

I am giving this place a three star because the food is very good. The pizza is decent, but I had a calzone the one day that was really really good. Also the woman with the black hair there is really nice and friendly. But ugh the guy behind the counter. I was trying to pay and he was so rude to me. I honestly didn't know whether to leave or what to do. It was so awkward and I was warned by where I was staying not to go there because of the poor customer service. But the day before same guy, very friendly,next day beyond rude. He said he didn't want to touch money wearing gloves? Well just say that right away. The guy the day before took my money with gloves and went straight to touching food. (not saying that is right, but he acted like they never do that) Customer service is obviously not a big priority there and it really put a damper on my trip. read more

Ordered 2 takeout pizzas for guests recently. One of the guests found a meal worm in a slice of his pizza. Yucky. We didnt finish eating! read more

Worst customer service EVER! The owner is extremely rude and two of three of subs ordered tonight are wrong. Every time I order there seems to be an issue. This is definitely the last time ordering from Pizza City. read more