Two Cousins Pizza Paradise

We had a good experience here! The food was very good and better quality than your typical buffet…read more We made reservations on resy which also noted a $10 per person fee if you cancel your reservation within a few hours. The price was $31.99pp but the cost of drinks was not included. Soft drinks were an additional $3.99pp. Overall if you're looking for Lancaster fare this place would be good to check out.

Tried this place after we tried Shady Maple because people had said it was much better-…read moreIt was not better perhaps even worse. Staff is rude Never received a refill of my soft drink Food beyond horrible- No seasoning Mashed potatoes had raw chunks of potatoes Fried chicken dry and tasteless Roast beef at the carving station on temp well done- No bowls at the soup station Save your money!!

Yummmmm 10/2/21

See all

Anna's Chicken and Waffles and a Beer.

Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm

3.4(245 reviews)

2.1 mi

Locally owned & operated

Free parking

We came out after a show at Sight and Sound theater which was awesome btw…read more A hungry bunch of ten people. Most of us ordered the make your own platter including the beef brisket. I personally ordered the beef brisket, the fried chicken with a side of Mac and cheese and seasonal vegetables. First the good, the fried chicken was fried perfectly with a nice crispy and so moist. The best part of the meal. The sides were good with a cheesy Mac and cheese. I was disappointed with the brisket. Although it had good flavor, it was super dry and those who ordered the brisket at our table agreed. We also ordered the whoopie pies which were disappointing as well. Would I come back...yes but would not order the brisket or dessert.

First time At the Smokehouse BBQ & Brew…read more We had the corn bread and burnt tips for appetizers hubby had the pulled pork and chicken and I had the SCHNITZEL AND SPAETZLE for dinner. The Burnt ends appetizer was the best I have ever had. The meat was super tender and the white horseradish was so good on it we bought 12oz to take home. Honestly that could have been my dinner it was that good. The pulled pork was good it passed my husband's test since he's from NC and still looking for one like home. The spaetzle was amazing, and as good as my mother in law made. Well better. And she's German. Such a great find. It will be on our list every-time we come back to Lancaster.

Steak with Mashed Potatoes & Veggie.

Hot Honey Grilled Salmon with Aparagus.

See all

Smoked Half Chicken

Strasburg Pizza

3.9(51 reviews)

2.9 mi

Ordered a large (16") mushroom and onion pizza, and I enjoyed it. My first time getting a pie from…read morehere and next time I'll ask for it to be cooked a bit more. It's not a thin crust, but seems the fermentation of the dough is long enough for a nice subtle taste. I did my fermentation for at least 36 hrs sometimes 72 hrs when making pizza dough. The sauce had nice balance of sweet to acidic. The low-moisture mozzarella could use a bit more pull (quality) but had enough flavor. Overall a good pizza, it will satisfy the craving.

Awesome food, great prices and the owners and staff are so very friendly!!!…read more They also give our Strasburg Senior Citizens group a 10% discount whenever we eat there!! :)

The pizza box

Thin crust medium size pepperoni pizza

See all

Fireside Tavern

3.8(329 reviews)

2.9 mi

My mom and I were driving to our hotel when we passed through Ronks and were trying to find a spot…read morefor dinner - I literally typed into Apple Maps "American dinner" because we were just feeling good quality American food and this place popped up! I am so unbelievably glad we stopped here because it was one of the most impressive and tasty dinners I've had in a long time! Their menu isn't super extensive but they do have rotating specials of drinks, dinner, and dessert. I went with the pork chops which came with their seasonal starch and vegetable which was potatoes and zucchini. The pork chop was super flavorful and cooked to perfection. The bacon jam had a sweet and salty vibe which only added to the flavor of the dish. I ordered a ginger and pear mocktail - refreshing. Their drinks looked amazing but I refrained from alcohol for the night , but they were definitely tempting. My mom loved her apricot salmon and had the same sides. Bread and salad a soup are all à la carte add ons. The roll was nice and fresh tasting and my mom had the tomato bisque which she loved and honestly smelled so good! It was covered in melted cheese - yum! We got dessert because of course we had to- all made in house and gluten free. I got the creme brûlée which was hands down the best creme brûlée I've ever had. You could see the vanilla bean flecks and it had a hint of saltiness which balanced out the creamy texture and sweetness nicely. My mom got the carrot cake which was multi layered and came with candied walnuts and caramel sauce. Our waiter was so unbelievably kind and attentive and personable. The restaurant had what appeared to be 3 main rooms. The bar looked gorgeous, we sat in one of the dining rooms which was simply decorated and a bit moody. The building itself is cool and they also had a nice outside area with beautiful twinkle lights. I'm so glad we randomly stumbled upon this restaurant and when we go back to Lancaster we'll definitely be back - prices were pretty fair! Overall, don't sleep on this!

Holy smokes Fireside Tavern, you hit it out of the park! For anyone who have kids and is gluten…read morefree, this place is fantastic! Upon entering we saw a table of books, crayons and drawing paper for the kiddos. We even got goldfish with our kids menus! What a dream for any parent having to bring our little rascals along to steal our food and complain about it too! Our server was absolutely wonderful even when dealing with our 2 unruly kids and a crying baby. Sorry about that. We were a party of 7 on a Saturday at 5pm. The menu looked wonderful with a ton of great options and our food came out so fast too, which is great when you have kids. We shared the poutine, which had a lot of tender meat, perfectly cooked crispy fries and a tangy and warm gravy. I would have liked more cheese, but I'm not complaining that much. I got the shrimp tacos, my kids got the kids cheese burgers, my wife got the crab cake sandwich and my friends got the onion soup, salad with steak and linguine with clams. For dessert, we shared the trio, carrot cake, mousse cake and crème brûlée. Everything was FANTASTIC! Fresh, perfect portions and absolutely delicious. I would come back here a million times. Bravo!

Cozy bar fireplace

Pork Belly Grilled Cheese

See all

Lavender Lemonade

Panera Bread

2.7(59 reviews)

3.6 mi

We don't usually go to Panera Bread unless we have a gift card due to its price. Mac and cheese…read morewas over $7. Food was fresh though. Place was clean with enough AC for the hot summer.

Out of hot Italian sandwiches. Out of Chicken with rice...Out of napkins. 37 minutes to get order…read more Bus pan area overflowing with dishes. A b l t was very good.

Hearty Fireside Chili & Rustic Baked Potato Soup

Kickin' Grilled Cheese & Creamy Tomato Soup Value Duet

See all

New Sandwiches

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

2.9(104 reviews)

3.4 mi

This was my first time ever having dinner at Olive Garden. It was good but could have been better …read more My chicken parmigiana was decent but the pasta sauce was very bland and needed help . My boyfriend had spaghetti with grilled chicken and it was pretty tasty. He loved his Pasta Fagiole and my Zuppa Toscana was very good . My only complaint..... we had to wait for breadsticks which were supposed to be unlimited yet , they had none ready. I asked for red pepper for my sauce ( hoping to help the blandness) but it took quite awhile for it to materialize as did the cheese grater which seemed to be the only one in the restaurant . All in all it wasn't a bad meal and we'll definitely give it another chance. Note: The manager stopped at every table to check in with diners and ask about service and dining experience. That doesn't happen at many restaurants so kudos to Olive Garden !

DISAPPOINTING !!! We ordered the HOUSE salads. When served in the restaurant, it came in a big…read morewooden bowl, and it was absolutely delicious. This was old, wilted had absolutely no flavor and was very light on the tomato, carrots and other components of the salad. The iceberg lettuce was tasteless. The pepperoncini peppers were not even cut up. The stuffed Marsala chicken was Only OK...... it was kind of dry. Could've used some more flavor. The breadsticks also were tasteless. This was very disappointing, and we will not go back!!!!

Fettuccine Alfredo: Our signature alfredo made fresh in-house every day, served over fettuccine.

Minestrone: Fresh vegetables, beans and pasta in a light tomato broth.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

See all

Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

Stoltzfus Meats

4.5(141 reviews)

2.2 mi

We stopped by for a breakfast before leaving town. We had 1/2 order of sausage gravy and a veggie…read moreomelet and biscuit and we tried scrapple for the first time. The sausage gravy was delicious and full of sausage. The omelet was also very good with a grilled biscuit. The scrapple was good and people around us said to try with syrup or ketchup but we had plain. It was a bit greasy but had a sausage flavor. There's plenty of seating and they bring the food to your table after you order at the counter. We shopped in the market after breakfast for some Lebanon bologna, sourdough bread, fudge and pumpkin whoopie pies to take to family. We would definitely return when in the area again.

This review is based off the pre-prepared/grocery side of the store (although we will CERTAINLY be…read moreback for the restaurant side.) While in town, we wandered in wishing we had already grabbed some baked goods earlier in the day. And with a mission to acquire some meat for the grill later in the day. Immediately we were met with a variety of whoopie pies (we got a traditional one and cookie one, both delicious), and most of all the BEST cinnamon roll we have ever feasted on. Not only was it tremendous but it was perfectly gooey, and the buttercream (or at least that's how it tasted) frosting in lieu of traditional icing blew it out of the water. We also grabbed some chicken bacon burgers which we grilled up and really enjoyed. Just wished the patties were initially bigger. We ended up putting 2 and 2 (out of the 4) together to make burgers which would actually survive the grill. In general the selection is everything you'd imagine in Amish country combined into one little place. Prices were excellent, quality was great. Definitely stop in!

To go and condiments area

Cheesesteak with sauce and side of coleslaw.

See all

Pizza City

4.0(72 reviews)

3.2 mi

We had the all meat Stromboli and it's one of the best I've ever had. Their tomato sauce that they…read moregive you with the Stromboli is very good. Highly recommend this place.

The food is consistently delicious, service is spot on. Ambiance... like stepping into a true…read moreItalian pizza shop! It's where all the locals gos

Chicken parmigiana sub

Inside Seating

See all

Order at the counter

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Danielle K.

29

2

0

12 years ago

This place was near our hotel and we wanted pizza! We ordered carry out and had a hungry toddler with us. The owner brought her food out (that we didn't order or pay for) to make our short wait easier. We ordered salad pizza and garlic knots. The hostess brought our older daughter crayons and paper. Our food was amazing!! But the hospitality that we were given was even better! Great prices too!! read more

Kyle S.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Staying at Hotel near Lancaster and found their menu Very friendly on phone, fast delivery and pizza tastes amazing! Right amount of sauce good amount of cheese the perfect mix Keep up good work! read more

Eric P.

0

1

0

12 years ago

Stopped in based on a recommendation. So glad I did! Great pizza and very friendly service--like they want you to be satisfied. Will definitely be back. read more

Kelly A.

25

9

3

8 years ago

Food was good, employees were very pleasant also helpful, and for a party of 7 our food came out very quick

Brandon B.

70

20

0

4 years ago

Some of the best pizza around great place great food great people always friendly and always great food

Shawn F.

43

2

0

4 years ago

We order pizza last night it was great will be eating there again. Nice people great Customer service

Mark S.

0

8

0

11 years ago

Food is great and the bread is fantastic. We crave it weekly!!

Two Cousins Pizza Paradise - italian - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Two Cousins Pizza Paradise also viewed

Capricio's

4.4

(118 reviews)

Great costumer service! Wonderful family friendly atmosphere. Owner and wife kept coming over to…read moreask how the meal was and how they could serve us better. Food was amazing. My husband and I had the manicotti and the chicken ziti. Portion size is larger than I thought and the prices are reasonable. Our meals also included a house salad and garlic knots. Everything was made quick, fresh ,and tasted wonderful. Overall my husband and I walked out paying $26. You really can't beat the price. Highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.

We were visiting from out of town and came here for some pizza and salad. Our hotel was close, the…read moreratings were high so we figured this would be a great place to go for some pizza. The slices they had out looked terrible and I should have walked away at that point. I ordered a margarita pie and my wife got a salad. She said her salad was disgusting and she hardly ate it. I wasn't impressed with the pizza either. The sauce was very plain. There was barely any cheese and the crust was a little too floppy for my liking.

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

4.1

(150 reviews)

The pizza and salad were delicious…read more We had the American Antipasto salad w/ balsamic vinaigrette. It was loaded with meat and cheese. Then we had a medium Brooklyn Full House (no mushrooms or extra cheese). We both agreed it was some of the best sausage we've had on pizza. One salad and medium pizza was plenty for the two of us. Servers were polite and had everything ready pretty quickly. We arrived around 530 pm on a Wednesday night. Plenty of seating inside. Plenty of parking as well. We would go back in a heartbeat!

Food was very good we are impressed. I got the large chicken vodka pizza and some fries for about…read more$30, it was a good quantity so I'd say it was worth it. The parking lot is very small for this location and the store is consistently crowded so be prepared to wait over an hour for one pie but other than that great experience.

Bacio Pizza

3.8

(24 reviews)

5 stars is on the cheese pizza I received on a delivery to my hotel. I don't know anything about…read morethe place. I asked desk clerk who delivers the best pizza he told me Bacio. So be it. Didn't expect much but this pizza was absolutely delicious! Crust crispy , cheese was perfect but the sauce was the bomb !

It's a nice little clean spot. I was there around lunch time last week. The counter lady was…read morefantastic doing just about everything. I ordered a meat lovers Stromboli. I eliminated a couple of meats and subbed steak sandwich meat. It was absolutely delicious. The sauce was on the side the way I enjoy it. Once again it was fantastic.

Pasquale's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.0

(284 reviews)

Gave this place another chance after a while…read more Allergen info: they do offer GF crust and dairy free cheese Food- pizza has been solid the 2 recent times we have gotten it. Love the old world pepperoni option. Offer all the regular toppings. Lancaster doesn't have many good pizza options and I'd say this is one of the better ones

I only get subs here. They are packed with meat and cheese. I also only get the Italian. The…read morerolls are firm on the outside and very moist and soft inside. I believe a half sub can be eaten by 2 people. Although you can eat inside the Italian restaurant and they have unbelievable deals, we just get the sub to go. The owner is always friendly and engages in a chat everytime. Pasquale's I will Be Back

Today's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.7

(70 reviews)

We were wanting pizza but wanted it delivered, so we remembered a menu we had gotten in the mail…read more Delivery for $30 order. Easy! We ordered a med cheese calzone, a med NY Style cheese pizza, and a tour of italy including soup and garlic bread. We ordered that for tomorrow night. Such a friendly staffer took our order and delivered it! The portions are huge! The taste is very good, worth the price to get delivery. We have enough for 3 meals I'm sure! The only hiccup is the tour of italy was missing the lasagna. It only had spaghetti and stuffed shells. We are very happy with our decision to stay in and let fresh made Italian food be delivered to our door!

Very good cheese steak! Bun was exceptionally fresh and hard outside soft inside. Very juicy and…read moretasty! Want Angelo's in Philly but i liked!

Rosa Rosa Pizzeria

3.8

(109 reviews)

Great place with Great pizza! We came for the pizza and we ordered a Medium Sausage Pizza. The…read morepizza came out perfectly cooked. The sausage had just the right amount of spice and the right amount of sauce. The size was perfect for the two of us. You order and pay at the counter and then wait for deliciousness. The location is clean and the staff is friendly. There might be a spaghetti pizza in my future.

We saw a reel about this bomber pizza on Instagram and tucked it away in our brains for the next…read moretime we were in the Lancaster area (we live in Pittsburgh) The restaurant itself is fairly rundown and old, but it seemed to be a popular place (more especially for college students). It is counter service with a variety of prepared foods ready to go for a slice or a pasta dish. We got the Lancaster bomber pizza which is half pizza and half Philly cheesesteak. The pizza side is pepperoni and sausage and the Stromboli side is steak and cheese. While it was a fun concept to try, it wasn't "knock your socks off good" haha! But for sure unique. We had plenty of leftovers and finished them up in our hotel that night. Worth a try if you like an interesting take on pizza!

Sam’s Pizza

3.3

(60 reviews)

Oh Sam's, I absolutely hate giving a bad review, but I also don't appreciate biting into food that…read moredeserves to go straight into the trash. I'll start off by saying that the service was great. We were greeted and served by a very nice young person who was super friendly throughout our meal, even when my kids were being total douche bags. Thankfully there was only 1 other table when we arrived around noon on a Friday and they seemed very pleased with their experience. Anyway, first weird thing is that when we arrived I had 2 water bottles, one for me and one for my kid. We were told that we were not allowed to put the adult bottle on the table. I understand restaurants not wanting people bringing in food or drinks, but we would have only gotten water regardless of your rule, so it seems a bit silly to not allow a water bottle on the table. So I put it on the bench and drank it anyway. On to the food. My wife got a turkey sub which was described as "slightly worse than something I could have made myself with packaged deli turkey." One of my kids got a slice of pizza, which she said was good, though it was very very light on the cheese. Other kid got a hotdog, which he loved. Good job on that. My salad was the avocado bacon salad with grilled chicken. I watched a "chef" microwave the bacon, which was hot but dripping in oil, not crispy or fully browned in the slightest. The chicken was cold in the middle and based on the taste and texture seemed like it was precooked, frozen and then heated. The avocado was surprisingly the worst offender. Though it was a PERFECT color with no visible imperfections, it was very cold and tasted sour, which leads me to assume it was frozen and defrosted. I don't know and I don't want to know, but I had to spit it out and could not finish even 1/3 of the meal after taking that bite of what I can only describe as an expired avocado pickle slice. I asked our server to remove it from the bill which was done with no questions asked. Other than that, the place was clean and seemed nice despite the food. I would not return here.

Sat outside in their small outdoor area. We ordered our "go-to" Sam's meal-Cesar Salad and large…read moreBuffalo chicken cheesesteak accompanied by an ice cold draft. What do we love about Sam's-house made rolls for the sandwiches, dressing on the side for the salads, ample portions, and really nice servers who aim to please. If you've worked up an appetite riding or walking on the Enola Rail Trail, stop into Sam's afterwards.

Pizzeria 211

4.3

(58 reviews)

Great pizza but the fact you can't buy a slice after 3pm is ridiculous. They really need to change…read morethis rule. Especially for people walking by that just want to stop in and try a slice and not have to wait 30 minutes for a whole pizza. And the prices are way too high. I understand it's quality food, but $21 for a cheese steak with no sides is insanity. With the prices of everything in life up so high, you can't get relief anywhere, especially places with decent food.

High quality ingredients come with a higher price tag! That is the case for Pizzeria 211. Very good…read morepizza with locally sourced higher quality ingredients. In today's world, unfortunately that means its a 23 dollar pizza. I have heard amazing things about the detroit style, I would like to get this next time. This time though I got a regular cheese pizza. Nice crisper bottom, thinner crust, savory sauce and a decent size that is comparable to a large at other establishments. The guys running the show were friendly and the pizza took about 25 minutes to get done. I was in and out when it was time to pick up! Great staff.

Wrightsville Pizza & Family Restaurant

3.5

(19 reviews)

Returned to our old haunts and ordered. a long time favorite: "ham boats" plus a margarita pizza…read more Ham boats were delicious... a simple sub sandwich (see my photo) with ham & cheese, and a few "Fixin's, slightly toasted....yum. Pizza was just OK. Crust was crispy but really lacked any distinctive flavor....sauce was same. Toppings were fair. (You can kinda "see" what I mean in my photo). Filling. Next time will probably just stick to the ham boats... Always a winner.

service amazing food awsome wouls never go anywere elsee' i got alfredo the portion sizes cheap and…read morebig

Finazzo's Italian Restaurant & Pizzaria

3.2

(33 reviews)