Passing through town, picked this place relatively randomly. Pizza was awesome, very light and fresh. Clearly fresh cut toppings. Service was great, nice quiet place, must stop! Wheelchair accessible, thank you read more

I'd give it 3.5 stars Pretty good if looking for NY style pizza Would come back again read more

Best Pizza in Lancaster PA. I had square pizza pie and round pizza pie so good. Owner and workers very friendly and very helpful. Restaurant is beautiful in side. I'll always eat here! read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

1st time here. Had the cheese steak with lettuce & tomatoes. It was great just the way I like it, but had to stop eating before I ate it all cuz it was so good. LAM had spaghetti and meatballs, served with a side salad and a whole loaf of garlic bread. She said it was all very good , noodles done right and not overcooked. Lettuce for salad was kinda clunky and hard to eat. Owner and server were great. A lovely experience. read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Spaghetti & meatballs, salad & a whole loaf of bread. - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

See all

Friendly staff, excellent service, large portions, delicious food, and extremely reasonable prices! read more

See all

Came here on a Friday around 12:45pm. Got the stuffed pepperoni and sausage pizza. I liked how the pizza wasn't too heavy. I wished they gave me a side of sauce for the said pizza but it was still very good and the service was excellent. read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Stuffed pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

My personal favorite pizza in Ephrata. Sauce is delicious. The sandwhichs are also super fresh and full of ingredients.

Despite the fan fare from some friends, this was just another pizza joint. You can do worse for sure and maybe it was an off night. Nicely put together restaurant, but the food was pretty meh. read more

Their pita pizza is amazing!!! And they aren't on the menu but the honey mustard wings are so delicious!! The buffalo chicken salad portions are so large! I definitely have to take half of it home! Great place to eat! read more

No negative reviews during this difficult time for the restaurant industry. We need to rally and do everything we can to support small business! Please be kind and don't forget to tip generously! The staff was super friendly! And the subs were great! read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was absolutely amazing! We had the stuffed cheesesteak pizza and loaded fries. We can't wait to go back and try more things.

Decor/service: we have only ordered to go from here but the dining area is small and the service is usually pretty quick. About 20 minutes from order to pick up time on average 4/5 Food: Pizza- the pizza is what brings most people in. The sauce is delicious and they put just enough on. The crust has a nice crisp but isn't burnt. It lacks a wow factor but overall it's good solid pizza that beats most of the area's basic pizza places 4/5 Wings- the wings were also very good. Cooked well and had plenty of meat on them. The mold have a little bit of a kick so I'd avoid if you can't handle any spice. 4/5 Corn nuggets- classic central pa staple done right. They were cooked well and not over cooked which seems to be an issue for most places. 5/5 Overall: solid pizza place with a different tasting pizza then the standard which most of the local places have. 4/5 read more

Was so hungry for pizza and there are so many options. Have never had Little Nicki's pizza yet so decided to try it. I saw that they have this "stuffed spaghetti & meatball pizza" which pretty much sold me in the name to order it however I was trying to be 'healthier' and just order it not stuffed which is also an option on the menu. I asked the worker what that will consist of and it sounded good so I went with it. While in the picture I attached to this updated review doesn't 'look' good I promise you it tasted delicious. It doesn't beat my favorite spaghetti pie pizza at Rosa Rosa's in Lancaster BUT taste-wise it was very close. The cheese + pasta + meatballs are just a combination you cannot pass up on top of a crispy crust. Will be ordering that again in the future! read more

See all

Absolutely the worst service I ever encountered, two teenagers girls that had no clue how to work the counter or the register. TOLD ME to grab my order off the counter, "only order on the counter" then had an emergency encounter where I could look at the order right away. When I opened my order it was the WRONG order!! Then when I called to come back to get the right order I was told "there was nothing to be done." Mind you I come here often absolutely will never be coming back here after the SECOND TIME of receiving the wrong order. read more

Now I'm from California visiting family and while taking a walk I happened upon Little Nicki's, I ordered a Italian grinder and while waiting I had a slice of cheese pizza. The value of both the slice and Grindr blew me away. The flavor of the grinder was off the hook. My slice of cheese was an appetizer as I walked about two miles home with my grinder whilst chowin down my slice. I was very surprised at all the flavor in both slice and sandwich. I'll be back next trip.. read more

We stopped by for lunch and waited over 15 minutes for anyone to acknowledge we were even there. So we turned around and left. Very non customer service focused. The food may have been good but we will never know read more

Just ok. Decent pizza and sandwiches, but nothing to write home about. Pizza ok, but sandwiches a little lacking. Not bad at all, just not compelling me to drive 20 minutes out of my way. A solid 3 star. read more

Got take out- everything was good! Employees and owner were very personable. Had a good experience . Food was good. Nothing bad.

Was really surprised good the pizza was ! I am from New York ! We have the best pizza in the world ! The service was good and the people were nice ! The ambiance was that of a typical Pizza place ! read more

I've been here twice and have enjoyed it each time. We first ordered their cheesesteak hoagies & fries they were very tasty. It's not philly, but great for the area and they give you plenty of meat. The next time I got a slice of the pita pizza. It's simple in flavor, but was really good. It has ham, lettuce, tomato & some pesto on top of the pita. The service is good considering it only one girl for the entire dining area. read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Cheesesteak hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

Ate here tonight because it was listed as one of the best pizza places in Ephrata. Mixed bag of great and terrible, so it gets 3 stars. I'm willing to give them another go next time I am in the area at the right time. We ordered the "Special" Stromboli, a side of garlic bread, and drinks. Garlic bread was an utter disappointment. Just needed something to snack on until the main food was done, and wasn't exactly expecting much for the $1.50 price, but it was a sandwich roll (maybe baked by them), with an olive oil and herb mix spread kinda unevenly inside. Warm and nice on the outside, but a little soggy. I like my garlic bread toasty/grilled so it's a little crispy. Oh, and they overcharged us vs the menu price ($2). Taste was OK tho -- 2/5. Drinks were typical, and they gave us abundant lemon wedges on request. They cut them the stupid-but-pretty way though. Forgot our straws, had to flag down the waitress for some. 3/5. Finally the stromboli. SO MUCH potential here, coulda been a 5/5 boli. We ordered their "Special" stromboli (basically a supreme pizza style) The dough was tasty and crispy. The fillings were ample and relatively well-spread. We made two alterations -- requested no hamburger (important for later) and subbed green peppers instead of sweet peppers. Let me reiterate, the boli was very well-made, but staff error killed it. First, it lists sauce as an ingredient but it had none. We asked for a cup of sauce on the side, but the waitress forgot, and by the time she checked back with us it was 20 minutes later and we were done. Second, we finally noticed there was no ham (an ingredient on the list) in our boli. Turns out, when we omitted "hamburger", the waitress broke up the word over two lines with her huge cutesy handwriting -- "ham" on one line, and then "burger" below it, so the cook left both off. So the boli drops to a 4/5. They offered an explanation for their error, but not an apology or remedy. No offer to remake (we'd only eaten 3/8 of it), no offer of a minor discount, etc. I'd have been happy if they just offered to knock off the price of one topping as a gesture. To be fair, the waitress was pretty busy, but it seemed like other tables got more attention. NOTE TO MGMT: I see now why most places call their hamburger topping "ground beef", to avoid the ham confusion when people abbreviate etc. Maybe consider following suit. Based on what we got, I'd expect their pizzas and strombolis to be excellent, but don't waste your time on the garlic bread. Will update if/when we make it back. read more

Don't let this little hole-in-the-wall foul you - it's a hidden gem! Pleasant staff, realistic pickup times and great pizza. You can never go wrong with this sicilian pizza! Crispy fluffy crust loaded with cheese. The best sicilian of my life! You can't go wrong here. read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Pepperoni Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Ephrata. Jerry makes a great pie and the cheese steaks are really good. Served on the right style bread. Excellent Pizza and steaks. read more

Friendly staff. Food made promptly. No matter what I order, it tastes fresh and delicious. Pizza and sandwiches are off the chain. Great spot to dine in or take to go if you're near the Douglassville area. read more

Very friendly pizza shop. The pizza is always consistent. The stuffed spaghetti and meatball pizza is an amazing pie. The pasta inside is always cooked perfectly. My family absolutely loves the stuff spaghetti and meatball pizza. This is a trusted pizza shop for a good consistent product. read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Spaghetti and meatball stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

See all

Typically, when we come to Ephrata everyone wants to order pizza one night, but I'm the problem eater of the group. This trip was quite the game changer. On a whim, we called Little Nicki's, a family favorite, to see if they had gluten free pizza, and to our surprise they did! We were excited to order take-out pizza for an easy dinner after a Christmas concert. We got a gluten free pizza with pepperoni and banana peppers; a large pizza with half pineapple/bacon and half sausage/mushrooms; a plain cheese pizza; and a chicken caesar salad. I could only enjoy the gluten free pizza, but boy was it good! It came in it's own pan with a pizza cutter to make sure we didn't have any cross contamination. It hit the spot! There was silence around our kitchen table as we eat the take out, and we have tons of leftovers for another meal or two. read more

See all

I LOVE their pizza. Grandma's is my favorite but I've tried many and never had a bad slice.

Great pizza and a friendly atmosphere. Clean and fast service. Love going there for lunch.

Definitely the best pizza spot in Ephrata. Their pizza blows the competition away. Finding a good cheesesteak in Lancaster county is like finding the pope in a strip club, yet theirs does not disappoint! read more

We LOVE Little Nicki's. BEST pizza in Ephrata (and we have a lot of pizza shops). Staff is always so nice too!

"Medium" buffalo chicken boli was so big it yielded three substantial portions. Not the standard "buffalo" treatment but still tasty and juicy. Oddly, rather than blue cheese or ranch it came w regular red sauce as a complement but hey, it is an Italian joint! The guys up front are consistently friendly, efficient and appreciate your business. And whatever you do, don't fail to order the garlic bread w cheese...omg-good! read more

We were at St Boniface Brewery for outside beers and then stopped here for salads. Generous portions with fresh ingredients and well priced!! Yummy. read more

UPDATE: I'm updating my review because I was very damn pleased to discover that the pizza here is as good as it has ever been, which is to say exceptional. BUT, in the spirit of the season this wise(ass) man comes bearing gifts of pizza-related knowledge: Little Nicki's makes their ricotta FRESH. For those unfamiliar with the art that is a well-made calzone, this is important. It's excellent ricotta, and you can't make a proper calzone without excellent ricotta. That'd be like Michelangelo sculpting his David from manure. It'd be like Da Vinci painting in mud. I'm gonna stop here before this Italian artwork metaphor gets away from me; try a calzone, and get it with a side of sauce. It's a masterpiece. Another thing I've discovered about this gem is that their hot wings are great. I consider myself a wing snob; I was born that way, and I'll die that way. I've long accepted this facet of my personality, this elitist attitude of my poultry palate. I know a good wing when I taste it, and these babies are good. Properly fried, no breading, moist chicken, crispy skin, well-sauced; the gang's all there. It's a good value, too, at $6.25 for 10 good-sized wings. Yes, there are people around town who get pizza from places other than little Nicki's, but there are also people who rock out to Creed and dabble in cross-dressing. read more

This was our first time in the area and trying Little Nicki's. It was fantastic! From being greeted with genuine welcome by a few different staff members to the kind service to the delicious food, my husband and I cannot recommend this place enough. We both ordered the special cheesesteak's and we would eat another if we were in the area. Thank you all for a wonderful experience! read more

Little Nicki's Pizza - Special Cheesesteak loaded with amazing flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Ephrata, Pennsylvania

Great spot for a great pizza and wings! We're never disappointed when we order from here. Staff is always pleasant and personable!

Manny is the pizza maker and is good. Nice friendly professional demeanor and great pizza

We love this place! We have to have their food anytime we're visiting my mom. Their sub bread is hands down the best. My favs are their chicken parm sub and their chicken cheese steak hoagie. read more

First time stopping in, was greeted immediately with respect. I ordered 2 pepperoni sticks and a side of sauce. Very prompt service, look forward to returning. read more

My favorite pizza place in Ephrata! This was the first pizza place I went to when I moved here from philly almost 10 years ago and I have never been disappointed! The owner is so kind and takes time to start up a conversation with me every time I come and remembers little things like always asking how my mom was doing when she was going through chemo. Next their food is absolutely amazing! From their pizzas to their pastas and their cannolis are to die for! I usually do take out which I have never been quoted more than a 20 minute wait when I call in. I have dined in a few times and all the staff was very kinda they offer booth and table searing.Overall this is a very family friendly pizza shop and I am always recommending them to everyone! read more

The food here is wonderful, however safety protocol during the pandemic is less than satisfactory. Masking for customers is not enforced. Wait staff are wearing masks, but delivering food to table of unmasked folks while carrying MY food is unacceptable. I will do takeout, but no longer will dine in. read more