As first timers, we were a little wary of ordering the elk, which is a very difficult protein to get right. They absolutely nailed it. Tender, not gamey, cooked for 5 plus hours until so beautifully rendered I would swear they coaxed fat out of it that doesn't exist. Sauces were delicious, especially the horseradish. The duck fat fries and watermelon salad were also winners. I was worried about ordering oysters this far from the ocean but whoever they are sourcing from did a great job. Delicious. Cocktails and dessert rounded out an exceptional meal and service was relaxed and attentive. We'll be back for sure next time we're in town. read more

This was our first visit to The McArthur, the newer restaurant on the FivePine property. We were excited to try it while staying at FivePine for the weekend. The staff was friendly and personable, and the menu looked promising. We ordered the steamed mussels, beet salad, McArthur burger, and wild mushrooms. The burger was probably the highlight of the meal. Mine was a little more done than I prefer, but it was still very good. The beet salad was enjoyable, though not particularly memorable. The mussels were okay, but several were chewier than I'd expect. The biggest disappointment was the wild mushrooms. I was expecting something that would showcase the variety and flavor of wild mushrooms. Instead, the texture and taste reminded me of the canned mushrooms I grew up eating as a kid. Nothing was bad, but nothing really stood out either. We passed on dessert and left feeling a little underwhelmed given the prices and the setting. Would we come back? Probably not. In fact, when we were deciding where to eat the following night with friends, we suggested Three Creeks Brewing instead. If you found this review helpful, give it a like so it can help others too. read more

See all

The service was impeccable. So helpful and informed as to the food offerings and the best wine pairings. There were four of us. The green beans and beet salad were the choice of appetizers. Both delicious but the beet salad won by a point or two. Braised ribs, mussels and the black cod. Good portion sizes. All very good. The ambiance was cozy, and not noisy. We will definitely return. read more

My husband and I dined here a few months ago. We had the elk sliders (fantastic!), steak, halibut cheeks and the corn. The halibut was extremely dry and the steak overcooked. We mentioned the dry fish as we were walking out to the owner / host only with the intent to help a new restaurant out -- his responds was they only cook the halibut for a few seconds in each side and they know how to do it right....well they were dry for us so either overcooked or worse sitting under a heat lamp for too long. Either way I would return or spend the money here. read more

I can't say enough good things about this place! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm, friendly service that made us feel at home. The atmosphere was cozy yet lively. The food was absolutely outstanding. Every dish was fresh, beautifully presented, and bursting with flavor. You can really tell the chefs put pride and passion into their cooking. Drinks were just as impressive, well-crafted cocktails and a solid wine/beer selection that perfectly complemented the meal. read more

The McArthur - Hazelnut Crusted Trout - New American Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

We had reservations in Bend but decided we didn't want to drive that far and we were so glad we pivoted. Our dinner at McArthur was fantastic, the service was great, the drinks were delicious, over all it was a great experience. It's a little weird when you first walk in, and the smell is a little "off" because of the gym next door but once we were seated the rest was amazing. I'd definitely recommend McArthur if you're in Sisters for the evening. read more

OK, a 3.8 but not a 4. Let's start with the noise. Really harsh. Overall little ambiance. The bar is the best part of the place. They could really use some art on the walls. And the lighting is just so... whatever, it doesn't work. For the prices one would expect tables that don't look like they came from the second hand store. It's all saved by the food which is really quite good. Superb menu and tasty with ok - not generous - portions. Some definite originality. Parking seems plenty right outside the door. I predict it will get better as the owner and chef are quite capable. read more

The food was good, really good. Their duck fries, poke bowl and oysters were all excellent. Fresh, flavorful, colorful, and nicely plated. The staff were attentive and friendly. The ambience is a different story. The lights are too bright, it's too loud, and the chairs/tables seem cheap for a $50/plate dinner. They clearly want to do well so I hope they update their tables, chairs and lights. I recommend they install sound dampeners on the walls and ceiling, update the lighting to something more diffuse, and replace seating with something more comfortable. read more

Ate there on 12/26/25. Were out of all fish dishes at 8 pm. Hamburgers were good but not great. Kind of lumpy/chewy meat. Odd. Shrimp curry dish nice but too much rice for the amount of curry provided. Service was average. read more

Fries and Poke were super good. Crab Cakes are the best I have had across the country. A bit loud but food was great!

Salad was good but $39.00 for steaks that were so gristly neither my husband nor I could eat were a deal killer. It was embarrassing for us to have to spit out the remnants of every bite. read more

Amazing! So glad we now have this exceptional restaurant in our town. Absolutely everything, service, food and overall experience was 5 star! We will be regulars! read more

Some friends and I just had an amazing meal here. Hands down, my new favorite place is Sisters. Food was fantastic and the service was wonderful. Our server went above and beyond to make it a special experience. I will absolutely be coming back! read more

This was my 3rd time to The McArthur. It keeps getting better each time. The service is wonderful and the food is even better. Wonderful and thoughtful dishes. Terrific wine and cocktail lists. Thanks for the wonderful evening. We will be back. read more

My wife ordered the halibut for $48. It was so dry it was inedible! When we mentioned it to the waiter he said he would tell the chef, it was the second time he'd heard it. I had the oysters and couldn't finish them they were anything but fresh! The furnishings looked like they came out of a cheap cafeteria. Total meal price $200 with tips! We're starting a pool to see which month they go out of business! read more

Had dinner at The McArthur for the first time this evening. The food and our server were great. Our group ordered steak, lamb, and trout. All were great. Someone in a previous view remarked about the furniture looking like something left over from a previous lesser restaurant. True, however I'm sure that will be taken care of in a future upgrade when the community starts realizing this is a great restaurant. read more

We ate here on a Friday evening and it was hopping. The food was fantastic. We had duck fat fries, oysters, salad, trout, duck and the wild mushrooms. All very tasty. The black garlic aioli that came with the fries was so tasty and different. Service was friendly and responsive. Toward the end of our meal the restaurant owner came over to chat with us as well. Highly recommend this spot and can't wait to go back; definitely the best meal we've ever had in Sisters! read more