Have been taking my car here for 5 or so years. Always felt like they did good work and were honest, and treated me like a person (not like "oh she's a woman so she doesn't know about cars so we can pull one over on her").
That is, until a few months ago. About a year ago I stared getting weird vibes from Steve. Couldn't put my finger on why though, and chose not to find a new repair shop because it was an inconvenience I didn't want to deal with. But a few months ago, I took my car in for an oil change and asked them to investigate a check engine light that my car was giving me an OBDII code saying the problem was the vanos solenoid(s), and told them my car was occasionally stalling out. Took it in, they changed the oil and "diagnosed" the code - from what they verbally told me, they didn't check the solenoids themselves, nor did they swap the car's two vanos solenoids with each other (standard diagnostic procedure to determine if the issue is the solenoid itself, or something else). They said the problem was probably my gunky oil (side note, when I brought the car in I acknowledged that I was pretty sure I had missed an oil change. I get the oil changed every 3 months because it's an old 2006 car; Steve checked their records, said my last oil change was 5 months prior, and said "no you didn't, your last oil change was in (month)". And I thought, ... yeah... that means I missed an oil change.) Anyway, they said that the problem was probably my old gunky oil, and that replacing it would probably fix the problem anyway.
When I picked up my car, the check engine light was still on. Thought that was weird but thought maybe they just didn't clear the code or something? Didn't think much of it until it turned off on its own two days later, turned back on a day after that, and then my car stalled out again. Called them back, took the car back into them, they did another diagnostic (which they charged me for again, despite not doing a thorough diagnostic to actually diagnose the issue the first time around). Said it was one of the solenoids in particular, which they determined by swapping them with each other. They recommended replacing the one that went bad, and the other one as well since they said it was likely to fail soon if the other one had too. I said sure, replace them, and asked for them to please return to me the solenoids they pulled from my car, because I like to tinker and understand how my car's parts work, so wanted to check em out.
They did return the parts to me, in the boxes the new parts came in - a brand that makes aftermarket parts. Import doctors has told me verbally on many occasions that they only use OEM parts or better, and the invoice from Import Doctors stated "OEM Parts" and charged me a price comparable to genuine BMW VANOS solenoids. The parts they put in my car though, were aftermarket solenoids with subpar reviews, that cost 1/3 of the price of the OE part. (Shortly after this whole ordeal my car had a separate cooling system issue that I chose to have evaluated and repaired at the dealership, as I didn't trust bringing my car to Import Doctors after what happened with the solenoids. I asked the dealership to please look at the Vanos solenoid and let me know whether they looked OEM or aftermarket. They confirmed that they appeared to be aftermarket.)
I texted them to ask about it, they didn't respond to my text or call back. I ended up disputing the charge for the parts, and the duplicate charge for the diagnostic, with my credit card company, and won.
Would not recommend this deceitful business to any car owner, woman or otherwise, hoping to find an honest mechanic. I personally wonder how many other times they pulled one over on me before I happened to catch this particular time.
___
As an additional aside, I've fixed and replaced a number of things on the interior of my car - retractable cup holders, trim, the car's CCC, a door window regulator, and my drivers side door lock actuator (the thing that makes a car's interior door-lock button & key fob both work to lock & unlock the door). My actuator failed and I couldn't lock m car door with the key fob. Import Doctors quoted $800-900 to fix it. I bought a used part on eBay, took the door panel off, and fixed it myself for 80 bucks (cost of the part) + an hour doing the labor myself. Next time I brought it in, I told Steve that the fob worked again because I replaced the actuator with a used part. His response: "welp, that'll work until it doesn't."
Yeah... the same can be said about... any part - new or used. And yes, I know that the lifespan of a used part is shorter than the lifespan of a new part. But even if it fails again, and I have to replace it again, that's still cheaper than having had them do it... I did take that into consideration when choosing to DIY the repair and use a used part.
His response felt dismissive and felt like, "silly woman, you should've just let us pros fix it instead". read more