Rating explained: Reservations for 4:00 p.m. for party of 3 on Easter Sunday
SERVICE: 5 STARS
Promptly greeted and seated upon arrival.
We didn't have to hunt for Hunter! Our waiter was very attentive without being intrusive and was helpful with all questions. Great manner about him...we wanted for nothing.
APPS: 5 STARS
1. Pan Roasted PEI Mussels - bacon, tomatoes, garlic, white wine, butter, grilled baguette - The mussels prepared this way, with the bacon, were probably some of the best we've ever had...and being New Englanders...we've had our fair share. These are outstanding!
2. Flash Fried Calamari - chipotle aioli and a sweet chili sauce - Simply put...they were delicious! Tender from start to finish! Highly recommend.
ENTREES: 3 STARS
Mother and Hubs each ordered a House Specialty...Grilled Shrimp & Scallops served with orange sticky rice, seared asian vegetables, soy ginger beurre blanc.
They both had the same experience...the shrimp were flavorful and cooked well, and though the scallops were cooked well also, they were tasteless. There were only 3 scallops and 3 shrimp so they felt the veg and rice (both tasty they said) were a bit of a 'plate filler' BUT...however tasty the starch and veg, one doesn't expect a $25.00 price tag for sides, especially when 1/2 the protein was tasteless. Too bad...it looked delicious.
I ordered the New York Strip Steak, served with whipped potatoes, asparagus, jumbo lump crab, lemon beurre blanc.
I'll start with the presentation...though pretty on the plate, I don't particularly care for having my food stacked one on top of the other. And this is the reason...the hot steak placed on top of the asparagus turned the veg brown. Bright green tips and brown middles is not how I like asparagus. The steak was ordered medium and what I got was two thirds medium well with medium in the center as the ends were thinner than the middle. Come on people...even I know it's best to have a piece of meat equal in thickness front to back!
That said, the first bite was yummy...very well seasoned and I think the juiciest bite of the night. The steak went downhill fast though, as what moisture it had was long gone by the time I was 1/3 done and the buerre blanc soaked into the mash. I did ask for more of that though...the steak needed the moisture. And while I appreciate a little fat on the outside of a strip...gristle I don't. Too much of that, on top of over cooking...not my favorite dish. Had it been a bit better cut and cooked to order, the $29.00 price tag would be reasonable. As it was...not so much.
DESSERTS: 4 STARS
The desserts were another story...Hubs raved about the cheesecake and Mother loved the tart and tangy key lime. I had the creme brullee and I think it needed a bit more in fridge to set (which is why I gave desserts a 4 and not a 5), there was a really nice burn on the sugar that added a layer of flavor you don't usually get with this dessert. Plus, it had a great crack!
So overall, taking everything into consideration, I think a rating of 4 is fair if taken into context.
Price wise...not too bad considering 6 top shelf cocktails, two shared appetizers, 3 entrees, and 3 desserts...all for $171.00.
Had the entrees lived up to expectations and lived up to the service, appetizers, and the desserts, that wouldn't have hurt a bit. read more