So it's been a while since we went to gill tavern. And tonight was a great choice. The menu was a list of wonderful flavors that made it hard to choose. My wife had the miso halibut and I had the brisket tacos. My wife won. But I was a close second We finished with the peach galette. It was dam good They had a street corn that looked amazing. We are coming back before the menu changes. Still I top recommendation if your near greenfield Massachusetts. Well done again. Oh and great service to boot. The gill tavern has it going on. The atmosphere in the restaurant. Still recommend the front room so you can watch the chefs cook. And can smell the meals. read more

The Gill Tavern - The crew. They are great - New American Near Me - Gill, Massachusetts

Everything about this place is amazing. The attention to every aesthetic detail, real oil lamps at every table, hand picked flowers, umbrellas outside, it all shows how much they care. The food was also excellent, I recommend going for any beef while you're out near pasture land. We had the burger and brisket tacos, amazing! Don't forget they have a full assortment of local hot sauces! The service is also great, really nice people. read more

See all

First visit to the gill tavern and it won't be the last. LOVE the vibe. Like a rustic general store. Beautiful bar, eclectic "open" kitchen which is an understatement. Great outside seating and the porch area is really unique. Beautiful days just take it to another level. Mother's Day dinner entrees were good. Steak, Niçoise salad and veggie tacos. Honey gochujang wings. Choch pot au crème for dessert. Wines are reasonably priced. Entrees I was most interested in going to other tables was the roast chicken and beans as well as the burger. We had a table by the window in the main dining area and it was think it was certainly the best 4top IMHO. Thank you GT. I was hoping soft shell crabs were on the menu. I'll be watching your FB page. read more

I have been to the Gill Tavern several times. Saturday night I had my birthday dinner there and I'm sad to say we were really disappointed. The steak was so tough and the burger was very overdone. Cocktails were spectacular and saved the experience. The food was not up to par sadly read more

My husband and I have enjoyed Gill Tavern several times. Last night we brought guests. We had an outstanding experience. The food and the cocktails were second to none. We started with the charcuterie and several signature cocktails. Wow! We had the lobster roll which was prepared beautifully in a delectable baguette. Our other 3 entrees were excellent too. A gorgeous burger, cooked just the way my grill obsessed husband liked it! The Cuban flatbread was loved as well as the outstanding fried chicken dinner. Anna, our server, was fantastic & very knowledgeable. So lovely! We will be back soon! Thank you James (our chef) for your impeccable attention to details! Highly recommend. read more

Wow! In this tiny town resides a five star dining experience. The setting feels like someone's home. I sat at the bar as I was eating along, but before long I struck up a conversation with someone else at the bar and the bartendress. I'd been craving steak and ordered their skirt steak. As a former professional cook at a high-end winery restaurant, I was shocked at how beautifully this whole plate was planned and delivered. It was beautiful and every element needed to be included in every bite. It had been a long time since I'd eaten such a perfect melange of flavors. The parsnip purée with the perfectly grilled steak blew my mind. And then the bar tendress told me that the owner of the place was the guy working the grill. I heaped praise on him and the rest of the staff. I can't wait to go back! read more

Delicious food. I had the curried mussels. My nephew had the hamburger, saying it was the best he'd had in his fifty years. He also loved the smoked cheddar rolls. Service was great. Liked the open kitchen and farm to table food. Nice outdoor seating options read more

We were driving through this picturesque town and found a small tavern in the town center. Walker Widner is the Chef/Owner and has found a beautiful building on the National Historic Register to serve his farm to table delicious meals. Locally sourced food is featured on this exciting menu of catfish to burgers to yummy pot stickers and beautiful salads. Thoughtfully prepared cocktails and amazing desserts. Please stop and enjoy!!! Friendly and helpful staff in a beautiful setting. read more

We went to the wine tasting event! Fabulous, great wines and the dining matches that Chef Walker & his team put together were sublime! read more

Hidden gem. Great service and Terrific Food. We had a great time and will be back for sure.

This place has curb appeal, quaint and inviting. Once inside that theme is repeated. All tables are separated with an adequate amount of space in-between so that you got to enjoy dining with your friend(s). The menu had everything from basic burgers to seasoned salmon. Our server was polite & knowledgeable. We definitely look forward to coming back. read more

One of New Englands'a best restaurants. Causal feel with wonderful food. Worth the trip for both the setting and the meal.

Everything is made from scratch and the service is amazing fresh and quality. The restaurant's environment makes you feel like you're at home. read more

This is a small tavern with a single chef so the wait was rather long, easily 45 minutes just to get our appetizers and another half hour for the mains. I tried the fried chicken which was a bit overcooked and not juicy, although it tasted fine. Sides were yummy, smoky beans, fluffy cornbread, coleslaw with a touch of cumin and the collard greens had a touch of sweetness. Wifey had the hamburger which she said was really delicious but her one side of sliced potatoes were cold when they got to the table and it was so busy there was no use asking to have them heat it up, it would have taken another half an hour, so that was very disappointing, they just weren't good cold so she didn't eat them and brought them home. I ate a lovely milk chocolate pot du creme for dessert, it came with a crispy lemon tinged shortbread cookie. I'd ordered a cinnabon to-go for the next morning and was quite surprised to open the box and find it looked like someone had eaten all the layers of the bun and left me the middle and then threw in some chopped apples and cinnamon topped with whipped cream for a consolation prize. I'm sure I'll heat it up and it will be warm and gooey and delicious but I've never seen a cinnamon bun that looked like this. This was our first time here and I would definitely come back to try other dishes. It is fairly pricey, about $150 with tip for 2, with $36 of that being the bar bill. The wait staff and bartender were very, very nice. We wouldn't eat here regularly it's far too expensive, plus we make most of the menu items ourselves at home -- steak, burgers, tacos, even pan fried chicken -- and I do like to eat food I don't normally cook for myself when I go out, but it's definitely a nice night out in a lively place. read more

The Gill Tavern - Alleged cinnabon. Who ate the rest of it??? - New American Near Me - Gill, Massachusetts

A great locally sourced restaurant in this area. It's one of my go to places for fine dining. read more

The Gill Tavern - Mexican style corn on the cob - New American Near Me - Gill, Massachusetts

One of those place's on earth. A true gem. Genuine passion for what they do. Small. Which makes it that much more special. Coming from a fellow small restaurant owner, most patrons have no idea how much MORE effort has to be put forth in a tiny kitchen to deliver whilst executing superior cuisine and service. This team/"family" are beyond passionate about your experience being delivered beyond expectations. To me it felt like returning to a best friends home. A rainy chilly days and the fire is lit. The candles flicker, the food is beyond phenomenal and you just feel home. Like you're best memories of comfort and joy. These guys should charge an entrance fee . It's that unique. read more

Good food. Good drinks. Nice people. Really really slow service. 30 minutes to get an appetizer 45 to get your food. And this is happened every single time I've been here. read more

Probably one of the best restaurants I've been to, the atmosphere is great , the staff is awesome & have the best tattoos& personality,so down to earth and casual, however the food & drinks are out of this world and fabulous.. if you think Hope & Olive is good this lil hidden gem makes it look like a drive through.. Absolutely So incredibly happy with our experience!! read more

Creative menu, everything fresh, you will try things you've never had before here and it will all be excellent. Wonderful staff, owner is very welcoming and cares about your experience. Highly recommend. read more

Great food and atmosphere. Perfect place to bring at date. Better to make a reservation not a lot of seating.

In trying to figure out why people love this place, I realized... it's the booze and wine list. Ok that's fair. It is a tavern, after all. The menu is really limited. The food just isn't amazing. In fact sometimes it's just straight up bad. Last night the catfish tacos (2 tacos for $18!!!) showed up burned black, with a tortilla that was ripped literally in pieces. The waiter was creepy with no personal space. The potatoes were dry and tasted like they had been left on the grill for too long. Two stars for the location which is pretty and the delicious pickles they appear to make. read more

Amazing food in a farm-to-table setting! Everything right down to the chocolate moose is made on-site and with attention to detail. Lovely historic building and has a very friendly staff. Nice drink menu with custom margaritas with an amazing flavor pallet! Great for any special occasion or just a night on the town. read more

Way too loud and severely understaffed. Waited 1:45 hours for our entrees to arrive By then they'd run out of NA beer.

Food- absolutely delicious. We had a delightful dinner which consisted of a gluten free flat bread with seasonal fresh vegetable placed on top of a homemade pesto sauce with a local cheese. Then we had a bass fish with delicious rice, delectable onions and vegetables. It was cooked perfectly. We can't really say enough about the People at the Gill Tavern. The food is always superb. Service is warm, friendly kind, and punctual. And for the best restaurant around on a cold February night for a fair price. We left the table well fed and smiling. I love the ambience at the GT. But this year our schedules and weather kept us in. If you have never been fight Mr. Snowmeister and go over that mountain -it's well worth it! We give it 4.5/5 Sad they ran out of Monkfish. Kelly read more

Been here only twice with our friends from Brattleboro, VT. and we really love it. located in an old general store with some tables on porch and some more out front, the feeling is historic, comfortable, and unique. The drinks are great. I had a "Baron in the Trees" both times and had to hunt down a bottle of Cardamaro so I could make them at home. The first time we went none of us really knew what an "orange wine" was. Waiter informed with a very complete description and offered a taste for free. Interesting. The wait staff we've had have been efficient, pleasant, and helpful. No complaints there. The menu is small (the restaurant and kitchen are small!) but very good with a range of options. We adore the smoked cheddar biscuits and the mussels as starters. The summer salad is also great. My wife loves the fried chicken with smoked beans and greens, and got it both times. The strip steak is wonderful and the salmon is grilled but moist. I've had a flat bread, which was delicious, if a bit on the dry side, and am grateful for the veg/GF options. We tried to order mussels last time but the truck was stuck in weekend traffic. We saw it arrive just in time for desert and were tempted to order them! The deserts seem to change, but they have had pot de creme both times we have been there, which is creamy and deep with flavor. Yes, the restaurant is small, yes it can get busy, but the food has been very good with some great "upscale country" touches; the wait staff, even if sometimes taxed on busy nights, has always been great; the "special" drinks are interesting and varied; and we love the location and the building. We "get" what they are doing and we appreciate it. We'll absolutely go again when we are out that way. read more

Gill Tavern is one of our favorite places to visit, created from a historical general store in Gill, MA, giving it unique charm and character, with it's open kitchen concept adjacent to the bar. Their cocktails are outstanding and mussels and homemade cheddar biscuits never disappoint! We love bellying up to the bar, receiving amazing service from Kendra, the bartender and Chef Walker and his team! We appreciate this establishment so much that this past May, we chose to have our wedding reception dinner at Gill Tavern with our family. Walker created a wonderful menu for us using local ingredients, making perfect recommendations with unique wines. (Walker was the first person to introduce us to Orange Wine which is now our favorite wine!) The Gill Tavern staff is always kind and attentive, making us feel welcome, cozy, and at home! read more

See all

I could have given this restaurant more than one star except that I never got the opportunity to eat their. We went on an evening and went into the restaurant which was very busy and decided to take a seat outside. We were seated in given menus and then we waited. And we waited and we waited and we waited. At no time in the next 15 minutes did anyone come to fill our water glasses or take a drink order or even introduced themselves as our server. So we left. And although it looked like it may be a nice restaurant it will not get my business due to the poor service. read more

The Gill Tavern - Sitting outside at this lovely historic restaurant - New American Near Me - Gill, Massachusetts

This restaurant is a local treasure that should attract more than locals. Well, it does, but I'm thinking: wonderful food, friendly staff, great lighting, even. It should have a line out the door every day. I came here a couple years ago, after places reopened post-Covid, based on neighbors' recommendation, and had a burger. It was memorable -- local meat and cheese, a bun from a groovy nearby bakery, organic greens -- and I remember telling a friend I thought it the best I'd ever had. I came in tonight for another (had a craving) but decided at last min to get the pan-fried chicken. Everything on the plate was truly sensational: really flavorful collards, coleslaw, beans. I don't know what made them all so good but they all were so good. And the chicken was moist and delicious and really hit home. The homemade (like almost everything, I guess) cornbread was a nice touch. Truly: wonderful. I come here a lot with my foodie pals visiting from NYC and Boston (and Santa Fe, as of a few days ago, as a treat after a friend's long drive to drop her two kids off at nearby colleges) and they are always so pleased. Kudos to all who make this happen. read more

I know why they call this website Yelp! Check out the prices. Absolutely nothing I can't make at home for half the price. I'm not cheap and I don't hesitate to spend when warranted, but I hate to get ripped off. Instead of going out with friends, we take turns hosting and everyone brings their speciality within a certain menu theme. Lots of fun and a lot less money spent. read more

This is by far our favorite restaurant in Western Mass! Wonderful, charming indoor space and fresh, inventive, delicious food and drinks. We've been coming here for years and are always impressed by the changing menu and unique and cozy space. One of the few places that actually seems to be a legitimate "farm to table" restaurant. Highly recommended! read more

We were really blown away with the wonderfully bold and playful flavors! I started with the warm beat salad then went for the honey and cider glazed chicken I highly recommend both! Some of the best chicken I have had in a long time, I found it smoky and sweet with a tang at the end it was just right! The best part is you get to see and smell it all being made with the open kitchen and cozy setting. It's that perfect balance between "cozy" and being able to have a nice private meal with friends! If your in the area and haven't checked this place out it's an adventure waiting to happen! read more

See all

Been back since my last review a few times. Just this past weekend I had dinner after a while and I was BLOWN AWAY by the new chefs. I thought this place was great before and now - I am dazzled. Something magical is going on in that open kitchen! read more

We were in the mood for Sunday brunch so we decided to try out Gill Tavern for the first time. When we arrived we were excited at the layout of the restaurant and the overall atmosphere was incredible. We loved the rustic feel of the restaurant and thought that the decor was comforting. Our waitress was very polite and the brunch menu was great. We ended up ordering a two egg sammy as well as the steak and eggs. When the food arrived the plating was great and everything smelled delicious. The potatoes were seasoned to perfection, the eggs were perfect and the steak was made exactly how I wished. In the end we thoroughly enjoyed our meals and we can't wait to come back in the future. The next time we stop in it will be for dinner since everything we ordered was perfect. read more

See all

Great food ,Drinks and service! Chef Walker and crew make the Gill Tavern a fun friendly place to have a great meal with friends and family. Outdoor seating is perfect when the weather is good and inside is cozy with a open kitchen.The Bar is small but a great place to watch the open kitchen . Wife had red snapper and for me it was a local steak with Brussels ,Delicious . read more

Such a cute restaurant with a great feel of small attentive atmosphere. Just a handful of choices but enough of a variety to please everyone. Cheddar biscuits yummy starter. Each on of us tried a different dish and loved them all. Cocktails were creative and good. Looking to our next read more

See all

I really wanted to like this place but three things made it meh, if not ugh: - We were seated at the two-top at the end of the bar and there were so many staff continually milling around there, I either had an ass or an elbow near by face through the whole dinner, and my partner and I could hardly hear each other from across the table because of all the talking and laughing happening right next to us. When I got up to go to the restroom and when I returned, I had to stand and wait for the staff to either stop chatting with each other or get their tray and go, much less notice that a customer was trying to get back to the table that they were completely blocking. It's a total bottleneck of staff, and customers should not be made to sit in the middle of it. Find another place for that table and just use it as a staff thoroughfare, which is clearly needed. - The smoked cheddar biscuits smelled and tasted like freezer burn and/or were stale. They were dry and hard, with very little flavor, ugh. - My entree had hard, inedible herb stems (I think thyme?) sprinkled all over it, which could cause choking. Half inch pieces, two inch pieces--a lot of little twigs that cannot be and are not meant be be swallowed. Fortunately, I spit out the two that ended up on my fork before trying to swallow them. WTAF??? Not an enjoyable time. read more

Got a word of mouth heads up to try this place. Basically a group of people working very well together in a modest location that provide outstanding results. Everything they do, they do well. Service was excellent, restroom was clean and the food of course is what you should be there for. Arrived for a late lunch and the place filled up quickly as we moved toward dinner time. It was evident that each patron arriving was back for more of the same wonderful they had last time. This was our first visit and we will be back. read more

Definitely head here for comfort food to sophisticated cuisine. Walker is the best! Don't miss his Smoked Cheddar Biscuits (everyone is sure there is bacon in there). Plus the wait staff is super friendly and will take excellent care of you. Go! Soon! And make a reservation - it's a popular destination. read more

The Gill Tavern - St Germaine Grapefruit Cosmos, house salad, and those biscuits - oh yeh. - New American Near Me - Gill, Massachusetts

Best restaurant in the Pioneer Valley! Food perfectly prepared ! As appetizers --- try the warm olives and flatbread that is superb! The brisket tacos or the monkfish for your entree. The desserts on the menu shouldn't be missed so be sure to save room. The pot du creme is my absolute favorite. Waitstaff are all very professional. It's a lovely and unhurried dining experience. I can't wait to return next week! read more

A delightful, delicious experience. Fresh, creative dishes paired with excellent service and charming ambience. Start to finish, we had an exceptional meal. My partner and I spontaneously decided to dine out after a long drive, it was 4PM and every place we wanted to go was closed until 5PM (fair enough but we didn't want to wait). I called The Gill Tavern and lo and behold they were open for service and booked us a table on the spot. We are vegetarians and I was pleasantly surprised at the many options available on their carefully curated menu. I'm glad I started the meal with a cocktail from the bar, it was the perfect size, well balanced, refreshing and relaxing at the same time. We ordered the Greek salad which turned out to be a lovely fresh take on the traditional. The greens were farm picked & gorgeous, razor thin onions, just the right amount of Feta and a perfect vinaigrette. A savory medley of cured olives on the side was the perfect touch. The vegetarian flat bread was golden and topped with Gorgonzola and more fresh greens served on a beautiful wooden board. The vegetarian tacos were great, bursting with clean, fresh veggies and an awesome dressing with perfectly roasted vegetables on the side. I was glad there was only one dessert option because I might have chosen something other than the Pot De Crème which was absolutely heavenly. We loved the music and decor, even the bathroom is charming. The service was warm and professional with just the right amount of engagement. The Gill Tavern maintains a wonderful balance of being both refined and cozy at the same time. Kudos to all and thank you for a great time. We look forward to our next visit. read more