This was our first dining experience in York, PA and it did not disappoint! We made a reservation and when we arrived we were greeted and seated within minutes and they already had the kids menus & crayons plus water cups for them ready! Our waitress went over all of the specials and was very attentive. The atmosphere was awesome, not too loud and beautiful decor and ambiance. I had the shrimp puttanesca and it was phenomenal, just the right amount of spice and brininess. My husband got the steak and crab cake and I stole a piece of the crab cake , it was nice and meaty and well seasoned! My mother had the ciopinno and although it was packed with seafood, the broth could of definitely used more flavor, the seafood was good but definitely lacking flavor. Overall it was a great evening out and we can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Great meal this eve as usual. Wayne was our server and he took excellent care of us. Oysters were amazing and the pierogies were delicious. I always get the blackened steak salad which I love drinks were also amazing. The pumpkin pie martini was phenomenal. read more

The First Post - Smith island cake - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

After driving for 8 hours, we checked into Holiday Inn Express at 3:30 and asked for a place he would recommend for dinner. He suggested The First Post right across the street. We were so pleased with our experience. Our waitress, McKenzie was so pleasant and helpful and the food was outstanding. The establishment was spotless and everyone was friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

What in the world...? When my friend's fam and we visited this suburban town of York we expected to see only lousy fast food and mediocre eateries... and right on our first night, we were proven SO WRONG by The First Post. Wow, I mean where do I even begin? Umm... the huge PARKING LOT that has a bridge ya gotta cross over a brook? How about that Irish gold style paneled exterior with exquisite sign? Or the friendly servers leading you to this cavernous, high-ceiling, solid brick-walled, wood booth'd bar/dining area that just invites you to sit and chow down? We were surprised from the moment we entered, and it just got better from there. The FOOOOD... is amazingly good here. I mean amazing. We were starving so we had ordered fried calamari, French onion soup, and some asian chicken wraps. That calamari was unlike ANY fried calamari we've ever ordered in the US... in that it actually was fresh calamari. Batter was so delicate and calamari actually had parts, not just all frozen Michellin tire-esq rings-a-dumbs! We've never praised fried calamari so much! Asian chicken wraps were devoured by two ladies and they didn't even realize there were 2 sauces to dip into. I think that says a lot. Soup was good, though a bit salty as they usually are - I just ordered it for my son who was craving it. It was nicely cheesy though. For entree, crab cakes were delicious with string beans & mash. My lobster roll was very lightly-sauced, with delicious side salad & hefty steak fries. My friend raved about his burger which had roasted mushrooms in em, and the salmon dish really stole the show - it was on a bed of charred medley of vegetable that was so earthy and tasty, and the fish was so juicy like it had been drinking mimosa. It was a slam-dunk dinner-in-a-bowl. Oh, did I tell you they had real great Manhattan, too? I mean, this place could not go wrong. I was so jealous of the diners (as if they were all from York) cuz this was seriously good eats... I couldn't really think of any other place like this in NJ. I already want to drive 3 hours JUST to eat here again. Highly recommended! read more

See all

I requested a Caesar salad with a hard boiled egg. It came with a soft boiled egg. When I asked for hard boiled the manager said no that was the way it came. Last I knew I was paying the bill and should have received my food the way I wanted it! Never was there a solution to this issue, not a discount or making it the way I wanted. If you go there.....be sure to check out what the chef wants you to eat. read more

Great food, great efficient and friendly service in a beautiful atmosphere. Well managed and consistent.

We sat down at lunch with the manager to book the upstairs room for a wedding rehearsal in October. He took our information and gave us the catering menu. Told us to let him know after the holidays what we wanted from the menu. He already booked it for the time we wanted. Now we are without a place to hold a rehearsal dinner.. so disrespectful!! read more

Have been going to this restaurant since it opened. Food is consistent, but the menu remains the same. Time to change it up!

Food was good and staff were professional but ambiance was a bit unwelcoming. We arrived with two kids and had many comments and eye stares/rolls about it. I know, I know, it's frustrating to hear an upset baby, but our infant cried a mere 5 minutes and our toddler was no louder or more annoying than any of the drunks at the bar. Despite having a kids menu, and seeing other kids, the experience was not like anything I've experienced. For reference, we travel and often visit many nice restaurants & have never had such an unwelcoming moment. read more

Had a lovely anniversary dinner at the First Post, with a couple minor hiccups that were taken care of for us. We ordered calamari to share. It was super fresh but could have been fried 1 minute longer to crisp the breading. I ordered 8 oysters and received 6. The additional two came later. My husband had crab soup. I ordered a NY Strip for my entree, but didn't receive a steak knife with it. The steak was great, once I could cut it. My table knife just couldn't cut it. My husband had a sirloin steak and crab cake. He said the crab cake was only okay. We shared a few really large creme brulee for dessert. Our server was not super attentive, but during the Christmas season, they were super busy. read more

See all

My boyfriend and I are lactose intolerant and ordered pick up from here because they had great reviews for allergies. Dairy allergies were mentioned during the call for the order however upon receiving our burgers they were most definitely buttered . We got these delivered as part of a party so I couldn't complain directly but i would definitely be cautious if you have true allergies and you're ordering for pickup! read more

Delicious crabcake meal! Service was attentive. This place is huge with an awesome atmosphere. Lots of menu items I want to come back and try! read more

The First Post - Crabcake - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

This was my first time in York, PA and the food at The First Post did not disappoint. We started with a bunch of appetizers and of the selection the crab dip was my favorite. I ordered the crab chowder soup which was a cream based soup and it was delicious, it was rich and creamy and had a bunch of crab. I especially liked the old bay seasoning that was sprinkled on top. For my entree I order the shrimp primavera which was delicious. The shrimp were a medium size and the pepperoni elevated the flavor. I really liked all the gluten free options. The service was outstanding and our server did not miss a beat. He was very attentive and checked back often. The restaurant has a great atmosphere and there is plenty of room for large parties. The have a huge bar if you are looking for a cocktail. Loved the architecture and history of the building. read more

See all

Very nice place for a date night! Went on a Friday afternoon and it was very packed. We sat at the bar and got service right away. The drinks were delicious. I got the seafood stew and raviolis as the appetizer. The seafood definitely did not taste the freshest. But the seasonings were very good. The food was on the pricey side, but worth it. The servers were quick and very nice. I definitely will go again! read more

See all

Another great stop. Food was great! The service was amazing. And thins place is huge. I would of never though. Great decor. Tried and true. ** tip. Make a reservation. read more

See all

Delicious and unique food options! The ambiance is really cool, and we had great service.

We were just there for Buck-A-Shuck night! Awesome time! The food was great and we love the decor at the bar. Bartender and the manager were very attentive and friendly. I suggest the Crooked Horse Lager. read more

Great service! The waiter came up and was very polite and patient with my young son who likes to order for himself. The food came out hot and quick every one of our meals were great! I will definitely be coming back to this lovely place read more

great experience! loved the food and the drinks. very cozy vibe. friendly staff! would definitely come again and sit at the bar to change up the experience. read more

I LOVE THIS PLACE! I have a coworker who recommended it, and we decided to make the drive down from the Harrisburg area. We were greeted warmly at the bar and served drinks quickly. We started with a dozen Blue Point oysters, which are very reasonably priced ($2.50 each) and were absolutely delicious. They do have $1 buck-a-shuck Tuesdays, which are typically Delaware Bay oysters which are also fantastic! We also had a very good crab soup and calamari, both of which were amazing. The calamari does have tentacles so if you're a tentacle lover then you have to try these! We have also been there twice for buck-a-shuck Tuesdays and everything is always delicious and service at the bar is fast, friendly, and professional. We are looking forward to trying other menu items. Great spot to drive to on the bike and have some good eats! read more

Happen to be in the area and this was close to the hotel and got a lot of good reviews. Easy to understand why. Well-made cocktails, nice beer and wine selection, and outstanding food. Nice size portions, and the prices are right even in this age of over inflation. The double cut pork chop might be one of the best I've had. Cooked to perfection despite the thickness. Not an easy task, especially since they do not sous vide it (at least according to the bar tender). They still put out good quality at a good price. My only issue was the forgetful and inattentive service, which was kind of surprising, considering we were sitting right at the bar. They were busy, but not that busy. Worth the trip. Enjoy read more

The First Post - Draft Beer Menu - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

I was impressed - food is heavy but very good. Good atmosphere. I will definitely recommend this place to others!

Came in with a large group on our vacation and glad we found them. The wine list was surprisingly good but we started with cocktails first. Great Mule in some of the largest copper cups I have seen! The Scotch egg was superb! The Yolk was just right and the sausage had great flavorings and a bit of a kick. Charred octopus was done perfectly and flavored just right. I opted for the Roasted Chicken and it was a large bird with some of the most moist meat i have had in some time. Spices and flavoring on the skin was amazing! read more

The First Post - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

I like the periodic menu update. Food is always great. Service is consistently wonderful. Ambiance is great. Reservations recommended but sitting at the bar is always great too. The bartenders are fabulous. Always our go to for date nights read more

Friendly servers, great food and clean fun atmosphere. Our waitress, Ericka, was phenomenal. I ordered gnocchi without sausage and with Alfredo which isn't on the menu. She had no problem getting that to the kitchen as a special request. The food was homemade and fresh. The free bread rolls are warm and buttery. I should have taken a picture of the inside of The chicken sandwich. It was perfectly seasoned and the cheese was melted. The bun was buttery and grilled or toasted. read more

The First Post - Chicken breast sandwich-perfectly seasoned - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Lettuce was fresh and I swapped the chicken for shrimp. The salad was massive. Next time I'll get the dressing on the side so I can enjoy the rest at home. Delicious. read more

The First Post - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

I've been there multiple times. I truly cannot remember any dish. I ordered not being a little better than I expected. Great all around menu, something for everyone. You cannot beat Tuesday's Buck-a-Shuck. But get there early. With the understandable migration of some of the staff from the Eagles Nest to the Post, table service is now top-notch too. read more

Service is usually top notch. Lunch and dinner are phenomenal. The brunch is only so-so for me. The private dining rooms are great for big parties. read more

First time going to The First Post. Restaurant was very nice and our server, Carly, was really friendly and professional. Tried a number of things on the menu: Raw oysters (blue points) Calamari Coconut curry soup (soooo delicious) Fettuccine Alfredo with lump crab Prime pork chop Everything was perfectly prepared and flavorful. Oysters briny and fresh. Couldn't have been more pleased with the food and the service. Prices are really pretty good too! Will definitely make this part of our regular haunts from now on! read more

This is one of my favorite restaurants. I was sent a notification by yelp that First Post was a great place to go for a budget dinner. Well that it is not. I think they have good food, good service and a good atmosphere and I highly recommend it. But it is not a budget restaurant. I think it's high standards at a fair price. read more

Friendly restaurant with a personality! Bar, private rooms and lots of nooks And crannies. Happy staff. Local beers. American food. I went for an American Banh Mi (roast beef on a thick round roll and orange sauce that wasn't too spicy. Fries were good too. If you are up in York, or not too far away, this place is worth a visit. read more

See all

Food, service, and ambiance were all great. The First Post is a very large establishment outside the main city of York. It feels like you're walking into an old train station that's been converted into a restaurant- you could easily get lost. We ended up getting three apps that were all delicious to the point where we cleaned every inch of each dish. I ended up getting the Lobster Puttanesca which was great - I think it had at least 4-5 big chunks of lobster claw meat in it. 100% would go again to try more of the food read more

The First Post - Lobster Puttanesca - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

We found it by mistake. Sits on a small creek, park on other side and walk over a little bridge. Ahi hi tuna sandwich on a ciabatta roll very good and a large portion of tunat Rt. Soup of the day awesome doesn't matter ,shrimp,crab etc. Chicken Caesar salad comes with fried cream cheese croutons. Comming in a guest said you have to try the pork chops . Great atmosphere and our host Daniella knowledgeable and friendly read more

Normally food is wonderful. Got the Lobster Roll Last night and there was barely any meat on the roll. Shocked a waitress even served this. read more

The First Post - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

We sat at the bar and had a excellent meal and dinning experience. Brandon recommended entrees that I normally would not have chosen. Brandon was personable and friendly. Atmosphere and cost was great. read more

I'm traveling from SD for work here in York. A guy on the plane told me to check this place out and I did. Wow! The food here is so good. I highly recommend creamy Crab soup, especially the Oysters, Baked Crap cake. The food was fast. The service was great. read more

The First Post - Fries calamari, baked crab cake, and Raw Oyster. - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Food was good, service a little less accommodating but that was ok we weren't in any hurry just wanted comfortable seating. I would recommend. One item I loved the first time we came there was the seafood you could order as appetizers. We'd order all different things and you paid per piece for example I had 2 shrimp and 6 oysters and a crab leg. You don't do that anymore? read more

The food is excellent and even tho it was very busy, there is enough staff to serve you well

Very good food, friendly atmosphere and ample parking. The meatloaf was good Plenty of seating inside but popular restaurant so plan ahead on weekends! read more

The First Post - Meatloaf - New American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Let me start off by saying this place is GORGEOUS on the inside! Feels like you're transported to a different time. All the food tasted incredible! I personally ordered the Chile Queso Burger and had so much flavor... guacamole steals the show and it also has strong cilantro flavor. I personally love cilantro but if you're not a cilantro fan, then I don't recommend ordering this. The meat in the burger was juicy perfection! My friends said their food was delicious! The reason for my 3 stars is that there was a bug (moth) in my friend's salad. I know that may not be 100% the restaurant's fault, but the incident was not handled well. First, we couldn't find our waitress...we waited about 10 minutes before getting up and looking for a waitress. Our waitress came and we explained what was happening (a bug crawled out of our salad), and then asks "you want me to get that for you?" She grabbed the bug and then we think she released it out into the wild. However, the manager was standing behind her the whole time and didn't address it. There was no "I'm sorry about this" or "we'll comp the salad." Ultimately, we didn't have to pay for the salad but it wasn't acknowledged . Very odd read more