Summary: The Fat Chef is a best-in-class steakhouse with mop buckets in the parking lot.
Located aside RT12 sits The Fat Chef. The building is for sale, sits in front of poorly maintained storage units. We were told that The Fat Chef leases the building and that the property has been for sale for a long time. From the outside it looks like a dump. For a nice steakhouse it's not what you expect.
Reservations - Saturday, 7:30p. Interior decor isn't that of a fine steakhouse. The floors are cheap tile so your chair slide around a little too much. Tables are covered in a plastic, where my wife sat the plastic was worn through. The chairs are padded but dated.
It's a small restaurant, Maybe seating capacity is at max 30-40. At 7:30 the restaurant was about 60% capacity. Saturday night, I guess I assumed there would be more guests.
Our waiter greeted us, he was professional but obviously not of top-notch steakhouse breed. That was ok though, he did an good job.
We reviewed the wine list, we decided to get a bottle for dinner. First impressions of the wine list is overpriced. Sure, you expect to pay restaurant retail, but the most least expensive bottle was $60. I'm used to upper $30s/lower $40s as an option. We chose a red blend, the Sean Minor 2022 Signature Series-Nicole Marie. I had no experience with the wine, but it was very pleasant. It was worth a $60 so I didn't mind as much that there weren't less expensive items.
For appetizer we opted for the Shrimp Cocktail. The menu says that there's four colossal shrimps. They are colossal! I've lived in major metros, traveled for over a decade 80k-100k miles a year, been to the best steakhouses in the US. I've never had shrimp that large. The cocktail sauce homemade perfection. At $34, expensive but you know you're getting something special. We waited 30min for the appetizer. The waiter apologized, that meant that we had to pace ourselves with the wine. A let down to the experience because we chose one bottle for the entire dining experience but now we're sipping water not wine to accommodate delayed courses.
Entrees come with a house salad and a starch. Solid, well-crafted dressing on an average dinner side salad. Nothing to brag about but nothing to complain about. A small soft loaf was served with compound butter. The bread was very pedestrian. The compound butter was exceptional. Heavily herbed, the enjoyment was that the bread showcased the butter. Well done, it's a detail that deserves to be called out.
We decided to each order the ribeye. Our waiter went to check if they still had the cut. He said they had one left. I let my wife take the ribeye and was happy to choose the T bone. We found it to be somewhat poor planning that they ran out of ribeye. We waited about 40min for the entrees. It was explained to us that my T bone was very thick.
My wife's ribeye is described to be 14-16oz. That's conservative. I'd estimate her steak to be 20-22oz, it was prepared perfectly and at $62, including a salad and potato is a fair, in the upper end of price. Her potato was a special prep that was like a twice baked potato with horseradish. She didn't think the horseradish was overpowering but balanced nicely.
T bone is described as 24-26oz for $84. I opted for the AuPauv Style preparation, $20. That priced my entrée at $124. It wouldn't surprise me if it weighed 32oz. They certainly underestimate their cuts leaving a nice surprise that they over deliver. I thought at first that they missed my AuPauv. I asked the server who pointed out the cracked pepper encrusted on my T bone. AuPauv is always a sauce prepared with heavy cream. In fairness, they do claim it to be "AuPauv Style" described as "Tri-Colored Peppercorn Encrusted with Brandy Glaze". I'm sure it was there but never detected glaze. The AuPauv was $20 extra I guess that's why The Fat Chef says "style", the encrusted peppercorn was WONDERFUL, for $20, I'd suggest preparing it as AuPauv, not AuPauv style.
Added colossal fried shrimp ($24) to my entree. Like the shrimp cocktail, your wow'd! Perfectly crispy, 3-4 large bites a piece with the homemade cocktail sauce - extravagance.
The steaks are the best you can get anywhere. Generous and prepared well. I lived in Chicago, been to all the steakhouses and a hundred other top steakhouses in major US cities. The Fat Chef's steaks are right there. You'll not be selling yourself short ordering a steak and you can be confident that you've had a top shelf steak. We finished with the Crème Brule. It was ok, no complaints but mine is better.
Is The Fat Chef overpriced? I'll leave that up to you. The restaurant is a contradiction that you need to accept going in. I paid $124 for my entree, and I'll say, for me, yes but I'll also say I'd completely understand if someone else would say no. The food is worth it. The experience in totality is questionable at that price. Understanding what you're getting and not getting is a critical key to finding the value of The Fat Chef. read more