If you're on the fence about going to Eagle, well just hop off already and get your bum over there. I finally did and realized I had been missing out all this time. This fantastically grungy place is fueled by a mix of thumping beats, leather harnesses, and shirtless men. Even at its busiest, the vibe stays open, fun, and surprisingly well organized. The Wednesday before thanksgiving is apparently known for being the busiest night at the Eagle, and this year's record crowd should have sunk the whole operation, but the staff kept the entire production going smoothly like it was rehearsed. The Eagle's security team deserves direct credit. They managed an impossibly massive crowd without a hitch. Even with thousands trying to get in, the kilometric entrance line and the coat check line that stretched to the roof moved smoothly and never descended into chaos. Dan in particular handled a near-impossible task: recovering my smartwatch from a crowd so packed I had assumed it was gone for good. He somehow retrieved it, safeguarded it, and returned it to me with the utmost professionalism. Music is solid. The vibe is leather and musk. The inclusivity is not just tag line but a daily practice. This bar deserves every positive review on this app. Ignore the haters. Peace! read more

What an amazing Bar! situated on 28th street, easily accessible and the staff are phenomenal! they're kind, fun and honestly make you feel right at home. Loved my time there and would highly recommend anyone to go for a good night out or even a chill drink or three ;P. Love Love Love!!!! Colin xx read more

Leather gay bar with a distinct edge in an edgy neighborhood with staffers who have an edge too : ) The whole vibe of the place is meant to be edgy and transgressive. It works on some levels and not on others (no one will be singing show tunes but everyone's trying to look very serious in a faux macho sorta way) Fun place to visit, but you wouldn't want to live there read more

The Eagle - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

attendees shady towards POC/newcomers, this one group was literally yelling get out of here in my direction. Also, went to rest room to get away from them and one came to my stall to kick the door open. never expected to have such a disgusting experience here. read more

Nice bartenders and great crowd. But for 10 cover, you could check out my coat as well. No need for another charge. Let's get real.

Love visiting this venue with my girlfriends! Hot boys all around. Note cash only, and beware of dark corners!

They'll loose your jacket. Went there last night and waited in a 30 minute line just to check my jacket. Kept the ticket till the end of the night. Gave the ticket to the attendant but they had given my jacket to someone else. They told me to wait till the end to see if it was somewhere, which it was no where to be found. They made no offer to replace it. I wear a L they gave me someone else's unchecked S jacket so I could get home in the middle of the winter. They take no responsibility for their actions of not properly taking care of your property. Even when a nice worker there tried to help me the Manager Oscar pretty much just shooed me away. And it was my birthday on top of it. Really terrible way to treat customers. read more

Bartender was super rude to me. I am not the type to complain about tipping culture but it's ridiculous to have to tip for water?! I feel like it's common courtesy for bars to supply water to their guests so they can stay hydrated and sober up. I'm from California where they usually have water and cups already out for self serve. I ordered 4-5 vodka sodas through out the night and tipped the bartender $2-3 every time. I asked for water once after that but tipped because I had an extra dollar left. After that, I asked for water two more times but didn't tip. I didn't feel like it was really necessary to tip for water? When I asked for water again the bartender handed me the water but angrily went on a rant saying I'm asking for too much water. And he said he would have to charge me next time if I asked for another one. He repeated himself twice pointing straight at me saying loudly "You're asking for too much water. If you ask again I'm gonna charge you for it" purposely in front of other customers to make me feel embarrassed. Horrible service. I'm sure it's because I didn't tip the past two times I asked for water and asked again. If he was a true bartender he would happily serve me water to make sure I'm hydrated. But seriously, am I supposed to tip for a cup of water? read more

First quality venue for your best bad decisions, lol. Honestly honestly though, it was a great time enjoyed visiting those place.

I Eagled regularly pre-pandemic for 10 years, one of my favorite places. It's had its ups and downs with the city and the neighborhood requiring changes, but all in all it's been my favorite late-night bar in Manhattan. On a good night it's packed with a rough sexy vibe and a lot can happen. I went back for the first time post-renovation about a week ago. Lots of straight women there around midnight. LOTS. Probably 30% of the people on the roof were women (fewer downstairs but still some.) Guys, this isn't the place to bring your girlfriends. It is not a zoo for girls where they can watch the animals play. It's a bar for men who want to be around men who look like men. I hope this was just an anomaly the night I went but anecdotally I've heard that there are a lot more women coming now after the renovation and the dance floor. If this is really the trend I'm not sure why I would bother to leave HK to come down here anymore. read more

Loved it ! Nice staff drinks reasonable! Wednesday nites are amazing! Had a ball The leather store is rather expensive- an Eagle cap for $35 ???? Really!!! Lol read more

A lot of space to dance and have fun but don't buy the merch. The vendor gave me the wrong size and the bar wouldnt let me exchange sizes.

Why charge $25 cover per person for a cash only bar on week days. No special event. There are better places like the Cock. read more

Great experience. The staff is really friendly and the bartenders are awesome. The music is amazing also read more

We came to NYC to celebrate my 50th birthday and decided on the Eagle, Sunday, August 6th. While at the Eagle, we met bartender Richard who we kept coming to for drinks and tipped throughout the night. We chatted up with him, informed him that we were celebrating my 50th b-day come midnight. We ordered a round of shots & chasers which he set up for us come midnight; midnight came, we took our shots and chasers. I later came back to Richard and asked for water. Richard turns away from the bar, took 3 steps and reached into the fridge, pulls out a bottle of water. I was all out of cash so I told him that a glass of water would be fine. Richard's demeanor instantly changed & his expression was obvious he was upset. Richard went on a rant, "You should have said something from the beginning. This happens all the time..., I know who you are (Richard acknowledged the relationship we had established earlier). He gave me the class of water and continued to lecture me. He then stated, "So what are you going to ask for next time you want water?" I am looking at him the entire time to see if he is joking/waiting for him to crack a smile; but nothing. So I answered him in a sarcastic manner, "I will ask for a GLASS of water next time?" At this point I rounded up my people, explained what occurred and insisted we leave and we left. All that over a freaking water bottle??? Needless to say, this put a damper on my 50th b-day celebration at the Eagle! I guess Richard really did want credit on that water bottle sale. read more

Best Paella I've ever had!! I went in after my friend told me about it and she was sure right! My life has changed

I usually try to spin through here if I'm visiting the city on a weekend. One of the best parts is an outdoor bar on the roof: even in cold weather it's nice to experience. No need to explain this type of bar, you like it or you don't. At the bare minimum it's a great people watching, live-affirming, diversity expanding experience! The music is pretty loud inside is my only complaint but that's expected, less talking more looking. read more

Cash only bar. We walked many blocks to get to the bar just to find out it's cash only! It's 2023. No bar should be cash only. What are they hiding??? read more

I was just at the Eagle this past week, 6-28-24 to 7-1-24. The last time I was there was in the late 90's and had a great time. The bar has improved and i was there 3 nights in row. Lots of very hot men of all races, and I felt very comfortable and had so much of a good time, I was escorted out of the building and I should have been lol! I highly recommend going there at least once to check it out. i hope I get to go back some time in the future. read more

Always a great vibe. Excellent djs. Cash only. Have a wonderful time. Can't wait to come back for some Susan Morabito. Drinks are just fine.

Bane: "Theatricality and deception; powerful agents to the uninitiated... but we are initiated, aren't we Bruce?" That pretty much sums up one's experience at the Eagle. Either you get it or you don't. One gets the feeling that as the years go on, activities have been calmed down or downright discouraged. Drinks are expensive and they don't take cards, but it is a historic bar catering to the leather/fetish community so it's a mixed blessing. To be honest I'm surprised it's survived this long. I hope it stays because gay venues are slowly but surely being phased out. Either way, please stop bringing ladies here boys...why this bar of all places? read more

Iconic piece of gay culture in the heart of New York City. Please be aware of their cover charge as they charge before the outlined times.

Best bar around! Richard always makea the experience extra enjoyable. He's the highlight of the night. Great crowd and always fun!

Totally trash fun. Overpriced but fun. Friendly staff (80%). Almost guaranteed play time if you're open minded.

Visited for the first time a week ago , wonderful experience and great vibe , highly recommend this iconic bar in NYC .

Paella? What?? I am nearly certain Paella is not on any the at the Eagle NYC. Hot leather boys and hard working men is the scene I am looking for and the Eagle serve it up fresh and raw - the way Daddy likes it. read more

$25 cover? For what? Pearl-clutching security constantly shocked that shenanigans might be happening? At the leather cruise bar? Look, if you don't want us to play at your place then we won't. Sadly, for all its history, this place is dead to me. No thanks. read more

Great atmosphere and location. They only take cash- who doesn't take credit cards now a days?

If you are looking for an experience of a lifetime then this is the place for you, I have never experienced something like this, it was my first leather bar ever and hopefully not my last one. Jocks out boys. read more

Walked in this place thinking it was a regular bar. A nice 20s-30s crowd, lots of walking space. I'm not a gay man but if I was and wanted to hook up ... this place! read more

Saturday Night Rip-Off Just arrived by Uber to have a quick drink, only to discover that there's a $20 cover charge. The Management knows damn well that the Eagle is one of the few gay bars in the city with an outdoor area, and so is taking advantage of the fact during the Pandemic. Besides the $20 admission fee, I end up paying $12/drink (excluding tip) for 3-4 drinks during the evening, wait in line 15 minutes just to get to the rooftop, then stand around for hours not meeting anyone. (NYC leather queens are too busy gossiping with their clique-mates.) At 2:00 am, I decide to go home alone, paying for another pricey Uber. I should never have left in the first place. Would have been better off watching Netflix. read more

Your bar is discriminating I went and they tried charging me and my gay friends $25 each but let other people in for free right in front of me read more

Not very good when a BAR charges $20 you can't move around. Drinks are reasonably priced for NYC, that and the DJ is all they have to offer. What a waste of my 45 minutes and $20. They don't have to worry about seeing me again. read more

So much fun and debauchery. Perfect for the single man on the prowl or adventurous couples. The staff has always been very cordial and professional. The crowd is welcoming and diverse. Drinks are strong, so pace yourself. We hadn't gone for a long time and tonight will be our third time this week. read more

You should really update your hours. I just walked all the way over here from the upper East side

Place is very limited to Wednesday and Sundays. Any other day this place is dead. Bar tenders are rude. Even the non bartenders, Specifically Joe, felt the need to push around paying customers because he was carrying a case of of beer. Joe really is the reason for this review. He really needed a power trip as a bar employee to yell at me and my friends for walking in front of him when he was carrying a case of beer. He physically pushed one of us and told us to get out of the way, we had no idea he was behind us. However, this is the customer service you can expect from this place, as all the employees cover for each other. I really hope joe felt visible for once in his life. read more

It was wild. I like it very, very much. And you can touch every body randomly. And everybody's enjoy it. It's great.

I'm gonna give this place 4 stars. All has gotten better except the three dollar coat check fee You should have a great time at the Eagle read more

Let's be real: you already know if The Eagle is for you or not. Either you're into partying with an Eagle crowd, or you aren't. You know whether or not you're OK with the typical shenanigans at this type of bar, or if you're not. Me? I'm a fan, and I had a great time. I ended up spending most of a Sunday at The Eagle, enjoying Beer Bust. Considering how expensive everything is in Manhattan, $4 beers definitely hit the spot. There was a pretty good crowd, made more dense by the fact that they keep the upstairs closed off until 7pm. Friendly guys that got... friendlier... as their BAC began to rise. I really liked the DJ, and I wish that more people would have been into dancing. But nope, this crowd isn't quite the dancing type. Once the upstairs did open, it was fun to explore. The setup of this bar is pretty great. I like the rooftop quite a bit, and I want to come back in the summer to see this place at 100%. The crowd was all pretty great and I had no problems making friends for the night. Not all Eagles are created equal. The NYC outpost is one of the better ones I've visited, and I'll be sure to return. read more

Extremely rude bar staff. They just walk away from you if you ask for water. Also they charge $5 for a seltzer and only sell bottled water and won't give you tap water. Extremely rude and stingy for a place that charges a cover and coat check fees totaling $20. A little human decency goes a long way. Will not be back to this dump read more