I'm originally from NY, so maybe I'm picky when it comes to bagels. I had their lox and cream…read morecheese. I told them to leave off the capers. It came with tomatoes, something else I never had on my sandwich. Something wasn't quite right about it, I didn't realize, but their bagels are just meh, they certainly are not NY quality. I had their cream cheese and bagels. I like poppy seed bagels best. There was way too much poppy seeds and the taste just wasn't great. I did have their potato knish, that was yummy. I tried to get that on my last day there and they were sold out. I asked for latkes, also sold out. I didn't try their reuben, if was staying longer I would have tried that. Weekends are very busy and no seating. They do have Dr. Brown sodas, so they do follow some tradition. I just wish they would get better quality bagels. But I still think it's definitely a worthwhile visit. Great location.

This is the place to go for lunch at Merchant Square. It's a small deli with large sandwiches. I…read moreordered the Reuben, but with pastrami rather than corned beef. It was good! It comes with Coca-Cola and your pick of chips. There's no space to sit inside, but there are plenty of tables nearby.

I admire this cheese shop in Merchant Square. It's definitely a place you'll want to check out when…read morevisiting Colonial Williamsburg. The first level is the market, filled with an abundance of craft beers, drinks, cheeses, breads, sandwiches, deli items, ingredients, and more. The lower level is the tasting room, and there's also outdoor seating available, although it can feel a bit tight. We didn't get a chance to try anything since it was close to closing time, but I can definitely see this place getting super busy on the weekends.

The Cheese Shop was highly recommended, and I can see why. It was a little confusing, but once we…read morefigured out the process, it was a short wait till we were enjoying our lunch. We ordered the Italian, turkey, and daily special from the counter. They use high-quality meats and breads. I really enjoyed my sandwich, which had a lot of prosciutto in it. I chose chips and a Colonial Williamsburg iced tea to go with my lunch, and they were good as well. It was a hot summer day, so this was the perfect spot to take a break and have lunch.

Rick's Cheesesteak Shop is worth the hype! I popped in for dinner just before closing on a Monday…read more The man behind the register was very friendly. I ordered their original cheesesteak with several toppings- jalapenos, grilled onions, and grilled mushrooms. The eight inch (the smaller of the two options) was more than enough food for one. The meat is loaded on. I used a fork to eat some of it so it wouldn't fall out. They sell Coca-Cola products, including Cherry Coke. The sandwich itself was very tasty! The cheese it comes on is out of this world. Inside, there are murals, tables, and a few places to charge your phone.

Legit.... this is the OG Rick's Cheesteak Shop. Like OG OG... they kept the original recipe and…read morehave the food to back it up. Me n my buddy did a whirl of cheesesteak places in the Hampton Roads area. I knew about this place because of our adventures in Williamsburg. I kept boasting about how good it was, so much so we drove from Chesapeake to Williamsburg JUST to eat dinner here. Is it that good? YES.. it's that good. I don't know what more to add other than the fact that if you're a Cheesesteak fan, it is mandatory to come visit here - you won't be disappointed. Food Taste: 5 Overall Service: 5 Value of service to cost: 5 Facility: 5 Ambiance: Very small place that doesn't have a lot of decor but that's ok.. the food rocks Repeat customer: yeah Dog Friendly: outdoor seating

Very friendly staff and the cupcakes are very tasty. The owner met us at the door and apologized to…read moreus for the A/C because no one the fritz.

So good. Get anything with the black salt garlic bagel . Love bake shop. Huge bagels and sammys.read more

The service provided by Jamie and Allison is always excellent and top-notch! Their exceptional…read morecustomer service and talent behind the bar are always a reason to look forward to every visit. The food is also consistently good and has highlights on each of the seasonal menus. Thanks for a great time!

Just happened to discover this place while browsing yelp looking for somewhere to get dinner with…read morethe family. Well it worked out well! The ambiance was very nice and way larger than I anticipated. I was nervous for a wait but although it was very crowded for a Tuesday there is ample seating. The food was really good. We had onion rings, sticky ribs, meatloaf, peach flatbread, and and kids burgers and pizza. The ribs were outstanding! So happy I threw them in the order last minute. Meatloaf was good and the flatbread was quite delicious. Kids enjoyed their food as well. Onion rings as well, can't go wrong. All in all a great meal at a nice looking restaurant and will definitely recommend it to others!

What has happened to Paul's Deli? We've lived in Williamsburg for over 25yrs and Paul's was always…read morea favorite for locals. We used to love eating here. Every time we went we saw neighborhood friends. But things have changed at Paul's. The food is bland and doesn't taste fresh. The serving sizes are smaller. I usually get a piece of carrot cake to go. Their carrot cake used to be amazing. Tonight when I got home and opened my to go box, I was very disappointed. Not only was the cake small, it was old and dry. I have attached 3 pictures. Two pictures are of the carrot cake Paul's used to serve. The third picture is what I brought home. Also, that small piece was $10.00. We were there close to two hours and only saw one other customer in the restaurant. I'm giving 2 stars because our server was wonderful.

Food was pretty decent. I ordered the French dip sandwich. They definitely provided the meat! It…read morewas loaded down. However, some of the meat was chewy and I had to pull off the fatty parts. French fries were great! At this location, you order at the bar and the food is brought to your table. It was brought it a timely manner. This is definitely a bar like location. The tables are worn down, the floor is sticky, and the walls look like they could be cleaned. The walls are covered in photos and memorabilia and you can just tell they need a good cleaning. Food was decent, service was good, but the location made me feel kind of dirty when I walked out. If you're looking for bar food in a bar like location, this is it.

The burgers and chili cheese fries were tasty! The service was superb and very friendly.read more

Top notch service and the food choices are plentiful. We started with the deviled eggs( not…read morepickled, as they have been in the past) and very tasty. My wife had the Cobb salad and added a burger patty..she loved it! I had the mushroom swiss burger( double w/pink ) and goodness it was delish and I had the side salad which was very refreshing.. Genesee cream ale for desert and the wife absolutely loves the margarita on draft. Thank You Cook's staff for amazeball service and great food!

First time customer to the Mellow Mushroom. While the restaurant was busy, we were promptly…read moreseated. Our waiter was attentive. The food was good. I had a calzone and my daughter had a thin crust pizza. Both were very good.

This was quite possibly the worst pizza I have ever ordered…read more The crust was thin, soggy, and completely lifeless. The cheese was essentially flavorless. But those were somehow not even the worst parts. Let's talk about the garlic. They used jarlic. Not fresh garlic. Jarlic. The wet, pre-minced stuff sitting in a jar of acid and preservatives. And you could absolutely taste it. It tasted less like garlic and more like someone poured citric acid over the pizza. That sour, metallic, preserved-garlic taste was everywhere. If your kitchen can make pizza but cannot be bothered to chop a clove of garlic, that tells me pretty much everything I need to know about the food. And then there was the spinach. I paid EXTRA for spinach. They put ONE piece of spinach on each slice. Literally. One. I actually had to look at the pizza for a moment because I couldn't believe someone had intentionally prepared it that way and then sent it out the door. One lonely piece of spinach per slice isn't a topping. It's evidence that spinach was once in the building. Charging extra for that is absurd. So, to recap: soggy crust, tasteless cheese, garlic from a jar that tasted like citric acid, and a paid spinach topping rationed out one leaf at a time. This wasn't mediocre pizza. Mediocre would have been an improvement. This was remarkably bad. The person who took my order was pleasant, knowledgeable, and helpful. That is the entirety of the positive feedback I have. I would not order this again if it were free. Never again

Andrea was wonderful to work with and the food was…read moredelicious! Everyone complemented it and asked where I ordered from. I can't even tell you what got the most compliments because the salads, the sandwiches, the meatballs were all so so good. Thanks again. I will definitely be back.

From the owner: At Divine LUNCHES, we believe a quality meal can come in a box. Let us make your next business…read moremeeting stress-free, at least the business of eating part! As the name implies, we primarily do lunch, but with a pastry chef on staff, we can whip up an amazing tray of baked goods for a breakfast meeting or any morning you want your employees to feel special. Does your office prefer to graze? We can do sandwich trays and family-style sides. Do you have an evening event that doesn't need to be fully catered? Our sandwich and dessert trays would be a great solution. Want to go beyond mixed nuts at your next Bunco, bridge, civic, or book club? Give us a call!

Excellent food with even better service and attitude. Looking forward to returning often.read more

The burgers are great, we've had the OG, the Josie Sue and the mushroom Swiss and all were bursting…read morewith flavor, fresh and filling! The tots and fries are both tasty and the small easily feeds 2 people. I love that fountain drinks are now offered instead of just canned/bottled. The staff is always welcoming and friendly too! If you love a good smashburger this is the place to go!