Stopped in to watch a college football game midday Saturday. Half the people knew the bartenders (who were great - covering table service as well, duper friendly). Good fried chicken sandwich, good variety of NA beers. Would definitely swing by here again. read more

As someone who has come to this bar regularly to watch Knicks playoff games, I can confidently say I will never return after what happened during the NBA Finals last night. What this bar pulled was completely unacceptable. They were openly reserving seats at the bar for certain people while telling everyone else they were unavailable. There was no advertised reservation policy, no advance notice, and no opportunity offered to regular customers. Apparently, the only way to get a seat is to know the owner, know the bartenders, or be part of the inner circle. What made it even worse was that my group had been sitting at the bar, ordering food and drinks starting around 7:30 PM, only to be forced out of our seats at 7:45 PM. The reservation signs on those seats clearly stated they were reserved for 8:15 PM. We were paying customers actively spending money, yet we were removed 30 minutes before the supposed reservation time. That is absolutely egregious behavior. I've worked in sports bars and have owned sports bars in New York City. In all my years in the business, I have never heard of reserving seats directly at the bar--especially during a major sporting event. It goes against everything that makes a sports bar successful. Bar seats have always been first-come, first-served. That's Sports Bar 101. I've spent plenty of money here over the years because it was always a great place to watch big games: good atmosphere, sound on the TVs, and a fun crowd. Unfortunately, last night proved that customer loyalty means absolutely nothing. Regular patrons were treated like second-class citizens while preferred customers received special treatment. For a bar that markets itself as a neighborhood sports destination, this was incredibly disappointing, unprofessional, and frankly insulting. If you're planning to watch a major game here, don't assume you'll be treated fairly. Unless you're friends with the right people, don't expect the same experience as everyone else. There are plenty of other sports bars in Brooklyn that understand how to treat customers. After last night, I'll be spending my money there instead. I won't be back, and I certainly won't be recommending this place to anyone. Let's Go Knicks read more

The Commissioner is one of my favorite spots to watch a game in Park Slope. The frozen margarita is a standout (and even better with some snacking queso). They've also got a great lineup of local beers if that's more your speed too. It's the kind of place where you can cheer, snack, and sip without missing a play. Darts and photobooth available to round out the fun. Friendly staff, fun energy, and a crowd that actually feels like neighbors. read more

The Commissioner - Queso and beer - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very friendly great service and all are welcome. Conveniently located and great place to watch any and all games as well.

Cool little bar my first time trying them from just walking in off the street with friends @10pm. The service was amazing very attentive the food and drinks came fast. I really wanted wings they ran out early so we didn't get to try them. But the food and drinks were decent. read more

The Commissioner - Grilled cheese with bacon 6/10 - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love this bar. I wish it was my local. It's that welcoming, fun spot where it doesn't matter if you're a bunch of rowdy guys (occasionally me), or my septuagenarian aunt who lives up the block on Garfield...everyone is equally welcome and equally happy to be there. The Commish has got all the things you need in a bar: Good beer on tap. Good music. Good vibes. Good games (darts, shuffleboard, assorted board games). All the booze. Good prices. Good food. It's bar food, but it's good bar food. You can just rock chips and queso to snack on, or you can go heavier with a burger, wings, hot chicken, chicken fingers and all the sauces. Quite literally they asked my friend which sauces he wanted, and brought him like five different dipping sauces when he said all of them. He was very happy, because who doesn't love dipping fried shit in sauce. I deeply, deeply appreciate the friendly bartenders, and the endlessly patient server who very recently had to deal with us standing in her path during playoff football when it was too crowded for everyone to sit down. I love that they put a mezcal and soda in a pint glass, because I need that hydration, and the ratio is just better. The owners and staff are all laid back, and obviously don't take themselves too seriously, as evidenced by the review they had printed up on shirts for the staff to wear: "The Chevrolet rental car of Park Slope bars." Really, there are no downsides to The Commish, unless you lament the demise of Pork Slope...but I've been here more than I ever went to Pork Slope, so I think it's for the best. read more

The Commissioner - Photo wall - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Was in from Boston looking for a good place to watch the Red Sox Yankees wildcard game after a long day at Methodist Hospital. Went to a few places recommended on Yelp which were all pretty bad. This was by far the worst. The place was packed. The game was on with no sound, obnoxious music was blaring and not a single, not one single person was watching the game. The vibe was and experience was not that of a sports bar, just an obnoxious local place for Brooklyn hipsters and young professionals. I love New York and I love Brooklyn but as sports fan this place is garbage and not a place to go enjoy a big game. read more

The Commissioner - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

One of the funnest bars in Brooklyn. Walked into a trivia night on Wednesday to find a pretty packed bar. Almost all the seats were taken and standing room was starting to fill up...on a Wednesday. Bartenders were friendly and ultra attentive. There were three bartenders which was more than sufficient for a weeknight. At least two bartenders checked in as I finished or neared finishing my beer. Service was ultra responsive. Draft list was solid. Mostly crafts with a couple macro favorites and a couple local options too. I started with a smoked lager from Finback, followed up with a Pilsner from Victory, and finished with an amber from Alewife. I ate an order of Nashville chicken tenders with tater tots. This is a five star review, so I'll be a little more critical on food. Acceptable bar food, but there are usually better options for grub nearby depending on the time. Come here for the drinks, atmosphere, and entertainment. read more

Love this spot. Service is always great and we love the ambiance & prices! We stopped in here for a quick lunch and a couple beers and we were both really pleased with our meals! Our favorite neighborhood spot. read more

The Commissioner - Chicken Quesadilla - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Poor service. Poor food. Came in on a Tues afternoon. Almost no one there. Took forever to get served and the food was inedible. Buffalo Chicken sandwich. Only one bartender working. Disappointing because I thought this place would scratch that 5th Ave park slope gastropub itch. read more

The Commissioner - Buffalo Chicken sandwich $11 - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Solid place to grab an after work beer or weekend patio cocktail. Service is good. Definitely has a divey feel to it

Awesome local Park Slope bar with lot's of great peeps & neighbors. Amazing staff - family friend like atmosphere. Great drinks - good food & awesome people. read more

This place handles food with care. The Commissioner uses ingredients worth the effort. Fresh components, good flavor profiles, affordable costs, and pleasant servers. All staff members show natural friendliness. I'm looking forward to going back. read more

I rarely leave reviews like this, but I feel a responsibility to warn others, especially those who are POC, LGBTQ+, or women-identifying. My experience here was deeply traumatic. I was assaulted on the premises, and when I sought support, the manager responded with racism and misogyny--on Pride weekend, no less. Instead of concern, I was met with hostility and dismissal. The bartender at the time identified himself as Daniel Burns (though the manager refused to confirm if that was even his real name), and he showed no accountability when I raised my concerns. The entire environment felt unsafe and discriminatory. The blatant racism, homophobia, and misogyny I experienced and witnessed made it very clear that this is not a place for marginalized people. read more

First off the commissioner is a GREAT place to go. It is kid friendly but also great for adults. There are board games and darts to entertain! Their cheeseburgers are delicious and the service is phenomenal! It is such a cute and cozy bar and it is a must visit if you're in Park Slope! It is also awesome if you watch sports because they have tons of tvs and they are willing to take requests! I highly recommend it! -Poppy read more

Went to this place for the first time a week ago- food was great, but Christina is the one who made our night! She was so friendly and gave us great recommendations for drinks and chatted with me while I waited for my friend. Thank you again Christina! read more

Best sports bar in Brooklyn! Amazing service, affordable prices, great atmosphere, and open outside in the warmer months. I can't say enough wonderful things about The Commissioner read more

Love these guys! We were in town for a few nights, ended up pre-gaming here twice. Super friendly owner, good food, good vibes!

Very solid bar overall. Laid back atmosphere, plenty of TVs that show all football games, great prices, solid beer list and extremely good bar food. Split a burger and the Nashville hot chicken and both were amazing. Will be back for sure. read more

The Commissioner - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place has been the best bar in town ever since I can remember! Shoutout the tender who wears the bandana . Seriously though I've seen a lot of joints try and match the commissioners (mish) flow, but this place is truly the day one. High dive is right next door and this is a premium example of a place that looks up to mish, but can't compare. Mish is the A1 spot to chill, watch ball, or play games with your friends. Love when the duffle board table is active! Once again shoutout bandanna tender read more

Great place to hang out with some friends. This review is only on the drinks as my friend and I came here on the day of the staff's holiday party so they had a guest bartender and no kitchen staff as they were all at the party. As there was no food available for the day they let us bring food in. Great drinks and company with multiple screens so we were watching the Grammys while we were there. There are also 3 dart boards for some game time and a picture booth in the back. read more

Super friendly staff and quick service! I stopped here to grab a quick beer on the sidewalk and a hotdog. They have an assortment of booze - tap, can, well drinks - pick your poison ;D The seating outside was taken at 6 pm so be prepped for that! I didn't mind ... I got my drink on! read more

The Commissioner - Outside - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I lost my virginity at The Commissioner. It's that special. Bring a date, steal a table - or sit at the bar! - and make memories. Besides picklebacks or a shot and beer combo, you can't go wrong with their namesake cocktail. It packs a boozy punch. Friendly service. Credit accepted. There's outdoor seating, I think. read more

Lively and friendly, even to this country-come-to-town Arkansas hillbilly . I enjoyed the vibe and the cider! read more

The Commissioner - Hot Spiked Cider - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great atmosphere, great food, great tunes. Watched a college football game here on October 7 afternoon Son and I had Nashville Hot chicken. It was excellent. Great laidback venue. read more

The Commissioner - Bar area - Pubs Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great neighborhood bar with friendly bartenders and good food. Nice vibe. The Nashville hot chicken is legit

Love this neighborhood bar! They have so much fun games and a photobooth, and their outdoor patio is very nice to hang out in. Great drinks, and the food always hits, whether it's just French fries or a burger/wrap. A neighborhood gem! read more

Came here on a Saturday afternoon and have no complaints! They shut down the street so we got to enjoy some outdoor dining in great weather and good beer. I got the Victory Prima Pilsner and it was good! Even the chips and queso were really good too! I'd come back to this bar if I'm in Park Slope again soon! read more

Stopped in for lunch. The vegetable quesadillas were the best I have had, with lots of fresh veggies well cooked but still crisp. Good fries, too and very quiet at this time. read more

The outdoor dining section is heated just what you need to grab a socially distant drink and munch on some spicy tots. If you are looking for a place to hang look no further. The atmosphere is fun and alive at The Commissioner. The staff is friendly and they pour a great libation- **tip** get the spiked cider! This place is a gem and worth the visit! read more

- good sports bar, you can see TVs from any location inside in the bar - nashville hot is really HOT! listen to the waitress when she tells you I was tearing, sniffling, coughing, choking, couldn't swallow, my wife sed my tongue was still tingly, my skin was still hot and tingly whenever i touched anything - fish tacos were gobbled - good chicken tenders - tasty fries - good service - alright beer selection - margarita was alright - i didn't like the hot toddy read more

I love this bar! Last night I spent New Year's Eve at "The Commissioner" & was blown away by the atmosphere, friendly bartenders (Melissa & Kareem) and the perfect cocktails. Although this wasn't my first time here, last night was the best yet. One of the owners distributed hats & horns, and the bartenders gave everyone Champagne for a midnight toast. Great night! read more

Came to visit my daughter in Brooklyn... Great bar great music great service. I'll b back from LA

Solid pub food until 2 am?? What else do you really need. Solid ambiance and cool music.

Enjoyed some beautiful weather with a beer at the commissioner. Also had some chips and queso which were pretty good. No complaints about my experience but nothing that pushed it over the top, either. read more

Went to The Commissioner on Thursday evening. Just had one drink, but was impressed by the atmosphere, and would absolutely come back for tots. Quality: Decided to grab a beer after dinner and stopped into The Commissioner. I was surprised at how busy it was since it was a quiet Thursday for sports. It is a friendly bar that attracts locals and creates regulars. Quantity: Solid pours and stiff drinks. Value: $6-9 for a Draft Beer. Ambiance: The Commissioner is a sports bar located in Park Slope. With lots of televisions, different bar games including darts and shuffleboard, and good specials, it is a dive that draws a crowd. Crowd: Sports bar that gets packed even if no big games are on. Service: Efficient and helpful bartenders. Parking: Tough street parking. read more

It's cold, we're a little early for our dinner reservation - how about this place for a drink? Yes - this place. My dining partner went to look at what was on tap, "you better come look - I don't recognize anything." (He's a G&T and Cider guy) So excellent selection of on tap brews - local-ish and otherwise. Nice place to hang out for a little or a long while. read more

Great beer selection, I went with the IPA as usual Came here on a Tuesday evening and had to try the spiked cider - it's sooooo good. I highly recommend it. Probably the best cider I've tried ($10) There's also a selection of yummy food - burgers, sandwiches, salads, tots. So do try it. We ordered the fried pickles, which I would skip because they are super thinly slices like chips but also got the loaded tater tots (with queso and bacon) and it was delicious Super chill atmosphere, the service was great and very attentive, and I would definitely come back! read more

See all

The ambiance is unmatched and they play every NFL game on Sunday's! An amazing bar with great service and prices can't be beat

This bar is FANTASTIC!!!! Families, first dates, friends, sport lovers, it's a place for ALL. I come here with my kids and husband the most but we've also had late nights in our twenties here and even daytime hangs with parents from out of town. It is the absolute best. The owners are extremely kind, fun and involved in the neighborhood. The drinks and food are 10/10. We truly love the Commissioner, keep up the great work!! read more