The platonic ideal of an Irish bar. The Guinness is probably one of the best in the city, the vibe is great, and all the food options are pretty solid. The potato wedges or popcorn with a ton of cheddar are great snacks, and the sandwiches are really good too. read more

Great pints, cool pub. No clue why non Irish music was blasting here, definitely negatively impacted the ambience and turned us off from a repeat visit. read more

As close to a bar in Dublin or Cork that you find in the US. Amazing place. Close to Barclays and Brooklyn Paramount.

One of the best Guinness' I've had stateside. The ambience was a little louder on a Sunday night than I would have liked for an Irish pub. However, the service was stellar and the vibes were there. A cute place to check out and I loved the indoor and outdoor seating options! read more

Perfect bar this will b my new nbhd haunt, plan on getting a lot of crispy beers here. Sooooo excited to try the food tooooo

Soft Creamy Perfect Temperature Guinness. I love the lacing in the glass afterwards. Beautiful cozy ambience and good service. Cheddar popcorn enjoyable bar snack. read more

See all

Overall rating: 5 I love this spot. I've been here a few times, with friends, with dates, by myself. I love it! It can be a little crammed on popular days, but it gives me the homey feeling every time. I recently found out they play blue grass on Mondays and it's so fun. I love folksy music. The salad was surprisingly very good. The bartenders are so nice and I really just enjoy this place so much. Highly recommend if you live in the folksy, hippy, chill energy. read more

Hartley's - a bowl of salad with hard boiled eggs - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent spiced beef sandwich. The beef, cheese, and dense bread were all perfect. The side potato wedges were also great but the sandwich is a revelation. read more

Perfect neighborhood pub. Dimly lit, a few comfy tables and minimal decor. I've actually had some nibbles here too and I was pleasantly surprised by that quality of food. I love the grilled cheese and the chutney that comes with the potato wedges. The wedges are a bit thick for my taste but still good. Cocktails are pretty strong, so you get some bang for your buck. A great spot for multiple occasions: first date, drinks with a few friends (probably not more than 4 as the place is still pretty small), or just a solo date to read your book! Bartenders are very warm and friendly. 4.9/5 read more

All of the food is delicious, all of the vibes are immaculate, everybody on the staff is a sweetheart. One of the best bars in Brooklyn. Trad night is such a joy, if you are free on a Monday read more

Hartley's - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I am pretty torn on this place. I get that it is a more authentic Irish pub in NYC than you would get in, say, midtown ... but there is a lot left to be desired. The food is very meh so don't come here for dinner I would say. The drinks are fine. The Guinness is good (maybe even better than elsewhere). But the service is just atrocious. They really need more bartenders and staff given how busy and crowded it gets. It just feels like the scene is a lot of Brooklyn hipsters cosplaying Irish bargoers. I would go back, not on a Friday night ... read more

Had a great time here on a Monday night and there was music and enjoyed going straight up Guinness style. A good vibe place.

Love this place. The staff is so incredibly friendly. You'll be shocked how amazing the food is as well. A great spot if you want to drop in for a drink or a bite. It promises for a great conversation every time you go. read more

After this first visit, I already know that I want to return here soon. The bar is cozy and chill. This is the type of place where you go to spend time with your significant other or close friends without distractions and within a comfortable environment. The young Irish bartender is a friendly guy. He's very welcoming and attentive. I tried the beef sandwich on soda bread. It was simple yet phenomenal. The fat kid in me wishes I had ordered a second one. We also ordered the cheese plate with a couple cheese styles, some sliced apples, more soda bread, and honey. They paired well and we were very pleased. On this night we did wine. I highly recommend the Côtes du Rhône if you're a red fan. Enjoy. read more

Hartley's - It's a really long name for a beef sandwich - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I went on a Monday night. Placed was packed and service required a long wait. Management needs to invest in more labor or look to expand. Vibe was overwhelmed by crowd and noise. read more

It's been a while since I've been to Hartley's. I stopped by on a Monday night and I was so happy that I got hit with their "Music Monday." Traditional Irish music, played live mind you, is so soothing and it totally matches Hartley's cozy ambiance. The venue is small, sweetly decorated, and dark --perfect place to bring a date or chill alone with a warm Guinness or a cool glass of white wine. You must try the soda bread. It's the perfect snack and my Irish pal says that it tastes "just like home".... read more

Hartley's - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wonderful place with wonderful atmosphere. Bartender was quick, menu very straight forward

Irish Bars in New York City are fairly common. Some of them are truly authentic. And others are run by some guy who has never been the Ireland, then slaps an Irish name on the place, and it become a typical Bro bar. You have to be careful. Where Irish bars aren't so typical is Bed-Stuy. For Saint Patrick's Day this year I figured I'd check out something close to home and hope for the best. And that's exactly what I got. Desires for Saint Patrick's Day include, avoiding packed crowds, having some tasty Irish beers along with some whiskey, chowing on some genuine Irish food, and avoiding Manhattan at all costs (Its amateur hour) After some research I figured Hartley's was the place to start the day. I knew it wasn't that big but if we got there at the right time, we'd be good. We arrived around one and it just right. Not dead, but not crowded either. The bartenders were doing their thing, slinging back beers. After a bit we got a table and ordered some grub. Soda bread, Irish Stew, and one of the most unbelievable beef sandwiches I ever had. Eventually it was starting to get too packed and some guy starting waltzing in wearing some frat boy outfit and started to give me PTSD of a Saint Patrick's day of long ago in Manhattan. It was time to go. Passed by later and saw people were falling out of the place. We beat the crowd. But I'm glad I came. I'll be sure to come back, their brunch sounds great. The staff is friendly. The prices are right and it's a charming place. read more

This review is long overdue. I first came here with a friend who discovered this then new spot before I even noticed it despite it being closer to my apartment. We sought refuge on one of the coldest day of the year-- seriously, folks were advised not to go outside for long if at all-- and found it super cozy inside. We had cocktails and some soda bread to share that night. I've since been with a few friends and solo once. I generally order a cocktail, either off their menu-- the vibrant pink cacti drink is my current favorite-- or a classic. But I also have had beer sometimes. Aside from the soda bread (yum!), I've also enjoyed the brussel sprouts (yum yum!). The bartenders are always super sweet. When not with friends, I've chatted up some kind folks at the bar. I like the vibes here. Perfect little bar for a quaint evening or afternoon of drinking. I'll be back for happy hour soon (with all my trips, i can't believe haven't yet!) and perhaps to check out their brunch menu. read more

The ambiance both inside and out at Hartley's makes it the kind of neighborhood gem-of-a-pub that I dream about. Inside, the space is small and intimate with a variety of seating options (tables, stools at the bar, and high-tops). FYI, they have outlets everywhere! The cocktail program is unpretentious, as is the service. I had a well rye and later, a glass of a French red blend. The wine didn't impress me, but the food did. I ordered radishes (comes with butter and coarse salt) and Irish beef stew. Both were a welcome relief after a day of travel and airport snacks. I do wish that for the price of my meal, I could have gotten some bread to eat with the stew and radishes. I'll be back. read more

Great little Irish pub. Homey, intimate, and got some good beers on tap. Def recommend for date night or catch up with old friends.

I love Hartleys but it's difficult to express why without just dragging someone there. The closest I've gotten is: "Imagine you went to a friend's well appointed living room and for some serendipitous reason there was a full bar and kitchen. Oh and every Monday a bunch of lads come 'round and play rousing Celtic music" The food is the best kind, very simple, but made with the best ingredients and well. They have some of the best Guinness you can get in the city, It becomes a virtuous cycle, they never stop selling it so it's always as fresh as possible. read more

Taylor was the best bartender I've ever had! she connected with everyone and had such a great personality. the food was amazing as well. 12/10 would recommend read more

Solid little spot, emphasis on the little. Ok to be fair, we were here on Saint Patrick's day, and it was as busy as you'd expect an Irish pub to be. We were smart enough (read, Mitch was smart enough) to get here before it really heated up, and for being one of the first groups to show, we were rewarded with one of two tables the place had on offer. The folks working that day were as kind as could be, even as drunker and drunker folks showed up (or were created in house). We tried a bit of the food, Erin got a stew that was solid, and I had a bacon and cheddar covered soda bread which was hearty and delightful. By the third or fourth pint though, it was time to check out as the place was wall to wall, and bro-ing up a little to much for our liking . Would love to come check this place out on a non drinking holiday, if you're in the hood you should absolutely stop in read more

Great little place, very cozy . They have music on Monday nights that gives it a great Irish pub vibe. It's small but wasn't crowded. I'm sure it can get pretty packed though. read more

Hartley's - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is the cutest, little bar I have ever been to. Reminded me of home. Feels like you're walking into a little, local house. Busy, with good atmosphere and friendly people. Would recommend for a nice, quiet drunk read more

Hartley's - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Reviewing the localS! Cute bar! Perfect for a date. Good music when they have it. Not the cheapest but yummy food! I'm more of a dive bar person. But I come her when I want to class it up a little but not get too fancy. read more

Went there for a beer and a bite. The Guinness was ultra fresh. The ambiance... just like everyone says, no frill authentic. Bartender=chill. The stew, I should have asked them wwjen they made it. Tasted like several days ago. Disappointed based on All the reviews. Maybe next time. read more

Came here for st Patrick's day and boy was it packed. I suppose the fact that it is an authentic Irish spot is the reason why. Anyway, it is a small space but cozy with good tunes and what looked like good food (I didn't eat here) and good drinks. I would like to come back on another day and see how different the atmosphere is. read more

Recommended to us by a couple of people in Brooklyn and we loved the place. Jimmy, one of the owners, was bar tending. He was friendly and efficient keeping up with the ever growing crowd. We couldn't have been more delighted when the session started and the sound of our Irish favorites filled the air. The food was simple and delicious completing a great evening. Monday nights the music starts at 8:30 PM and the place really fills up. Cheers read more

Hartley's - Refreshing Cider! - Irish Pub Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They play the kind of music you'd hear on a Microsoft tablet commercial and serve IPAs to cringe thirty-somethings who scream-sing Happy Birthday on the weekends. read more

Hartley's is one of the best experiences I've had in a long. Long time. The food is on point and the service is great. The down-homey authentic Irish feel (+ hot Irish bartenders) don't hurt. read more

See all

This place is right down the street from me and I wish I made it inside more often! The bartenders are always personable, the drinks are cold and tasty, and if you choose to order food, it's simple, fresh, and hits the spot. This place is very unassuming while having a lovely, clean, charming and cozy vibe inside. I'm not a big drinker during the week, but they have live Irish music on Monday nights! So while a Monday night beer is not normally in the cards for me, it has been a few times. It's always a great atmosphere. This is the kind of place where you would WANT to be a regular and the bartenders to know your name. I need to get working on that! Worth a visit, great place for a casual drink or two or thee or more. A real neighborhoods gem. read more

Came here last Monday with a couple of friends, they have music playing on Monday nights. The place gives out a very cozy, casual vibe. Had a nice time here. 5-stars. read more

My hubby & I went to Hartley's in search of an low-key evening where we could enjoy a few drinks and grab a bite to eat. After traveling throughout Ireland, we had fallen in love with delicious food, brown bread and the Irish hospitality. Hartley's is the first bar in Brooklyn we have ever visited that was most reminiscent of our time in the Emerald Isle. Food: - Brown bread: DELICIOUS, my first bite into the bread immediately transported me back to Ireland. It was warm, fresh and perfect. I couldn't help but smother it in the creamy butter and a sprinkle of salt. - Cheddar toastie with bacon: open-faced brown bread with cheddar cheese and bacon perfectly toasted was perfect to share between me and my husband. - House-spiced beef of soda bread: STAR of the show! The beef was flavorful and melt in your mouth good. I will crave this sandwich on a regular basis. It was THAT good. Drinks: - Great selection of beer on tap as well as a cider and a few different options for red/white wine as well as some delicious cocktails. Basically, there is a drink for everyone. Ambiance: - A lovely, no frills pub. Small in size, but that adds to the cozy charm. Overall, the drinks were great and the food was delicious! This is not your typical bar food- I will crave the beef sandwich/brown bread and cannot wait to return and try the Guinness stew. The service was impeccable, Michael, the bartender/co-owner was so welcoming/hospitable. This is my new favorite spot!! read more

Excellent service. Lovely ambience. Good music. Loved the food, the brussels sprouts were perfectly done. Real soda bread. The cheesy toast has a magical cheddar. The bartender said they were going to start doing brunch soon. read more

See all

Came by last Saturday and had a great time. Ask for Stephen!! Have him pour you the best pint of Guinness in Brooklyn. Great place to unwind with a witty bartender. read more

Pretty good food and surprisingly so because this place looks like a casual Irish dive bar. Its also hidden on a side street so you wouldn't even know its there. Has a very romantic low light setting. The bartenders are friendly and they're prompt with bringing Food out. My favorite dish was the Brussels sprouts. Cooked and flavored well. I ordered the bread and butter and wouldn't do that again. The bread was very blah. But otherwise an enjoyable experience! read more

Hosted a private event at Hartley's for my husband's 40th birthday. Mike and his team were a pleasure to work with. Extremely responsive in planning communication, very clear and accommodating and I felt the whole experience was really well priced for the quality and service we received. Day of we had around 15 people and Mike behind the bar was awesome at handling my 1 off requests and generally managing a pretty energetic group. Food and drinks as always excellent. Great time and a chill crew to deal with. If you're looking to throw an event with an intimate, elegant but also casual and relaxed vibe, highly recommend Harley's. Also, that irish soda bread. Mmm. read more

Cozy, charming, authentic Irish pub tucked away right off Fulton Street. Having lived abroad in Ireland, Hartley's truly feels like going back there! The owners are very friendly and great to talk with. The drinks are great and so is the food. The potato leek soup is divine. Can't wait to come back! read more