We came hoping to eat outside in the great weather, but it was full, so we accepted a seat inside. Half full, but with a party in back, and it was loud for a while. The music lowered then conversation. The party had moved past announcements. Ordered Firefly 75s (a rife on. French 75) which were all made though in a tumbler rather than a stem. Caesar salad was ample for us to split before the large "Lord of Brooklyn" pizza-- the reason we came, with its smoked ricotta. Pie came, which was excellent, cracker crust, spicy sausage, but with plain ricotta. Good food, just not what we craved. The red wine we wanted took a while to order at all and even longer to arrive. We like this place. Ain't fancy, but has good pie. Just a touch off that night. We'll be back. Outside I hope. read more

Nice little bar in Bayridge. Loved the pizza. My wife had a calzone which was also delicious.

The food is just okay, very overpriced, but it's close to me so I tried to take my sweet Midwestern there for dinner, but rudely got yelled at to leave by a random man at the bar, with no reason except there wasn't room (there were lots of available tables); and the staff said nothing and seemed to defer to this guy. Walking out, there was a very nice young couple who were also kicked out who said this was the second weekend in a row that happened to them. Never going back again. read more

Yet another great example of why Bay Ridge may just be the great underrated culinary neighborhood in NYC. Throwback atmosphere and music, eclectic decor, and most important, seriously delicious grub. My pizza had a delightfully flat crust, tangy sauce, and a Pete among of cheese. My dining companion enjoyed her kale salad with chicken. Is there another visit on my future? I can only hope so. read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Last weekend I went to the Brooklyn firefly with my mom for brunch. We got the rice balls to start off and they were really tasty, I really liked the sauce that they used with them. I then ordered the calzone which was very tasty and worth the price. The food was good, but nothing really stood out to me, I would definitely recommend this place for anyone looking for a new brunch spot in the neighborhood. read more

See all

So the drinks and size of the margaritas for 31 and change for two way over prices . Plus tip for 2 33-34 bucks is way to much and they over load you ok ice and to use the small glass. Or coming back here again. And barely any tequila in it. Server was shaky or over whelm b it I just got up and went to get drinks myself . Stop cheating the customer but serving extra ice i really don't like businesses like this and when they do this . Waste of money . We went to near by place and it was cheap and great and alcohol was no less and definitely less ice. read more

I went here for dinner and the vibe was soo chill after a stressful day. The pizza was amazing and the server was very friendly! I will definitely come back here one day with my friends! read more

See all

Food was very good. We had only apps but they were all good. Nice atmosphere, music was a little loud but not terrible. Service could've been a little more attentive, but they weren't bad by any means. Would definitely return. read more

See all

Tucked into the corner of a beautiful Brooklyn neighborhood, Brooklyn Firefly feels like it's been part of the block forever, in all the right ways. I came in with six buddies for the first time and was immediately struck by the vibe, welcoming, stylish, and full of soul. The pizza? Top-tier. Crust, toppings, balance, all dialed in. The meatballs? Just right, classic, comforting, and full of flavor. Drinks were solid, and while there wasn't live music that night, I hear they host it on select evenings. It's the kind of place that feels both familiar and special. Brooklyn Firefly isn't just a meal, it's a reminder of what a neighborhood spot should be. read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I loved Mama's meatballs--so flavorful and delicious! The place has a nice, cozy, and artistic atmosphere. I'm really happy to have found such a great restaurant in Bay Ridge. Would definitely come back again. read more

See all

**The Brooklyn Firefly** - 1/2 Cozy Bay Ridge spot with excellent inventive thin-crust pizzas (Scalabesh and Saturday Night Fever are highlights), solid draft beers, and a great live jazz & blues vibe. Dog-friendly patio is a bonus. Friendly service, reasonable prices, and real neighborhood charm. Highly recommended for pizza + music nights. read more

Happy hour only at the bar is ridiculous! Give me (and the rest of us a break) what a lame rule!

My daughter and I decided to have lunch at this establishment. From the outside of this place it has a cute vibe... Once inside the ambiance was cute and the hostess sat us down immediately. The menu was short and to the point ... which we both like and wasn't difficult to choose what we wanted to eat. On the menu the pizza selection had lots of different specialties which was new to us ... We ordered what we know and the Margarita pie was "DELICIOUS " it did not disappoint. When we go again we will have another pie on the menu with its unique flavors... The server was always asking us if we needed anything else and we found that delightful.... The bartenders were polite . Overall we had a great time and great food.. Two thumbs us read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Margarita large pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The Firefly has quickly become our new favorite place! We were pleasantly surprised by how much we enjoy this bar--it's truly the best. We now go out of our way not! to make reservations so we can sit at the bar, which is the coziest and most beautiful space, reminiscent of something you'd see on TV. One thing that stood out is a sign stating they reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. While this is understandable, it does feel a bit unwelcoming. However, the atmosphere is warm, and the bartender is incredibly nice, which contributes significantly to our comfort and enjoyment. We sat at the tables and the waiter got a lot of things wrong last time so we're just gonna stick to the bar because the bartender is great. The pizzas are fantastic; we love the variety they offer, and the two different sizes make it very reasonable. The kick in the a** and the white pizza with fig are the best! The appetizers are also good . They do a special fire fries which is similar to smashed potato, the giant meatball which isnt really worth the money but its still yummy, the rice balls are much better than average and the arugula salad has a lot of taste with a not too sweet dressing and gorgonzola. I did notice I was charged for a side of aioli that I didn't receive, but that didn't dampen our experience. We love the drinks and the beers.! Overall, we had a blast and are looking forward to returning every week. We've already been three times and are headed back next week! read more

See all

Food is fine. Bartenders are unwelcoming. I've been here multiple times - both at the bar and at tables. The food is fine - pizza is tasty, salads and sides are good. The bartenders are truly unfriendly. Working from home, sometimes I need a change of scenery. At least 3 times I have come in here alone, and not one of those times have any of the bartenders been friendly or welcoming in any way. They take your order and often walk to the other end of the bar and then sit there looking at their phones or talking to other staff. I've had to flag them down even while the bar is empty just to get service (the check, more napkins, a glass of water, etc.). I just ran into a friend today and we were talking about places and the first thing he said is how much he dislikes the bartenders at Firefly. It's a shame, because there are not a lot of places where you can both eat and drink at the bar in the NW part of Bay Ridge. Do better, Firefly! read more

Super fun place to enjoy a meal with friends and family. Server was very nice. Prices are high but they are high everywhere these days. Vegan and traditional options. We shared three kinds of pizza, the fries and an order of arancini. All were delicious! Loved sitting outside on a warm evening. read more

A fun and funky find in Bay Ridge - where you can never starve! My friend and I walked in to a friendly greeting, and sat in one of the booths with a cute retro jukebox. In fact, the whole place has a great retro vibe, including art and music! I had the 86th Street pizza - which was one of the best homemade I've ever eaten. With an egg cream, of course. Was glad to see that. My friend had the Margherita, which she enjoyed. We ended up taking extra slices home. But since there's always room for dessert, we shared a tartufo. The waitress was sweet and accommodating. I'm so happy we found the Firefly, and I'm definitely coming back! read more

Love this place, my partner and I come here about once a week and I finally got around to writing a review to show my appreciation. We love the vibes and the food is incredible. The only downside to the food is it's incredibly oily, but other than that it is PERFECT. Amazing vegan options, the San Gennaro is my favorite. Chrissy (sorry if it's spelled wrong) is super sweet and attentive. Also the hand painted signs and overall branding is superb. read more

1. Quality control inside the kitchen was absent. A party of four. We ordered two pies and one calzone-- all of which were very overcooked-- the crust, bottom and top, was charred on both the pies and the calzone! The interior dough was not overcooked and the pizza was edible, but the crust was actually blackened. It was at the high side over overcooked. Very overcooked. I kept checking in with my party to make sure it was okay. It turns out that they were too polite to admit it to me during dinner but afterwards everyone concurred that the food quality was poor. I had initiated the dinner by inviting everyone and they felt sorry to tell me they weren't enjoying it. And even though I was dissatisfied, I didnt want to be loud about either to my group or to the staff. And I decided not send the food back especially since it was a birthday celebration for my mother-in-law and sending a whole spread of food back to the kitchen is just a huge bummer, and adds an element of tension to the dining experience. But the poor quality of the food did in fact dampened the celebration, and we were all disappointed in the end. The bill came to almost $200 including tip and it feels insulting to have been served such subpar food. My in laws finished eating, but they left a massive plate of burnt crust behind. 2. Also the waiter did not once come around to the table to ask us how our food was. He was a nice guy but the service was LACKING. Before we ordered dessert I told him about the pizza being burnt. Which was met with an insincere "sorry about that." 3. While making the reservation, I indicated it was for a birthday celebration. That fact went completely overlooked or disregarded by the staff. Sad attention to detail. The customer service was negligent. In conclusion: We've eating at Brooklyn Firefly on multiple occasions. But after this experience we are unlikely to return, even though we live in the neighborhood. And extremely unlikely to recommend the place. And we've already shared about our experience with colleagues and friends. And we wanted to actually write a review here and elsewhere, even though I haven't reviewed anything online for years. Don't waste your money. Very disappointing experience. read more

Love the decor and vibe of this place. I was here in the past when it was Yellow Hook Grill. The waiter was attentive and kind. The pizza pies and calzone were delicious! Their dough was so good and their crust had the perfect crisp. I did not like their Brooklyn egg cream drink so they took it off the bill. It was basically just syrup. Other than that, everything was really good and would love to return. read more

See all

Strolling through Bay Ridge, you have your pick of food and drink spots representing any culture you can think of. That being said, there is something very comforting about the corner neighborhood pizza joint. Brooklyn Firefly takes you back to those times, but with alcohol, live music, and a backyard. I ordered the Margarita Italiana, which had no real flavor connection to a margarita, but was super refreshing nonetheless. Imagine a spiked punch with a hint of citrus - perfect summer drink. My friend scarfed down one of Mama's Meatballs, which was no small feat. Scanning the patio area I noticed pizza after pizza arriving to peoples' tables. It was such an eye tease given that my belly was full from having had dinner elsewhere. Is it ironic that I saw my first firefly of the summer in their backyard? I'm taking it as a sign to go back for slices and live music. read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Margarita Italiana - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Despite my having been here a few times already I've never gotten around to sitting down and composing my thoughts about The Brooklyn Firefly so I'm going to use a recent visit to resolve that. For many of the Bay Ridge lifers, this restaurant occupies the space that was formerly the home of the famed Lento's pizza. This space was known and loved for its thin-crust pizza. At the time, this was not a common thing but now you can get it in a lot of places. Lucky you. Thinking back to my time before this latest visit, I recall having half of a wonderful cheese pizza with another friend and a few cold beers. They have a full bar, but I am not really the biggest spirits person so a Budweiser or Coors Lite suits me fine unless I am on one of my not drinking months. That pizza was super tasty and didn't last long since we were both quite hungry. It's easy to eat four slices of this since its not as thick as most pizzas. Fast forward to this past Saturday I was out walking with a friend and we met up with others who were heading there for some cocktails and decided to join them to catch up. We decided to sit at the bar area in the front. Spatially speaking there is a lengthy outdoor dining area and several tables in the rear of the restaurant. They raved about the cocktails but I was not drinking this time around. I think one of them was called The Gelston and my friend had a Pumpkin beer. Eats were decided upon so we ordered up some Rice Balls (there are three to an order) and a pizza with half-spinach and half sausage. Good stuff for sure. There is a free WiFi signal so one can do their check-ins and foodie captures and shares across their networks. The prices are very reasonable and the staff quite friendly. I'll be coming back sometime in the future for sure. read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Part of the bar at The Brooklyn Firefly. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great neighborhood place with a lovely patio and good pizza. We went on a Sunday afternoon and were seated quickly on the dog-friendly patio. The service was friendly and attentive. We had the spinach and mushroom rice balls, fries with lemon ricotta dip, a large Verrazano boy, and a large Saturday night fever minus the meat. Everything was fantastic! Lots of vegetarian options, or the ability to make things vegetarian (they also have plant-based meats for those who like them). read more

A cool Brooklyn spot this a subtle mix of Hip Hop and pizza. There is a bar that greets you when you walk in. Towards the back is a cool dining area. There is outdoor seating as well. You can take in the sights and sounds of BK while enjoying a pie There are vegan options. Today I had a vegan calzone. It was a good size and filling read more

See all

My boyfriend and I have been here a couple of times. We love the meatball here. The rest of the food is just fine. Some pizzas are good like the one with a nice of meats. The drinks are solid. read more

See all

It's such a darling spot for darlings. You can talk the night away with a beau or chat up a storm with your gals, this spot hits home for many different reasons for dining out. The casualness makes you feel comfortable no matter who you're with, and if you're still nervous for whatever reason, order yourself some liquid courage while you wait for some delicious pizza. What I found weird is the restroom downstairs for the ladies... the faucet doesn't work. Or at least it's only giving out scalding hot water and the other spouts give out sad dribbles of semi-cold water. It's like, "Do I wanna boil my skin off or do I wanna leave without washing?" I'll let you think about which path I took. read more

I went to the bar with a friend recently. The drinks and live music were great! The staff is also very friendly.

Cool place, great vibes. Loved seeing the history in pics along the walls. Came on a Sunday afternoon, not too busy. There was a wedding party so the dj was pretty good. Pizza was delish paired well with the arugula salad. I'd come back to try more on the menu. read more

See all

Warning brutally honest review: the staff is nice and the place has real potential, however the food is beyond terrible, I was violently Sick from here, had to be some kind of cross contamination in the kitchen. Beyond sick, you cannot pay me enough to eat from here again - it was the chicken. Absolutely horrible place needs to be shut down, yellowhook grill was great, place needs new owners who actually know what their doing and know food. Don't even get me started on the blonde woman there, total piece of crap read more

We stopped by Brooklyn Firefly recently for some pizza, and had a great experience dining outside in their yard. The nice thing about their outdoor seating is that it isn't in the street or on the crowded sidewalk, but is a large, private space outside the restaurant (the same outdoor seating they had before the pandemic). The tables were spaced apart, and everyone wore masks. The menu has lots of pizza options, as well as rice balls, calzones, sandwiches, and desserts. We got one of their vegan pizzas (they have 4 options) - the Shore Road, which came with tomato sauce, house-made vegan mozzarella, caramelized onions, mushrooms, garlic, and basil - and it was really tasty. They have a good pizza dough with a crispy, chewy crust, and the toppings, especially the caramelized onions, were delicious. Since I'm more of a toppings person than a crust person, I did wish there were more toppings that extended all the way to the crust, but that's just personal preference and very minor. Looking forward to trying more of their pizzas, and hoping it stays warm enough to eat in the yard! read more

See all

I've had the opportunity to dine at the restaurant both during Covid (outdoor seating) and have had delivery a couple times as well. I'm not going to talk too much about the food except to say that the pizzas that we've had are all delicious. The thing my family and I were incredibly thankful for during our in-person dining experience was how helpful and pleasant our server was. A member of our family has a food allergy, and our server took the time out to check and also double check in some cases that nothing we were going to order would cause an issue. It was this attention to detail and caring/understanding attitude that kept us ordering for delivery as well as keeping them in our rotation for safe places we can eat in the neighborhood. read more

This is a wonderful neighborhood pizza restaurant! The ambience inside is really lovely - a good balance between casual and classy; Low lighting, but unpretentious vibe. Bar in the front, some tables , then a back area with more of a dining room setup. We sat in the middle area, but could see the back was filled up and there was live music. The food is outstanding. A little expensive, but you're getting quality for the dollar. I had one of their calzones and it was loaded up with cheese and fillings. My wife is gluten- and dairy-free so she got a GF/ Vg pizza and said it tasted like ... a really good pizza! Nothing compromised. The truffle fries were excellent as well. Our server was very nice and all the staff were friendly as well. A great spot! read more

Love the decor old school 50s pizza parlor feel. Staff super friendly. I only ever tried the pizza and it's ten out of ten !! Come here read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Margarita Pie PERSONAL - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Not much went right here tonight. We reserved a booth for 2 on Resy but the guy out front told us "sorry, the booths are all reserved." We explained that we were one of the ones who reserved it, but he did not want to hear it. We showed him our email confirmation stating we had a booth clearly, but he was really short with us. We had to ask for a manager, who did not come out, but we were accommodated. There was no music, which happens a lot lately. There was a private party in the back, which surely brings in good money, so can't really blame them, but the live music used to make this place special. Finally, the pizza was very mediocre. It was underbaked, not hot, and the dough was floury. 2 stars for the lovely waitress. We're gonna have to look for a new pizza restaurant, minus the jazz unfortunately. read more

I've lived in Bay Ridge for quite some time and I can hardly believe I've never been to The Brooklyn Firefly. My friend and I came on a Friday evening around 5:30PM. There were plenty of picnic tables available outside until groups of families arrived with their [not so well behaved] children. There's also plenty of seating inside but it's pretty dark and cavernous, though it may be nice on the days when there's live music. We shared The Big Ragu [$12] which seems to be The Brooklyn Firefly's signature recipe. I'm not someone who seeks out rice balls so I don't think I've ever had one but this was one excellent. The outside was perfectly fried, and the inside was creamy with the rice, beef, and assorted vegetables. They laid in a somewhat chunky tomato sauce, I did in fact scoop up some of the tomatoes with my fork. There are three rice balls to an order. I had the personal sized Saturday Night Fever [$18]. Even though it is meant for one, it could most definitely feed two, with about 6 generous slices each. Regardless, you may not want to share, this very well may be one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Caramelized onions, hot honey, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, and of course, tomato sauce. There was sweetness, there was spice, there was a little of everything and it was quite nice. Even the crust was crunchy and chewy with perfect char marks. I also had the Margarita Italiano [$13], made with grapefruit juice, so it was slightly different from what one would expect of a margarita. It was fine, it wasn't the best margarita I've ever had. My friend had a Shirley Temple [$3] and she seemed to enjoy it. Splitting the bill down the middle, it was $35 each, and roughly $40 after tax and tip. read more

See all

Best pizza I've ever had! Got the one with hot honey on it! Delicious! Service was fantastic and the decor and atmosphere is top notch

Cool ambiance, kind service! Subpar pizza unfortunately. Ultimately, the margherita and mushroom were quite good, but nothing particularly extraordinary. The vodka pie was bad :( For the margherita, the sauce to cheese ratio was super different across the pie, it was odd. The cheese was bland unfortunately. For the mushroom, it was the best of the bunch. But a tad too doughy! The vodka pie was undercooked and almost raw in the center. We had them put it back in the oven, which turned it into an ok pie. But I feel like the vodka pie was bad enough to merit a 3 for the food as a whole. Also, again, similar problem to the marg, some slices had sauce, some totally didn't?? I'd go back, but I won't be fighting to do so by any means, especially in Brooklyn. read more

Ambience and food is top tier the jazz music is calming and great for a local hideout and vibe read more

The Brooklyn Firefly - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We grabbed a drink at the bar while waiting for a table. There was a live dj and great vibes all around. Since it was really packed, the service was on the slower side. We ordered some of the server's recommendations. The appetizers were disappointing, the mama's meatballs and rice balls were ordinary and could've done without. I always need a white pie, the truffle mushroom needed more flavor but the fresh spicy flavors of the kick in the ass pizza was really good. I'll be back for that and their yummy cocktails too. read more

See all

Super cute atmosphere and delicious food. Definitely the best pizza we had in Brooklyn (and that's saying something!). The salads were generous and fresh - especially loved the pear and arugula with Gorgonzola cheese. So so tasty! Good prices and friendly service. read more