The food here is fantastic! Came here one evening with my girlfriend for some drinks/dinner and we had a great time. I ordered the buffalo chicken sandwich with fries and she got the nachos with cheese and chicken and it was phenomenal! It was easy to get to and the service was A+. Definitely hit them up next time you're in the area, you will not be disappointed. read more

Hostess was nice and attentive. Waiter was friendly and very attentive and checked on us frequently. Ordered the "RI" Calamari for an app. This was priced at $21 which is pretty steep for Calamari appetizers in general. We got a lackluster scattered plate of sad, poorly breaded and soggy calamari. The breading was falling off most of it especially when you'd try to fork it up. The cherry peppers draped over the ones in the center added acidity, but further sogged out the already not well prepared squid. The hangover burger was cooked to medium rare, as I asked and was tasty. Fries and onion rings were totally fine. My table mates both got 2 different chicken paninis and thought they were mediocre. Some of the wait staff were joking around throughout. Didn't seem like there was a great management team in place. I'd definitely look around for other places next time I'm in that area read more

We stopped in here on a recent trip through Oyster Bay. It used to be Canterbury's, and if anyone remembers that place, aside from the name change and a few new decorations on the walls, it looks almost the same. The food actually wasn't too bad. As an appetizer, we got the Rhode Island Calamari, which was fantastic! I ordered the Fig & Prosciutto Flatbread pizza as my entree. It was good. I liked the combination of sweet and salty. The people I was with both ordered a burger, which did look good. The service was okay, I guess. It took the waiter a while to get around to taking our orders, and then even longer for it to come out from the kitchen. My food was lukewarm, but I was hungry, so I ate it. The place was nice and clean and well-lit. Okay, so here's why I'm leaving a 1 review: At the end of the meal, the waiter came over, handed us the bill, and said if we went online and left a 5 review, then showed the review to him, he'd give each of us a free beer. I find this to be dishonest, so here's your review. I don't need to be bribed with beer. read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Classic Burger - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Not busy initially and service was sparse Water has to be prompted to be refilled Hamburger wasnt a good portion and side dish sparse Then it's became similar to Applebee's/ friendlys... There was peace/quiet which Became families galore. Good 4 them bad to hear one another talking. Parking wasn't available.... had to park around back and locate spot They had a rear entrance Place was clean Toilets had paper Won't be back there's taby's with better taste and Freshness and ample portions next door Costs were a bit high even for my neighborhood read more

A nice local lunch spot. All dishes we ordered were quite pleasant and tasty. The wings and fried calamari were surprising great! The steak was not a winner though. Very very fatty. SKIP this! Clean establishment and good service. Good for laid-back brunch. read more

See all

Teddy's has been my local watering hole since it opened. Always like family in there! Good food, good friends and good drinks! They keep em' coming for me! Love Teddy's! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

The food was really good and the service was too! The falafel burger is a lot of bun, so my partner peeled the bottom off and doubled it up, but said it was delicious. I can attest to the fact that his fries were hot and tasty, too! I had the fig and prosciutto flat, which, while not what I was expecting (it's not actually covered in sliced figs-there is a tasty figgy jelly like substance drizzled over flat), was also really good. Definitely look at photos from fellow yelpers for an idea before you order-wish I had! The atmosphere was warm and friendly & we'll definitely be back! A whole bonus star for not forcing plastic straws on customers & the water carafes at the tables-nicely done! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Cute and cozy! Perfect for a damp March day! - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Yeah it was ok. May even be 4 stars. We were there with a large party and the food was so-so. It could have been this way due to the large party, idk. Love the musician in the corner. The night we went, the guy was excellent! It's a charming, warm, comfy and cozy place in the winter. It's got New England charm. The town is super cute too. Would love to return and explore the shops. read more

Casual, good for families. Pub food. Nostalgic atmosphere decorated in honor of Oyster Bay's own President Theodore Roosevelt which is entertaining. Service was nice. Atmosphere good. Space fun and honors the local communities. Food was ok. If they focus a bit more on the food it could be great!!! Food is good, but not great. Can be though. It really can be! I'll go back in a few months and try again. read more

Excellent service. Friendly and open atmosphere great place to go during the Tuesday car shows. Fran was great!!

Great staff great food love this place Fran and Tuna at the bar make a mean drink outdoor seating and good amount of space on the inside live music on the weekends !! read more

Fav spot in Oyster Bay. Staff is amazing and spoils my family from time to time with green tea shots on the house. Type of place where you can listen to live music with just a drink and apps and leave oh so satisfied! read more

American The site of the old Canterbury Ales, Teddy's Bully Bar evokes memories of 26th president who summered in Oyster Bay. The place hasn't changed a whole lot from the old CA days- maybe it is a tad brighter in there and the bar apparently has been reworked. Speaking of the bar, which is where I sat, it seems to me that something has changed here. I could be wrong but either: I have either shrank in stature quite a bit The floor got lowered somehow The barstools shrank The bar got raised. Since a long time has passed from when I visited last, I'm going to go with somehow the bar got raised higher. Was sitting there and the bar was almost level with my shoulders. I mean, I'm not a midget but sheesh- I felt like a little kid in there while sitting at the bar. Something was off there. Beyond the odd bar (or stool) size, the food was decent. I went with a BBQ pulled pork sandwich with fries. Food came out fast and was hot- maybe too fast but I suppose you have to make the BBQ ahead of time. Fries were cooked well. Sandwich portion size was somewhat small but they put in a lot of fries, so your call if it was worth $18 or not. I washed it all down with an adult beverage and headed out - Probably a decent place to visit if in the area - not sure if I would make a special trip to try it. I would call it a solid 3-star kind of place. Parking on the street or in the lot behind. read more

Came in here for lunch. First it's a cute place, second it's great for kids. My son was in his glory here. $10 for kids is basically food, drink, dessert yay. My burger was okay. My mom was loving her lunch and service was good. I'd recommend this place. Good instagram whoever runs that because that's how they got my attention :P read more

See all

Nice food. Pretty cheesy. The servers were nice and polite. It took pretty long for the order to come tho. read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Mac n cheese with buffalo chicken - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

I am local and keep coming back hoping to find a dish I love but unfortunately so far everything is just kind of okay. My kids do love the chicken tenders and say they are the best around but a very small portion. I recently had the French dip and it was so dry! Even with dipping in the au jus it was like sand in My mouth. Since it's convenient and my kids like it I'll try again snd hopefully find something that I can use as my stand by, but so far I usually leave feeling disappointed. Staff is super nice tho so there's that! read more

Kids are running the joint! Bottom line-kids are running the joint. This was our 3rd time visiting this place since the change from CANTERBURY ALES. First 2 times we sat at the bar and had a kid-early 20-something year old tending bar. Both times texting on their phones and chatting with each other. Had to interrupt them to get some sort of service. Tonight we went to try having dinner. Waitress asked if we would like to start with appetizers. We ordered appetizers. Then, we sat there - our appetizers came out - no asking if we had decided on main courses. So, we eat the appetizers. We finish the appetizers. They clear our appetizers. Then our waitress asks if we would like to order main courses. By this time I am half-full and half-pissed. My wife was still hungry so we ordered a sandwich and we split it. After finishing our waitress is standing by the computer chatting with another young waitress. After flagging her down to get her attention I ask for the check. Still had to wait. Every time she passed our table she would look at me and snap her fingers as if she was thinking: "Oh, damn! Their check!" this happened twice. Finally got the check. Paid. Left the first recommended gratuity (20%, 25% & 30%). Each time I have been there I haven't seen anyone over the age of 25 working there. No manager (unless he hides in the office). Food wasn't bad-ok, I guess. Service stinks because nobody is watching the kids. Ah, Phooeey! NEXT! read more

I used to come here regularly, but just visited and really just meh. It's nice enough inside, supposedly to look like a T. Roosevelt era bar, but it's too faux. Nice enough service, but the Caesar salad was the worst I've ever had, bagged iceberg with bottled dressing, come on, get a chef. The burger and fries were fine, but just too underwhelming to recommend. Not inexpensive, either. read more

Unexpectedly amazing! My sister and I used to ask patrons coming out from Teddy's if they liked the food and most of the responses we got were "Meh - typical pub fare. We come for the drinks and the music." We were turned off by those words - until one night, we decided to try something new because none of us had a hankering for Tabby's or Wild Honey or any of the other places nearby. It was one of the best meals we've had. I ordered the chicken kebabs with the jerk sauce on the side. The sauce was unexpectedly light and the next time I get it - I think I'd get the jerk sauce on the chicken. The kebabs were tender and the yellow rice pilaf to go with it was perfection. We sat outside. My sister's boo got the fish and chips, my sis got a caesar salad, and mum opted for the falafel burger. Everyone was beyond pleased with their noshes. We also got some beers and I got the Paloma. Everything was delicious! I went back another time with my bestie and sat indoors opposite the bar. She ordered a hamburger - it was very messy but also delicious. We got lucky and had some live music and it was really nice. I tried the falafel burger without dairy - it was alright but I think I would have enjoyed another round of the kebabs more. There's only one restroom per gender and it was quite a wait when I needed to use it. The stall is too small - No one can sit or hover over the toilet with the stall door closed - better to remove the stall, since it is a one person restroom anyway - and have more room to maneuver oneself instead of being awkwardly angled. Soap & toilet paper refills need to be better handled. Walk with a tissue - just in case! Happy eats! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Inside - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Food and atmosphere are really good. Drink prices were fair. We like that they have a popcorn machine and Halloween candy for the kiddos. The service is in need of improvement. Getting seated at our table was good, but it took us quite a while to get our order in and then getting the check took way too long. read more

Avoid at all cost place is gross. Frozen food. Bad staff, warm beer, nothing professional at all.

Can only comment on the food based on delivery at the brewery next door. The convenience can't be beat but the food quality was pretty mediocre. We sampled the margarita pizza, Mac and cheese with fries, burger and chowder. The burger was the best thing for sure but it was quite salty. The pizza was a no-go and the fries were soggy with the Mac and cheese (maybe from condensation in the container??). The chowder was a bit thin and quite $$$ ($12 for a cup). Maybe we will try additional items next time we go to the brewery?? It's the convenience that gets you! read more

The good: location. Right in the middle of it all! Decor: love it! Really embraces the surrounding areas and rich local history Menu: lots of options for everyone! Music: live band while we were there. They sounded great and the volume was perfect! The not so good: Wait staff: our waiter seemed enthusiastic at first blush but not once did he check on us, we'll until it was time to give the check TO us. We went through the carafe of water pretty quickly and it sure would have been nice if our waiter refilled it for us. The place was pretty empty so there really is no excuse other than they just didn't give a crap The food: sandwich's , burgers all cooked and presented nicely. Cole slaw comes in a little Dixie like cup that you might do a jello shot in. I'd rather you give me no coleslaw than a half a fork full of coleslaw. Burger isn't house made and the fries certainly aren't. Disappointing considering the bill was $82 but I guess this is the high rent district. Not a bad place if you want to hang at the bar and drink and if I lived closer I'd probably visit once in a while. I'd say this is a 3-3.5 star place. read more

Came here with my son for dinner, he had a kids meal which came with free ice cream and I had the new mahi mahi sandwich along with the Orange Creamsicle spring cocktail, everything was amazing!!! The atmosphere and the staff were great! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Orange Creamsicle Martini - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Nice bar and grill restaurant. very open and airy. Bar area is equal with tvs playing various sports. Bar tender was extremely friendly and attentive. Traditional Buffalo wings were lightly breaded and cooked to perfection. Grilled chicken panini was flavorful and toasted perfectly. If you're in the area looking for casual eats, this place is a nice choice. read more

This place is just 1 whole mess, staff would rather talk to friends and drink than deal with customers. Bartenders are slow and just not that good. They used to have a good bar staff here only reason we ever went back. But now it's all down, food is all frozen and looks like zero effort put into it. Our last waiter was a tall white kid who was just to busy saying hi to all his friends then give service. Place is more of a local hangout than anything else. read more

Rene provided us great service! Was a great place to bring the kids. Food was great and plenty of beer and drink options.

I've been following Teddy's on instagram for a while now and finally made my way in. I was so happy I did. The theming in this bar is so good, very old timey, a great nod to our past President. We ordered some cocktails and the muscles to snack on while we listened to live music by Joe Pianos. Such a fun evening. They even have popcorn! Can't wait to come down for a full dinner, theres a dining room in the back. See you soon! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Teddy's Tea and Old Fashioned - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Stopped in for a late lunch and a few drinks and had a very nice time. My wife ordered Edith's panini , and I had the bison burger and there wasn't anything left. Prompt service with a smile . Definitely will come back when in the Oyster Bay/East Norwich area .. read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Bar area - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Food , service & ambiance!! Nice location with live music, excellent bar.Excellent spot for couples to get together.

great food and music. Guinness is great and the staff is the best. I will definitely come back

Good food and nice vibes. Came here for a late lunch and ordered the veggie panini. My parents got the fried oysters, crab cakes, and poke salad. The oysters and crab cakes were very good, lot of crab. The veggie panini was mediocre, but the fries saved the show. I love a place that does fries good, crispy exterior and fluffy inside. Loved that all of the fries were crispy and you weren't stuck searching for the crispy ones. The service was decent. We were seated immediately and our waiter was nice. They were quite packed and only had two servers, but the service was still good. Nothing was outstanding, but also nothing to complain about. A great pace to grab a bite to eat and enjoy a drink. read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Fried oyster - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

This was a great surprise. We went to explore oyster bay and like most places that are seasonal... not much was open! Apparently in summer it's much better. With 3 kids and 1 dog we were looking for a warm place to eat. Teddy's was perfect. Great selection of beer. The lady who served us was very attentive to us. We sat next to the fire place that was a nice touch. We had burgers and fish&chips. Everything was fast and tasted so good. Love this local shop with a great welcoming vibe. We will be back. read more

See all

Teddy's has great food, good prices, and an excellent staff. It's right downtown in Oyster Bay, and connects well with the history of the town. So why only three stars? Two critical flaws. First, it's pretty bright, and that detracts from the ambiance, especially in the evenings. Second, they have live music on Friday and Saturday nights, and other times: and the bands are quite good. What's wrong with good live music? Nothing! I'm a musician and my bands have frequently played in similar spaces. But... The music is so critically loud that you can't have a conversation. I've seen staff leave the place when they get a phone call. The bartenders can't hear you. This isn't a metal concert, it's a family restaurant, and until and unless they get their act together I won't be returning. read more

Decent pub grub. Good beer options. Standard pub fare at acceptable price for quality. Standard service. Easy parking in lot behind restaurant. Fun Teddy Roosevelt decor. Not a destination but not a bad choice if in area. read more

Nice chill vibe , live music, food SUCKS. I'm a local and want so badly for this place to be good. My wife and I came here a lot when they first opened, took a year off after being repeatedly disappointed by the food. Went back recently for lunch because we like to support local businesses and were reminded why we don't want to eat here. Cool place to grab a drink and listen to some music though. read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Reuben. Corned beef was chewy and the cheese cold. It's like they're trying to make a bad sandwich. - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Food was good but service was one of the most awful I have had, didn't get menus for about 15 minutes from being there then after 25 minutes of being there we had to move from the bar because we were being ignored to a table where the server did not acknowledge us once again for about 10 minutes even tho the place was empty and we finally got a server after an hour of being here. Great food but will not come back read more

Great ambiance! Service was quick. We tried the pretzel and beer cheese and the cheese was unfortunately super watery. Besides that, I will definitely be coming back for another meal! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

First time here today with a friend for lunch and I instantly knew I was going to like it. Great spot that's deceptively large, as it goes pretty far back. We got the meatball appetizer which was perfect to share and they were really good! I got a Cesar Salad, which was just okay. Nothing spectacular. I usually judge a place on whether or not I'd go back, and I definitely would! read more

Teddy's Bully Bar - Meatballs - American Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Let me start by saying I do plan on coming back to see if this place merits another star or two but I can't give it anything higher than what I've given it because of our rather UNUSUAL issue last night. Let me explain: My friend and I arrived for our weekly Monday night dinner. This place got a decent write-up in Newsday, and it was open on Monday (something that seems to be getting rarer these days). We decided to split an order of nachos as an appetizer. These were VERY good though my friend maintained he's had better guacamole. I wouldn't know; I shoveled it to the side as I've never been a fan of that green slime. I'll have to remember to ask them to hold off when I come back. In any event, we both decided we wanted to order the Cuban Sandwich. When the waiter came back for our order, we told him we each wanted the Cuban. He repeated: "Okay, two Cubans" and then walked away. When our sandwiches came back, we thought they looked odd but ate them anyway. I've had non-traditional Cubans before but this was odd. I've NEVER had anything "green" on a Cuban other than the pickle and I've certainly never had a slice of apple on it. We both decided the sandwich was "okay" but definitely NOT what we were expecting. When we got the bill, we saw why. DESPITE repeating "Okay, two Cubans" what we ACTUALLY received was two "Edith's Paninis!" Seriously, they don't even sound REMOTELY similar so I don't know how this got so screwed up. We paid the bill since we both finished the sandwiches but now I have to go back and see what their CUBAN sandwich tastes like. Perhaps I should order "Edith's Panini" instead and see what they bring to the table? In any event the service was VERY good, they were all very attentive, friendly and polite. I just wish they got the order right but I will give them a second chance as everything but that was positive. read more