Friendly staff, great baked treat. Sizes are great, plain cold brew is my go to but the roast is great that they have. Great ambiance, feel cozy and friendly. I go every Saturday morning after a long work week! read more

I wanted to love Sweetie Pies but too many things were off for me. The delicious Spinach Cheddar empanada is listed on the website menu, but they have no food menu of any kind at the shop. It turned out these empanadas ALSO have chicken, much to the disappointment of a vegetarian like myself. This snafu could have been avoided if there were at least food labels on the items in the bakery display, but there were not, and no prices either. Not a deal breaker by itself, you can always ask the staff, right? But they are SO busy that I feel guilty asking and holding up other customers. After a lunch that left me with a bit of a tummyache, we wanted to get some sweet treats to go, but being reluctant to ask about the identities and prices of most items, I walked out with less than I thought I would, which just left me feeling kind of bummed. Clearly I'll need to take careful notes from other Yelp reviews for the next time I visit (still hoping for a redemption). read more

Came here on a nice day to meet some friends for coffee and a bite. It's a beautiful location and the outdoor patio is perfect to hang and chat with friends. I ordered an egg bite and an iced hazelnut latte. I got the egg bite within minutes, I'll share why later in my review. The latte took a bit long as they clearly forgot about it. I waited almost 10 minutes watching them give everyone on line after me their drinks. I had to ask for it then finally got it. Finally sat with my friends outside and took a bite of the egg bite. It was ice cold. I wasn't informed they serve it cold! I it wasn't flavorful so I didn't even eat it. I took a sip of the hazelnut latte And it was missing the hazelnut so it was a plain, bitter latte. I had some sugar in my bag and that helped but I was so disappointed. I try to avoid franchise coffee shops and support local but they have to be somewhat good for almost $11 for a small iced latte and cold egg bite. The outdoor patio area was nice and clean at least. read more

One of the cutest coffee shops I have ever been to! As I walked in I felt as though I was transported to a different time and somewhere in New England. Everything in regards to decor was quaint, clean, and homey which I adored. The service was particularly fast for us busy as it was. I thought we would not be able to find seats actually but there is outdoor seating as well as indoor seating. Finally, the cookie was delicious and I devoured it in one sitting. The coffee was good too and there were plenty of options for even the pickiest coffee drinker. Definitely a place everyone on Long Island should experience! read more

See all

Stumbled upon this coffee shop while we were in Cold Spring Harbor. The staff here are friendly & helpful and the restaurant itself had a quaint & homey feel with only 5 tables inside but there's also outdoor seating as well. Tried their organic Colombian coffee (black), which was great, the banana walnut muffin & almond croissant were not bad. The muffin had good banana flavor though it was dry and the croissant isn't your typical flaky, airy & buttery croissant- this was dense, gooey with almond cream filling and had a cookie-like crispy texture. read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

I stopped in while in the area and got a black & white cookie. The cookie was good but the snobby attitude of the girl behind the counter wasn't. read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Black & white cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

Nice outdoor garden area to enjoy your favorite cup, and also a table in front. A very good place to stop for a tasty snack and a coffee when in the area, read more

At Sweetie Pies on Main Street in Cold Spring Harbor NY. Cute little place. Yes there are Pies. Some unique things to buy, a single serving honey bear and a Mila's YUCA puff snacks. They do take credit cards for payment. - Note- I did not see an additonal fee for card use. read more

See all

One of my favorite coffee spots on LI! They have so many fun flavors, but my go to is usually the sweet mint in an iced latte. They also have really delicious pastries. Just note that it does get busy and there's not much seating inside, so it's not really a place you would stay long at. I brought my computer here a couple weeks ago because I was hoping to sit down and do some work, but I couldn't get a seat so I ended up taking my coffee to go. Not a deal breaker though because I really do enjoy their coffee! read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Sweet mint iced latte - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

The cutest little coffee shop. Came on a Saturday afternoon and it wasn't very busy. The inside is very homey and cozy, but there isn't much seating. I got a gingerbread iced coffee. I thought the flavor was just okay, but it was very mild. I have tried other flavors in the past which I liked more. They have many flavors to choose from which I love. I also got a birthday cake scone which is my absolute favorite and a must try when you visit. Definitely stop by when you're in the village! read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Gingerbread Iced Coffee & Birthday Cake Scone - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

Was really looking forward to trying this place again. They don't have as many vegan food options as they used to. The coffee was OK. Really cute environment as always. prices were a little high, but not outrageous. Hope they get more vegan options soon. read more

This place is so cute! The old cottage feel is adorable. The coffee was AH-MAZING the vanilla was so fresh. The service was fast and easy as we took home apple and blueberry pies. Update: pies were the best pies we have ever had read more

See all

Popped in for a coffee on a weekday afternoon. Surprisingly busy with lots of people hanging out and chatting. The coffee options were great! There's lots of different syrups that you don't normally see which I enjoyed. Prices are comparable and there's a good amount of seating. There also were a lot of cute products for sale by the counter and had gf snacks available. read more

Love the coffee with coffee ice cubes! Also amazing iced teas. Have tried multiple baked goods like different muffins and they're always good too. Definitely a great spot! read more

A cute spot right off the main street for some caffeination! Inside is quite cozy, considering Sweetie Pies is literally located inside a repurposed house. One room is for ordering your coffee or treats, the other has seating to crank out some work files or relax. I ended up ordering a mocha and a gruyere french onion croissant and got my order relatively quickly which was quite nice. The mocha itself was serviceable. It had that slight bitterness which I looked forward to in a mocha. But it also didn't taste much like chocolate either. Just generically sweet. The french onion croissant however, more than made up for it! A lot of onion and gruyere flavor. A bonus is that the cheese melted outside the croissant, so you got a bunch of toasty, crispy bits on the outside as well. Delicious. Overall, I think its a wonderful place to pick up a coffee if you're in the area. Just grab a cup to warm up while strolling the harbor! read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

This is a place that doen't care about its customers. They are supposed to close at 5:00. We got there at 4:30, got our cofee, and sat down. Suddenly, they decided to close at 4:50. Of course, they could have said this before we and a number of other people ordered coffee, but they had to squeeze out that extra few bucks before closing. I hope they got a lot of mileage out of the extra 10 minutes they got, because we will certainly not be back. read more

Such a cute little spot for morning coffee and a small breakfast. I ordered a lavender honey latte and it was perfect. I also tried their Everything Frenagel (a flaky cronut-like bagel) served with scallion cream cheese. It was really good! I sat out back in their little outdoor garden. It was such a great little spot. I got to watch a little chipmunk run back and forth. So cute. read more

See all

Always a special treat to stop into this cute cozy little coffee shop. Delicious macrons

The coffee's not bad, but the employees seem confused about their own menu. I initially asked for an iced flat white (typically an 8-10 oz drink, I said anywhere from 8-10oz of milk is fine) and the cashier asked if an iced cortado is okay. I said sure, and when the drink came out it was a 16oz iced latte. Since it was supposed to be a cortado (a drink that's equal parts espresso and milk) I asked if they could remake it with equal parts espresso and milk, and they gave me a drink with 10oz of milk. Their coffee is good, so I just took it, but their complete inability to follow instructions when both times I told them exactly how much milk to put in it is perplexing. Also, how do you work at a specialty coffee shop and not know the basic makes of classic drinks? For that reason I can't say I would recommend this shop, if I really wanted an espresso macchiato or hot cortado and got handed a latte's worth of milk I would be very disappointed. read more

Cosy coffee shop , lot varieties of bake goods ,coffee and tea selections .and they also selling cute souvenirs !! read more

See all

Came here for a quick coffee and snack during the winter. It's such a cute spot to grab something or chit chat with someone casually - you can also walk and shop afterwards as well which makes the location optimal. The specialty rose coffee I got was great and also ordered a tollhouse pie to go which was a great pie! Such a rare find too as I don't know too many locations that sell them! read more

See all

A classic cold spring harbor staple. Everyone knows that sweetie pies is your "go-to" for any coffee, tea, or sweets cravings. Lots of indoor seating options with a beautiful back courtyard area to enjoy the fresh air and village of cold spring harbor. Highly recommended if you're taking a trip out to this small quaint village. read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

I came mostly to enjoy the back garden space and seating area. That part was beautiful and quiet enough given it was right off of main street. I tried a turmeric latte and there was no flavor. Not enough turmeric and no black pepper or anything else to elevate it. Several other coffee shops have much more complex and interesting flavors along Long Island. I would probably come back and try something else but I was disappointed by that drink in particular. read more

Great food and amazing coffee Ambiance is nice, it's located in the center of cold spring harbor and service is 10/10 read more

The food was stale and I could tell it was old and also not made in house. The 2 older women that own and run the place are very rude and snobby and unless you're a local they make you feel like you don't belong there. 0/10 would never come back. read more

One positive thing that's come out of this quarantine is that I've had plenty of time to try places that I've never had the time to go to. The weather has finally taken a turn for the better so my best fiend and I (along with the kids) took a drive out to Sweetie Pies for some coffee and a walk around CSH. It was worth every minute of the 35 minute drive! The line to get in was pretty short when we arrived around 10:30. They let one group in at a time to order from the hallway of the building so we only waited about 20 min or so. There were so many things I wanted to try so I ordered a bunch: s'mores iced coffee (coffee ice cubes in it! How does every place not do coffee cubes?!), the chocolate chip scone, lemon bar and rainbow crumb cake. Everything was fantastic! The scone was perfect scone consistency (which is a huge pet peeve of mine), the lemon bar was AMAZING. Uber lemony and the crust was flaky and perfect. The rainbow crumb cake didn't disappoint. I've had that cake many times from a different shop in Astoria and it was the same moist, amazing cake that it always is. We sat in the little courtyard in the back while the kids played and enjoyed our treats then walked over to the water on a gorgeous Saturday. I'll definitely be back, even when quarantine is over. I can't wait to try other items! read more

See all

Came here once before, but did not have a chance to try their goodies. After seeing their instagram pics I developed a huge craving for their rainbow crumb cake. I appreciated having a window at the door to take the orders rather than going into a crowded coffee shop to comply with social distancing. I ordered an iced sticky bun latte made with oat milk and hubby had an iced snickers latte. We also got the rainbow crumb cake and a pecan bun. There is outdoor seating in the back of the place but didn't get to check it out because a heavy rainstorm rolled in just as we were leaving. We will be back! read more

See all

Such a quick and easy process on this trip to SPOM. You walk up to the counter, view the options they have to offer, pay and they give you the bag. Just so wonderful! The menu was right there along with staff wearing mask and hand sanitizer at the credit card reader. We opted for the birthday cake scone with beautiful specs of sprinkles and a delicious frosting on top. The classic but always favorite rainbow cookie crumb I wish was a bit more plentiful in size was still delicious. And they had something called the monster slice (or similar to that), layers of brownie and peanut butter and cake. I don't know for sure but it was pretty miraculous. They still have tables and chairs set out for those that want to have their treat to stay. We chose to go and will definitely be back another time! read more

See all

My gf took me to breakfast here on my birthday and we LOVED it. They have a really adorable garden to sit in. The coffee was really good. I got the snickerdoodle iced coffee. The breakfast was amazing!! If you come here you must get the everything Frenagle with chive cream cheese. It was absolutely delicious and perfectly flaky. We also got the ham and cheese croissant that was tasty too. Also, my gf got us the birthday cake scone to share for the occasion. Usually we aren't too much of a fan of scones since they are dry a lot of the times, but we ate every last bite of this one. It wasn't dry whatsoever and was so good. It is such a cute spot. I highly recommend it! read more

See all

Sticky Bun latte with oat milk and rainbow crumb cake from donut diva = perfection. Always a 10/10 experience here read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Monster Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

Overall nothing special tbh, but maybe the only shop of its kind for the area. I got the crumb cake which visually looks amazing, but it was pretty dry. Took a couple bites and put it away. I'll try to revive it in my air fryer when I get home lol. I also got the Sticky Bun latte and it lacks consistency. The cinnamon is prominent but the rest of the drink falls flat. Only drank half. The place itself is cute tho and service is cool. But not sure I'd come back here if I'm in the area again. Would probably find a coffee shop on the way here instead. read more

Great service Great carrot cake Great interior Pretty good tea and coffee Love it. They also have a nice garden in the back read more

Finally came here while in town and such a cute place and delicious baked goods! I cannot wait to come back here. My son also loved the organic chocolate milk they had and of course my cookie :) read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

I absolutely love your coffee but wanted to let you know that the Gourmet Whaler a few doors down is fighting some weird war with you. We walked in with our drink to grab a pastry and this woman behind the counter grabbed the drink and poured it into one of their cups. Super strange behavior! read more

I live about 30 minutes away from here but have seen people post on social media about Sweetie Pies. I decided to take the drive to check it out. It was a weekday around 10am. Parking on the actual street is a bit rough but I saw there was a municipal lot diagonal from the location that had plenty of spots. When I saw the sign, I walked in and it was kind of like a mini house. Very cute. Their door is on the left. Not sure what was on the right. When I walked in it's very tiny. There were two people in front of me, so it gave me a chance to look at the many (no prices list?) They had a table to sit at inside but also a few tables out side in the front and the back to sit at. Side note: I sat outside to take a few pics and I got two mosquito bites. I was wearing perfume but who knows, so that made me rush a bit! Coffee: I did a medium Sticky Bun iced coffee. The barista told me it wasn't exactly like a cinnamon bun because it had some mix of hazelnut/caramel/cinnamon. I tried it anyway. They put actual coffee cubes in their coffee too so it doesn't get watered down! For a flavored coffee I didn't think it was overly sweet which I liked and was originally worried about. However, the coffee itself didn't seem that strong to me. 9/10 Food: I noticed on social media they have some speciality pastries. I wanted to take two home to try. I did the chocolate chip scone (DELISH! 10/10). And the infamous Rainbow Cookie Crumb Cake. But the RCCC was sweet and I only tried a little piece (6/10). Both of these pastries were HUGE and weighed a TON. I definitely could not finish one in one sitting. Price: For a medium iced coffee and the two pastries my total was $17.50 - I thought this was very high... There was no pricing on the menu hanging so it was a bit of a shock. Due to the distance and price, I don't think I'd drive 30 minutes again. However, it definitely is a good spot and if I was in the area I'd probably stop in. Still 4 stars :). read more

See all

What a cute little spot in Cold Spring Harbor! Came to check it out today. I absolutely adored it! First of all they have indoor and outdoor seating. In the back and in the front! So so cute! Perfect for warmer weather! They have street parking only. I came in on a Sunday evening and they were busy! Must be very popular. They have everything between coffee and teas to scones and muffins. They also have super coffee as well! They sell some gluten free stuff here as well! I had bought an iced vanilla coffee and a walnut muffin which came out to be $8 and some change. A little pricy but definitely worth it. I will totally be returning earlier in the day to check out their pastries! read more

See all

Location is adorable. The town is very historic and worth a walk around. There's an outdoor garden in the back. Do yourself a favor and try the rainbow cookie crumb cake! I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Happened to be in the area for a wedding and stopped by to grab some pastries. The pumpkin chocolate chunk crumb cake (made by the iconic @donutdivany) was great, and the raspberry bar was amazing. They have indoor and outdoor seating, and the employees were super nice! read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - pumpkin chocolate chunk crumb cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

Pretty cute place with outdoor seating in the back. Sweet service. You order at the counter and they bring it to you at your table. Bit expensive, city prices. I got an almond milk latte for $5, and I wouldn't say it was quality coffee (I was disappointed, but I am very much a coffee snob), but it seems you come for the quaint little atmosphere. It's a hotspot in town for the baked goods. My friend got the acai smoothie and seemed to neither like or dislike it. Three stars it is. read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

Coffee and treats! This cozy shop located right on main street in the town of cold Spring Harbor is charmer. When walking through the front door of this shop you notice a few tables and people coming in for their morning coffees. I went with an iced coffee which had a lot of flavor with some nut notes to it but was pretty weak. While searching through all the pastries which looked amazing. The rainbow crumb cake is what I decided on and it was a delicious decision. It had the hard crumby top with the bottom being moist, making every bite perfect. When you walk outside back onto the porch you notice below you a beautifully manicured garden with tables to enjoy our coffee and pastries and once those are finished you are steps away from the cold Spring Harbor Park. In short: - Cozy coffee shop - Good Pastries - beautiful garden to sit in read more

Sweetie Pies on Main - Bakeries Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all