I've tried a lot of coffee around the CSH, huntington area, and this was by far the best. The barista gabby was amazing, and the cold spring latte was phenomenal. Will definitely be returning! read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - Cold spring latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

High-Caliber Brew Undermined by Indifferent Service A craftsman can pull the finest roast on the coast, but if the handoff at the counter lacks care and effort, the whole operation takes a hit. Hospitality isn't just about handing someone a paper cup; it's about taking responsibility for the person standing in front of you. Cold Spring Harbor Cafe proves they have real talent behind the espresso machine, but the front counter dropped the ball on the basic duty of customer care. CATEGORY BREAKDOWN 1. Coffee Quality & Flavor Craft: 9.5/10 The coffee itself is fantastic, and credit is due where credit is earned. I ordered the s'mores coffee, and it was flat-out delicious--rich, perfectly balanced, and delivered on every note without tasting artificial or cloying. My wife ordered the signature Cold Spring Harbor latte, and it was just as well-crafted: smooth extraction, clean milk texture, and dialed-in temperature. The kitchen and barista work behind the counter clearly knows what it's doing. 2. Counter Service & Hospitality: 3.0/10 This is where the wheels came off. The front counter crew was flat-footed, disinterested, and unhelpful. Standing face-to-face with a paying customer requires engagement and basic respect. Instead, we were met with indifference, like taking an order was an interruption rather than their primary job. A bad attitude will sour good coffee every time. 3. Inventory Stewardship & Preparation: 4.0/10 Running out of stock happens, but running out of a wide swath of core syrups speaks to sloppy inventory management and poor preparation for the shift. If a specialty beverage program leans on flavor profiles, you have to stay ahead of your supply line. Being caught completely dry across the board shows a lack of foresight. 4. Problem Solving & Customer Guidance: 2.0/10 A true professional adapts when resources run low. When a shop is out of half the board, an attentive worker steps up, explains what's available, and offers an honest recommendation to help build a great alternative. We got none of that--just a blank stare and zero effort to suggest a path forward with what they actually had in stock. You shouldn't have to pull teeth just to figure out what a cafe can actually pour. 5. Atmosphere & Setting: 8.0/10 The setting carries that classic, quiet Cold Spring Harbor coastal charm. It has the right bones for a dependable neighborhood cafe where people want to linger, catch up, and enjoy a slow morning. Clean, cozy, and aesthetically well-suited to the historic hamlet. 6. Location & Access: 7.5/10 Cold Spring Harbor parking and Main Street traffic always require a little patience, especially on clear weekend mornings. You take the walk with the territory, and strolling through town isn't a problem, though finding an immediate spot right outside the door is rare. PROS & CONS * + Top-tier specialty coffee; the s'mores coffee and Cold Spring Harbor latte were exceptional. * + Charming, scenic harbor setting with great local character. * - Counter staff was unhelpful, detached, and lacked basic hospitality. * - Major inventory shortages on syrups during regular operational hours. * - Zero initiative from staff to recommend viable substitutions or menu alternatives. THE VERDICT: 3.0 / 5.0 The coffee in the cup earns an easy five stars, but the transaction at the register dragged it straight down to average. When you charge premium prices in a town like Cold Spring Harbor, your front-of-house staff needs to match the quality of the brew. Dial in the inventory, train the counter crew to take ownership of the customer experience, and this place would easily be a local titan. For now, it's great coffee saddled with indifferent service. read more

See all

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe serves some truly incredible coffee, but the overall atmosphere and customer service left quite a bit to be desired. The Pros: To-die-for coffee: The quality here is outstanding. Hands down some of the best coffee around--rich, smooth, and noticeably great quality from the first sip. Convenient weekend parking: Parking is located right across the street from the cafe. Since we went on the weekend, we didn't have to pay for a spot, which made stopping by completely painless and easy. The Cons: Unwelcoming staff: The customer service was a major letdown. The staff was super unfriendly and gave off an attitude that made us feel more like an inconvenience than paying customers. Bare, confusing interior: The space inside is extremely plain and minimal--so much so that when we first walked up, we honestly weren't even sure if they were actually open. It lacks warmth and charm, especially for a cute village cafe. Worth a quick stop if you're purely chasing high-end coffee and want easy parking, but don't go in expecting warm hospitality or a cozy sit-down vibe. read more

See all

Order the cinnamon crunch latte!!! It's definitely sweet so if you don't like sweet coffee then order it half sweet, but it was delicious. The cold foam with the cinnamon crunch cereal was a great addition. It's small inside so it's not a good spot to get work done, but I recommend stopping there to get a coffee. They have a menu with their regular drinks along with a seasonal menu. There is parking across the street in a big lot. Can't wait to come back and try more of the menu. read more

See all

Such a charming little spot in the village. Kiera, the barista, could not have been kinder & more attentive. When we walked in, we were the only customers, she was alone, but quickly the place was much busier & she was alone & handled everyone promptly! My gingerbread latte was delicious, & when she realized they were out of the cookie for the top, she suggested replacing it with the little tree cookie, which she didn't have to do, but it was such a nice substitute! Dad loved his hot cocoa! I will absolutely be back! read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - gingerbread latte with tree cookie topper (sub because they were out of gingerbread cookie) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

The pistachio latte was very nutty and smooth. Their unsweetened iced tea was so fresh and lemony it was amazing. Ambience was cute but felt somewhat empty inside. Drinks took a very long time despite only having one person ahead of us. Would come back again to try again. read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

It's so cute in here! I popped in after hiking the cold spring harbor trail. I ordered a medium cold brew with oat milk and vanilla, and I got my coffee in two minutes. It tastes fantastic! I'll be stopping in again next time I'm in town. read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - Medium Cold brew - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

Beautiful clean, locally owned Cafe in the middle of historic Cold Spring Harbor. We were lucky to have stumbled in on their 1st day, as the smell of fresh paint is still in the air. The two young women who own and operate the Cafe are super nice and patient, as the place is getting busy with local customers (and very kid friendly) I tried the Vermont Maple Latte and my daughter had a hot chocolate. Both very good and not overly sweet. But my favorite thing about it is that I'm sitting in a 200+ yr old building in a historically preserved town - one of the few left. Don't sleep on this place for a relaxing Sunday in old long Island. I read more

See all

Came to this cafe after looking for a place to hike in the area. I saw the latte in the pumpkin and I was sold! Cold Spring Harbor Cafe is a very cozy and intimate cafe. Emily was a major help and gave me her best recommendations to try. 10/10 I love everything I had and will be coming back to try more. read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - Pumpkin Spice Latte with Oatmilk in a Pumpkin. Hot Chocolate with Oatmilk and Pumpkin spice. Chicken Noodle Soup. Honey Rosemary Biscuit. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

This place is not worth it. We waited in line for a very long time before someone would even make eye contact with us. The staff was running behind the counter frantically. Once we ordered and received our drinks we were all very disappointed. Not only was it $8 for a medium coffee, all our drinks tasted terribly. Highly disappointed. read more

Only 2 of us walked in and were only customers in the store, nobody said hi, never asked if we were ready to order. Girl at cashier could not have been less interested. We just ordered, she never acknowledged the order. Never said thanks or confirmed card went through. Somehow she never uttered a word to us. Then the smoothies came out and were avg. read more

Whether you like your coffee and tea cold or hot, there's a cool new cafe in Cold Spring Harbor. The Cold Spring Harbor Cafe has bright, understated and welcoming aesthetic. Pistachio is a flavor not enough American purveyors appreciate. The nut latte is just one example of the thoughtfully curated menu of offerings. If fruit concoctions are more your jam, CSHC makes smoothies and juices to order, with ginger shots for an extra juice boost. Fresh pastries round out the perfect breakfast or afternoon snack. Salads and wraps will soon complete their lunch menu. Nicer still, unlike those obscenely greedy corporate coffee joints, the CSHC doesn't charge an arm or leg, and it doesn't nickel and dime you. read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - Entrance - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

Must try pineapple mint juice/smoothie and Vermont maple latte! The girls working were great and got my drinks out pretty fast considering how busy it was on a Saturday afternoon. Definitely a great spot to stop for a drink when driving down 25a. Will be coming back! read more

Cold Spring Harbor Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cold Spring Harbor, New York

See all

Coffee is SO GOOD! I also love working from this little spot. There are outlets, great wifi, and window seats! I love it!

It's giving-I have zero experience in food, service or coffee but who cares??? I've got disposable income, so I'm an entrepreneur! Despite the no bueno feng shui, limited menu and overall generic vibe, I'm thinking this place will survive- Simply because CSH folks like to support their Main Street. I mean, if Sweetie Pies can make it in this town... lol read more

This cafe instantly put me in a good mood! The coffee was perfect, the staff was kind, and the vibe is just so inviting.

I love Cold Spring Harbor Cafe!! I came in when they first opened and had an amazing latte. It is the perfect cafe to sit with friends, do work, or just relax and enjoy the atmosphere. The service is amazing, they work as quickly as possible, and the drinks never disappoint. There are so many menu options and they are constantly coming out with new drinks. The employees are all so sweet. I have never had a bad experience here and would 10/10 recommend to anyone in the nearby towns!!! read more

the drinks were nothing special, but extremely over priced. Went with my daughter and it was above $30 for 2 drinks, honestly outrageous.

The interior was simple, clean and pleasent. The matcha I got was delicious. Glad I stopped by! I'm pretty sure it's their first day and I didn't even realize it. This place is going to do well. read more

Very cute new cafe in town. Food selection is sparse but the coffees were great! Tried the s'mores latte and a Vermont maple latte and both were delicious! Will be back! read more