Stopped in for a quick latte. The parking isn't the best since it's in a tight shopping center but the coffee is definitely worth it! It was pretty busy for a Thursday morning. The interior has some seating and is decorated really cute. I ordered the Banana Cream Shaken with oat milk and it was sooo good! You can tell they put a lot of love into what they make. It came out to $10.86 for 16oz. Definitely a treat. I didn't order any food but the baked goods looked really delicious. I can't wait to try more lattes from them! read more

See all

This local coffee shop hit all the red flags for me: Over $10 per latte for a double shot Whole $1 extra for oat milk (it's 2026, oat and cow milk are about the same price, maybe a slight upcharge but $1?) No espresso shot difference between their small and medium lattes aka you're paying for another 4 ounces of milk and not anymore espresso They only serve their specialty lattes in a medium, so you're forced to pay extra for a milked down latte, once again it's wild that upgrading from small to medium means more milk but not more espresso and you have no choice. They fill the cup to the absolute brim with chunky ice read more

The customer service was honestly one of the best. When there was a delay on our bagel order the employees made sure to check in to update us. It was well worth the wait as the bagel was fresh and one of the best we had in the area. My son enjoyed their cookie as well as their turkey bacon ranch sandwich. The iced latte hit too. My son ordered a customized smoothie and it was fresh and filling. I would be back to try more items from their menu as well as their drinks. read more

See all

Nifty local spot in Wantagh with really cool flavor combinations for both the coffee and the matcha, but it was the nut balls/bites that were the standout eats. The shop is cool and cozy, staff are fun and friendly, and these little energy balls with the funny names were delicious. Local staple for sure if you're looking for a cool coffee spot to try. read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - 20 oz Banana Cream Shaken Espresso - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Obsessed with this coffee shop!!! Recently bought a house near the area and I couldn't have been luckier to have this coffee shop nearby. I would definitely recommend to try their lattes, shakes, matchas, homemade nutribomb and their delicious paninis. All are done with clean ingredients, organic and gluten free. Right now an absolute favorite is their banana caramelized latte. Wow PLEASE give it a try! They do bring seasonal lattes as well which makes it always even better. Follow their instagram page for their latest flavors.I also love their motivational quotes on their lids shows the love and appreciation they give their clients. The paninis- absolutely love them. It is on the pricier side for a coffee shop but with the clean ingredients it's understandable. Service is great-sweetest baristas. It's our go to spot! read more

See all

Talk about an upgrade for the neighborhood... As a local to the area, I've been wanting to try this spot for some time. I walked in and was literally in heaven by the ambiance and friendly vibes! My friend and I came here for lunch and so happy we did. Lots of amazing options to choose from. We both were interested in 2 different turkey sandwiches so the manager suggested to split up 2 sandwiches on separate plates so we could each have a half--- genius! I got a strawberry matcha latte with oat milk and my friend got one of their summer specials, coconut cold foam cold brew. She gave it 2 thumbs up and said it was MUCH better than the big coffee brand down the street! My strawberry matcha was chefs kiss... I should've gotten the large. The sandwiches came out warm and were delicious with LOTS of greens. We ended the meal with an amazingly soft and not too sweet chocolate chip cookie. Just a perfect meal and the perfect place to meet up! I will definitely be coming back to try more! read more

See all

Came here to try the cookie I saw on yelp that looked delicious and sadly all out. I tried a lemonade instead which was good. Week later on mother's day my hubs got me one :) as he went right as they opened. Cute little place. read more

Cute cafe where i got a latte. It was good but quite expensive so not sure I'll be going back often read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - 16 oz Iced Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

best coffees, smoothies, food, everything. I have been a returning customer for years now. great place!

Such a cute spot! We came here early on Saturday morning and ordered a smoothie, cookie, turkey arugula panini, and the caramelized banana coffee. The caramelized banana coffee was absolutely delicious!!!! It tastes like actual banana (and maybe it is because everything is freshly made), actually everything that we tried was delicious though. The turkey panini tasted fresh and delicious, and they also make whipped cream in house. All of the girls working there were extremely friendly and helpful as well. For anyone who tries to be a bit more health conscious like myself, I really wish there was more places like this. You can tell that they really care about the quality of everything they make and I will definitely be back soon! read more

See all

An adorable, clean cafe right off of Wantagh Ave just north of the S State on the east side. In a little recessed strip that has easy in & out parking. A great selection of specialty lattes, baked goods and paninis. Calm, peaceful seating. The most $$ we have paid for the lattes, a med butter cookie with cold foam was like 8 dollars, and a very nice sourdough bagel with homemade maple butter was a whopping 10..however, it is not inexpensive to run a business and I am happy to see them thrive. So many folks walking in and genuinely seeming pleased with the place & their purchases..all smiles ! read more

Excellent choices for food and drink. Give it a try you will definitely find things you will love. It is very healthy but also not extreme. read more

Amazing coffee and breakfast shop! Unique flavor design with simple ingredients. Avocado toasts and nutribombs are light taste palette and fulfilling. Perfectly balanced Dish presentation is amazing, include those masterpieces in your menus! read more

Always consistently great coffee, which is what you want from your local coffee shop. Great vibes - love the positive notes on the coffee cups. Super friendly staff. Lucky to have this gem in the neighborhood. People complain about the price but, you get what you pay for! read more

I originally visited this shop because of the high ratings and wanted to feature it on my TikTok review page. I'll be honest, the coffee and food were good and the handwritten notes are a nice touch. However, the experience after my visit has completely changed my perspective on this business. I posted an honest breakdown of the value for my audience, pointing out that a latte and a bagel swap (due to them being out of sourdough) came to $29.33. Instead of taking the feedback professionally, the owner has spent making videos mocking "cheap" customers (which are now deleted) , and even using fake accounts to bypass blocks and using her friends to write on my comment section with "friendly" fake reviews. As a creator I value authenticity! I cannot in good conscience recommend a place that mocks its customers for questioning a $10.00 latte. People work HARD for their money and spending an hour's wage on a coffee shouldn't result in being insulted by the owner!!! Its very unprofessional! read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Nice little coffee place. Limited seating. Wished they offered a better selection of music playing in the background. read more

See all

The drinks and food are just absolutely mind blowing and savory. I also love the service here. The messages on the cups bring positive energy and help start the day with a smile. The decor is warm and welcoming. Second time visiting read more

See all

This is such a cute place with an awesome vibe. The owner and the young lady at the register were very nice. You can tell they use excellent ingredients and there's a lot of love that goes into their food/coffee. I got a caramel latte and an avocado toast. Both were Really Really yummy. I will definitely be coming back when i'm in the neighborhood read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Avocado toast - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

This place is my favorite place. Me and my daughter walk here and get our favorite shake/smoothie or If daddy is on no sleep an iced coffee. The staff is so kind and friendly and the decor is just a chill vibe Love to just sit and hang as we wait for our food. Not going to lie I order in bulk, coconut cups and nutribombs are a staple to my life. Best surprise is when my wife gets stuff from here and I wake And there is a Daytripper in the fridge. I'd be lost without this place, Keep up the great job!!!!! read more

The best & cutest coffee shop around! Not only is the coffee actually amazing, I'm obsessed with the nutribombs and avocado toast. Always good vibes inside & the workers are so sweet! 10/10 you have to try! read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Iced cold brew with MAPLE cold foam & 2 Nutribombs UNREAL - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

This is a local, clean, friendly small business with great hot and cold drinks and snacks. It's enjoyable.

Just moved to the area and since I WFH I figured I'd take a walk and try it out. The girl behind the counter was extremely nice and patient with me since I had no clue what I wanted. She showed the me fall menu and I went with the classic PSL... and it was DELICIOUS! I figured I'd try the protein balls and also a hit!! I asked for the pistachio one and asked the person working to choose another one from me. She recommended the Oreo one and yup!!! Both were awesome!!! Def going back when I need to step away from my computer lol read more

Cute cafe with great lattes and sweet treats! I didn't have any of the treats but they looked delish and are all gluten free....

Great coffee, way better than starshmucks! I also love how they have non caffeine options too and variety of sweet treats. Workers are always super friendly. read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Vibes are very judgmental at this place. Owner uses her Instagram profile to post about how annoying her customers are. In one post she complains that people order too many banana lattes. Take them off your menu so? Idk why you would ever complain when you charge $11 a pop for them. Also posted that the saying "the customer is always right" doesn't apply when she's working. Crazy mentality as a small business owner. read more

I have had the salted maple latte which was delicious and the pumpkin cold foam latte which was yummy. I got an assortment of protein balls, the Schweaty, the coconut and the pistachio. All of them were good. They were remarkably filling. I ate one and it satiated my appetite for a few hours. Remarkable! Service was friendly and quick. read more

LOVE this cafe ! The atmosphere is gorgeous, staff & owner are so sweet and friendly, they made me feel really welcomed. the coffee is delicious, i wish the location was closer to me!! food is also very good, Avocado toast was the perfect pairing for morning coffee and great portion size. Parking is also very spacious. This is the perfect cafe whether you're running in to grab your order or spend an afternoon inside. cant wait to come back read more

Coffees and smoothies are amazing here. I'm addicted to the protein balls. Love this cafe so much, I highly recommend giving it a try!

I just tried the caramelized banana Matcha, and roasted garlic Panini. I loved both! I highly recommend. It will definitely be my new favorite stop for my daily Matcha! read more

I wanted to leave a positive review since I did enjoy my food and drink. What really turned me off was seeing the owner publicly mock customers on Instagram for mentioning pricing. That response felt very unprofessional and disrespectful. I believe feedback should be handled with maturity, and unfortunately this experience has made me decide not to return. read more

This is a great little cafe with high quality ingredients. The coffee is really good and they put inspiring lil messages on your cup. The balls they make are delicious and so are their muffins. Again premium ingredients in everything they make. You will pay a premium but it is worth it. At least I think so. Friendly owner and staff. read more

The food was so fresh and delicious, everyone who was working there was not only friendly but they were so helpful as well and the place was so clean and cozy, I would highly recommend coming here read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Avacado toast with fresh mozzarella peppers with balsamic glaze - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

I've been wanting to visit for quite some time. So happy they extended their hours! Lovely local café, great food and drinks. Sweet service. Thank you! read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

This is my favorite place !!! Love to get my specialty coffees and the muffins and protein bombs are so delicious!!! Not to mention what a wonderful and friendly staff !! This is definitely a great addition to the neighborhood. read more

Great coffee and food! Loved the vibe. The owner and manager are very friendly. Highly recommend.

Today I had the hot maple latte, better than dunks or sb and same price if not cheaper that what they cost, easily my favorite coffee Also got the hot honey avocado toast on sourdough (minus pickled red onion) the owner made it herself and i can't stop thinking about it And lastly I got a small golden milk, you buy this bc it makes you feel incredible read more

Great coffee, delicious treats, super friendly, awesome ambiance with great vibes! Came in for vanilla latte that was perfect, also got Nutribombs: pistachio, pink Himalaya, coconut, s'more's, and oreo. Everything is fantastic read more

Simply Spinelli Cafe - Fantastic vanilla latte! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Not only did the ambiance pull me in the smell was amazing. We were greeted by two smiles and a hello. We ordered the Avocado toast hot honey and fresh mozz. That was the best avocado toast I have ever had in my life the combination was out of this world my one year old couldn't stop eating it. We were checked on by the owner and when we told her she was so thankful. Def my new coffee spot support small Buisness read more

Delicious food and beverages made from real ingredients. And the nicest, friendliest, sweetest staff!! Not to mention the awesome vibe! Simply the best!! read more

I rarely write reviews, but I will now because someone else had a bad day. This place is a blessing to the neighborhood. After losing my favorite coffee shop about a year or so ago, I was super excited to see this place pop up. Friendly people, beautifully designed store, and even better... COFFEE! The nutribombs are amazingly delicious too. The avocado toast, the paninis, all super tasty. Highly recommend you pop in. read more