Smartwich is temporarily closed! Closed as of March 29, 2026. Relocating to a new spot in Syosset....opening sometime at the end of April 2026! New Location: 98 Jackson Ave Syosset NY 11714 Looking forward to visiting the new location! read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Closed as of March 29, 2026...Relocating to a new spot in Syosset....opening sometime at the end of April 2026! - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

Everything about this place is amazing from the owner Chef Guerrieri to the amazing creations you won't be dissapointed.

As a strict vegetarian/mostly vegan, a sandwich shop will never be my home away from home, but given the vibe and enthusiasm inside this place ALONE, I almost want to go back, after 40 years, to eating meat. Well...not really, but you get my gist. For my maiden voyage to Smartwich of Syosset, I went with the Mozzarella Smartwich and (sorry, Chef Michael) removed the cheese. Still, it was really tasty and really filling. The toasted Portuguese bread made it really rock. I also tried, for the first time ever, Bay Leaf Iced Tea, which sounded like a disgusting concept when I read the label, but ended up being really delicious. I highly recommend giving it a try. So many places have tried and failed at this location, but I really think Smartwich is going to make it. My friends who, unknowing to me, had been going to the old Hicksville location for years rave about it all the time, so my guess is that Smartwich's meaty items are as outstanding as what I had. Good luck to Smartwich, and welcome to Syosset! read more

I had to give this place another try, and I am glad that I did. I ordered the sardine (fresh) sandwich, and it was phenomenal. The homemade Portuguese bread had a crispy exterior and a soft and warm interior. The sandwich itself was an explosion of flavors that I love: salty, briny and fresh, and the portion was huge. The condiments were very good and well balanced. I will come again soon to try another one of the Chef's sandwich creations. The Cold (but without ice) Bay Leaf Tea was an instant favorite of mine. The Chef was in the store and recommended it because it has many health benefits, including regulating blood sugar levels and reducing cholesterol and blood pressure. The sandwich came out in five minutes. The Chef was there, and he was very kind to me, engaging in friendly conversation. I can't recommend this place highly enough. read more

See all

Cuisine: 8 Service: 10 Decor: 7 Value: 9 Overall: 9 If you remember the small chain of Smartwich Sandwich Shops that once occupied Manhattan, and you miss what they served because they all disappeared during the pandemic, then look no further. Chef Michael Guerrieri is back with a bang! Only this time, it's in Hicksville, Long Island. Luckily, I had the pleasure of dining here twice in the last week and tried a handful of his offerings. Let's just say that you will likely not be disappointed with whatever you order, but read on for my favorites. First of all, I have to mention the amazing bread, which is always the most important part of any good sandwich. Chef Michael scoops out some of the middle, and then toasted them perfectly. Slightly crunchy crust, while fluffy and airy on the inside. Just right. Now onto what's between the bread. SQUASH BLOSSOM (8/10) - The overall flavors of the sandwich were great, but I do wish that the fried squash blossom was crispier. The bacon bits adds a nice smoky and savory note to the otherwise vegetarian dish. SARDINES (8/10) - Imported directly from Portugal and pickled in house, these sardines are delicious, especially paired with pickled onions and pickled tomatoes. The touch of aromatic olive oil completes the package. SAUSAGE (10/10) - Wowza! This sandwich was magnificent! The sausage crumble was soooooo flavorful. Slight bitterness of kale somehow matched amazingly. However, please ask for Calabrian chili oil. Add some to each bite and it will be taken to the next level. I will be back for this bite for sure. OMELETTE (7/10) - I enjoyed this sandwich, but it was relatively light in flavor. The vinaigrette was not noticeable and I would have liked more. When I added a little rosemary olive oil to the mix, the taste was elevated. ROAST BEEF (6/10) - This was one of their most popular sandwiches. However, I was not a big fan. The deli meat was tender, but felt too heavily processed. Also, the sweetness of the relish turned me off completely. OCTOPUS (8/10) - I know it's expensive, but I need to feel more of that tenderly cooked octopus in each bite. The vinegary salad paired well. Hard to complain, but next time, I'll ask for double meat. Lol TUNA (6/10) - This was not bad, but so much large chunks of celery. It felt more like tuna was the co-star highlighting the veggie sandwich. Obviously, with all the celery, there was a nice crunch to the texture, but I would have preference more tuna. PASTEL DE NATA (10/10) - I had my fair share of these delicious little tarts from different parts of the world. These were as good as any I have tasted. Creamy custard with a flaky crust. What's not to love? Chef Michael is one of the most friendliest owners I have ever met. He is proud of his country (Portugal), his products, and wants to share it with everyone. We had a wonderful time listening to his stories and enjoyed our visits very much. He told me that there are plans to open up more towards the west. I'm begged him to open in Forest Hills, or at least Queens. I need that sausage sandwich in my life. read more

See all

Stopped by on a random Saturday afternoon to try this hidden gem out. We got the turkey sandwich (we originally wanted the chicken put the pastrami paste has pork in it) and it was delish! I really enjoyed the bread, it was super fresh & the veggies paired with the turkey complimented each other so well. The sandwich itself is pretty large, you can probably split it with someone else. I guess just one minus star because the guy making our sandwich didn't change gloves; he had a wet towel and wringed it out and then touched the bread/made the sandwich. Slight change of cross contamination with chemicals here, it didn't bother me but it might bother other customers. Other than that he was quite friendly & accommodating as it was our first time there. Cant wait to come back and try the octopus sandwich. read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Turkey - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

Food is fresh and delicious, chef is extremely hospitable and proud of his creations, pricing is fair and reasonable. This will become a regular stop for me, and I don't live around the corner. My sandwich eating husband proclaimed it was one of the best sandwiches he has ever had. Can't recommend enough! In Francesco's Bakery in Hicksville. read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Fresh turkey sandwich on Portuguese bread. Perfection! - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

Two amazing sandwiches at Smartwich! Got a Steak Melt that Chef Michael made for me, and the new Stuffed Jalepeño special which was absolutely incredible! Chef does an amazing job crafting his recipes and putting the highest possible quality into every dish! Always a pleasure coming to Smartwich! read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Stuffed Jalepeño - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

This smart sandwich shop has the best with fresh ingredients on Portuguese bread. Chef creates seasonal specials as well. It's casual take out or eat in but definitely worth the trip. Today it was Italian burrata, w arugula,tomato, procuitto and a honey jalapeño drizzle. read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Smartwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

Friendly amazing staff and great tasting bread! This place is located inside Francescos Bakery, I passed it at first. The manager and staff immediately greeted me. I used another reviewers suggestion and ordered ahead. I had the bay leaf tea and the mozzarella sandwich. Both were good. The bread is delicious! I will certainly try the octopus next! read more

This place is inside Francesca's bakery. I've been here a handful of times and this past time I went, I finally got to meet Chef Michael! What a great person with a true passion for his business. The sandwiches are always very fresh, flavors so balanced and the bread is top notch! When I eat a sandwich, usually some of the bread gets thrown out but not here! I eat every morsel. They also have a seasonal special sandwich. I have to say my sandwich always tastes great but this time around with the chef himself actually making it- it took on a whole another level! Absolutely delicious! read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Roast beef - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

A friend of mine was raving about Smartwich so we decided to go together to check this place out for lunch recently on a weekend. The place is housed inside of Francesco's bakery, and I got there around 12. The young man working behind the counter seemed pleasant. The place itself is just a small stall, but there are a few tables inside so you can dine in if you want. From the reviews I saw, I decided that getting the roast beef sandwich ($13) would be a good choice for a first timer. They also have some drinks and I ended up getting a barley tea ($2.50). Total cost of the meal was about $16.86 with cash payment. There is a small credit card fee so be aware if you are planning to pay by card. There are a lot of good things to say about the sandwich. First off, I was pretty impressed by how big the sandwich was. If you're not that hungry, I think you could get two meals out of it. Secondly, the bread quality really stood out. It seemed really fresh and fairly crunchy; excellent. The roast beef was pretty tasty and they put some sweet peppers in there as well. Everything seemed really balanced about the sandwich and it came together so well. I was going to just eat half, but I ended up wolfing the whole thing down cause it was so tasty. The barly tea was pretty good. It's not a super strong or sweet flavor, but pretty light and refreshing. All in all, the meal was excellent. The sandwich definitely feels better quality and higher end than most other sandwiches you can get. I would give Smartwich 3 stars for the present moment. My meal was excellent but I feel like the prices are a tad high. Not egregiously overpriced, but slightly so. If the sandwich was between $10-11 after tax and if the barley tea was $1.50 or lower after tax I would give out an additional star. Definitely looking forward to trying out another sandwich at some point in the future. read more

See all

The food and service is wonderful. I highly recommend the sausage and octopus sandwiches...so good!

Smartwich -- What a truly special place! I can't say anything new here that hasn't already been said. Each sandwich is its own unique creation, on delicious freshly baked Portuguese bread. Smartwiches are also best eaten when they are hot and fresh, so I personally wouldn't buy them unless I could eat it right away! I like all of the sandwiches here, but my favorite might be the sausage. I can't describe exactly why, and I don't even typically like sausage, but it's just pure umami deliciousness. I also like their specials that have come and gone, such as squash blossom, and pizza! The Chef is also very friendly and sociable, making the whole experience a great one. The only thing I don't love is the location (feels industrial, wish it were closer to me!), but I can live with that. read more

One of the best sandwich shops I have ever been to. How lucky that it is right smack dab in the middle of Long Island! Chef Michael was very kind and friendly, also made an amazing sandwich. Been back a few times and each sandwich is different and unique. All of them are different but delectable. Currently working my way through the menu. Mozzarella was my first and still the one that hooked me in and won't let me go. read more

See all

The bread is the best around. I drive a long way for it. The pizza is incredible. Highly recommend

Can a sandwich be like a unicorn? Well, if so, the magic happens at Smartwich. It's the most delicious "sandwich" spot around. I've eaten the Crudo (vegan) Smartwich a number of times and it just gets better. Chef Michael is sweet and has great energy and is very passionate about his food. read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - The Crudo (vegan) Smartwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

Best sandwich you can get in Nassau County. Starts with the bread and every accompanying ingredient is a perfect complement to the whole. Service is friendly and quality is top notch. Ambiance is quaint and perfect with others or solo. read more

Incredible sandwiches and an even more incredible owner! The chef is super kind and goes the extra mile to make your experience special. The flavor combinations are spot on, and I've never been a daily sandwich person--until now. Located inside Francesco's Bakery which is very prettily remodeled by the way, this place is another great find. Don't miss the pulled pork or turkey! Can't wait to return. read more

Wow! The sandwiches are amazing! First, the bread is a perfect bread - crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. I could eat this bread every day. Onto the fillings. I can't quite decide whether the sardine or the octopus is my favorite. I think I will have to go with the sardine sandwich. The sardines are nicely marinated and lemony and delicious. When I went to get my sandwich, the chef showed me a video how he marinated them. They are perfection. The octopus sandwich was also great. The octopus was perfectly tender and juicy. The bacon and the roast beef sandwiches were also great. Definitely will go back for more. Or maybe for more sardines. So good! Highly recommend this place for lunch or dinner or a snack. read more

See all

Okay let me put all of you on. These Sandwiches were absolutely delicious. I had multiple and they were all fantastic. The chef that was making the food was absolutely hilarious on top of being a fantastic chef. Great experience. Will be back for lunch sometime soon. Go check it out! read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Sandwich Making area and menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

I don't like to write a review after only 1 visit. But sometimes an experience deserves instant adoration. One of my companies yards is 2 blocks away. So I've passed by often. I usually get off late & hit up Francesco's for some pastries. Smartwich is usually closed but Chef Michael let me in on a tip. Order online and ask for a later pick up time and they will hold the sandwich in the back for you. Awesome! Now, the Long Island food scene has gotten so phenomenal that I have not had to return to the city for a great meal in five years and this sandwich shop (Chef Michael corrected me..it's a Smartwich hahaha) is one of the reasons why there is no need to travel to NYC for great food. Fresh ingredients. The bread not like a semolina bread, or a sourdough, which has a flavor all its own. The Portuguese roll is warm and crusty with a light flavor that allows the ingredients that it will be stuffed with to shine. And shine it did. Chef MICHAEL gave me a rundown of what his sandwiches have to offer but for an omnivore like me it is hard to make a decision when everything looks and sounds delicious Chef Michael recommended his latest creation of roasted artichoke hearts with burnt pepperoni. Accompanied by a host of other delicious fresh ingredients: Roasted Peppers Roasted Onions Pecorino Cheese Rosemary Olive Oil Tomato Arugula Vinaigrette The artichokes themselves belied their true identity to a meaty texture that was incomparable to any other veggie sandwich I have ever had. Incredibly delicious with the veggies alone, the crunchy saltiness of the pepperoni just heightened it to another level. I am mad I haven't come here sooner. Chef Michael's exuberance was intoxicating. I was actually giddy leaving the store with my Smartwich because of his passion that he showed for his craft. Make it a must go to if you love an excellently made high quality sandwich. 1-23-2024 read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - A Special: Artichoke Hearts w/ Burnt Pepperoni.....AAAAHHHMAZING!!!! 1-23-2024 - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

I'm obsessed with these sandwiches. My favorite is the crumbled sausage. Tried the daily special with salmon, capers, Dijon, dried pepperoni, artichokes atop their delicious Portuguese bread loaf. Unreal! Like sushi, mixed with French country side, mixed with your Grandma's freshly baked bread. Chef Michael is in tune and willing to adjust any sandwich for you. Love this shop! read more

See all

Ive had 4 of the sandwiches, and all of them were delicious! Chef Michael has an amazing personality and is focused on your happiness. I intend on being a customer for many years! read more

Wow! Amazing sandwiches! I had the octopus sandwich...absolutely delicious, tender octopus perfectly seasoned with crunch diced peppers...just perfect! And I have half left for dinner! My husband had the roast beef, tender and well-seasoned, thinly sliced and perfect. The dressing was delicious! The bread on these sandwiches is spectacular! The bay leaf iced tea was also a treat! We will definitely be back!! read more

This is by far the BEST sandwich spot on Long Island. The chicken sandwich is my favorite and I find myself craving it every week. They also make wonderful salads. Deff try the octopus salad ! My favorite part about it is how healthy and thought out the ingredients are, I never feel gross after eating here. Extremely clean place as well. The owner is an absolute doll - extremely welcoming & treats everyone like family. I can't recommend this place enough. 10/10 recommend !!! read more

Legit! Woke up somehow craving a roast beef sandwich. Decided I would have to earn it with a calorie deficit. 7 miles of Jones beachfront later my appetite was raging. Tore into the bag as soon as I got home and tried desperately not to wolf it down. What everyone posted about the stellar fresh crusty Portugese bread (Pao Saloio) is true. Crunch crunch! The tender rare beef accented with vinegary peppers and sweet relish that brought this sandwich to life. Ooops no pictures-you can see everyone else's posts for that. Again legit read more

**OUTSTANDING ARTISAN SANDWICHES ** **FAST AND FRIENDLY SERVICE ** OVERVIEW: The other day, a few of us were talking about why sandwich shops like Subway and Blimpie, are so darn awful. One person, mentioned the pre-sliced, sweaty-looking cold cuts, and phoney tuna. Next, someone brought up the not-so-fresh, wilted toppings. But then I added, that one of the most important aspects of a hero sandwich is the bread. And at these places, it's just so mushy, and fake-tasting. Even worse, it smells weirdly artificial. And that foul, artificial bread smell is the first thing that hits your nose when you walk into one of these places. "Hell", I said, "it's almost like the Pillsbury Dough Boy farted right in your face". But at Smartwich, each sandwich starts off with a large, freshly baked Portuguese bread that's crispy on the outside, and soft but substantial on the inside. Even more, before each sandwich is made, the bread is toasted in a special oven, so the end result is a fantastic crunch every time you take a bite. And regular cold cuts? Forgedaboudit! All the meats here, like the roast beef, turkey, and chicken are freshly roasted, and then sliced. And of course all the seafood, such as the, tuna, octopus, and sardines are made fresh and marinated for the best possible taste. In addition, I also must mention the feeling of freshness you experience when tasting the vegetables, herbs, and condiments used in each sandwich. In particular, the fresh arugula, watercress, peppers, and other greens used in many of the preparations are just over the top good. Then last, but not least, each of the twelve different sandwiches have been created with a master chef's expertise, for outstanding taste. So now, for comparison. let's imagine you ordered a roast beef hero at a standard deli, or - God forbid - Subway. You'd receive cold cut roast beef - and then most likely - lettuce, tomato, and mayo, on a crappy hero roll. But here at Smartwhich, freshly roasted sliced beef is complimented with super crisp watercress & tomato, carmelized onions, chopped sweet banana peppers, and then topped with herbed horseradish-relish. And all of this, is on that wonderfulI crunchy Portuguese bread. So now, once you take that first bite of the sandwich, its immediately obvious that you're about to enjoy something special. WHAT'S GOOD TO ORDER: - My favorite choices here would be in this order: Roast Beef, Mozzarella, Octopus, Chicken, Omelette, Sausage, Tuna, Egg Whites, and Crudo. My least favorite was the Sardine sandwich, but I'm not a big fan of sardines to start with. YMMV. - Any of the sandwiches can be converted to a salad, and I can report that the Octopus salad, and the Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Spinach salads are delicious, fresh and filling. - The Pastel De Nata, (Portuguese Egg Tarts) are crispy, and perfectly sweet. These are some of the best egg tarts I've tasted. SERVICE/ DECOR: The owner, Chef Guerrieri, is friendly and wonderfully animated, especially when he recommends any of his sandwiches - just like an artist would be, describing one of their masterpieces. Also, the chef and Nick, his assistant, seem to genually care about each customer, and are always happy to say hello and take your order. And then, after placing your order, the sandwiches are always ready quickly, even when it's a busy time of day. The shop occupies a small portion of Fancesco's Bakery. It's decorated in a straight foward way, advertising the different sandwich options. And there are two small tables available for eating-in, though most of the business here is grab and go. PARTING THOUGHTS: Chef Guerrieri is an accomplished sandwich artisan, who owned two popular specialty sandwich shops in Manhattan - until the Rona forced him to close. But now, luckily for us, he's back in action in Hicksville. And I have to say that, whenever I have the pleasure of eating a sandwich here, I'm hit with this special feeling, that I am experiencing something exceptional. And this is a rare occurrence indeed, with perhaps the Banh Mi sandwiches at Ha Long Bay in New Hyde Park, or Joju in Elmhurst giving me this same type of feeling. So the bottom line is, if you're in the Hicksville area, and looking for a delicious sandwich - you'd have to be an idiot, to go anywhere other than Smartwich. Seriously. read more

See all

Did I drive 45 minutes out of my way to try a sandwich spot? Yes, yes I did. And boy am I glad I did! Mike the owner was so charismatic towards me and the other customers inside ordering. He explained all of the sandwiches and how they were made and how everything is fresh and me made to order. It mixes Italian and Portuguese styles and I was blown away. The smartwich shop is located inside Francesco's bakery and while the parking lot is huge, it is at a very busy intersection so BE CAREFUL when pulling and out. Quite scary. Now back to my sandwich, I tried the tuna fish and it was made in olive oil, just like my grandma made it and was so unbelievably delicious. Mike offered me this spicy almost olive oil and it was a perfect addition to have my sandwich get taken to the next level. I totally forgot the name of it but it was delicious. I have leftovers and I'm so excited to have them tomorrow for lunch! read more

See all

From the service to the menu, all amazing! The menu makes you come back each day to try another "smartwich" Located inside of Francisco's bakery A beautiful place. read more

See all

The 5 star reviews are truly real. We had the pleasure to try the pastel de nata when one our friends brought it to a gathering. I have been thinking about them and finally got a free Saturday morning to got see if we can score some (it goes fast). It is located within Francesca Bakery, so one may miss it. We walked in and saw an empty case, feeling very disappointed that maybe they didn't have any or it was too early (it was around 11am). Then Mike came out to introduce himself, where he's from, and then his passion about each and every sandwich. LOVE IT! If I could, I would order every sandwich to try. My husband and I ended up trying the Octopus and the Bacon. Every ingredient in the sandwiches pairs perfectly with each other. The octopus was flown in from Portugal and was so tender. Everything was so fresh. I would say that a touch of vinegar would blow it over the top, but that's me. Bacon is good, but you haven't had mind blowing until you try Mike's! It was an explosion of the most perfect harmony of flavors. Yes, that is a yogurt sauce in there and not mayo. That bread though! It's so good! You know what makes a good sandwich is that the bread outside is crunchy but soft inside to hold all the yummy ingredients. Then Mike packed us 12 pastel de nata for us to heat up at home. He even gave me a free one hot out of the oven for the amazing visit. It taste like a creme brulee in filo dough. It was smooth and creamy, done right! We will definitely be back to try the others. Trust me, this place is that good! A gem to the neighborhood! read more

See all

Absolutely the friendliest sandwich service ever! The host responds to your gratitude with a heartfelt, "No, Thank you!" The Portuguese sandwiches are amazing--crunchy bread, fresh ingredients. I tried the chicken with pâté and the BLT with special Portuguese mustard. My kids adored the cheesy mozzarella sandwich, not on the menu yet, but if you ask, you might just get lucky! read more

Smartwich Sandwich Shop - Cheesy mozzarella goodness! - Sandwiches Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

A chef hand crafting delicious healthy sandwiches! Sign me up. This is a destination lunch spot. 10/10 for creativity and taste

Got Turkey and their bacon on roll today. Michael the Chef was teaching a young girl today, while a young man was apply for a job. The notice for help wanted is on the front of the counter. it notes must be good with a knife! read more

See all

Literally what I want every food experience to be like. Greeted personally by the chef, an explanation of his background, a walk though of the menu, and a customized sandwich selection. What more can I say? Oh right, the food review. I went with the crudo (vegan) but then added mozzarella and hot sauce. He was really selling it by mentioning how fresh the ingredients were and how refreshing it would be on a hot day like today. He wasn't wrong. The bread was delicious, the veggies were fresh. Everything I wanted. I also couldn't pass up a pastel de nata! It was sublime. They do this series called "first bite and fall where they ask if you wouldn't mind having a bite of the dessert on a quick video they use in their Instagram stories and marketing. As a Yelp elite, I was all too happy to participate! I didn't have to fake a thing, my reaction conveyed just how amazing my first bite was. I chose to take my lunch to go, but they had six 2-tops for anyone who wants to stay and enjoy - it's a very nice atmosphere! read more

I love their sandwiches! The hero roll is wonderful; a light crunch on the outside, soft on the inside, and excellent taste. As a bonus, the owner is a delight to talk to! read more

Delicious bacon,tomato and mozzarella on incredibly fresh crusty bread. Wonderful service from Chef with a caring smile and couldn't have been more helpful. read more

the sandwiches are unique and the taste is amazing. i ordered 5 different sandwiches today for office and everyone loved them. it starts with great hero bread. read more

HELLLO!! If you haven't tried this place ya got to. We couldn't choose so many options that we got a ton of them. Homemade everything. The owner grew up in Naples and lived Lisbon. Get get one. Eric Clapton can do it. So can you! read more

Absolutely loved our sandwiches from here!! The staff was so nice and accommodating, parking is ample, and the food speaks for itself. It's inside Francesco's bakery in a small corner of the bakery. I ordered the pork sandwich special for my hubby, and I got the chicken sandwich but with the turkey instead. It was AH-mazing. The sandwich had pastrami spread and whatever that is, I need more of it in my life. The bread really makes the sandwiches. It's super crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside and just ties the sandwiches together. Can't wait to work in the area again to try other sandwiches--- I mean smartwiches! read more