I finally had the chance to visit the New York Beanery, and I already can't wait to go back. Pete was incredibly kind and patient, offering great suggestions for both food and matcha since it was my first time there. As a matcha lover, I took his recommendation to try the brown sugar matcha--and it absolutely did not disappoint. I ordered the avocado toast (I believe it was the California) and really enjoyed it. I also tried a bite of my best friend's panini, which was fresh, flavorful, and delicious. The ambiance is cozy, relaxing, and perfect for a casual date or catch-up. Highly recommend! read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Food was overpriced. The iced coffee had no coffee taste, except for the bitter taste of coffee when it's sitting old. And you kind of get attitude from the barista when asking if they could replace it or remake it. Two breakfast sandwiches and two horrible iced coffees and it came to $46. I'd rather go to Dunkin. read more

First time finally trying here, I would go back but not a daily thing. I got a small vanilla honey iced latte that is so good. It's not over sweet and can taste the espresso. I also got the empire panini, which was also tasty but small. It was wrapped for like 10 minutes before I ate it and got soggy quick. I feel like it also should have full pieces of grilled chicken rather than cubed, to add to height. visual isn't super appealing but again flavor was great, I am definitely full. I would say the two of these together are more worth like $15 rather than the $20 something it came out to. Staff was pretty nice, not overwhelming and handled the rush well. Overall 8/10! read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

The breakfast is delicious again! So many options and tasty without being heavy. I love the New Yorker and all the avocado toasts. Coffee here is good too but I never have any of the sweet lattes as I'm more of a purist. read more

The coffee options are awesome! There's a really good amount of options to choose from. They have seasonal menu items so that's always fun. The parking kinda stinks but you should be able to find some street parking. Everyone inside is super nice they can help edit any order to your liking. They have more than coffee too. There's tea, food items and other snacks to choose from. It feels like a rustic coffee house when you're inside very quiet and the wall is awesome for pictures. read more

See all

First time here got the rainbow cookie cold brew with oat milk and the matcha chip cookie. Both super good although a little too sweet on the coffee. Service great the baristas were fast and sweet. Their menu was huge with a lot of options. Want to try one of their matches next. The parking however was a little confusing. read more

New York Beanery - Rainbow cookie cold brew - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Coffees are amazing and they are always busy . Nothing more to say but the flavors are very good I always ask for less sweet and they come out perfect ! Also a good place to study or catch up on homework very small though ! read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

I love their drink menu. They have very fun drinks and selections too. I wish the road wasn't so hectic to get in/out! Besides that, the place is very nice read more

This little coffee shop has a difficult parking situation. It's a bit confusing where to turn in. Once in, you'll find a rustic, small shop with a friendly staff. They were willing to make me a coffee that wasn't on the menu list (flat white). The coffee is medium to strong with solid cups but flimsy lids. While I didn't eat here the table next to me told me the food was very good. A nice coffee experience that is worth stopping by for. read more

See all

Love the coffee & food here! Big fan of their crème brûlée latte and also their peanut butter coffee! The employees here are really kind as well and offer great suggestions! Just make note they are closed on Mondays! They have a great feature where you can call or text your order in! Ample parking behind the facility. Great place to check out and try something new! read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Our bldg had a pop-up in the RXR Plaza in Uniondale. They gave us free complementary drinks. I chose the strawberry matcha latte drink. The drink contains strawberry, milk, and matcha. It was so good and freshing. The drink was a tad sweet but overall tasty. Thank you for coming to our bldg. read more

New York Beanery - Strawberry matcha latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Bought a blueberry pie when they brought their pies to HSS Tuesday Nov 25. Delicious full of blueberries. It was blueberry crumb.

We found this gem on IG and took a chance on a rainy Saturday afternoon. Upon entering, first thing one does is look up to the menu on the board. First thing we noticed, no prices. No prices on the menu either. When we asked one of the staff, she didn't know the prices either. I thought that odd. What distracted us was the cacophony of sandwiches, paninis, breakfast offerings. I settled for a turkey club panini. Good choice. I also ordered a Mango Bubble Tea. Sooo good. Especially, chomping on the Bobba tapioca beans. And the piece de resistance, the crumb caaaaaake!!! It was filling and buttery. I could not finish my sandwich and cake. My gal pal who accompanied me ordered the chicken bacon ranch panini. She ate all hers. The food arrived warm and quickly, but without utensils. Another oddity. I had to ask for them. I guess you don't need a fork to eat a sandwich. But still. Not crowded on this rainy Saturday, but people were coming in and out. Music was soft in the background. The three ladies behind the counter, worked efficiently and quietly. Nice quiet spot for a nice quiet Saturday. My meal came to $26. The one bathroom is unisex and clean. Parking is best in the rear. read more

See all

I recently ordered from New York Beanery as a way to support a local, growing business that seems to have decent reviews across delivery services and online media platforms. I ordered something plainly simple so I can try out both their pastries and iced coffee, without having to spend over $20 for one order, though my total amount did come very close to that. I decided to buy their "Cookie Crunch Latte" with a single brownie to go with it, and was pleasantly surprised by how neatly wrapped and secured everything was when it was delivered to me, including the brownie that was wrapped in plastic that I'm assuming was a way to retain freshness and moisture. The coffee tasted a bit off as I did notice that all the sugar content and, what I'm assuming were cookie bits, sank to the bottom of the cup. The coffee itself tasted mediocre and a bit watery, and it was a true pain to spend almost 5 minutes stirring the sunken contents at the bottom of the cup to give the coffee the sugar it was evidently missing, even though I requested my coffee to be made with extra (more) sugar. When the contents were finally evenly mixed, I took a lengthy sip and was disappointed when the taste didn't really change all the much and most of the sugar was coming from the whipped cream that was already slowly melting into my drink. After being slightly disappointed with the coffee, I opened my neatly wrapped brownie, in attempts to save my less than satisfactory experience with my drink. The brownie---to my surprise---was delicious and decadent. Whether the plastic was solely for the delivery or for the purpose of maintaining freshness, it definitely eliminated the occasional dryness and chalkiness that some pastries can have. The brownie mixed with the "watery" coffee, made the overall score of my order way higher and effectively gave the coffee the flavor/sugar it was desperately missing. Overall, a great experience but due to the cost of my order despite how small it was, I will not be ordering from this business again unless I feel up to ordering another delicious brownie (which I very much recommend!). Good job, NYB! read more

Cute shop with lots of choices and friendly service. Very odd that the menu had no prices. I got a medium bubble tea, a small bubble tea, and a small box of 2 macarons. This all cost me $16. I know the macarons was about $5.25 because I asked. I'd give 4 stars if there were prices posted. Boba texture was a on the firm side, but the drinks tasted good. They use powdered mix for the boba, which is pretty standard at a lot of boba shops. read more

See all

I want to love it here! Having passed this place for years, I was always curious. Stumbled upon an instagram post of their Iced Strawberry Matcha Latte & knew it was time to go. I have been visiting for months now, sometimes as often as 5 days a week. I do believe loyalty & continued support should count for something. Consistency is not really a thing here so I have been reduced to sticking with what I love and hoping to love it on that given day. They offer a couple different options for Matcha Lattes. Most notable are the Lavender & Strawberry. They offer milk alternatives & I usually opt for Oat milk. New York Beanery absolutely offers a superior Matcha Latte!!! This makes it difficult to enjoy a Matcha Latte anywhere else. I have tried Classic New Yorker & other Egg Sandwich menu items as well. My sister is a big fan of their Grilled Cheese with Bacon. Their menu also features Acai bowls which we have not yet tried. They have baked goods, both sweet & savory. During the warmer months they have an outdoor seating area/tent. Currently there are tables & window seating indoors. Parking is behind the building, you have to enter the lot shared with Lake Town Motors. read more

See all

Extremely slow. Very short with customers. first time coming here, never coming there again.

I love the New York Beanery. The food is delicious, the staff is friendly and courteous. Such a cute little coffee shop that I've been coming to for years! I recommend the honey vanilla chai latte! Their breakfast items are so tasty and it really is tough choosing what to try! The macaroons are a tasty treat to take home for later! Wish I could give them 10 stars! read more

New York Beanery - Absolutely delicious! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Cozy little place with welcoming staff. The dark roast coffee was solid. Tried a breakfast burrito that was good except it would have been better if they toasted the tortilla wrap. So many other things I didn't try but they looked pretty good. read more

I was in the area for a business meeting and didn't have time for breakfast at home. Searched in google for good breakfast spots and this place came up. I'm happy it did! Went here 2 mornings back to back. The coffee/ice coffee was so delicious and fresh! The breakfast was scrumptious and very good amount. Customer service was great and I was able to prep for meetings within the place with their free wifi available. I'd definitely recommend this place to everyone! read more

See all

NEVER coming back here. I paid $12 for a latte that the barist made INCORRECTLY, then refused to remake it for me. What kind of business hires lazy, inept employees like this???? My order was placed correctly, and it was their job to make it right - which they very rudely failed to do. Do not come here. read more

This place should not be in business unless you like horrible, watered down coffee to go with your ice cold breakfast burrito. Tried the Highland Panini as well which was another disgrace to the state of New York. When I asked if they would kindly switch out the burrito for a small açaí bowl, I was told they would not exchange food or refund it. It took me 3 tries to even speak with the manager as she kept sending out a poor waitress to face the music. Finally, the manager offered to only remake the burrito which I should have accepted just to throw directly in the trash. I wouldn't eat here again if they paid me. read more

Soooooo good! Closed on Mondays, a lot of parking in the back, tables both inside and outside, and really nice atmosphere, as well as a clean setting. My s'mores iced latte was marshmallow and mocha and was delicious. Food came out super quick and really well made. Staff was very nice and patient, kid friendly ( they were very sweet to my toddler as he picked out his muffin ). Lots of different menu items and pricing was very reasonable. Five mins from our house, we'll be back weekly! read more

See all

Such a cute place. People were very nice. The food did come out quickly and it was good, however, it could have been better. The avocado fusion was very flavorful but it would have been so much better if the toast was warm. It was cold like it was defrosting from the freezer. The same for the wrap. It's super cold, the egg was good but the cheese never melted. The flavor was good but it would have been better if it was warmer. The coffee was great. Dairy free option available. The hot chocolate was very good. Perfect temperature to drink right away. Would try again read more

See all

I am addicted to iced lattes and have very high expectations . This cafe met them all. The choices were great, staff friendly and helpful, and most importantly, the coffee was delicious. read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Excellent flavors. Attention to detail. I have been coming here for years and have never been disappointed. read more

New York Beanery - Pumpkin pancakes. A friend had them the other day and I had a bite. Spectacular. I had to come back and get my own. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Have been wanting to try this place since they opened and finally got a chance. I appreciated them letting us call and pay ahead by credit card. I had the iced rainbow cookie latte and my husband had the strawberry banana smoothie. The rainbow cookie latte tasted just like a rainbow cookie! I've never had a latte like that. They offer different milk options so I had mine with oat milk. My husband enjoyed his smoothie and said it was refreshing on a hot summer day. The only con is they are a little pricey and they close early at 3pm. I'd come back though! read more

New York Beanery - Iced rainbow cookie latte with oat milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Small coffee place with all of your essentials. Coffee was good but I wish there were some fresh baked goods. I would go back as the location is very convenient and outside rush hour a good place to do some work! read more

Great spot for a quick bite, coffee or other specialty drink. If you order an iced drink via their website or UberEats, they don't add the ice until it's being picked up (appreciate this). Have tried a few of the breakfast items; breakfast burrito, croissant sandwich, spinach pastry. Ingredients can be replaced/removed to your liking. Worth a try! A few seats inside and seasonal outdoor seating. My personal fav is a decaf iced almond milk latte w/ SF honey vanilla. Hands down my favorite latte on LI. read more

See all

Had a nice lunch sit down with mom and my aunt here, it was really unexpected but the parking lot totally won us over and we were pleasantly surprised at the shop. I had the avocado toast and the only turn off was the insane amount of chipotle aioli they put on it, it was overwhelming and I had to wipe it off. The coffees and donuts were really really good, I think they need to work on the paninis being less salty overall. The service was great and the space itself is clean to fit a few people comfortably read more

Cute coffee shop with a lot of options, but the latte I got was just average. I had the lucky charms latte and at a large for $7 I was really expecting it to knock my socks off. It was just okay which for what I paid was pretty disappointing. The coffee wasn't standout and it ultimately tasted like a cup of milk. They put a lot of care into make the latte and they're extremely friendly and patient, but for that money, I could have gone to Starbucks and got something reliable. They do have a number of other things on the menu that sounded good and if i was in the area or if someone wanted to meet here, I would be all for it, but I won't be going out of my way to come here. read more

Decent food and drinks. Very trendy inside and staff is friendly. Priced competitively with competitors, but for quality of coffee, would rather get a Starbucks. This is cool to have once in a while to switch it up and have something different. They have a lot of pretty good food options as well and some indoor seating. Alittle too loud inside to work from as the cafe is pretty small. All in all, a decent coffee place in Suffolk county. read more

New York Beanery - Balsamic avocado toast. Cookie butter latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Small lil cafe right in the heart of Amityville. The closest place to home I could find boba tea!!! Great staff, very friendly, accommodating, and delicious coffee and tea. read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Randomly stumbled upon New York Beanery over the weekend as I ran some errands and was in dire need of a morning pick me up. Safe to say I was glad to have picked this coffee shop over any other in the area as the service was quick as can be, all covid protocols were being followed and most importantly the food and bev were delish! I kept it simple with an iced latte because if a coffeehouse can't get that right, I dont even want to think about what else is wrong. The coffee was tasty, well balanced and just enough ice to ensure that it was cold but I wasnt getting cheated portion wise. Food wise I opted for the spicy BLT which hit the spot just right. Loved the addition of spinach to the classic sandwich. I'll certainly be back in Amityville and on my way to my final destination, New York Beanery will be a pitstop. read more

New York Beanery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

The açaí bowl was only 1/2 filled, the açaí was freezer burned and quickly melted into a watery mess. The fruit was chopped into tiny, flavorless pieces. I asked for a Nutella add on and got a big dollop of some kind of firm chocolate spread in the middle - definitely did not have the hazelnut flavor or smooth texture of Nutella. I also ordered a latte, which was good, but way too much foam. More of a cappuccino than a latte, but the flavor was good. I'm not sure what the other menu items taste like, but hope they fix their açaí bowls. read more

Amazing coffee spot right on Merrick rd. The staff were super nice and service was quick! The ambiance was super fun, this place is a great alternative to all the chains seemingly on every corner. read more

Starbucks who? First time trying this place and I'm hooked. Went with the rainbow cookie iced latte and breakfast burrito. Top notch quality. You can taste the fresh brewed espresso, not watered down, and everything is the perfect ratio. 10/10 recommend! read more

New York Beanery - Rainbow cookie iced latte & breakfast burrito - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

Super expensive, not soft and chewy at all! They were pretty hard and chalky, even the filling was powdery. I regret spending money on these, I threw the whole box out. read more

New York Beanery - Macarons, super expensive and hard and chalky, I threw the whole box out - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

We recently moved into the area and have been on the hunt for a new coffee spot. Unfortunately, I don't imagine the Beanery will be it. While the spot has all the hallmarks of a cute local shop from pastries to chalk painted walls of their drinks, the product and service leaves something to be desired. This was our second time there, and service was just as slow this time as it was last time. The barista almost gave my drink to two other customers. I ordered the coconut matcha and the matcha was so poorly mixed, it was clumpy at the bottom-- akin to drinking mud. My girlfriend ordered a cold brew with a splash of oatmilk and it looked more like a latte. We both half drank our $20 order, and left pretty disappointed. read more

New York Beanery - Poorly mixed Matcha-- like drinking mud - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Good macarons. The barista was very nice and helpful. She had great recommendations . I bought 1 of each flavor macarons. Some were average, but for the most part, they were crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside and have a generous amount of filling. The parking is really limited. There are 3 spots in the front, then more in the rear but not that much more, and the backup room is tight for those with SUVs. As far as handicap accessibility, they have 1 handicap parking spot in the rear. The threshold is a bit high for self sufficient wheelchair enabled, but do-able with assistance. read more

See all