a must when in town, for your sweet tooth or for a gift . oldest building in town, nice people working there; good ice cream! read more

To the Point: Ordered $150 plus worth of product that was acknowledged but I never received. (Previously shopped at Watson's Chocolates, East Amherst,, Never had issues.....) Sadly disappointed at the customer service. I contacted the store for delivery specifics and I submitted an order online on the afternoon,12/16/25. I was informed by the (young sounding, likely high school age) employee that the orders usually ship 1-3 business days (according to the website US priority mail) but with the holiday may be up to 5 business days.....ok that will still work. I received an email shortly after I ordered online that the order was accepted and being processed. Card was charged on 12/17/25. Order was to have the items during the Christmas holiday. 12/27/25 No order arrived. I sent an email to address listed on website, inquiring about my order. STRIKE 1 12/30/25- NO response from mgt. STRIKE 2 12/30/25 called the store requesting to speak with a manager, request refused. Employee instructed me to send email to the address listed. I stated that had already had been done, had not received a reply, and requested again to speak with a manager, Denied. Employee stated and attempted to check store data base regarding order. Was told that they didn't have the access level to check deeper, Thus the reason to speak with a manager... No information, tracking regarding my order was accessed STRIKE 3 Was told it would be looked into and I would be notified via phone. I understand holiday is busy mail season, US Priority states 1-3 business days, 9 Business days later, no order arrived. Poor service and no confidence in any further order deliveries, based on my experience. read more

You want to buy a quart of ice cream and a cone? Apparently you have to buy the quart at the counter inside, then go outside and get in another line and order the cone outside at the window 6 ft away, even though the ice cream comes from the same place. Ok, it helps your work flow, but for the customer it makes no sense. Or you can just go somewhere else because this is something a place does when they have too many customers. ----( I appreciate the response but it must be confused with a similar customer encounter. I had several in my party that already ordered outside, but I attempted to order inside to buy a quart of ice cream and one to stay. But their "policy" meant I wasn't interested in waiting in line inside to pay for a quart, then go outside and waiting in another line to order and pay for a cone. And it turns out 10 min later it started raining and everyone ordered inside anyway. There may be business reasons for the policy but it doesn't make sense for the customer. read more

Yummy ice cream!!! Inside was so cool. So fun to look at the wall of visitors. There were lots of chocolates and other sweets but they're pretty expensive compared to prices I'm used to. I got a double scoop so I could try the pumpkin gingersnap and Halloween treat flavours. The pumpkin one was very flavourful. I was glad I had another flavour to mellow it out. Both were great and very creamy. We sat outside to enjoy the sun. Very nice place read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Village favorite! Wide selection of homemade ice cream flavors. Some traditional, many unique. I always love browsing the candy and chocolate selections and checking out the comic books & collections upstairs. Service is great & it has a small town business feel. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Wow! What a great place to stop for ice cream! From the delicious homemade choices, to the fun comic book stuff for sale, to the other treats, to the location by Glen Falls, this is a must stop destination for the warmer months! I have visited a couple of times, meeting friends to have lunch, walk around town and the falls, and grab a treat and have always been extremely satisfied with the visit! They have so many good choices of creamy, handmade options. I love their fresh waffle cones! Another thing that sets them apart from the abundance of yummy homemade ice cream in WNY is all the fun stuff in their shop! The upstairs has so many fun toys and trinkets to browse, and there are a variety of other candies for purchase that you can bring home so the treats don't stop. Location can be everything, and I highly recommend pairing a stop for ice cream with a walk around Glen Falls, what could be better? read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

I like everything about this place. The history. The ambience. That it has indoor and outdoor service windows and outdoor seating to enjoy the beautiful Glen Falls Park with your dog. The orange chocolate ice cream is worth traveling for. All of their ice cream is quite good. And all of their chocolates and confections are of high-quality. Although their menu says they have coffee, they don't. For some reason, Sweet Jenny's simply does not serve coffee, which is a shame because that would really make this place an ultimate dessert stop. When customers show the servers behind the counter on their phones, that the digital menu says coffee, they claim that it refers to coffee ice cream. When the weather is warm, there is nothing like walking the park with a cup of sweet Jenny's delicious ice cream in your hand. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Sweet Jenny's was our after dinner treat for the day. It's a very cool, renovated historical building that once served as a flour mill, among other things. It was built in the 1800's. It's very interesting inside. Primarily a homemade ice-cream shop, they also have a lot of chocolate candy and other items for sale. You can view the ice cream production area through a large window. It can be busy but it's a stop you won't regret. It's a beautiful spot and a wonderful place to get some great ice cream. I had a Turtle Sundae. Yum. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Exterior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

Buffalo is apparently know for 3 food items: Buffalo wings, beef on weck and sponge candy. And as a Giants fan, I will also remember them for that missed field goal that put them on the streak of 4 straight Super Bowl losses! I tried the wings and the weck, so I had to try this sponge candy. Sweet Jenny's was nearby and so picked some up. They are not cheap! 1/2 pound was 16.95. Wow! These sponges must be soaking up the $$$!! Were they worth it? Maybe if you never had it before. The toffee in the middle melts in your mouth and so you are left with a chocolate toffee mix that is pretty enjoyable. Think of a Heath bar but instead of the crunchy chewy toffee in the middle, it is a crisp center that disintegrates as you chew it. Not bad. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Pretty expensive bag of sponge candy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

While they no longer offer the toppings folded into the ice cream, Jenny's is still some great ice cream in the heart of Williamsville. I enjoyed the Cookie Monster (chocolate chip cookies and Oreo cookies mixed into some vanilla ice cream, dyed blue). read more

Sweet Jenny's - Enjoying Jenny's ice cream at dusk - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

So easy to work with them to do a fundraiser there! Would not want my fundraiser at any other place

Nothing goes together better than ice cream and summer. Sweet Jenny's is a staple when it comes to Williamsville and ice cream in WNY. I will say, I am not the biggest ice cream person. I enjoy it but I'm not the "every summer night needs ice cream" kinda guy. But this place really has something for everyone. We went with family to go grab ice cream, walk around Glen Park (stay tuned for that review too), and celebrate a couple of birthdays. When you walk in, there is a sense of nostalgia and almost wonder like quality. It reminds me of ice cream shops from my childhood that really established some core memories. Definitely some great vibes in this shop. I ended up getting some of their Oreo Cheesecake ice cream. Just a single serving which was a really great size and pretty good value-wise too. I also ended up finishing up some of the soft serve twist we had for my son. (We call that the Dad Tax) The ice cream was phenomenal when it came to flavor and it wasn't too frozen or too melty, just right in the consistency department. Overall, I gotta give it up to the staff here. They have quick service, super friendly, and put out a great product. There is also a Willy Wonka size amount and variety of candy available. Stay tuned for the dentist review I'll have after eating all of that too. So fun, and we will definitely be back for more! read more

See all

Ice cream in a local spot that offers a fun vibe. Yes. Jenny's is a large red building that clearly holds some history just by looking at it. You'll find street or lot parking and head up the stairs to the entry. Inside it splits to an upstairs area that holds a shop, while downstairs is the ice cream and sweets area. They are located near a bunch of restaurants and quaint stores, so it's easy to do several things if you're looking to make a day or adventure out of it! The staff was always friendly to us when we'd pop in, and it was easy to love the whole experience. Overall: A Parking is the only real hiccup here as it's a busy area, but it's worth a bit of a trek for a sweet treat! read more

This place is all about the Comics, chocolates and ice cream.Great place to find unique comic books.Make sure to indulge and enjoy some amazing chocolates.I really enjoyed my delish three scoop ice cream that was perfect on a hot day.I chose amazing flavors like almond joy, orange chocolate and monkey business, plus don't forget the creamy whipped cream. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Sweet Jennys - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

This business is so cool , there's something for everyone to enjoy.First up for those that enjoy comics there's a plethora to choose from.If chocolate is your thing then enjoy some delicious and creamy Chocolates. Lastly the best way to calm the heat , grab some cool ice cream.I tried the three scoop with yummy whipped cream with flavors like salted caramel, monkey business and granny apple. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Sweet Jennys - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Amazing place with delicious ice cream, candy and gift items. Inside an old cider mill built in 1811 - such a treasure to enjoy. A must when you are in Buffalo! read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

Adorable spot, fast service, excellent ice cream!! I had the creamsicle. Others in my group had Butterfinger and cookies and cream. read more

Sweet Jenny's - We ate the ice cream too fast for pictures of that! :) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

If you go for the ice cream alone, it's amazing. If you go for the homemade chocolate alone, it is even better. If you go for the comic bookstore and collectibles upstairs, you have found the perfect experience. The service there was unbelievable! Super friendly, extremely helpful and the owner is a great guy. I had three generations of my family he was attentive to every one of us - he ask names and how we all fit together. The store is amazing and he did justice by the old flower mill. It is a very relaxing walk-through,l the old building and taking your time to experience all that it has to offer. Such a great concept and greatly executed. Owner should be proud. It is the perfect. "Buffalo" experience. read more

Tasty ice cream and lots of options. When I visited Sweet Jenny's, I was excited to see all the options. Ordering happened at an outdoor counter and the pickup was a few paces down. They had a line, but moved quickly through it. I went for a one-scoop option of one of their chocolate specialty ice creams. The ice cream was rich and one scoop was enough. The only seating they had was outdoors on basic outdoor tables. The tables didn't have umbrella or shade, so we didn't stay for long. I'd say that this place is definitely more of a grab and go scenario, which is fine by me. I liked it! read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Im always amazed at the great service that Sweet Jenny's provides to all of its customers. The variety of chocolates they have is top notch in the area along with the taste. In the summertime, the ice cream they offer is always a great way to cool off. This is a must stop for anyone who lives or coming to visit the Buffalo area! read more

Sweet Jenny's deserves 10 stars! They offer the best chocolate you can get anywhere around here. A huge selection of ice cream, sorbets and milk shakes. And all kinds of candy. And the staff is so friendly. One of my favorite spots to take the kids and watch their faces light up when they walk in. read more

Every time we come up to Williamsville, we must have Sweet Jennys. We left Pittsburgh In enough time to make it before closing time. We were so happy. I almost always get the cinnamon nutmeg (you can't really taste the nutmeg) because I love it. However, I thought I better branch out and try Something new. Chocolate peanut butter swirl got me. It was creamy, chocolate peanut buttery deliciousnesss. My husband wasn't super impressed with the butter beer. It sort of tasted like butterscotch but didn't blow us away. He normally liked the other flavors that he's tried. They're quick to get you your ice cream. We really enjoy them. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Chocolate Peanut butter swirl was creamy deliciousness. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Such a cute little ice cream place! They had tons of unique flavors to choose from. I got the Oreo cheesecake ice cream and it was really good! The ice cream base itself tasted like the cheesecake flavor, which was great. The staff was friendly and got my ice cream to me so quickly. You order at one window and then pick up your ice cream at another window. There's also a little candy shop inside with so many different kinds of chocolate and candy. I liked looking at all the classic candies! Overall I really enjoyed it here! read more

Sweet Jenny's - Oreo cheesecake ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

Pretty good. Def looks like the local ice cream shop. They make all their ice cream and chocolate there. I had a rainbow cookie milkshake. Now I realized after ordering it, it's not Italian rainbow cookie. So a bit mis leading. It was vanilla ice cream with sprinkles, red food coloring and some chocolate pieces. It did hit the spot though and was refreshing on the 80 degree day. They should use boba straws or something wider when the ice cream in the shake has chunks. It was hard to use the straw to drink it when the chunks got caught in the straw. Also you can't try any flavors :( so docking a star since if I was able to try the rainbow cookie I would have realized it's not what I thought. Otherwise staff were nice. The chocolate is okay, I had a caramel cheesecake truffle. Didn't really taste like either. Just a sweet truffley thing. Really cute store though with a comic book shop on top. The building is super old and has so much charm. read more

I have received an ice cream pie from Sweet Jenny's for my last 5 birthdays (and mother's day) and I NEVER WANT ANYTHING ELSE. Ever. Their homemade ice cream is absolutely to die for and their vanilla cookie shortbread crust... man oh man... I love it. The owners are also AMAZING and I love their positive, upbeat, wonderful and uplifting Facebook posts. What an asset to the community! read more

Every time I go to Sweet Jenny's the employees are very kind and patient, the owner as well is super caring and very kind. The candy and ice cream is also amazing, I highly recommend! read more

Sweet Jenny's is definitely a Williamsville staple. The people working at the window are always lovely and even long lines move relatively quickly. The flavors rotate and they have some really special options. I'm not a fruit ice cream person but their black raspberry peach is incredible. My only criticism is the vegan ice cream is very icy rather than creamy. It's been disappointing and even more expensive than the other ice cream, which is already quite pricey. read more

Walked in, got some ice cream, played some asteroids, dude went on a tangent about Mr. Beast, the nice bearded owner gave me a free sky lander. 5/5 experience, I highly recommend to everyone who is near the area. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Sweet Jenny's was one of the stops that we made on our ice cream and chocolate tour of Buffalo! This location was very unique with the mill and the comic book store above. The chocolate was the best that we tasted out of the other stops we made. We also had a chocolate sundae with some fixings, and that was delicious as well! read more

See all

The ice cream and chocolates are absolutely amazing and delicious. The people that work there and the owner are amazing people and are extremely welcoming. The building has a very old school, rustic feeling with a ton of fun memorabilia. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Best stuff for May the 4th! Chocolates, bantha milk ice cream, minis, stickers, and more! Chocolatier, Ice Cream Maker, and Awesome Comic Book Shop. Sweet Jenny's is unique and I love it! read more

See all

The Stracciatella flavor is legit the best ice cream I have *ever* had. And I have lived in NYC! It's a rich vanilla with tiny shavings of chocolate. I also love their vegan peanut butter chocolate when they have it! And you can't go wrong with Sweet Cream or Double Dark Chocolate. read more

I received this box of chocolates for my birthday and it was an amazing assortment of goodies. They were very tasty and I enjoyed them a lot. They have great customer service and I highly recommend them. read more

Sweet Jenny's - Birthday chocolates - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

See all

You are coming here to enjoy everything they have to offer. So many different types of chocolates and of course their house made ice creams. What a assortment of different types of flavors. I didn't get chocolate on this trip. But the ice cream I purchased this trip, was Bailey's and a jack Daniels. Both flavors require you to be 21st old. As for the taste, I feel both tasted quite similar. I feel they both tasted more like a coffee ice cream, than what the liquor they were suppose to be. BUT it still tasted good, and you could feel the alcohol in the ice cream. I will be coming back to try the other Sweets Jenny has to offer. read more

See all

What a great store! From ice cream to chocolates to some vintage candy as well. Always someone to help you and there's even an inside area to enjoy your ice cream on a rainy day. read more

See all

Never have I ever experienced better customer service... not only were the workers lovely and accommodating, even the owner introduced himself and showed us around!!! We planned on making a return visit for the ambience and experience alone... but then we tasted homemade chocolate and ice-cream, which was second to NONE!! 10 out of 10... Highly recommend! read more

Sweet Jenny's - FREE HUGS ice cream flavor is delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York

Looovee sweet jenny's. They have some really good and unique flavors. I highly recommend the oreo cheesecake, and the cookie moster ice cream. Those are two flavors that are really hard to find! But also, sweet jenny's does not have these flavors every day. Their menu seems to change a bit, probably based on availability, so i usually call ahead just to make sure they have my favorites :). Sometimes they don't! They can also make a milkshake out of any ice cream flavor, which is cool. They are pretty good. Great location, great staff, really quick service. They have benches and tables, and you can also just walk around the area and visit Glen Park next door. There's also an area to sit down and eat inside, as well as a cool comic book store inside, with some memorabilia and stuff. My only critique is there's usually a lot of bees when i go in the summer time. One of my favorite ice cream spots in buffalo! I highly recommend. read more

See all

On a hot and humid Sunday afternoon, Sweet Jenny's came through with the treat to cool me down! Some family and I walked over after grabbing lunch across the street and were able to go right up to the outside window and order. Due to COVID, they're asking people to remain outside and order/pickup their treats, which was fine with us. You can go inside but you'll need to wear your mask! Once our orders were placed, we walked onto the porch (shaded, thank goodness!) and waited for our treats to come out. The staff working were incredibly friendly and happy, which is so nice to see during these times. I ended up ordering a small, or single scoop, of their Oreo Cheesecake ice cream, in a bowl. I've had my eye on that flavor for a while and it lived up to all the hype I'd built for it! Their hard ice cream is all homemade and you can tell. The ice cream itself was incredibly rich and creamy with tons of Oreo pieces, which complimented the cheesecake flavor (and pieces). The price for my single scoop was very reasonable as they gave me a very generous amount of ice cream! I don't come to Sweet Jenny's often, or to any ice cream place for that matter, but I definitely want to as they have so many flavors I want to try. They dish up a great experience all-around, from customer service to their delicious, homemade hard ice cream! read more

fairly quick - trim, shape, cut, base coat, top coat --all done. and I leave happy as can be. They are top manicurists!!!!!!!!!!

Oh the sweetest of treats from ice creams of the most wonderful flavours to chocolates of every type in every form from bunny's to baby yoda... Sweet Jenny's is located in the heart of Williamsville in an old mill barn, while they may not be milling with the water of the glen park waterfall anymore, they are still churning out some amazing sweet things! A massive icecream selection that is all made in house with flavours like Oreo latte, double dark chocolate, pumpkin ginger snap, and Cookie Monster to all the classics. Massive rotating flavour selection, vegan options, sundaes, and in season the most glorious house made waffle cones that make the whole building smell delicious! The chocolates you can buy too are made every day, dark chocolate turtles to chocolate covered pretzels or fancy truffles, it's a chocolate lovers paradise. This is quality local stuff and worth the price tag. Yes, it's a tad high where a double (true not heaping) scoop will run you at over $5 but definitely worth it and especially bringing your hard earned dollars back to your local community in exchange for some amazing flavours. They roll out the waffle cones after Easter weekend (I'll be back soon) I would say ice cream season is upon us but in my world it never ended! Enjoy! read more

Sweet Jenny's - April 2021: double scoop, top Oreo latte, bottom double dark chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Williamsville, New York