Speedy service with a smile offering cones, specialty sundaes, milkshakes ,mists and floats.I ordered the baby strawberry sundae and for the price it was a great deal.The sundae was a bic3 size portion and tasty with the right amount of strawberries and whip cream and even a cherry to top it off.You can dine in or out and lots of parking in their lot. read more

See all

I came with my wife on Mother's day. I had seen where they offered moms a free small sundae. Very generous of them. I ordered a baby butterscotch sundae, and it was very good. They have several outdoor picnic tables for when the weather gets warmer. Our counter girl was very friendly and efficient. We will definitely be back for more, read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - baby butterscotch sundae (minus a couple bites) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

With fast and friendly service, I ordered a baby Sundae in butterscotch with whipped cream and a cherry it was so delicious and a generous portion.They offer milkshakes,floats, cones, sundaes and mists. You can eat indoors or outdoors with plenty of on site parking. read more

See all

Cute ice cream shop in North Tonawanda . I got a small bourbon caramel crunch cone and it was enormous . I had to put half of the cone in a dish so I wouldn't drop it and make a mess . My companion's hot fudge sundae was a generous portion as well . Staff was nice and efficient, establishment was clean . A nice quick stop to satisfy my sweet tooth. read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

I had the maple sundae in a cup. It had maple ice cream which was very creamy and delicious. It had chopped pecans, whipped cream and caramel with maple drizzle. 10/10 recommend. read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Maple sundae in a cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

Love this local ice cream place! They usually have a special flavor each week! My favorite is the orange creamsicle! Yum! read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

Love this place. Great place to go hang out and have some ice cream. And what is also great is that it is part of Wurlitzer Pizza. So you can take the family and have some pizza/subs etc and have some ice cream for dessert. Very comfortable and a nice place to just sit and enjoy. Nice neighborhood establishment and our go-to for take-out or to order at the counter and eat there. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Reasonable prices. Highly recommend. read more

Having our original plan fallen through, we went up the street to find a quick solution to our hunger. And unlike the "happy mistake" that I picked out of the freezer, this place was anything but. We wanted pizza, and they were only offering pepperoni, so I skipped out. Probably for the better, as my mate, who bought two costly slices said it was too doughy, the sauce was flavorless and while the cheese was fine, the barely there meat did not merit the 3.50 price tag. My pals ordered sandwiches, which they said were not up to their usual quick dining snuff. Alright enough to eat, with its thick bread, but not really the birthday meal they were hoping for. We were all curious about the Blue Moon mystery, so not seeing anything worth my banging buck on the vegan menu, I picked the Happy Mistake, marked a dollar out of the freezer, only to be told by another disinterested employee that it was in the system for $2 despite the sticker and then she would not change it. Still nobody could figure out the mystery but I think I won today. Or maybe not considering the ceiling dripped on me as flies buzzed around my head. There's a sign explaining that prices are inflated due to the nature of today's world but they don't post the new prices which for a group on a budget definitely knocks it down a star. And honestly the only thing giving it the star is that they boast a long list of Perry's to choose from. There are too many other options in this neighborhood for a quick bite to suggest coming here. Sure you can dine in but maybe sometimes it's worth just getting take out. read more

See all

Always a great place to go to. Huge selection of Ice Creams, the ice creams are all very good, and they are generous with the portions.

In my opinion excellent ice cream and custard very clean the young ladies working behind the counter were very polite everything was clean and to my surprise there's a pizza shop inside the ice cream shop a dream come true Took my granddaughters there after soccer practice and the menu is way too big it took them too long to read everything just to get the first thing that they looked at The atmosphere in this ice cream shop was perfect we'll definitely go back read more

Recently after my mom had dental extractions, we decided to stop for a milkshake. The girl that wait on me was extremely pleasent and helpful. The location and place itself was convenient for a one stop purchase for pizza through Wurtilzer Company or icecream. The baby twist ordered was fine, a few stars were taking off for the milkshake. Ordered a large size parkerhouse milkshake, that overall as I did try it had no taste, all you could taste was the icecream carton. I understand not a lot of people don't buy icecream in December. Little disappointed as the milkshake was $5.45 and had to be thrown out. read more

Visiting family and decided to stop on in for this ice cream. They have frozen custard and ice cream so very got what they craved! They offered us to try out some flavors which was definitely appreciated as they had some flavors i haven't heard of. I tired the Salted Caramel coffee ice cream and I was in heaven! read more

So Jamie's not only has a full menu of Perry's ice cream but custard too. They also have two Specialialty brands that I included the menus of that we definitely have to come try. Jamie's is definitely a neighborhood ice cream favorite. The young lady who was working was absolutely lovely. Professional , helpful and cheerful. Not as easy as it sounds these days. After a very long deliberation we decided to go with items off their specialty sundae menu. One Trash Can Sundae, vanilla, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce , rainbow sprinkles , whipped cream and a cherry! One Volcano Sundae, inverted waffle cone,vanilla custard, dripping with hot fudge and peanut butter sauce,surprise strawberry ice cream core, frozen strawberry, whipped cream and a cherry. It was a lot of everything all for $13. We definitely wanted to lay down and take a nap after that. But honestly Giffords and Ashby's are both ice cream brands with really unusual flavors that sound well worth driving back to try. read more

See all

Most excellent! We were craving ice cream, so we headed on over to Jamie's. It was my first time here and I have to say.... completely satisfied! The staff was friendly and I enjoyed learning the difference between custard and regular ice cream. I ordered a root beer float that was delicious. What's more, they gave me the leftover can of root beer to refill my float! My friend had a sundae and she loved it. Definitely would go here again! read more

See all

Owned by Jamie Cullum, Jamie Redknapp, Jamie Carragher, Jamie Theakston, and employing head ice cream chef Jamie Oliver. Oh wait, those are all British celebrities. OK, how about, it's owned by Jamie Foxx, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jamie Lynn Sigler, Jamie Lynn Spears, Jamie "James" Franco, and Jamie E from Yelp Buffalo (swoon). What to get: Soft Servce What not to get: Soft during coitus, she might feel rejected or annoyed Why: idk I'm not her, don't soot the messenger How to improve: Stop serving Perry's! Make your own hard ice cream! But hey, I guess if people want Perry's, sigh. Your soft serve, however, is top notch. Jamie's is a really lovely Ice Cream shop with delicious soft serve in North Tonawanda. Their hard ice cream selections are Perry's (which is a local brand but is not made in house and so I'm not into it), but their soft serve is all theirs, and it's delicious. I've tried about 5 different flavours, which they vary often, and every single one I've had was perfect. The vanilla, the chocolate, the strawberry, and others. While I prefer the custard at the heavenly Hibbard's in Lewiston, and for hard ice cream I'm more into Antoinette's and Sweet Jenny's, when it comes to soft serve in WNY other than Hibbard's, it's Jamie's and it's Green Acres. Absolute perfection. Not a lot of people know about Jamie's, and maybe North Tonawanda locals would like it to stay that way. This is not somewhere that kids and families from all over the region will come for ice cream. It's a neighbourhood shop for people who live in these parts. But I'm not one of those types who wants a place to be hush hush and secret. I want places to thrive and make money and succeed and stay in business forever - and that goes for all businesses with decent morals. So I want people to know about Jamie's. And that is why I wrote this review. And on a macro level, that is why I Yelp. read more

See all

Decent ice cream with a ton of variety. Usually never a long wait and they have so much variety for sundaes. They have arctic blasts (custard with mix ins), multiple flavors of custard, hard packed Perry's ice cream and Slushees. Good place for a small or large group to stop for a treat. Plenty of parking and in the same building as Wurlitzer Pizza. A regular stop in NT. read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

I frequently stop here for ice cream while in the area. Decently priced. You can get standard soft serve and Perry's brand ice cream read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

A very nice ice cream place. Lots and lots of flavor choices. Plenty of seating outside, even with current Covid-19 regulations in-place. Ice cream was delicious, and it was ready in an instant. The only drawback is that the menu is kinda confusing. Different colors, font styles, and sizes make it difficult to read. read more

Love love love love love!!! Did I say love??? In the midst of this crazy world we're going through right now, I wanted to treat my daughter to some ice cream after she did really good on her math lesson! I don't live in tonawanda but was dropping something off when I saw this place! I thought, forget andersons! Let's give this a shot! Looks locally owned and operated! Let's support the small businesses!! And I'm so glad I did! We got 2 ice creams for $10 something. Mine was a medium peanut butter something Sunday and hers was cookies and cream with sprinkles and whipped cream. It was phenomenal!! If you need a place for ice cream that's not a chain, stop by here!! You'll thank me later! read more

Had a meeting at the public library in NT and couldn't miss a chance to stop in for ice cream. My two friends got the orange chocolate custard. They loved it just isn't my thing. My nephew got a scoop of cookies and cream and chocolate chip cookie dough. He highly recommends that combo. With all these choices I settled on my standard twist with rainbow sprinkles in a waffle cone. Hard to find one as delicious as my Anderson's. But this was great. You can taste the love. Freshly made daily and a laundry list of different sundaes the can make for you. They are also connected to Wurlitzer Pizza Co. never had it but it smells great. Staff is young but always kind. read more

Lots of parking, pizza next door, and SO MANY FLAVORS. Not just ice cream, but sundaes, pie and ice cream combos, and gluten free desserts. Some outdoor seating and a while bunch of tables placed haphazardly inside, but we were the only ones there. They have tiny cups for water to wash down the sweetness too. Sign was up saying to ring bell for service but they called over before we were even ready to order. read more

It's pretty sad when all the girls behind the counter greet my family or I with ... you're back again, huh?! They do a great job with ice cream. My little guy loves when we bike ride here and he gets his vanilla cone with rainbow sprinkles. We like how there is always a big assortment to choose from and every season...there are new flavors. Try the apple pie dessert. It cannot be to calorie friendly, but it is delicious. read more

This is a small ice cream shop with a large selection of Perry's ice cream, but also their own custard with a variety of unique flavors like cotton candy and raspberry in addition to the usual chocolate and vanilla. Prices are comparable to other ice cream shops. Service is friendly and efficient. read more

I stopped by this ice cream shoppe while home in WNY on a quick trip. I was craving soft serve with sprinkles. You don't really get that kind of ice cream elsewhere, especially where I live in CO. It's all froyo and hard homemade ice cream places, which are expensive! But for some reason I didn't get my twist with rainbow sprinkles, I got Perry's because its a staple in WNY isn't it? It was good of course. The establishment was clean, the people friendly. I'll be back when in town again! read more

We complained TWO YEARS AGO (2019) that they didn't POST THEIR PRICES in the store. Every time you need a price they have to run around to ask someone who might know. Skip ahead to this year (2021) and the prices STILL ARE NOT POSTED! Are they running a scam? I haven't seen any other places without prices. I will be reporting this to the county. read more

Decided to order my childhood favorite Perry's "Mint ting a ling." Upon first bite it was obvious it was not mint ting a ling as advertised but some kind of mint chocolate chip. My son took it back up to the window and explained this is not what we had ordered. The girl said "Oh, we don't have Mint ting a ling right now just Mint Chocolate chip but we can remake you something for $1" by this time the ice cream is starting to melt every where. I go back up this time and explain that you have something advertised, we were not told it wasn't available when we ordered, I'd like something different please. I'm guessing she was the manager, turns around from scooping ice cream & yells to me from across the room that the flavors are the same thing and that if I don't like it I can pay for something different. I set the melting cone inside the window & said no thanks. We'll go else where that actually serves what is advertised & has better customer service. read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

See all

The worst Sundae I every have. You can count the nuts on it. There Medium milkshakes is small to others places like Hoover. Dee'sDees. Last time I go there. read more

I have three favorite ice cream places in the 716, and this is one of them, (Condrell's and Nina's are my other faves). If pressed to choose a top-spot, most days this would be it. Jamie's has excellent soft-serve, and my favorite fluffer-nutter sundae in town. I have quite the discerning marshmallow-PB palate, and this sundae does not disappoint--lots of gooey sauce, whipped cream, and reeses-pieces a top airy, light vanilla soft-serve. It is simple bliss. My fam' is always pleased with their picks too; the hubbs likes a cherry-chocolate sundae concoction, and the kids usually go for one of the wide-array of hard-scoop Perry's flavors. The atmosphere is a bit 80s, a bit old-timey, with ample seating inside and out. Prices are very reasonable, and the teens who work the counter are usually pleasant. Attached to Jamie's is Wurlitzer Pizza, so you can make a whole gluttonous meal out of one visit, if you'd like. In the summer the ice cream line can get long, but they keep it moving pretty quickly and it is worth the wait. If you have a hankering for a stellar soft-serve treat, head to NT and give Jamie's a try! read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Moving sucks. A quick break and a quiet dinner for two with a mountain of onion rings helps. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

The charming young man by the name of Sam served us and I must say his dirt was more bussin' than Otto's. Highly recommend asking for his service. read more

I have come into jamies the past two days and it's ridicoulus at how much an ice cream cone has cost. I used to come here because it was the cheapest place around. NOW three small cones cost $20 and then the next day a small cone and dole whip cost $15... and both times we ask the worker if that's correct and both times they gave us attitude and said yeah that's correct. DO NOT have your prices listed if you're going to double the price at checkout. NEVER coming here again unless the idiot workers learn how to use a cash register and read prices correctly. Platters just got a huge bunch of new loyal customers!!!! read more

Very good for any type of ice cream ! Custard is very good. Hot fudge is delicious along with the peanut butter topping and marshmallow topping! Service is always good and prices aren't bad! read more

Jamie's is awesome. Although the inside does smell a bit like fryer grease (thanks to Wurlitzer Pizza which shares a building) they serve up Perry's ice cream, which everyone knows is the best. My only complaint is that a baby-size cone is easily enough for two adults, but since the prices are so reasonable I don't complain very hard. (Plus, extra ice cream). They have picnic tables outside where you can sit and avoid getting ice cream drips in your car. read more

I have lived in Buffalo my entire life, and although we don't have a warm climate all year long, we still love our ice cream. Before moving to my current home I had never been to, or even heard of, Jamie's Ice Cream. My husband grew up in that neighborhood, and it's one of those long time local traditions. Now I see why! Jamie's is not your run-of-the-mill ice cream joints. They carry Perry's ice cream in a myriad of flavors(for those of you who are not from Buffalo, Perry's is made locally and distributed to over 30 countries!). Now for the best part......Jamie's has so many specialty items it will put a permanent smile on your face. From shakes to sundaes, you can have something different every time and never run out of options. Ice cream......it's not just for summertime anymore! read more

Jamie's Ice Cream - Worms n Dirt Sundae! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - North Tonawanda, New York

Freshly baked pie ice cream sundaes and everything else you could possibly want! The sundaes are big enough to share. This would be a great spot for motorcycles to stop since there is ample paved parking in the plaza. read more

Been going here since I was little love it here, good custard and the sizes are really big for a good price. They have a custard machine with 9 different flavors so you don't have to just choose between chocolate vanilla or twist. These's Carmel, pistachio and cool flavors like that. There's a good list of stuff to choose from. read more

Nice little neighborhood ice cream shop. Large variety of goodies Generous servings Very friendly staff Ice cream is typical quality. Was hoping to be surprised with some excellent homemade ice. It wasn't but still enjoyed our custard dipped and fudge sundae. read more

Absolutely terrible customer service. Went to get ice cream and they served all 4 people in front of me and when it was my turn to order they shut the lights and wouldn't take my order because they were closed. They closed at 8:30....I went to order at 8:32 WHILE I WAS IN LINE for longer than 5 mins read more

Always the best ice cream in NT. Would've given 5 stars, but the line is normally outrageously long. So then the wait is. Need to work on more servers taking orders. read more

This location is in route to thruway and my son usually sees it so we stop in. The inside is split with a pizza place so you get the generic grease smell and feel. They have a big ice cream selection but they like many other ice cream shops use younger people to work there. This isn't a bad thing but get ready for the usual double repeating of your order. I'm glad they hire younger teens because God knows they need something to do during the summer. For a quick, clean and friendly location this is the ice cream shop for you. Banana splits are on point!! read more

Fantastic spot. You know it's a great ice cream spot when you order a small that looks like it could be a large. Sprinkles on point. Fudge is delicious. 10/10 read more