This is not a pink cup -- it's a loganberry milkshake! Even as a Buffalonian, I was skeptical of this tasting good. I was pleasantly surprised by the flavor and want another one already! Also, lots of nice seating outside and super friendly staff. Check this place out before the snow hits! It'll be here before you know it... read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Loganberry milkshake!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Went to Frosty's with my grandson and his girlfriend on a warm afternoon. I lived on Broadway 2 blocks away in 2004-2014 so I took my grandson many times for ice cream here he was 4 when I 1st took him now he will be 25 next month and he is paying for my ice cream! I had a baby cone of blueberry cheesecake loved it with plenty of pieces of cheesecake and loads of blueberries!!! My grandson had a warm brownie Sunday he almost finished it just like a child he could never eat all his ice cream that's because you get a lot with whatever you get! Plenty of brownies, whipped cream and chocolate sauce looked so good! His girlfriend got a strawberry daiquiri in a cup she really liked it she ate it all . They have plenty of choices at Frosty's there is something for everyone and wooden trains for the kids to play in while you are there. It brought back memories we haven't been there in about 6 years we are already planning another visit by the end of summer maybe a pineapple milkshake next time they are awesome here! The young girl was so friendly and helpful to help us decide what we wanted! I remember the workers were always friendly especially one of the owners who always wore a silly hat! We missed him today! read more

See all

Sorry no photo, too busy eating! Love the soft serve and the portions are gigantic! Always have a long list of Perry's ice cream you don't see anywhere else. Cute old gas station building and climb on toys for kids. I would come here every day if it weren't for my diet! read more

Oogie Boogie approves! Came at the right time as it just got done raining and there was no one there. Perfect little treat with so many different options. As always, service was great and cashier was nice. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

This is such a cute little ice cream shop on the popular Broadway street. Their parking lot is essentially non-existent so your best bet is to park on the street. They are cash-only but if you forget cash, they do have an ATM attached to the back of the building. At first glance of the menu, it is so easy to get overwhelmed with all of the choices - hard & soft ice cream, sundaes, milkshakes, full ice cream cakes, floats, etc. The prices seemed a little high for the standard ice cream cones, until you see the size they actually give you. If you order a small, prepare to get atleast a medium that you would get at other places! I ordered a small and couldn't eat it all! This place is super busy in the summer so prepare to wait in line! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - This is a small?!?! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I am so glad I discovered Frostys! I already loved them when I discovered that they had a entire vegan menu (and normal ice cream too!). I became obsessed when I tasted the vegan mint chip ice cream. Not kidding when I say I thought about it every day for like a week after eating it. Then I returned and ate it again and it was as great as remembered. The portions are huge! I recommend getting a small and you will still be full. Also, it is cash only but they do have an atm. The best thing about frostys is the variety. They have milkshakes, sundaes, ice cream cones, ice cream cakes. Try it all! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Vegan mint chip ice cream (size small) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

I have been a regular at both Frosty's locations for many years. They offer flavors you can't find anywhere else, especially when it comes to frozen custard. And their cones are quite large. I'm a big girl who loves their sweets and even I have a hard time finishing a medium. I've never dared try a large. They're so big that they can't roll them in sprinkles. Yeah. That's crazy. read more

I scream, you scream! Who doesn't love ice cream? I've been coming here for years and Frostys never disappoints. Huge variety of ice cream flavors, including vegan options, sundaes, milkshakes, ice cream sandwiches, ice cream cakes, and so much more! Today when we stopped by, I got a bowl of "very bad breakup" which was oh SO GOOD! If you're like me, a "baby" size of ice cream will be plenty. It might just be one scoop, but it's a giant scoop! It's also a great place to bring kids, they have a wooden fire truck kids can climb inside of and play. They've also been doing a great job to keep social distancing in place by drawing lines and arrows on the ground to direct traffic. FYI - its cash only, and although there's some parking near the shop, most people park on the street. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

My Favorite place for ice cream! Also, the cakes are better than anywhere else. Yum! I can never get an ice cream cake anywhere else! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Frostys ice cream cake! The best! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Even though I live in the southtowns, Frosty's is my favorite place to stop for ice cream. We always try to swing by when we're in the area during the warmer months. This place is always bumping, too, due to the great location on Broadway in the heart of Lancaster village. They have a HUGE menu, but my favorite part is the amount of non-dairy options! They usually have two non-dairy flavors of ice cream, plus sorbet, and a dole whip. They can also make floats, sundaes, and other goodies with those non-dairy flavors so you're not just stuck with a plain cone. I've had the peanut butter oreo sundae twice in a row and it's fabulous! My only complaint is that it's sooo full of goodies it's hard to eat without dropping some of the toppings- which is a good problem to have. They have a lot of seating and a few umbrellas so you can get out of the sun. Parking can be tight so we usually head for the side street next to the shop to avoid getting into & out of the lot. read more

Last night we stopped by this Frosty's, (they have two, another in Depew). At this location, parking in the small lot is limited. It was pretty busy when we went, so we had to park a ways down the side street. But we were planning on taking a walk after ice cream anyway, so no big deal for us. This location is CASH ONLY, so be sure to have some green on you if you come here. There were enough benches and tables to accommodate the crowd, although most were full. Just an FYI that seating may be limited if they are particularly busy. This Frosty's is in a rickety-looking little building with window service. One window is to order, and the other side is for pickup. The menu is a haphazard assortment of boards, and faded printout pages. The window service team was very friendly. I didn't see a sundae I wanted, so just asked if they did a fluffernutter kind of sundae, and the worker kindly pointed me in the right direction. So don't be afraid to ask nicely for what you want if you don't see it in the wonky menu printouts. Frosty's offers several alcohol-infused options. You do need to show ID to purchase these. My husband had the Strawberry Daquiri sundae. It was a very generous size, all dolled up with a drink umbrella on top. My husband said it was very fresh fruit and creamy ice cream. He could definitely taste the booze, too. I took one bite, and it did have a little kick! My Fluffernutter Crunch Sundae was also sizable and delish. The vanilla soft serve was just how I like it, very light and airy, and somehow less cold than typical soft serve. After we ate, we took a stroll around Lancaster. The hubbs was definitely walking a little zig-zaggy, so his ice cream's alcohol content was sufficient. :-P The cash-only payment, lack of parking, and disjointed menu makes this Frosty's not my absolute favorite ice cream stand. But if we're nearby and in the mood for a cold sweet treat, Frosty's still has a lot of delicious offerings that get the job done. read more

See all

We ordered a small cone (no pic because it was seconds until my husband took a bite and I'm not quick enough). We also had a Yelp Elite sample of a strawberry daiquiri sundae. The cone was huge and the ice cream was so good. The sundae was full of strawberry daquiri ice cream, regular strawberry ice cream, strawberries, sauce and whipped cream. I couldn't eat it all so I gave the leftovers to my dad and he LOVED it. Frostys is a great stop! read more

See all

I wish I knew about this ice cream stand the first time I took my boys to Como Lake Park. Like most ice cream stands, they offer Perry's Hard Ice Cream and probably have one of the largest assortments, but they also have custard and various specialty items. One of my sons had a "baby" cookies 'n cream. It's one big scoop. A small is two scoops, a medium is three, and I think a large is four. My other son had a small dirt and worms sundae with their vanilla custard, oreo cookie crumbles, a few gummy worms and whipped cream. I had a small shark attack sundae with this blue raspberry sauce that hardens into a shell on the outside but also oozes from the inside, gummy sharks and whipped cream. Personally I would have gotten a kick out of a red sauce, but I suppose that would be less enjoyable for the kiddies. All this was under $10. They have a few covered benches and a couple wooden vehicles my boys enjoyed playing in. read more

See all

I met the owner Dave while ordering a single scoop hard ice cream of coconut with chocolate bits! It really hit the spot with this heatwave/covid-19 this year! Dave was more than 6 ft from me with mask on but his eyes smiled brightly! I discovered a Wine Ice cream as well, YES that was also put on my Bill! The total was less than $9.00! I got a Reisling Ice cream for later! You will be caredellThere is no picture of my cone! I ate it too fast...next time I'll post it. The area has a wooden train but yellow tape prevents the kids from playing on it. It has social distancing is here, Cash only please! Too many flavors for ice cream (Perry's Brand 40 varieties) cones, slushies or milk shakes to mention, just support the local business! You will not be disappointed! Fyi: I went last night and had 2 scoops of Kalua Almond Ammaretto! Don't judge me, it's so damn hot! read more

See all

Holy options! And size! Frosty's has been a favorite of mine since I was a kid! They are taking necessary precautions for covid- they even were wearing ice cream themed masks They are cash only, but have an atm on site. As someone who is Dairy Free- I was shocked with how many Dairy Free and Vegan options I had and how much they give you. They have a wide selection of Perry's ice cream, soft serve and hard serve. I got a Fizzy with lemon sorbet and strawberries. It was exactly what I needed on this hot day. All workers are extremely nice. Can't wait to come back ! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Loved it! Just so you know it's cash only but they have an ATM there. The menu was great and the ice cream (Perrys I had) was good.

Frosty's is for sure a treat! The building itself looks like a little old house from a children's fairy tale lol. There is plenty of seating and a few little things for kiddos to play in. They have everything from Ice cream to custard, smoothies, vegan options and more! They are also cash only but there is an ATM read more

See all

Delicious! Serving Perry's ice cream. Lots of options, including dairy free. Cash only, which is not ideal--especially in a pandemic. But on-site ATM for those of us that rely on plastic payment. While I didn't finish the whole thing, I appreciate the generous portion sizes! The small is more than enough ice cream with two huge, heaping scoops. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Dairy free Cookies & Cream and Queen of Hearts! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Great ice cream with a wide variety of flavors and options. The historic building is really unique and adds to the experience.

This is a small ice cream shop in Lancaster. A friend met me here yesterday after work. It was our first time here. We both saw their Facebook advertisement mentioning their new flavors. (The PB & J Twist at the Broadway location and Strawberry Banana Swirl at the George Urban location.) We stopped here because we wanted to try the PB & J twist first. It was peanut butter custard swirled with a strawberry dole whip. We each ordered a small. They were HUGE!!! They were definitely the size of a large and I was so happy about that. Unfortunately, this place is cash only!!! That sign made me sad. I got here first so I mentioned that to my friend who took out cash on the way here for us. (I usually never carry cash on me.) Besides the HUGE (small sized) peanut b & j twists, we also each had some liquor flavored ice cream. I had strawberry daiquiri and it was so good!!! (This business also sells wine ice cream, ice cream cakes, cones, sundaes, banana splits, arctics (like DQ's blizzards) and many other cool things!!! The people here are friendly and have great customer service skills. There are picnic benches and wooden equipment for kids to play on. There is some parking behind the business or you can park on the street. Come check out this cool little ice cream shop. You'll definitely be happy that you did!! read more

See all

The ice cream is great, and the people who work there are always friendly! The only negative is that it's clear the accommodations are in serious need of a facelift. We're always nervous we're going to break through the tables, and the play equipment seems to be on its last legs. It would also be great if there were some napkin dispensers outside. It's ice cream, so you pretty much always need more! read more

I tried to hit on the cute girl serving me, but I got a Frosty reception. I was like, "are you married", she said "no man. But you can do the job, when you're in... your dreams." So yeah that didn't go well for me. What to get: vanilla frozen custard. I'm a traditionalist, so I only get their regular frozen custard, which is excellent. It's not the best in town (hello Abbott's!) but it's certainly very tasty. Much like my girlfriend. Good things about Frosty's: - excellent vanilla custard - they have an insane selection, like, too much to try in 25 visits. - they are very innovative with the sh** that they come up with. - they are wildly popular so they make tons of crap, so everything is fresh. - they are fairly cheap, especially if you order smalls and baby sizes. - they replaced someone's ice cream after she argued that she got the wrong thing. Bad things about Frosty's: - they use Perry's ice cream instead of homemade, so get the soft serve unless you love Perry's. - some of the servers are not the friendliest, hence the name of the place. - they are closed all winter... which is a long f***ing time around here. - their stuff is way too sweet... especially when you start adding stuff to it. - so much sugar in these products that your face will screw up and you'll become diabetic. - as the other reviews attest, they're not always so good about replacing stuff. - the lines can be very very very long on a warm day, especially in the evening. Skip Dairy Queen, skip Cold Stone (permanently... ew), and come here and give your dessert money to a local place instead. It's delicious and the servers will make you feel tiny if you ask them out. In more ways than one. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Baby vanilla n cherry dipped - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Omg so many options to choose from! Love the varieties of ice creams, shakes, sundaes, and they also have liquor hard ice creams, wow can't wait to try other items from Frosty's soon. We went mid afternoon so it wasn't too crowded. I got the salted caramel pretzel sundae and my friend got the cannoli sundae. They were so big and perfect for a sweet treat. Both the sundaes were so delicious. Luckily me and my friend came empty stomach, so we finished our sundaes. But definitely worth having dessert as a meal and this satisfied the sweet tooth. read more

See all

Great ice cream place. They have soft serve, Perry's hard ice cream and sorbet. I had a twist soft serve dipped in chocolate. It was very good. They have cake and waffle cones. Lots of hard ice cream flavors to choose from. Great prices too. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Twist soft serve dipped in chocolate. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I love Frosty's!! Close to home, huge selection of Perry's flavors with inventive flavors for sundaes and their version of blizzards. Friendly staff and reasonable prices. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Popular on a warm summer night - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Cool place. Tons of flavors to choose from and things for kids to play around in/on. Prices are great. I will definitely go back the next time I'm out this way. So glad I stopped! read more

I don't want to be harsh but when I go to an ice cream place and you have no hard vanilla ice cream then you probably shouldn't even be open. Also, their dip-and-dot thing I ordered had freezer burn. So 0 for 2 on my experience. read more

How could you not like frosty's? This is truly a neighborhood ice cream shop. It's a little converted gas station that looks like a gingerbread house - extremely charming. The baby size cone is the perfect dessert size. They have probably a hundred different things to choose from, and I'm able to get two cones for less than $5. All of the people who work there are very friendly and welcoming. My favorite flavor this summer was the honey roasted peanut. It was a sad day when they ran out. It was okay though because they still had a bunch of Perry's flavors which are outstanding. Go here and make memories with your family and friends. read more

Went to try the "YELP" special tonight, since I'm on a mission to fill up my passport card for YELPs Ice Cream month & to help raise $ for Mercy Flight. Now, Ice Cream is one of my favorite foods, but I personally was not excited about raspberry sauce on my Ice Cream or Fruity Peebles, yikes~ My husband and 2 kids thought it was good. The banana split walking by us looked amazing, and I don't like fruit on or in my Ice Cream. Frosty's is clearly a residents favorite, as parking lot filled up quickly and lines were forming to Order. Perry's Ice Cream is everywhere, so I don't have to go back. Cash Only too, there is an atm on site. Wooden train for kids on cement, not grass~ Picnic tables looked dirty. Only outside seating. I'm taking it easy, since my family enjoyed the experience tonight. read more

See all

We visited last night to try out the cannoli sundae. We definitely were not disappointed! It tasted amazing and was plenty to share between two people. Their menu is a bit disorganized and chaotic, but newcomers just need to take their time and read all the options! I also got a root beer float, with lactose free ice cream- which was really good! Really awesome they have so many lactose free flavors too. Also just a note- the line was super long when we arrived, there was about 15 people in front of us. And we got through the line in about 10 minutes. They move really quickly and it's totally worth the wait. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Cannoli sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I give this place a whole frickin 5 stars!!! (until I get fat) :P This place is nothing short of amazing. You would think soft serve is just soft serve, but they soft serve is special. It's super creamy and tasty! I don't even know how to describe how creamy and velvety the soft serve is. They also have hard ice cream from Perry's, which I am not a huge fan of, but they have so many different flavors here that I am forced to like it. The cannoli ice cream is actually pretty damn good, but not even as close to being as good as their soft serve. The soft and hard ice cream are pretty decently priced. From baby sized one scoop to large size three scoops. The small size is $2.65 for soft and $2.75 for hard. Small size is more than enough for one person. Their sundaes are a bit expensive considering it's just soft serve and not so kosher toppings like gummy worms or something for about $5.25. They also have strange pricing for other things like 50 cents for a waffle cone, but then 50 cents for sprinkles. Huh? Anyway, you can forgo those, just get the damn soft serve! The place is actually pretty cute. It's outdoors so they have different hours depending on the weather so I always call ahead of time. They're super friendly and fast. They have benches with umbrellas outside for you to sit, but they also have like wooden cars and trucks (I think that's what they are?) for little kids to play in while enjoying ice cream! :D read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Warm brownie sundae and small ice cream cone with cannoli and kahlua amaretto almond ice cream! :) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Ugh so many children. My nightmare. Anyway, there are so many options it is severely overwhelming. I usually get cotton candy anything and everything. But they have Perry's, which isn't my favourite kind. SOOOO, I got a Samoa arctic swirl thing....so freaking good. I enjoy that there is coconut in every bite. Unlike Dairy Queen blizzards, where their proportions of toppings to ice cream are like 1:5. Dumb. I got my Dad a warm brownie sundae, which I asked for with hard chocolate instead of vanilla custard. They got this correct. I asked for my Samoa arctic with chocolate ice cream as well....they gave me vanilla. Luckily, I don't hate vanilla I just prefer chocolate. So, not a deal breaker, but still disappointed. My step-sis got a twist with chocolate sprinkles....boring. But she got a baby size, which is a normal human size small. My step-mom got a Reese's arctic which also looked decent but I hate peanut butter. The line went quickly, and they served pretty quickly. It's a cool place and I didn't realize it was on the registry of National Historic places, that was kind of neato burrito. CASH ONLY. Be aware of this or you will be sadly disappointed. I never carry cash so if I want Frosty's I have to be prepared. X's and O's! J read more

See all

Excellent frozen bananas, good chocolate and great with nuts. Local business which I prefer to support.

Staple of Lancaster! Perfect place for a date or to bring the kids! Owner is almost always here wearing a funny hat! And the service is phenomenal! Been coming here for years! Since I can remember I've always remembered the fun I would have coming to frostys!! At times there will be a wait, but if your a local this shouldn't be a problem because there's always someone around to talk to! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Loving me some ice cream!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

We were going to order a three scoop hard ice cream. We picked three different flavors and they said you could only get two flavors. Don't get more than two scoops unless you are fine getting more than one scoop of a flavor. The ice cream and cone tasted great. Big sizes. Small building falling apart but looks cool. Two wooden trucks for the kids to play in. 4 out of 5 stars. read more

Disappointed with Frosty's. I ordered an arctic with Heath bar. I tasted it and there was little to no Heath so I returned to the window. They told me "there's a little in there". I said that's weak, please add more. He returned with a little Heath bits on top. The Heath had no chocolate on top so basically this was an over priced cup of vanilla soft serve. read more

This is a cute, very busy ice cream place that is open in the summer in Lancaster. It is always busy and I usually have to park on a side street, because parking is very limited. There are plenty of picnic tables to sit at and lots of people bring their dogs. They have a lot of choices, but I usually just get 2 scoops of whatever flavors intrigue me that day. I also love taking our dog once in a while and she loves us extra when we take her there. She gets the puppy ice cream that has dog bones in it. She goes nuts over this and doesn't lift her face from the bowl until she's done. So take it from me and our dog, you will enjoy your visit here. read more

Stopped here on a whim while on a road trip. We actually drove by at first, caught a glimpse and kept going. We looked at each other a few miles down the road, I pulled out the trusty smart phone where yelp told me it might be worth it so we turned around. Definitely ask what he recommends for the season! I just had a scoop of southern apple pie and my husband had two scoops of pumpkin pie & we both had waffle cones -- both flavors were AMAZING. Aside from the delicious ice cream, this place is fantastic. We stood with the owner for a while and he told us how he burned up his corporate suits & ties to start living his dream, making people smile. To this day, it has to be one of our favorite memories of the trip. read more

I was looking for Vegan/Dairy Free uneven options and this spot popped up! Omg it was delish I got a strawberry milkshake and it was Devine...had real strawberries and was really good! So glad I found it and will be visiting again real soon!'n read more

Man, I've been falling down on the Yelp job lately. Just not enough food exploring in my life these days. I need to be more like a hobbit, and go on adventures with food at the end of them. Frosty's isn't far from where I live. My husband and I can make a nice evening walk of it. I'm of the opinion that we shouldn't keep ice cream in the freezer anymore, we should only have ice cream if we're willing to take a walk to get it. He's a little less sure but we do like our walks and I like good ice cream. This tiny neo-Tudor dollhouse thingy is on the National Register of Historic Places because it was built in the '30s for a gas station. It's been an ice cream shop for a little over ten years. They have every kind of frozen dairy concoction you could ask for, including soft serve custard, thirty-something flavours of Perry's hard ice cream, milkshakes, "Arctics" (soft serve with mix-ins), ice cream cakes, sundaes, banana splits, and apparently some kind of frozen doggie treat in case you went there with the excuse that your four-legged friend needed some exercise. There's no indoor seating. You get your treat and you sit at a wobbly sticky outdoor table or you take it somewhere else. Wobbly sticky outdoor tables are part of the charm of this kind of place, in my opinion, unless you're allergic to hornets. There's also some playground equipment so your kids can burn off the excess sugar energy. Plan to spend some time relaxing and chatting with one ear open, because there will be a lineup on a hot summer evening and you'll be called up for your order when they get to you in the queue. Warning to other Canadians coming here: get the small version of anything if you plan on finishing it yourself. Seriously. If you don't believe what you've heard about American portion sizes, Frosty's will make you believe. read more