Frosty's has been a staple in our family's summers since we moved into the area. My son who just turned 3 has already been to 4 opening days. (That math is crazy) We saw they were opening a couple days due to warm weather and had to get over there to get some ice cream and say hello. It was PACKED! Probably would be less packed now that the weather is cold and snowy again but we waited in line and got our treats. I ended up going with a root beer float this time. We also had an assortment of cones and dishes of soft serve with plenty of sprinkles. We can't wait until they open up fully for the season and will be here quite often. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

This is a nice ice cream shop with lots of options! They also have vegan ice cream that I heard multiple people ordering. I wanted to try the sponge candy sundae and it was massive! It only comes in 1 size and way too much for 1 person so I wish it came in a smaller size too. The richness of the Carmel plus sponge candy just made it a lot to eat. I usually just get a cone here and go with a baby size because the cone sizes are also HUGE. They always get people through so quickly even if the line looks long, it's just that good that a lot of people want to visit! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Sponge candy sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

I had to go here immediately when i saw a photo of the sponge candy sundae and it did not disappoint i got a mix of hot fudge and Caramel which was the absolute perfect match to the chunks of Sponge Candy, they were definitely generous with my portion! No indoor seating but there's a good size parking lot so we just ate in our nice warm car. There are several tables and benches outside too. The girl working the order window was super friendly and patient with the 3 kids we had ordering. They have ice cream nachos which were also delicious read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Sponge candy sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Last time we visited we talked with the owner about some special flavors ice cream he has occasionally. Some might say weird, like pickle ice cream. It's almost the end of ice cream season so we decided for one more stop at Frosty's. They close on October 17! The choices were (of course) limited, but he recommended trying a Maple Bacon Sunday. That is really good. Vanilla soft serve with maple syrup and bacon crumbles, plenty of bacon crumbles actually. The sweetness of the syrup and the taste of bacon are a great combination. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Maple Syrup Sunday. Sooooo good - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

Nick you got yourself FIVE STARS!! First what an incredible welcome!! My out of town friend had never sampled loganberry so on the recommendation of friends we stopped by Frosty's on a VERY HOT AFTERNOON needing to cool down and your LOGANBERRY SHAKE was the perfect answer. This shake shouted BUFFALO with its subtle sweetness (Sometimes Loganberry drinks can be too sweet.) and fruitiness. The top quality ice cream made this a really great shake!! As we sat in the car savoring this cool treat we both agreed that we should order milkshakes more often! My friend noticed the dog treat sign immediately, which is a cool offering for four legged friends. And, I was impressed by the significant number of vegan/non-dairy options but for me Buffalo's favorite creamy and luscious Perry's ice cream that Frosty's offers is always at the top of my favorites list! We were welcomed like old time friends and there are benches to enjoy your ice cream at but we went back to our air conditioned car ... it was a HOT DAY but Frosty's definitely made it "cooler" ... definitely try the Loganberry Shake! My Delaware friend now wants to know where she can get Loganberry near her home. read more

See all

You get a lot of bang for your buck at this place! They serve Perry's ice cream and it's cash only... there are lots of options here for all the different ways to eat- vegan, dairy free, egg free... they are very generous with their portions and their prices are reasonable We ordered cones, a hot fudge sundae and a cheesecake sundae... they were all huge, cool and tasty treats! I recommend this spot if you are in need of an ice cream treat, you can order ice cream cakes, ice cream sandwiches, shakes, fizzies, sodas, cones, sundaes... you want it, they make it! Go here, eat ice cream!! read more

See all

This tastes so good, would have loved to sit outside on their patio but it was raining. The girls working were friendly and fast. I highly recommend this place. Been going there since we moved into the neighborhood in 2015. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Location sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

The ice cream flavors are limited as Frosty's is closing for the season on October 17th. No chocolate so I had a one scoop "baby" cone of Mint-ting-a-ling. Nice and refreshing, even on a rainy day. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

Winding down and closing for winter in October! Few more weeks till the long wait for next spring! SpongeBob candy sundae made my week oh so much better! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Sponge candy sundae! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

The loganberry milkshake was super delicious! I enjoyed the service as well. The laddies were very patient and polite.. Theres nice area for the kids to play and mingle. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Longaberry milkshake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

The loganberry milkshakes and the chocolate milk shake are absolutely amazing. They taste so fresh and cold. Frosty's by far has the best ice cream options at either the Depew or Lancaster locations. You literally cannot go wrong. The service is literally immediate. Your order is taken and you do not wait long for your dessert. It's truly a great experience. Both locations are along busy roads but offer up good views and scenery. The tables at the Depew location are clean and ready to sit at. Enjoy your frozen ice cream! read more

See all

Frosty's is an amazing ice cream spot! Lots of options for hard/soft ice cream as well as gluten and dairy free options. They have a rotating weekly dairy free soft serve as well so there is always something new to try. They have lots of outdoor seating so they are a great stop on a hot (or cold) day read more

See all

Great to Frostiest open again! Makes summer seem closer! Enjoyed some delicious Milky Way ice cream ! Always big and reasonably priced

One of my favorite summer time ice cream spots! The cannoli sundae definitely is intriguing , refreshing and very large size wise! The service was lacking the last and most recent time visiting however. We tipped and I had gone to ask a question, the younger girl shut the window pretty much in my face And she did not even attempt to answer. I was polite as usual and figured ( hoping anyways) that she did not hear me and maybe looked the other way. read more

Me and my family visited Frosty ice cream in Depew last evening. I ordered a chocolate malted large made with hard ice cream shake. When I receive my shake, it tasted pretty much like milk, not much ice cream or chocolate or malt in it. When I took it back to the window the young lady said there was nothing she could really do about it and she also refused to throw it away for me and pointed to a trash can around the corner of the store where I can toss it. I ask if I could perhaps have a soft serve cup, she charged me the $3.50 gave it to me and I left. I was very disappointed and of course we will not return to frosty ice cream so sad. It was mine and my family's first time and we will never go back. read more

Got the four scoop ice cream and it was excellent. They serve a fair amount. Very good selection of flavors.

The owner of this place is a nice person but he hires kids who think it's party time. We were there on Friday night at 6:30. They didn't care what order the customers orderes came in. All they were concerned about was laughing it up and having a good time without doing much work. PJ cools is run much more like a business and not a frat party. I recommend PJ cools where you're treated right. read more

I've never been to a worse ice cream shop in my life. I went at around 8:45 to get ice cream with my cousin. We saw on the insta page that they had lime and raspberry dole whip and were thrilled. When we got there they said they didn't have dole whip today and wouldn't let us sample anything bc two people were behind us. My friend met us up there and got a cherry dipped cone and it was chunky and in a dish. They said they were low and then gave us another one (we asked for it in a cone) and it was in a dish. Workers were nasty and rude. The ice cream was terrible and we all threw ours out. Get better service. Additionally, they claim they are good with allergies and want everyone to be able to enjoy but don't have separate toppings for allergy orders like mine. read more

See all

Hands down one of my favorite ice cream places in WNY. Frosty's has a huge menu with something for everyone--fruity, chocolatey, milkshakes, ice cream cakes, smoothies and even vegan and wine ice creams are on this hefty menu. The staff are always friendly and they offer special/seasonal flavors that rotate so you're never bored. It's cash only but an ATM is right on site. Family friendly seating in the back and they even have your fur babies covered with their Doggie Delight treat. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Brownie Sundae with nuts - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

I'm so happy to have a good vegan ice cream/dessert option I went back lol so good. I'll try something different next time read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Dole whip float - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Well it's taken me awhile to add this well deserved five star review but here it is. We picked up some really yummy treats and brought them all the way home, so the photos truly don't do them justice. But the taste was amazing!!! First let me tell you about the Pina Colada hand made pint of ice cream we brought home. The one with pieces of coconut in every mouthful. The one with just the perfect sweet to alcohol ratio so that you don't want to put it back because it's burning your mouth but just want to keep having another bite and another bite. Each bite you put in your mouth was so much fun, so full of textures and flavors that you almost didn't want to swallow it because the fun would be over. It was that good!!! Then there was the cannoli ice cream sundae with pieces of waffle cone all through it and plenty of cannoli ice cream!! Just delicious!!! Didn't travel that distance well but still was well worth it. I'm told that the blue raspberry slushy was delicious and very refreshing!! The specials that are up on the board aren't on their website menu, so you may be in for a really fun surprise when you get there. I most definitely would stock pile pints of their home made delicious treats in my freezer now that I know what I'm missing!!! Because once I tasted them I'm almost certain I can hear those pints calling me.... You know you want another spoonful.... One more bite..... read more

See all

Great selection of ice cream varieties with caramel. The logan berry shake was tasty on a very hot day.

Delicious ice cream and friendly staff. Perfect combination. After going there to try a delicious Strawberry Daiquiri sundae we had to check out the rest of their offerings. I was instantly drawn to the wine ice cream. It's made at Mercer Dairy in Boonville NY (tiny town about 35 miles north of Utica, yes I've actually been there). We bought some to bring home. It was the perfect combination of merlot wine and creamy cherry ice cream. Chatted for a while with Nick, the owner. Super friendly. Told us his mother makes all of the brownies at home that they use in their sundaes. Nice family business. Before leaving I also noticed that they serve frozen custard. I'll definitely be back to try that! 2021-123 read more

See all

What a fantastic experience visiting Frostys on George Urban Blvd for Yelp Elite Week was! It was quite busy when we got that but despite that service was quite quick! They were well prepared for the event with a QR code to scan to check into the event and a list to check off with my name. The strawberry daiquiri sundae was loaded with fresh strawberries, coconut flakes, whipped cream and alcoholic daiquiri sauce. It was absolutely delicious! I was so impressed with the taste and presentation of the sundae. It came with an adorable Yelp umbrella and some Yelp sunglasses! My fiance also ordered the cookie monster sundae which was advertised on the sign out front. It was huge and he really enjoyed it. The place itself had a huge menu and lots of special features including specialty ice cream cakes and a fruity pebbles & cheesecake sundae that sounded amazing. I'll definitely be back if I'm in the area!! A must visit for ice cream. read more

See all

Frosty's has so many amazing ice creams to choose from! From normal vanilla to orange mudslide. The service was quick and friendly dispute it being busy. It is a great place to take your S.O. or your family with it's relaxed outdoor seating area read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Vanilla guva ice cream float - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

I came here for the first time , because of a Yelp Elite Perk & I'm so glad I did. I brought my 2 sons so we could all enjoy ice cream together. There are so many flavors here, if I wasn't already getting the Strawberry Daiquiri Sundae, I have no idea what I would've finally decided on & how long it would've taken. My older son ,Jeremy got the Raspberry Merlot pint & he wasn't 100% thrilled with it. He said it didn't have much flavor. My younger baby got the Peanut Butter Explosion Sundae & it looked amazing & he let me taste it And Omg, DELICIOUS!! I am a true pb lover. My sundae was soooo good !! I absolutely loved it. The prices were not bad at all ,especially compared to other places & the portions we received. I wish it were closer to home, it would probably be my only ice cream shop. There was a very good amount of parking & a cute little setup in back to eat. I enjoyed this place a lot. read more

See all

Nick has turned this place into a must stop for ice cream. Actually anything you desire in ice cream form from cakes to cones. The choice of flavors are excellent, some are local and only available in batches. You won't be disappointed. read more

Ice cream was really good. Fast and friendly service. The ice cream took about 2-3 minutes for three item order which isn't bad at all and they were fairly busy. This was my first time here and I will definitely be back! The fruit was so fresh and they don't skimp on ingredients either. Very delicious. read more

See all

The cashiers were super friendly and fast. The kitchen looked clean as well as clean tables to sit at and enjoy your iceceam. The soft serve was creamy and delicious. I had a tropical frosty, and it was tangy and sweet read more

See all

Came here for a Yelp event and had the POG juice float, which was pretty good! Good amount of ice cream, but needs some more juice! Fast and friendly service, I'll be back for sure. The only bummer is that it's cash only. Plus side is that they have an ATM. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - POG juice float - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

We came for the Yes Elite event and so glad we did. I had the complimentary Yelp Strawberry Daiquiri Ice Cream. It had rum in it which I really didn't taste in it (probably will pass out soon ) I really enjoyed the sundae and strawberries (One of my favorite fruits). It was a generous portion. My husband got the chocolate cone. He ordered a small and it was way bigger than any of the other places we've ever gone to! Their ice cream is very good and I do highly recommend going here. We will have to frequent it more often. Well not close for us, it is worth the drive! Check it out! read more

See all

We ordered a small cone (no pic because it was seconds until my husband took a bite and I'm not quick enough). We also had a Yelp Elite sample of a strawberry daiquiri sundae. The cone was huge and the ice cream was so good. The sundae was full of strawberry daquiri ice cream, regular strawberry ice cream, strawberries, sauce and whipped cream. I couldn't eat it all so I gave the leftovers to my dad and he LOVED it. Frostys is a great stop! read more

See all

Alright so it has been years since I've had ice cream, so when I got the invite to go try Frosty's I was super excited. I was happy that there was more non dairy options and I was allowed to choose in order to replace the Sundae Daiquiri. I went with my son after work on the hottest day in Buffalo lol and boyyyyy was it a great way to cool off. My son got the strawberry cone ice cream topped with rainbow sprinkles and I got the non dairy cookies & cream. So as we were checking out the staff noted that it's cash only and I didn't have any cash on me but luckily there's an ATM. Great save but I hope they will take credit cards in the near future or invest in a square chip. We enjoyed our ice cream sitting inside the mini bus or truck I think lol. Then I let my son play in it a little bit before we left. Will definitely come back. The staff were nice and the customer service was great. read more

See all

I have been a regular at both Frosty's locations for many years. They offer flavors you can't find anywhere else, especially when it comes to frozen custard. And their cones are quite large. I'm a big girl who loves their sweets and even I have a hard time finishing a medium. I've never dared try a large. They're so big that they can't roll them in sprinkles. Yeah. That's crazy. read more

I ordered my vegan ice cream birthday cake here and it was really good, everyone liked it! I got an ice cream sundae and it was also really good!! $7 and it was huge enough for two people. ** They only accept cash! But they have an atm right outside that charges 2.50 ** they're really fast workers because it was so many people in both lines when I walked up and I got my order relatively quick. The employees are very helpful and patient, even when I ordered and went to the atm after. Love it here and can't wait to go back!! I have a loyalty cake card I can't wait to use! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Vegan Chunky Monkey ice cream sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

We came by for the ice cream sundae offered for Yelp Elite week. The ice cream sundae was wonderful! My wife ordered a milkshake which she also thought was marvelous. The large number of offerings posted on signs outside was almost overwhelming. We will definitely stop by for a treat again when we are in the area. read more

See all

I recently moved and was SO stoked Frostys was right around the corner! The folks who work here are absolutely lovely. They do a great job letting you know their specials on both Facebook and Instagram. Each week they have a different specialty soft serve and dole whip. Sometimes you can imbibe the two like when they had peanut butter soft serve and strawberry dole whip.... omg I wish it wasn't winter. That's the thing, they're only open for the summer which is understandable but man, sometimes you crave it! One thing to remmeber- it's cash only! They do have an ATM but I went once when the atm was down and that was a sad time. read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Pistachio soft serve! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

Being dairy free it's super difficult to find an ice cream shop that provides these options along with it tasting good and let me tell you.. THIS WAS AWESOME!! They had SO many different flavors for dairy free/vegan milk shakes, a few hard serve ice creams, cakes that were dairy free/vegan, and many toppings you could put Into the ice cream/ milk shakes. The taste was amazing and the prices aren't bad at all! we got a dairy free milkshake with a topping and a swirl with a topping and it was less than 10 bucks! Also, the sizes are huge so you really can't go wrong trying a new place! Super happy I tried this read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Classic swirl with sprinkles, dairy free coffee shake with turtle topping mixed into it - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

I'm overly impressed with Frosty's! I saw the Loganberry Ice cream advertised on Facebook and I'm so glad I was able to get my hands on it before it sold out! If you're a true Buffalonian, you will love this twist in loganberry. My boyfriend also got the cannoli ice cream and that was also incredible. (Made by Perry's) For two ice cream cones with 2 scoops each, we only paid 8$. What a deal. I can't wait to go back and try other menu items! read more

Frosty's Ice Cream - Loganberry Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Depew, New York

Serving sizes are huge, custard is smooth and delicious, service is nice! Got the cheesecake custard and it was soooo good.