Had the Animal Burger and it was so delicious! Would definitely eat here again. Not a huge fan of the shark bites but the beer battered onion rings were great. My children liked the grilled. Because of Covid, had to sit outside but it would've been nice if the outside tables and area were cleaner... there were flies everywhere! read more

Since the new ownership, the quality of the food and flavors have improved dramatically! I'm happy this business was able to bounce back! Yummy fries and burgers. read more

If you want an awesome burger then hit this spot! Great fry options as well! It's under new ownership and if you've been here before then you'll notice the difference. Menu, food, and service is on point! The specials are creative and delicious! Get your burger fix here!! read more

Surfside Burger Shack - Today's special- Pepperjack, egg, bacon, and maple syrup with a side of garlic fries. - American Near Me - Eureka, California

quality is ok food is very greasy so if thats an issue for u here may not be the best read more

Horrid customer service. I was publicly berated by all 3 employees for asking for fresh fries with a to go order that had been under the warmer for 30 mins. I was told it was my fault for not ordering clearly. I was then told it's illegal to order food I didn't buy, so I would be "made" to purchase old fries. I said I would just buy the burger and was told I couldn't buy it if I didn't buy the fries and that I entered into a contract when I phoned in my to-go order and had no choice but to buy the whole meal. The owner is clearly having a bad day, but to repeatedly verbally attack a customer over $2 worth (MY Cost--theirs is of course much less!) of fries is just plain bad business. It was a special birthday lunch delivery for someone I love, so I wanted something amazing. The last meal I had at Surfside was greasy and expensive but i wanted to give them another shot. Since I was refused service if I didn't buy 30 minutes old fries, I left. Even if this request (fresh to go food) was unreasonable, it's insane to me that a local business (especially this one, that lost tons of customers due to a former owner accused of pedophilia) would lose a customer over something as inexpensive as a small fry. As a side note, went across town and spent $6 less for the same thing (but hot and fresh!)at an AWESOME local spot--we for sure will be going back there. (thanks, Stars!!!) Asking for fresh fries at Surfside will get you asked not to return...with a side of especially snarky attitude. Try Mike's Drive Up, Stars, or Toni's and thank me later. This town has plenty of better options! read more

Pretty good tasting burger but the fries are weird. They were tough and chewy, like old and refried?

I've been going here for a good while and I just recently fell in love with them all over again. I just had a bacon blue cheese burger that was perfectly cooked, and for the side I shared an order of their rip curl fries and shark bites. The rip curl fries have changed my life. I think every day, the sun is going to be just a bit brighter. When I see potatoes, I will always smile as I remember this wondrous taste experience. A bit pricey, but it is worth every penny. read more

My husband wants to go here to eat every chance he gets. He loves their animal burger! We eat here all the time and have enjoyed everything we've tried. Good customer service. read more

Upon walking out of Surfside after getting food for the first time, i was pretty pissed when i checked my garlic fries before leaving and they had no garlic on them at all. I apologize for my scowls and stares but also think forgetting garlic is kinda a stupid move.. I was already thinking in my mind the kind of ranting yelp review I'd write but after getting in my car and tasting the food, it's super dank. Like some of the dankest food you can get in Humboldt, and simply forgetting my garlic does not warrant a bad review. The fries were covered in garlic salt and (now) fresh garlic and my little 18 year old woman self downed a large meal of the stuff. My chicken strips were crispy and dank as well. My only suggestion is get more tangy ranch... now that would be dangerous read more

Surfside Burger Shack - American Near Me - Eureka, California

Their patties are tasteless. They were a pale grey, reminding me of old meat that has long ago seen it's prime. I actually removed the patties and refused to eat them after choking down half my burger. The veggies must have been bought from Walmart somewhere on the east coast, transported by donkeys, frozen every night and thawed every day. They too were hideous. The ambiance of the joint was nice enough, very Surfer with pictures and all that jazz. I just couldn't get past the food. This was a wholly unmemorable eating experience. Well... that isn't true... "I wish i could forget it" would be more accurate. read more

This place has such a fun vibe! We enjoy coming in for the best burgers in town. They have high quality beef and fresh bread. The staff is always quick and friendly which is helpful when you're in a rush. read more

I've worked in restaurants for years, so its tough for me to write a harsh review. I know that a lot of people have unrealistic expectations. That being said, this is the absolute worst restaurant I have been to in Eureka. Overpriced, below average food, surrounded by paintings that look like someones midlife crisis project. read more

Surfside Burger Shack, I had high hopes for you. You filled in a long-empty former Subway in Eureka's blighted downtown -- and for that you deserve praise. I also give you credit for serving microbrews on tap, as well as local grass-fed organic beef -- the latter offering, I should note, increasingly becoming a Humboldt norm (Star's, Lost Coast, etc.) But your burgers are unacceptably bad. The HUGE, white, airy buns -- with no whole wheat alternative offered -- are out of touch in these organic, low-carb times. Your burger toppings have zero pizzazz -- just a slice of yellow onion, a couple of dill chips and iceberg lettuce. The salmon burger, which somehow receives praise elsewhere on this page, has the look and taste of a farm-raised, pink-dyed frozen pattie from CostCo and again, that awful white, airy bun with 1950s toppings. The decor bears a striking resemblance to ... yep, Subway. Think hard, yellow benches at fixed-length distance to the table. Awkward if you're a larger person, want to put a kid on your lap, etc. I really wish you guys would replace the Subway furniture with moveable tables/chairs, offer whole wheat buns and pick up some interesting, zesty toppings at the farmer's market. And avoid that frozen fish aisle. There may be hope for you yet. read more

Surf side was the best burger in humboldt county. After visiting last week I was disappointed to say the least, the bacon cheddar was always my favorite but it seems like the beef was lower quality tough and not properly cooked, the bacon was way too fatty and also undercooked. The rings and fries were good as ever though, probably the best rings I have had in the area. They expanded the dining area and put in a jukebox and pool table, but I go there for a good burger. The decor doesn't matter as long as it's clean, and they are passing on the remodel cost by raising prices. Not a good idea. I hope the folks in charge can get the quality back where it once was, I wouldn't mind paying the extra $ if it was the same food they served a couple months ago. read more

This is probably the worst burger place I've ever eaten at. Hamburgers are better at McDonald's which is sad. The onion rings are greasy and tasteless unless you use a whole bunch of ranch. Extremely expensive for nasty food read more

Surfside Burger Shack - Absolutely worst burger and greasy tasteless onion rings ever. Go only if you want to be disappointed and waste a lot of money - American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

The service here is absolute shit. My friend wanted 20 cash back and the rude girl that took our order told her that she couldn't due to being too busy??!!! Also while ordering (mind you I have never been here and will never come back) yelled at me that what I ordered is a special so I couldn't get what I wanted. I highly recommend that nobody spends their hard earned money at this horrid place! read more

Ok, I went back with a coworker for lunch. It was waaayyyy better than last time. The fries were good. Not black like last time. Must have been fresh oil? Very large portion as well. The burger was very good. The bacon on it was kind of 'meh', but they put a real lot on there. The bun, however, was still terrible. For $10.00/combo, a pretty good value. They stepped up there game since I was there last...but a burger joint has to have high quality, fresh buns...They have to...and sadly, these buns were not fresh, and they didn't seem to be of the highest quality. I will now consider them a viable lunch option...but I would consider them one of the better burgers in Humboldt if they improved their buns. read more

Not from the area so I thought id try something local. I guess it's my fault for going despite the reviews. The burger tasted pretty good but by the end of the meal it was just a pile of goop around a burger. Kinda tough to eat. My biggest qualm, though, was the fries. Raw. It was like they were dumped in the fryer for 5 seconds then thrown in a basket. Greasy disgusting mess. Had as much I could stomach. Fifteen dollars for something I had to force myself to eat is not ideal. For the money this place is definitely not worth it. Go to Lost Coast Brewery instead that place was delicious. read more

Had some very expensive, extra greasy, underwhelming so called "food" here for dinner. Shark bites, smallest Western burger, onion rings, veggie burger, and the worse chicken sandwich for $45. My kids and I were bummed. Surfside was so good a couple of years ago. I absolutely do not recommend eating here. A huge disappointment. read more

Fantastic service and awesome food. The SPAM Oinkers are the bomb! Congrats on 2nd place for the Spamley Cup read more

Surfside Burger Shack - American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Best gluten free burger ever. They were so nice and extremely informal about the gluten! Made separate fries even! I love how cautious and understanding they are. Plus it taste AMAZING. I have been craving it since I left. Can't wait to go back. My son always brings a ton of quarters for the games! He loves the chili dog! read more

Food is 5 stars. So nice to to have fries that are not just a pile of grease. Great burgers. However, the space does not look or feel very clean and that kind of makes me icked out. Cleanliness is so important, and it does not seem to be a priority here. But it's not awful or anything, and the food is very good. read more

I love their burgers!!! It's also fantastic that they have local beer and cider options. Friendly people!

One of the worst burgers that I have ever had. I have no clue what their seasoning is, but way to go on screwing up a grass fed burger! When I told the employee I did not care for the burger and it tasted like hotdogs, she responded: "grass fed beef tastes like hot dogs to you?" No it doesn't! Your burger does! I asked for my money back that's all. She brought it back to me and told me that this place isn't for me!! Oh well I've been kicked out and will no longer go back there! I shouldn't have cursed, but get real. Oh I also own a restaurant. Not everyone is going to like your food! Maybe order it without the hotdog spice? read more

This place has the best burgers in town. Service was friendly. You can tell they put love into the food. Keep up the great work, will be back read more

Best Burger this side of 5 Guys. They have a good selection of toppings. They also have fresh cut fries which is always a plus and an adequate beer selection. The only negative I can see is they are a little pricey. A great laid back atmosphere and the people behind the counter are always pleasant and chatty. The South Western and fries is the way to go! read more

love this gem! food is scrumptious service is impeccable setting is amiable You can really tell how much detail and intention the owners have put into this place as they have completely transformed this joint! Every plate is served to perfection making my mouth water before the food even reaches the table. Will be back time and time again (: thanks!! read more

Loved this place. The staff was super friendly and very accommodating. My onion rings were burnt but I wasn't going to send them back and the waitress came to my table and said she noticed they were not up to par and was dropping another batch for me. Burgers were on point. I will definitely be coming back. read more

The burgers are top notch. Even the 1/3 lb. ones are quite large and super tasty and there are 1/2 lb. versions if you want more. I eat here about twice a month and have never been disappointed. I like the bacon cheddar and the mushroom swiss. The meat here is Humboldt grass fed. One star off because they won't or or can't make a burger any less than medium well, which I don't understand since they are using high quality meat. 2nd best burger in Humboldt! read more

Uhg. I stopped by here after a recommendation from a "friend." Got the bacon cheese burger with onion rings. Rings were nasty. Bun was stale. Burger was inedible. Tasteless hockey puck. Never again. read more

Excellent! My family and I walked in not knowing they closed 5 minutes ago. The woman behind the counter let us know that they were closed but shed be happy to take our order. To make it quick and keep it simple we ordered burger. I saw they offered a veggie burger so I got that. They packaged our food to-go but said we were welcome to stay and eat inside while they clean up. (I love great customer service!) The fries were fresh and thin cut with the skin on they were delicious. My veggie burger was a "garden burger" and hit the spot with all the fixin's. My husband and daughter got the burgers. My husband claimed the "best burger" he's ever had. First time I've heard that in over 22 years of marriage. Can't wait to go back! read more

I love this place! Their burgers are my favorite besides homemade. They have yummy Arise Bakery GF buns, and a dedicated GF fryer for French Fries. The owners are total sweethearts, and often there working hard and giving great service! I have nothing bad to say about this biz in anyway. I have been going there at least once a month for years and their food only gets yummier. I particularly love the Mushroom Swiss Burger, and also appreciate them offering 1/5lb sizes (as an option) for those of us that don't want a giant burger patty every time. read more

First time there. Ordered bacon cheese burger, onion rings, mushroom Swiss burger, regular fries, and chili fries. Burgers were good. I prefer mine a little less cooked, but other than that they were great. Chili fries were outstanding, same as the onion rings. The fresh cut fries were ok, nothing to brag about. Will definitely be returning! read more

Surfside Burger Shack - American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Great burger, and great vibes. I got the western bacon and added jalapeños. It's great to get such a tasty meal for this price and support local at the same time. I no longer live in Humboldt, but if I visit again, I'll be making a stop here for sure! read more

So good! Love the hole in the wall feel. Gets busy @ lunch = good sign, right? Ps: try the zucchini sticks:) Best I've found in humboldt. read more

The menu selection is pretty tempting with lots of interesting burger options, (fried eggs and maple syrup?) as well as hot dogs and non-burger fare... It's a tad pricey (akin to Sohum prices).. and a burger, large order of onion rings, and 2 drinks was $25... The onion rings we're nice and crispy, but, under seasoned and ultimately just tasted of grease... My Bacon Cheese Burger was tasty... but, nothing to really write home about... Otherwise, it was nice that they brought the food to the table after we ordered at the counter... but, our table wasn't very clean and the TV was too loud... Their self serve soda machine also seemed to be having a lot of issues... Overall... meh... read more

The GF and I were roaming around Eureka unable to decide on a place to eat. We finally chose the Surfside and parked outside a long the street. I have to mention that the street parking in Eureka is scary! Open the passenger side door and you have a pretty good chance of having it taken off by a passing vehicle! Makes you wonder what they were thinking when they decided to put parking out here. Anyways, the cashier was friendly, offering a recommendation on his fav burger of the moment. Food came quickly and was cooked just right. BBQ sauce wasn't too overpowering. I liked the onion rings as well. The cashier even came by to make sure everything was good. Only small downside was that both of our combos came out to just under $30. Ah well, we were on vacation. read more

If I want to get a burger I know I'm going to enjoy, this is pretty much where I'll head if I'm anywhere near Eureka. A full-on combo meal with fries and a drink is going to run about $12, and I'm usually not into spending that much at a burger joint, but every once in a while I'll treat myself. I usually get the bacon cheeseburger combo. What makes these burgers stand out as opposed to the other joints in town is the seasoning and ingredients. Most burgers that I've tried at other places are just plain bland, even with all the fixins included. However, surfside burgers tend to buck the odds. They're juicy, and I can distinctly taste the patty, the thick strips of bacon, and the cheese. The fries are kind of hit-and-miss depending upon how closely they're minding the fryer. Sometimes they come out ok, but then there are times when I've got a basket of perfect-looking fries, only to discover that they've been fried so hard that they're completely hollow inside. I also appreciate healthier options like the salmon burger, which I've also gotten a couple of times. There's a fair amount of indoor seating, but it gets crowded around lunch. All-in-all I give it 4 stars. read more

I'm not a huge burger eater, but OMG! I had the Western Bacon burger, it was so good! I can't wait to go back and try the mushroom Swiss burger. The flavors were exceptional! read more

I've been to the Surfside Burger Shack three times now- once in the middle of a weekday during the busy time, once on a weekend during the lunch rush, and just now, when I called in an order to go. All three times, when I made my initial order, they were absolutely slammed, yet remained friendly, polite and attentive. The burgers are huge and fabulous. A single mini patty is more than enough for me, with extras if I'm hungry. I usually like my burgers medium rare, and they cook them well, but I haven't asked yet whether they cook to order, and there's nothing posted about it. This would make a great burger transcendent. read more