Cancel

Open app

Search

Sully’s Grill

4.5 (54 reviews)
Open • 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

Sully’s Grill Photos

Business Info

SULLY’S GRILL ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Dogs allowed
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sully’s Grill

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Meal and decor

Just a wonderful experience. I had the chicken salad sandwich with a side of potatoes. Cup of coffee. Served by Heather and very enjoyable on all levels. Always loved the hardware store and now even more, because of the restaurant!

the heirloom tomato panzenella salad (did not have any heirloom tomatoes, just romas)  #ReviewsByRL
Raena L.

I hadn't realized that there was a little cafe inside Sulliven's hardware & nursery. We called ahead, and they said the patio was #dogfriendly -- so, yay! There was a little rudeness from a man behind the counter as we took our dogs out to the patio, but we had called ahead to make sure it was ok! (3 adults, 3 well trained, behaved & tired dogs, coming from an event). Our server was very nice and wonderful. At one point, the rude guy came out to the patio, apparently we were seated at the table right in front of a walk in fridge he needed access to. My dog was in front of it, laying down on the cement. The guy yanked open the door before I even realized what he was doing, not only scared my dog but also hit him in the leg with the door. Didn't apologize, didn't even say a quick "oops, sorry" and hadn't asked us to make way, which we would have gladly and quickly done. Then he storms out of the fridge and now I'm like, "dude, you hit my dog!" He responded, "I had to go in there" well then, just ask! (yes, my dog was fine or there'd have been a real problem!). Then I could see him inside complaining about us to other workers. Our server, who was wonderful, was appalled by this behavior from him. She actually started crying. Totally not her fault! Then he didn't come out again, but others had to access that fridge about 3 more times during our lunch. It wasn't a big deal to them or the dogs, so I'm not sure why he had such as issue. We did not experience rudeness from any of them (and by then we also knew they had to get in there -- so easy to move the dogs!) Our food was in fact quite pretty, and tasty. The patio has ceiling fans, and beautiful flowers surrounding it. So it makes for a lovely setting. My friends had the heirloom tomato salad (but see pics - it had no heirloom tomatoes, just romas), and an egg skillet. I had the open face mushroom sandwich with guyere and onion jam. My sandwich was definitely a #yum, as was the side cup of soup - it was the soup of the day, an artichoke veggie. So, overall, we had a wonderful server and tasty food. I choose to ignore the jerk with zero people skills, because apparently he can cook. I really appreciate places that are #dogfriendly -- and the inside of the store definitely is at least. #ReviewsByRL

Tofu Bahn Mi with Carrot soup.
Ted B.

I'm a vegetarian and this one of the best spots I've been to and it is in a hardware store - wtf?!!! It's too bad I had to travel from Upstate NY to go to this place. Yummy, a hidden gem!

Chicken Torta Sandwich
Kyle E.

Absolutely loved this place. Located inside of a hardware store. This little grill was delicious. The ambiance is really amazing. We sat inside and enjoyed the ac. However, they patio looked pretty. Server could've been a little bit friendlier. However, the food was amazing. We ordered the Chicken Torta sandwich, brisket sandwich and ramen. The favors were spot on and the smoked chicken and brisket were cooked on the green egg. Which can be purchased in the store. I highly recommend eating and drinking here. Will be back!

Richard P.

I was in Sullivan's Hardware to pick out a Christmas tree when I spied a sign saying "Sully's Grill." Who expected a small grill inside an indie hardware store? Apparently, I should have. I will admit that being a newbie to Sullivan's I was utterly amazed at how big the place is and how much it really offers. Sully's Grill is, indeed, a little grill with dine-in tables. Most of the tables are taller (and not wheelchair friendly), though there's an accessible table close to where you order and the counter itself is accessible. Of course, everyone was so friendly that the idea of accessibility wasn't a huge issue. Sully's Grill is advertised as open Tuesday-Friday for lunch from 11am-3:30pm and for train snacks from 4-9pm. Yes, Sullivan's Hardware even has a little train feature. I swear, this place is so huge I think you could live there for days and not get noticed. Okay, I'm exaggerating a bit. The grill itself is rather small, but nicely decorated. The menu consists of snacks, salads, sharables, bento boxes, drinks (including beer, wine, coffee, hot cocoa, and others), and some sandwiches that are served with chips. Right now, they even have some holiday-themed options. While I wasn't in the mood for a meal, I did have a very large cinnamon roll and hot cocoa for about $5. The person working the counter was extremely nice and moved a chair so I could sit at a table. The tables are nicely spaced and everyone was wearing masks/socially distancing. The cinnamon roll was utterly amazing and the hot cocoa was pretty awesome, as well. I would easily return for lunch. You can rent out the space for events and they also offer cooking classes. This certainly isn't what I'd call a fancy joint, but it's comfy and friendly and clean and has great service. I enjoyed what I ordered. The prices are fair. Sullivan's seems to do a brisk family business so I'd imagine it's a great place to grab the kids a snack or drink. I can't quite justify calling this a 5-star experience, but it's simply too unique and awesome to consider anything less than a 4-star. Sullivan's has long been known for service and this continues at Sully's Grill. They have an amazing assortment of holiday goods and trees at Sullivan's and it's a great time to check out Sully's Grill. I'm sure glad I did.

Newly moved to Indy and found this gem . Wonderful banana pancakes and sunny side up eggs

Excellent atmosphere, delicious food and super friendly service ! Brunch among the ferns was super cool.

Chelsea S.

This has to be the best kept secret in Indy. A full-service restaurant tucked inside a hardware store!? Silly's is open 11 AM - 8 PM daily and serves brunch on the weekends. My mom and I visited for Sunday brunch. The atmosphere is delightful! You are basically in a greenhouse with hanging plants everywhere. The menu is fantastic - we couldn't decide so our server encouraged us to get a couple things and share - a fantastic suggestion! She even brought out extra plates and was super attentive while we were there. We ordered the mushroom skillet off the brunch menu and the antipasto couscous salad off the regular menu. I started with a cup of the soup of the day - garlic Parmesan - which was unreal! Everything was so surprising and delicious and we can't wait to go back!

Special- brisket quesadilla
Natasha K.

If you have a chance to dine in at Sullys and sit beneath the beautiful hanging plants. DO IT. It's an delightful dining experience. We started with the sangrias which were both equally delicious. I preferred the flavor of the white sangria a bit more. Food wise- we started with pretzel sticks- delicious! My daughter had the pizza bento box and my mother and I shared the brisket quesadilla special. I would never think to put zucchini & asparagus in a quesadilla, but it worked! Really a great little lunch spot. I would love to come back and take a cooking class as well!

Robyn W.

Isn't this just the perfect little cafe ... For a hardware store!? It really is perfect. Nice bites for a shopping day trip .. Hearty enough that they'll take the edge off hunger, but not too much. Kinda perfect cuz I don't want to go box to juggle with all my purchases from the store as well! Right in the middle of Sullivan's you'll find this little cafe... We had a short wait so we put our name in right when we got to the store and shopped a little while waiting. They take your number and text when your tables ready! I had a brunch option (which they deserve Saturday and Sunday until 2pm) the egg spinach mushroom and gruyere skillet. My companion had the breakfast sandwich... Both were great. I quite enjoyed chopping the potatoes that were my side and letting them soak up some of the liquid from my running eggs, I even noticed the coffee is good but didn't happen to catch what beans they use. Overall this is much better than I'd ever fathom for a cafe Ina hardware store! High quality ingredients, well crafted yet simple dishes... Simply perfection. Glad I finally tried this place... Rounds out a perfect day of shopping.

Pretzels
Rachael J.

Who knew there was a restaurant nestled inside a hardware store? Apparently everyone but me, but I finally made a trip to try it. It's decked out with Christmas trees and decorations for the holidays. With that, there is a train that runs every probably 15 minutes or something for children and they run rampant around so go at your own risk- or bring your kids, whichever is your cup of tea. I ordered the sangria and it was so sweet I almost couldn't finish it. The pretzels and cheese were perfect. The pretzels were soft but also chewy. My husband ordered the rigatoni and said it was alright. I ordered the smoked chicken sandwich. It was good- however I think they forgot the cheese as it could have used a little something extra. All around an interesting experience for a week night.

Salmon Sandwich

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Unfortunately, we went on a Monday and they were closed. Will try again another day. Have been there other times and the food was very good.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of curt m.
294
12
1

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Love this place, great menu & service! Food is very fresh, and only downside is sometimes they run out of dessert!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 8
Thanks 0
Love this 6
Oh no 0
Photo of Shelley M.
59
290
414

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Awesome and unexpected! Menu like I'm in San Diego. If you're in Sullivans Hardware, do yourself a favor and eat here!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Sully’s Grill

Is it an option to dine with a dog in the winter months?

I don't believe so, as the patio would not be open. The servers were quite pleasant but the cook was quite rude as we had to walk our dogs through the interior area to get to the patio to dine. I'd call to verify, though. Dogs ARE allowed inside the… 

Is the seating outdoors?

there is indoor seating and also a patio under a canopy / umbrellas.

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for American 3,498 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Fire and Ice Cafe - Toasted Coconut Chocolate Caramel Latte

Fire and Ice Cafe

4.6(56 reviews)
1.6 mi

I've been gluten-free for over 10 years, and I can honestly say Fire & Ice Cafe served me one of…read morethe BEST gluten-free breakfasts I've ever had! The biscuits were so light and fluffy I almost cried. Seriously! If you're gluten-free, you KNOW how rare that is! And the French toast bake? Pure bliss! Not dense, crumbly, or mushy. Just absolutely delicious! What impressed me even more was that my friend, who isn't gluten-free, couldn't even tell the difference! Fire & Ice Cafe has figured out how to make gluten-free food that doesn't feel like you're missing out. It's not just good for gluten-free. It's genuinely AMAZING food! I wish I could give more than five stars! I'll definitely be dreaming about those biscuits! Cute space with modern decor.

So glad I discovered this adorable cafe on Yelp while I was in town for a work trip. It was a rainy…read moreFriday morning and after checking out of my hotel, I needed a quiet place to work for a few hours, a strong blast of caffeine, and something to eat. The moment I walked in the doors of Fire & Ice I knew Yelp did me good! The space is bright with a modern farmhouse feel to it. There's a fireplace, lounge seating, tables and chairs, and even a bar area (that's where I decided to sit). The ladies behind the counter were nice and gave me some recommendations. I went with their banana bread latte with oat milk and one of their biscuit sandwiches with egg and American cheese. Both were absolutely delicious and I would order again. I'll add that the restroom was clean, but the wifi wasn't that great. I ended up using my hotspot while I was there. This place is also women-owned and totally gluten free. Seriously, I had no idea until a friend told me a few days later. They're clearly a lot of things right!

Photos
Fire and Ice Cafe
Fire and Ice Cafe - Biscuits and Gravy & egg sandwich

Biscuits and Gravy & egg sandwich

Fire and Ice Cafe - Great location

See all

Great location

Flatwater Restaurant - Korean bbq tacos

Flatwater Restaurant

4.3(528 reviews)
1.4 mi•Broad Ripple
•$$

Stopped in for Quick sandwich and beer and glad we did! Due…read moreto the horrific heat wave, we sat inside, but there is a great area to eat outside and will once it cools down. We got a brisket bbq grilled cheese, really good and simply with a new twist. Also, the brisket Reuben is another sandwich we ordered and it was delicious. They pride themselves on their bbq and it was really good. The service was top notch, gave great suggestions and was always around if we needed anything. Overall, great experience and will definitely be back!

Flatwater Restaurant was just okay this time around. We ordered the pork tenderloin with mac and…read morecheese and the shrimp tacos. We both agreed the mac and cheese was the best part, really good. The rest of the food felt a bit bland. The tenderloin was filling, but the mayo and toppings didn't add much flavor. Even the waitress mentioned she prefers it with ketchup and cheese. We have been here before and remember it being much better, which made this visit a little disappointing. Service was solid. We had no wait at 7:30 on a Saturday, the food came out quickly, and our waitress was friendly and helpful. The ambiance is still a big plus here. The space looks great inside and out, and the location along the river is hard to beat. It was a little chilly when we went, but on a warm day sitting outside would be ideal, especially with live music.

Photos
Flatwater Restaurant
Flatwater Restaurant - Korean BBQ briskett tacos

Korean BBQ briskett tacos

Flatwater Restaurant - Strawberry lemonade smash

See all

Strawberry lemonade smash

Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant - Cajun Pasta

Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant

3.9(466 reviews)
2.7 mi•Meridian Kessler, SoBro
•$$

The wind alive, the leaves falling, seasons are changing and on this crisp fall morning I found…read moremyself stumbling into Aristocrat Pub. A pub that resembles ideas of England. But with some American ways of life. I opted to sitting in the patio garden area and was pleasantly surprised by the collection of plants and calming atmosphere under the shaded trees. Deciding on the beer cheese burger and fries, I was in for a treat. The fries are unique... in a great way. They are big and crispy and you can tell are made with some pride. The burger was good. The bacon crispy, the bun tasty with the pretzel element. However , the beer cheese wasn't necessarily beer cheese. It just tasted as though they put some of the yellow processed cheese you'd get at a concession stand. The burger was still good in my opinion but that cheese knocked some points off. Overall. I would definitely come back. Welcoming people and atmosphere.

We stopped in for a late lunch on the Saturday before the big race. Aka INDY 500. We probably…read morearrived around 1:30 (party of 5). The receptionist/hostess was less than friendly by saying before I even said anything and/or before we were even greeted "we don't have any open tables, it'll be a while". I was like "do you want my name and how many people are in our party?" She just seemed bothered by us wanting to eat at this establishment. We probably waited 15 mins and were seated at the very back of the restaurant in a huge booth. Our server on the other hand was extremely friendly and gave us great service. I ordered the sweet chili chicken wings. They were very tasty but I couldn't finish my order if 10. Parking: not sure if they do have parking but we parked on the street about a block away. Free street parking but a very busy one way street so keep that in mind.

Photos
Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant
Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant - Grilled Tenderloin Sandwich

Grilled Tenderloin Sandwich

Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant - March 17th

See all

March 17th

Sully’s Grill - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...