I hadn't dined here for several years but we frequently visit Big Lug, which is one of my favorite restaurants. We were in Fishers and a couple of friends suggested that we come here for a late lunch. We arrived around 3 pm on a Sunday. There were only a few other tables of diners at this time. Our party of 3 was seated promptly. We ordered chicken and noodles, a tenderloin, and a veggie burger, a side salad, and Brussels sprouts. I'll mention that there were very few vegetarian options on the menu. Actually the only vegetarian entrée on the menu was the option to substitute a veggie burger for one of the burgers. There were several vegetarian sides. We all enjoyed our food. The tenderloin was huge, chicken and noodles tasted homemade as well as the mashed potatoes. We all enjoyed the Brussels sprouts. We didn't receive the fresh baked bread but after leaving we looked at the menu and it said "Fresh baked bread (upon request)" and we hadn't known we had to request it. Next time we will know it is only served upon request, but I wish our server had asked if we wanted bread, especially with the chicken and noodles. Our server was pleasant but didn't stop by our table again after he took our order until it was time to bring our check. Someone else had brought our food out. It would have been nice if he would have stopped by once to check on our table. The food was excellent, we all said we would come back for the same items we ordered today but would also like to try other entrées. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Veggie burger and Brussels sprouts - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

When my parents visit one stop I must take them to is Sahm's. We went for dinner Wednesday around 7pm and invited and few more friends for a total of 7 people at the table. My daughter wanted a mocktail and the waitress carded her for a beverage that has zero alcohol. The waitress said they have to card. Great so my daughter got a water. The waitress was not attentive, we had to ask someone to get her to come to our table. Considering the place only had about 5 tables at that time we shouldn't have had to ask for her to check on us. The food was ok at best. The lemon chicken had a soggy coating and just didn't mesh well with the arugula that topped the chicken. We were not asked if we wanted dessert and just asked if we were on one check. We had 2 separate checks for the table. My friend paid for her family and I paid for my family. As we checked our bills to make sure we are paying for what we ordered we noticed a 20% tip added for a large party. Large party? There's 7 people. So we asked about it and the waitress said they add gratuity for more than 5 people and it was in fine print in the menu. Her exact words. So many things are wrong with that. Let's start with more than 5 people a tip is added. 8+ people is considered a lrg party. Not to mention 20% That's absolutely crazy. I will never go back there. I've been a server for over 20 yrs and have been out of it for sometime now BUT 20%. Bye Sahm's maybe that's why your restaurant was dead. read more

Very good tenderloin & tacos today during mushrooms Hamilton County tenderloin trail visit. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Tenderloin Tuesday brought us back to a neighborhood favorite restaurant. Though I usually get tenderloin grilled, today I went with the Hoosier traditional breaded version as did Tami. I chose onion rings as my side, Tami had her favorite Mac & cheese on the planet side. Great Sammie, great service, great experience. read more

This has been on my to-try list for a while and I got the opportunity yesterday for my work team's holiday lunch/gift exchange. We had a group of 9 and had to wait a bit to be seated but it was no issue. Our server was very prompt and professional with the service. It didn't take long to order and receive our drinks. Since we were there for lunch, we skipped apps and just had entrees. They had a few vegetarian options! After confirming with the server that their "vegetarian" patty (that's how it's listed on the menu) was from the Beyond brand, I opted to get the Turkey Chipotle with that substitution. Most of their entrees come with 1-2 sides. I chose the spicy garlic cauliflower. It was a huge serving and way too much for lunch lol I had to take some to go. The burger was well flavored and messy due to all of the sauce/toppings but the highlight was the cauliflower! I honestly could've just had that and a side of fries. My colleagues were all raving over their meals, too, so we were a pretty satisfied group. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Turkey Chipotle Burger (sub Beyond Burger Patty) - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

4 stars. Service is always good here. Food is decent enough. I haven't found anything to wow me, but I've never left hungry, either. Cheese curds are tasty. The club sandwich is filling. The Rona salsa tastes homemade. (I'm not a fan of their salsa verde.) The desserts all sound delicious, but I haven't tried them, yet. I'll keep them in the rotation, for sure. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Cheese curds - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We stopped by Sahm's for lunch today--a place we've visited many times over the years, so we had a pretty good idea of what to expect. As usual, it was busy and a bit noisy during the lunch rush. The food was good, but it didn't quite live up to the high standard we've experienced in the past. The flavors just weren't as strong or memorable as before. What used to feel like an A+ experience now lands somewhere between an A- and B+. We'll still return, just probably not as often as we once did. read more

So last night was our second time having dinner here and they have wonderful food. I took one star away because service could be a little better. That said their service is better than most. They have some great fried chicken, mashed potatoes were good too. Loved the cornbread but I will warn it's super dense and more like a cake taste which is fine with me because I like sweet cornbread. They have a great wedge salad. Meatloaf is not bad. It does seem that most everything they make is fresh which is an unheard of concept anymore so we love that. Like any other place hosts aren't trained very well and they like to herd people all into one concentrated area which we don't like. We both forgot our wallets which has never happened before but the good news is if you have cards in your Apple wallet they will work on the readers they use table side. I saw on the table they are doing an Easter Brunch buffet and are taking reservations for that now. The menu looked great for that event and we are considering taking our Mom but I was hoping they would have that good fried chicken on that menu but it wasn't. Neither time we have been there has a manager been to our table but if they had stopped by they would have heard that we are fans! They also have some sort of rewards you can signup for. The pics I will add are from both visits. Definitely a solid 4.5 star restaurant read more

See all

Please try out their amazing wings! They have been having wknd specials which is 12 wings for $10. Flats and dummies mix and you can pick 2 flavors. Extra crispy cooked to perfection. We have done them multiple times now. Also having special for Super Bowl. We order ahead and grab to go. Comes with sides of ranch or blue cheese and carrots and celery. Plan to for today. read more

Been to Sahm's a few times now and I can say it does not miss! Great, warm, almost comfort-food. The other day we ordered take out for lunch and I got the triple decker club sandwich and hot honey Brussel sprouts. They were both fantastic- highly recommend the sprouts. Usually service is quick & friendly and the restaurant is inviting and clean. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Triple decker club and hot honey Brussel sprouts - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Went to the Sahm's off 116 and Allisonville to meet a friend for lunch on Monday / workday. We got seated right away. I used to visit another when they had the locatoin near 69th & 96th, but hadn't been to this location. I opted for my pre house favorite, the Buffalo chicken sandwich. And I was going to get the fried mushrooms that I remembered loving, but I saw the special side was fried green tomatoes, so I opted for that. Both, sooo good! And my friend had a salad with shrimp, which was accompanied by a slice of the famous coffee cake. Check out my pics. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Salad with shrimp and the famous coffee cake #yum #ReviewsByRL - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Service is TOP NOTCH!!! Stick to the American cuisine. Tenderloins are a great classic sandwich that you'll never go wrong with (unless they put mayo on the bun and your wife hates mayo!). Salad with chicken whether it's grilled or breaded chicken is a good fresh option that will fill you up. Clam chowder was very tasty. If there's anything to maybe consider, the Baja tacos were nice, but not that special. Pecan pound coffee cake served with salad is also kind of interesting. Atmosphere is nice. Workers keep very busy. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - We were too busy eating the tasty food and forgot to take pictures. Sorry. - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We love Sahm's! The food and salads are amazing in the service couldn't be better. It's great to have a local pub that you can sit down and enjoy a good meal. read more

Sahms is a great family oriented place. The facility is large as is the menu. You will find something for everyone in your party here. Our large group felt very welcomed and comfortable. We had an outstanding wait team. All were very friendly and worked to serve our group well!! I had the breaded tenderloin and onion rings for my meal. The onion rings were built on a thin piece of onion. The breading is moderately thin with a slight spice. The ring is thin enough that it hooks itself to the other rings. You will probably find the ring a bit greasy.,,but delicious! The breaded tenderloin was excellent. The Pattie is large and easily over hangs the bun. The meat is a bit thick so it hasn't been beaten to death. It was very moist and tasty. The breading is light, has a moderate amount of thickness and a slight crunch. The sandwich came with a good selection of garnishments. Overall the tenderloin was outstanding! If you have a large party, kids or just want a good solid meal...give Sahm's a try!! read more

See all

We stopped in at 3:30 on a Sunday and it was close to 1/4th full. Bar was hopping. Restaurant atmosphere was nice. Staff was stretched hustling to clean up from an apparent strong lunch crowd and getting ready for a dinner crowd but were still attentive. We got our food really quick. Food was great! I had the spinach dip and my spouse had the French dip. Good for families and larger groups. No outdoor seating that we saw. read more

Our recent experiences -- whether dine-in or carryout -- have been great! We consistently choose Sahm's for lunch or dinner at least three times a month. On our most recent visit, we sat at the bar where Jenny took great care of us. The friendly service and tasty food always brings us back! Oh, and also the Sahm's VIP Rewards Program -- very much appreciated! P.S. Don't forget to get a slice or two of their World Famous Sour Cream Coffee Cake! P.S.S. Their chili is amazing! Be sure to get the toppings -- shredded cheese, sour cream and onions. :) read more

See all

Well we actually went for Easter Brunch. We had a reservation, we were early but sat immediately, and greater by our server . Food was decent but learned it was catering from an outside company BUT I understand the reasoning being they don't specialize in breakfast . But from the service alone I would give them a chance just to try their lunch or dinner. read more

Stopped here for dinner last minute. Unlike many places in Fishers I was able to be sat right away. Our sever came over quickly and took drink orders. I was waiting for someone to join and told her to be on the look out for that person and then we would order (I already knew what they wanted). As soon as that person arrived she quickly came over to confirm I was ready to put the order in. The server came over and check on us frequently, but not too frequently. If she saw us in conversation she kept walking. Some servers will just come and ask if you need anything not reading the room. I ordered a Salmon Greek Salad. It was okay. Nothing overly amazing, but not bad either. It was mostly lettuce with little toppings but the Salmon was a nice size and cooked well. It was a bit of an older crowd and it's a little dark inside but I think that is intended, just not my style, I like more light and airy but for what it is, I think it is fine. The only complaint I really have is there was food all over the carpets all over. I mean in the entry, to at the various tables, to the bathroom, I mean just so much food. Not sure I have ever seen a place with so much food on the floors. Seems like someone would vacuum in between times, maybe they were short staffed, not sure but it doesn't make you really want to eat there if the floor is an indication of what it may look like in the kitchen. I still give it a 4 because I'm hoping it was just a fluke and the food was solid read more

We had a party of four eat lunch at Sahm's and almost everything we got was not very good. The prices were high for the quality of food we had. We all feel we wasted our money on these meals. So, we agreed not to come back here for lunch. read more

i went to the Sahms at the Fishers community center today and Lucas was very kind, he greeted us with a smile, he joked with us and told us to have a nice day, he just overall had a great vibe and made us want to come back. 5 stars would recommend. read more

We ordered the take out holiday meal for 8 offered this past week and were extremely pleased at the overall package of sliced ham, green been casserole, turkey ball dressing, roasted broccoli, walnut salad with creamy dressing , cranberry sauce and powdered shortcake! The pre-scheduled pickup times and locations were very efficient and convenient, the trays and instructions made for quick and easy reheat, the food amounts were plentiful and it was all very delicious!! The price was great and we continue to enjoy the leftovers. Happy Holidays!!! read more

We had no idea how happy we would be with the decision to try an unknown restaurant but followed yelp again to success. The service, food, drinks were superb! I highly recommend you give this family owned restaurant in a non assuming strip mall a try.The decor is pub food oriented with a large bar, hint if they are packed go to the end of the bar and find three hidden bar service tables. Our servers were excellent! read more

Friendly service and reliably good meals. There's almost too much to choose from in the menu. If you can't find something good on their menu, then you aren't hungry. They used to have these amazing carrots curls and I'm really sad they're no longer on the menu. I keep hoping they'll bring them back. read more

Great food reasonably priced. Good service. Terrific tenderloin and great for lunch.

Very outdated little place. It seems to be catered to an older generation. The food was very bland. I added salt and pepper to the Mac & cheese trying to save it. But it needed some help. Burger also very meh. Nothing special about it. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Mac & cheese - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Service is always amazing at the bar on Sunday nights. Spinach dip is delicious Bread comes out warm and fresh. Weekly (two weeks now) specials are a great change up since I eat here every week, it's great to switch it up sometimes and they always have something great to try. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Friends of mine know I was at a very opinion palms restaurant. But even after the less than stellar experience I had last time the food was so good! So I tried it again Food even better than it was before. And the wait staff was super friendly and on point. I have a fabulous Irish coffee more than I expected delicious lol... I had the fried chicken, broccoli, cornbread, and mashed potatoes with gravy. Serving sizes are enough for me to have dinner tonight at home... And everything is so fresh. Sahms is a wonderful home cooked meal...the bar area was inviting today and I love the tvs. just go! read more

Sahm's Restaurant - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

The food was splendid, I got the pork tenderloin it was great, there was even enough extra tenderloin for my daughter to eat and she loved it. The service was great our servers name was Julie and she got our drinks right away and was so very nice, the food got out so fast. The ambiance was great to, yes it was dark and kinda hard to see but the food and service was great so it made up for it and the had music going that was good example party in the USA and a bunch of other great songs. And because my drink I got was so good I had to go the bathroom and the bathroom was good they had a bunch of stalls and urinals to go to the bathroom!! read more

The food was excellent and fast. I got chicken wings were perfectly cooked and the sauce was so good, took very little time to come out. One thing even better than the food was the waitress. Her name was Julie and she was great! She was so nice and gave us some great service she was marvelous. The ambiance was pretty nice but it was a little dark. The bathroom was very clean. I enjoyed my experience and definitely recommend, if you go ask for Julie she is the best! read more

Had lunch, crowd was not bad, no wait. Plenty of parking in this small strip mall. Sahms has it regular menu and then a special menu. Always check the specials, I order from it about half the time. Today I ordered from it and had the cashew encrusted tilapia. It came with rice pilaf, seasonal veggie, which was Brussel sprout with balsamic vinegar. It also came with a side salad but they let me substitute a cup of chicken velvet soup. I started with the soup, it was good but a little too salty for me. I typically have had fish encrusted with pecans so the cashews were a nice twist. It had a gravy or gel on top, it was quite delicious. The Brussel sprouts were a nice surprise and very tasty. I didn't get it this time, but their coffee cake is delicious. I've always had good food at Sahms. Service has always been very good read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Cashew encrusted tilapia - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

First time here since their old location behind the Hilton Garden Inn. Still the same quality...can't beat their pork tenderloin sandwich. Also tried their Alaskan clam chowder for the first time...VERY good and indeed got some to go too! Their in house brewery also brews outstanding beer. The best part is the VALUE you get here. In the year 2024 with most restaurants now charging outrageous prices Sahms still holds the line and gives you value. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - The pork tenderloin. - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Sahm's caters to a decidedly older crowd and I had to remind myself I'm middle-aged now after all. I think part of the attraction is this is a place where folks feel like they are definitely getting bang for their buck. No minimalism here! Entrees, including a good number of specials, come with two hefty sides, which makes for a lot of food. The menu is an eclectic mix of American food, including a standard melting pot of borrowed ethnic-ish (Mex-, Italian-, and Asian-) inspired dishes. But whether it's the specials menu or the list of sides or the whole menu in general, there's just a ton to choose from. I ordered the Mediterranean Salmon; the fish is wood-grilled with sautéed artichoke hearts, tomatoes, feta, capers and Kalamata olives in a lemony beurre blanc. One side was a loaded baked potato presented on the entree plate and the other an iceberg wedge, which was hefty for a side salad. I left overly stuffed because I didn't have the will power to box half of it. My dining partner had the Chicken Avocado, a Tex Mex type preparation, which came with at least a half an avocado on top, a pleasant surprise. Food is seasoned for the age of the crowd (we lose tastebuds especially for salt as we age--LOL!) so there's nothing subtle here. It's full bore in the flavor department. Wait staff is friendly and moderately attentive; it was a busy Friday night. Prices are extremely reasonable with entrees priced $14.99-20.99. I hadn't been to this location yet, or any other Sahm's in years. It's a great neighborhood joint and definitely a local institution for a reason. read more

We wanted a local bar for date night and Sahm's delivered. I don't usually expect top tier cocktails from a more low-key bar, but our were top notch. My husband said his manhattan was better than the steakhouse we recently went to. I got the special burger and it was amazing. All in all it was a great little spot with intimate dive bar vibes, great cocktails, and delicious food! read more

Arrived early, and didn't need a reservation. Many choices of salad dressing. My wife and I ordered the baby back ribs. They have a large variety of salad dressings. The house dressing is delicious. Be adventurous and not take a dressing you know. Do the house dressing. The reviews said the baby back ribs were awesome and they did not disappoint. There is a good choice. My mushrooms came with a horseradish sauce for some kick. I would come again. read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Half rack - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Went here a couple of weeks ago and happy to say I was so impressed with the service and amazing food! Norah was so great and efficient making sure we had a great experience. Cant wait to go back! read more

Chelsea was kind and attentive to our needs. Great breaded tenderloin sandwich! I highly recommend Sahm's and the dining experience.

My family went to Sahm's for an early dinner. We were seated promptly even though they were very busy. The food was good, large portions for the money.The restaurant itself is unassuming, located in a strip mall, but the menu is extensive. My husband and I both had the sirloin steak, which was very good. The entrees include 2 sides that you can choose (there are so many to choose from!). My son ordered shrimp and enjoyed it. Overall a good dining experience. read more

Sahm's food never disappoints. I actually haven't gotten a burger here before but was told the homemade knot rolls are amazing. I decided with the Clint Eastwood burger. Typically I am one that is finicky about my bacon. I hate when bacon isn't cooked enough and is chewy. This burger did not disappoint! And the onion ring was the perfect added crunch. The burger was very juicy and flavorful. At the time I wasn't even that hungry but I ended up eating the whole thing because it was that good. The fries were nice and crispy as well! So many different types of sandwiches I want to try on the menu especially with the homemade buns - definitely a game changer! read more

Sahm's Restaurant - Clint Eastwood burger - American Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I have been coming to Sahm's for years in a few locations when they have moved. They are always busy, the food is always consistently good. Their menu has a wide variety of American dishes and a specials menu that changes. It does get a bit loud when it is crowded. read more

Had the Monday special tenderloin and fish and chips. Hadn't been there in many years but still very good food and reasonable prices.