Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Broken Barrel - Geist

    4.6 (5 reviews)
    Closed • 4:00 pm - 10:00 PM

    The Broken Barrel - Geist Photos

    THE BROKEN BARREL - GEIST ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like The Broken Barrel - Geist

    Recommended Reviews - The Broken Barrel - Geist

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Joey K.
    114
    29
    11

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Peter P.
    257
    2381
    5706

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Aaron S.

    Aaron S.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Nice atmosphere at the bar. Nice selection of Allocated Bourbon. Above the main restaurant, take the stairs to the left.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of D V.
    0
    56
    2

    5 years ago

    Great bourbon selection, priced right, and comfortable environment. I'll be back soon since it's so close to home

    Business owner information

    Photo of Aaron S.

    Aaron S.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Broken Barrel - Geist

    You might also consider

    Whiskey Business

    Whiskey Business

    3.6(147 reviews)
    4.1 mi
    •$$

    First off let me say I had grandkids with me so could not go inside for the full restaurant…read moreexperience. I ordered online and order was ready way before the estimated time of 40 minutes. The server got the togo order for me and brought it to the door since I had the kids. I appreciate that. Now for the food, this was very limited sample so don't let it prevent you from trying the establishment. It looked fun inside and there was a patio outside for dining and hanging out. DYNAMITE CHICKEN ROLLS $12.65 Egg Rolls Stuffed With Grilled Chicken, Spicy Black Beans and Corn. Served with Southwest Ranch. These were dry and not spicy at all. There were about 3 beans and pieces of corn per half eggroll. If the ranch was inside the eggroll, I couldn't tell. Only the space I chose made it spicy at all. It came with a small pile of shredded lettuce and again several beans and pieces of corn. ISLANDER BURGER $17.25 Premium Ground Beef, Grilled Pineapple, Tropical Rum Glaze, Cheddar, Mayo on a Toasted Bun Good concept, plenty of pineapple and mayo but not much flavor. I don't know if the meat is seasoned but it sure didn't seem like it. Not much bourbon glaze or flavor there either. Cole slaw side was creamy and a good portion size.

    My friends and band perform here so far I've had the wings, a wrap, boneless and fries. It's a fun…read moreatmosphere the bartenders have solid pour. The only thing is you might want to bring an extra layer because the times I've come it's been a little cold in the place

    Photos
    Whiskey Business - Main bar

    Main bar

    Whiskey Business - Cheesecake Brownie Sundae

    Cheesecake Brownie Sundae

    Whiskey Business

    See all

    Rye Bar - rye bar

    Rye Bar

    4.6(24 reviews)
    16.3 mi•Wholesale District, Mile Square
    •$$

    I'm currently staying at the Indianapolis Marriott Downtown, which holds in its lobby the Rye Bar…read more I came this evening post a training and was so impressed with the selection and prices. While the menu looked great, I was able to order a custom old-fashioned with Buffalo Trace KY bourbon, black walnut bitters, demerara syrup, and Luxardo cherries, and it was perfect. The bartender was not only skilled but also fun to chat with, which made the experience even better. The aesthetic here is modern, chic, and clean, and the service matches the vibe - professional, welcoming, and attentive. This is definitely a spot I'll keep coming back to during my stay. Whether you're a guest at the hotel or just nearby, Rye Bar is absolutely worth a visit!

    Stopped in the Rye Bar for a night cap and although the bar was stacked, Dennis the bartender was…read moreone funny and knowledgeable dude. He spoke my level Japanese which is almost zero but was a fun character and excellent bar Our group consisted of individuals with a taste of good bourbon and the Rye Bar's inventory included some tasty and exceptional examples. The concern now is the Coach will on the trail to find the ones we tried and make them part of his impressive collection. The bar is located on the lobby level of the Marriott Downtown Indianapolis and was very busy but the bartenders did a fantastic job at filling the orders. The Rye Bar is rated as a highly recommended bar to quench your thirst.

    Photos
    Rye Bar - Rye bar

    Rye bar

    Rye Bar - Buffalos trace old fashioned

    Buffalos trace old fashioned

    Rye Bar - Buffalos trace bourbon barrels

    See all

    Buffalos trace bourbon barrels

    FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale - Caesar salad

    FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale

    4.3(616 reviews)
    5.0 mi
    •$$

    The room was packed, the energy was high, and then the food arrived. Before the plates even hit the…read moretables, that rich, unmistakable aroma filled the air, the kind of comforting smell that only comes from a true scratch kitchen where real chefs handle real ingredients with absolute respect. I watched as people took their first bites. Forkfuls paused mid-air, conversations instantly ground to a halt, and eyes widened across every table. Jake Burgess and the crew from the Burgess Restaurant Group weren't just catering an event; they were executing a masterclass in craft for a crowd without taking a single shortcut. "You have got to try this," someone blurted out to my left, leaning across the table before even finishing their bite. "I'm tellin' you, Jake and his team don't miss," another replied. "Between FoxGardin, The Den, Bonge's, Carnegie's... it doesn't matter which spot it is, they nail it every single time." Taking it all in, it hit me why they stand so far apart. In a world full of safe, forgettable catering, Jake and the Burgess Restaurant Group served up the kind of deep, craveable food that ruins standard dining for the rest of us. It's the kind of cooking that makes you immediately start planning your next trip to one of their spots before you've even finished the meal in front of you. A massive, heartfelt shoutout to Jake Burgess and the entire Burgess Restaurant Group: FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale, FoxGardin Family Kitchen, The Den, Smoky's Concession Stand, Bonge's Tavern, and Carnegie's. Thank you for keeping us exceptionally well-fed last night!

    Was in the area and decided to grab lunch as we often do when in a different locale…read more Noticed FoxGardin had great reviews and was very close by. We weren't going to get an appetizer but the bone marrow fries looked so good in pictures that we had to try them. They did not disappoint. Very large serving and extremely flavorful. Easily an appetizer for 4 or more people (there was only 2 of us so we brought some home). My dining partner is not normally a fries person and she loved these. For entree, my dining partner had today's special which was a shredded chicken sandwich that had a jalapeño cheese sauce and the house chips. She said it was very good and again half the sandwich came home. I had their breaded tenderloin which was very good, with nice breading to meat ratio and was a bit larger than the bun. It came with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles. It came ala carte with no sides. Service was excellent, exceptionally friendly and really took care of us. One of the best waiters I've come across. Inside is a bar/pub like feel. We opted to eat in the air condition enclosed "patio" type area which had a bit more light, but was also noisy today due to the tin lined walls/ceiling and another group that was quite loud. Made it a bit hard to converse. Normally don't think this would be an issue. While not tons of items on the menu, the selection was quite varied and you could really splurge on a filet or other such dish and really go all in for a more lavish dinner or have a burger or tenderloin, all at any time of day. Parking was right in front of the restaurant but could see it being a bit tight on a busy day.

    Photos
    FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale - One of the bar / rooms

    One of the bar / rooms

    FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale - Cookie and Ice Cream

    Cookie and Ice Cream

    FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale - Lots of photos on the walls

    See all

    Lots of photos on the walls

    SNUG - Tasty

    SNUG

    4.8(45 reviews)
    13.1 mi•Irvington

    SNUG is a charming and lively pub that much lives up to its reputation for being well, snug! We…read moredon't mind because everyone was in good cheer and we got to enjoy live Irish music. The potato leek hand pie was delicious and so were the Che Chori veggie Shepard's Pie Empanadas. We of course had to try as many of the Irish specialty drinks including the SNUG Butter Beer with SHANKEYS WHIP, Ginger Beer and Vanilla Cream. We had never tried Shankey's before but immediately picked up a bottle at Total Wine with If you LOVE Ginger Beer definitely try the Irish Mule S9. We also enjoyed the BELFAST COFFEE made with Pangur Potin, Shuv Cold Brew, Simple, Vanilla Cream and Cardamon. Snug Whiskey Fest is coming! May 15-17, 2026. Exclusive Tastings, TWO Brand Expo events, Festival Bottle Releases. Snug Whiskey Fest is Brand Storytelling, One Drop at a Time.

    Popped into Snug to grab a cheeky drink before dinner. Snug is the perfect place to pop into and…read morefind a drink -- the door is open. (Literally. They had the door open, which was letting in the fresh almost-spring air.) Drinks are pretty much all they have at Snug, to be honest. Don't visit thinking you're going to find a meal, because they don't have a lot of food beyond locally made hand pies and empanadas, a grazing board, and something called Snug Nuts. (Which brings to mind certain ... images.) I didn't get any food, just a Road & Coke, which is a whiskey with a Coke and lime, similar to a Cuba libre, although a Cuba uses rum. It was delicious, but a little light on the booze. It was only $5 and change, though, so it's kind of like what do you expect, really. It was a nice drink to sip slowly while I sat in the small, cozy bar. Speaking of bar aesthetics: Snug lives up to its name. It's tiny and dark but inviting. It feels like stepping into a hug. A hug that can also provide you with copious amounts of Irish whiskey, which sounds like the best kind of hug, to me.

    Photos
    SNUG
    SNUG
    SNUG

    See all

    Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars - Outside patio

    Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars

    4.1(155 reviews)
    8.4 mi
    •$$$

    Blend is an institution -- it's my happy place away from home. The owner, Cory, busts his behind to…read moreensure everyone feels at home here. The cigars are exceptional and the selection best in Indianapolis. The drinks are plentiful, and you will find something you will love. My go-to is their Blend Old Fashioned which is always a double pour. They don't skimp on ingredients, and when Cory's wife is in the kitchen... oh my. Get the mains and DO NOT skip dessert. This needs to be your go to every Saturday night. Trust me I've been around the block. Nothing comes close to Blend.

    I was in town for a company holiday party at Harry and Izzy's across the street, and once the party…read morewas over about 10-15 of us decided to continue the evening at Blend for a couple of drinks and a cigar. They were very accommodating to such a large group, many of whom are not really cigar smokers. At the back of the space is a large bar with an equally large humidor behind it. The humidor attendant was helpful and patient with the members of our party that didn't really know what they wanted. We were seated at a long table near the bar, though we took up a couple of smaller tables as well. They do a phenomenal job of air quality management, even though there were a ton of people smoking, the air seemed quite clean, enough so that a non-smoker would probably be comfortable hanging out with a friend who was smoking without being uncomfortable. Though they only have a small selection of beer, they did have some fairly good options. I had a Goose Island Cherries Jubilee Bourbon County Stout (quite nice), and a Camacho cigar. I didn't have any food on this visit, but the menu did look promising, even if a bit over priced. Overall this is a very nice spot for a cigar and a drink, I will likely be back when in Indy again!

    Photos
    Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars - Enjoy my birthday out on the patio with great friends! At Blend

    Enjoy my birthday out on the patio with great friends! At Blend

    Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars - Hell of a view for the playoffs, isn't it?

    Hell of a view for the playoffs, isn't it?

    Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars

    See all

    West Fork Whiskey - Westfield - Honey limited edition

    West Fork Whiskey - Westfield

    4.3(164 reviews)
    14.8 mi
    •$$

    West Fork Whiskey in Westfield is coming to an end. This was the perfect place to gather with…read morefriends, enjoy a whiskey tasting, and take a tour to see firsthand how the spirits were made. The distillery created an experience that went beyond just great whiskey,it gave people a place to connect, relax, and make memories. The Stave was a cozy spot inside West Fork Whiskey to sip crafted cocktails, while the Mash House offered food that made it easy to spend an entire afternoon or evening at West Fork. Even if whiskey wasn't your drink of choice, West Fork was a welcoming destination for everyone. Whether you stopped in for dinner, drinks, a tour, or rented the event space for a special gathering, there was something for everyone. While we're saying goodbye to West Fork's Westfield location, thankfully this isn't the end of West Fork Whiskey. You can still enjoy their cocktails at West Fork Social House in Fountain Square. West Fork Social House serves coffee during the day and whiskey-forward cocktails at night, carrying on the welcoming community atmosphere.

    I was really sad to hear that West Fork Whiskey will be changing hands very soon. I've had nothing…read morebut great experiences here. Everything from the Winter Market, a Galentine's Day Event, tours of the distillery and tastings but especially the food!! The Whiskey drinks and cocktails are excellent as well. They even have cool merch and a distinctive vibe just a fun place and somewhere I enjoyed bringing friends from out of town. I will continue to support the brand and look forward to more events at The West Fork Social House in Fountain Square. Best of luck to the owners and the staff during the transition.

    Photos
    West Fork Whiskey - Westfield - Event center

    Event center

    West Fork Whiskey - Westfield - Grab some fun tshirt, hats, and cups on your way out!

    Grab some fun tshirt, hats, and cups on your way out!

    West Fork Whiskey - Westfield - Entrance

    See all

    Entrance

    The Broken Barrel - Geist - whiskeybars - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...