Opening qualifying statement - This is a 4-star rating based on comparison to other record stores in phoenix area (poor area for record stores), if you're from L.A. or NYC this may not apply to what you're used to. That said, here is my breakdown by major category of what I feel is important in a record store:
Used Records: 3/5 - This isn't really the place for used records, yes they have some, but they just don't have the room for a ton of records in here, and they utilize most of their space with new, and cd's. So it is what it is.
New Records: 4.5/5 - This is the best part about this small local record shop in my opinion. They have more new records than most in the valley, and you can tell they actually put some thought into what new records they order every week, rather than just ordering the billboard top 40 artists or whatever.
Genre Variety: 3.5 - This was very difficult to grade because while they do have a good array of variety within specific genres they have, they have a couple genres that are either non-existent or barely there like Blues/Reggae. For the genres that they do have decent quantities of you'll find a refreshing array within that genre, for example hip-hop you can find old school, new school, mainstream, underground, etc, etc, etc. In general, if you're looking to score some used Howlin' Wolf records, or some used Frank Sinatra, or rare Pink Floyd used records or going to have a limited limited selection and low chance of finding what you need here. But if you're into finding some Black Keys, White Stripes, Kanye West you'll be very happy here.
Customer Service/Atmosphere: 4/5 - This is more a personal taste thing, personally I love that feeling of digging in crates of beat-up old records in a hole-in-the wall smelling like musky aged vinyl rather than the new-agey hipster feel of this place. That said, it's a very cool hipster-style place to grab some vinyl. And the times I've met the owner I've been very pleased at her attitude towards keeping real record stores alive and being openly against downloads/itunes.
Composite Overall: 4/5 - I hope that they continue to grow, and eventually expand or move into a bigger location, would love to see what they could do with more space, they could easily become the go-to place for vinyl in Phoenix if that happens. Right now I'm still giving those honors to Revolver, but Stinkweeds is a must-stop too when I get downtown. And really, I love going to both Revolver and Stinkweeds as they compliment each other nicely, contrasting styles, you can definitely go to Revolver and still go to Stinkweeds after and be very happy with both experiences. read more