Food (4/5): mostly a hit, sometimes a miss. I'm a big fan of unique food combos and most of the dishes deliver on interesting and delicious. It's great that the Arsenale had some off-menu stuff and that's what intrigues me enough to come back.
Service (4.5/5): overall pretty great. We didn't feel rushed to leave, but sometimes a dish was dropped off with just a three-word description. I would've liked to hear more about the process but there wasn't time to ask. But considering we were a walk-in on a fully booked Friday night, it wasn't a big deal.
Value (5/5): if you're not picky, the Arsenale is essentially a 10-course tasting meal which is a steal for two people.
We sat at the counter with swing-out seats (cool), although me being shorter than 5 feet was unfortunate because I couldn't stop the seat from swinging around since my feet didn't touch the floor. I think I got an unexpected glute workout trying to keep my seat in place.
I'm a sucker for tasting menus so we chose the Arsenale ($51 per person; everyone at the table must participate). It includes four mini plates, three starters (meats/fish/veggies), two mains (pasta/risotto), and one dessert to be shared. They scale up the portions based on the number of people. We walked away feeling full/stuffed. Any prices below are mentioned a la carte from what I saw on the menu.
+ Fried oysters: Great combination of textures and flavors. It had some citric acid taste I couldn't place (from the pickled shallots/miso?). The chewy oyster, fried batter, crunchy endive, and sour/salty sauce worked well together. This wasn't specifically on the a la carte menu.
+ Potatoes: This tasted like pretty simple mashed potatoes with a hint of cheese, but in a vague cube shape topped with fried onions (?). I'd never had fried onions and mashed potatoes together before, but it's a solid combo.
+ Meatballs (polpette, $4): If you like meatballs, you can't go wrong with this. The tomato sauce tasted very much more like tomatoes than, say, a marinara sauce.
/ Whipped cod (baccala mantecato, $4); this reminded me of dried squid. Not bad, but not my favorite. The squid ink bread was chewy and room temperature so I didn't love it.
--
+ Misticanza Salad ($14): No porchetta like mentioned on the a la carte menu, but I think the server mentioned something anchovy? Croutons were soggy but delicious. Cheese + greens + pickled carrots are a great combo. The accompanying bread slices were room temperature but fine. I didn't understand why it was served with the salad, but I love bread so I'm not complaining.
+ Butternut Squash ($15): Once again, interesting flavors. This reminded me of sage browned butter pasta which reminds me of movie theater popcorn. The contrast between the prosciutto, toffee crumble (?), sunflower seeds, and currants were unique to me and went well together.
- Lamb: I was strangely unimpressed with this. Supposedly the lamb was braised and pressed but it seemed kind of dry, a little gamey, and just not that flavorful. The crispy greens, pickled raisins (?), and polenta went well with the meat, though. This wasn't specifically on the a la carte menu.
--
- Tagliatelle with Vongole: This tasted like really, really, really salty pasta water and clams over well-done egg noodles...I wasn't a fan. This wasn't specifically on the a la carte menu.
- Rigatoni: The rigatoni tasted like whole wheat noodles and were lightly spicy, cooked perfectly al dente. Unfortunately, I didn't like this because it was so salty.
--
+ Torte with kumquat and pistachio: This kind of tastes like orange banana bread. I don't love kumquat or pistachio, but I liked them in this torte. If you like a denser, cakier dessert, this is great but not specifically on the a la carte menu.
+ Latte (extra $4.50; not part of Arsenale) - My boyfriend was pleasantly surprised how well it was prepared. He said the coffee quality itself tasted as expected and the milk foam was messed up, but it didn't have that grimy taste lots of restaurants have when they don't clean their machine.
+ Black currant sorbetto (extra $4; not part of Arsenale) - Super sour, slightly tingly on the tongue, and reminded me of haw flakes (or mint/raspberries). I loved the texture.
The two pasta dishes were way too salty for me and I wouldn't try them again, but my boyfriend thought they tasted fine. I let our server know and he offered some substitution so I would come away feeling full. I ended up getting the fried oysters and meatballs again, although those also tasted saltier and not as great the second time around. I do appreciate the fantastic service, though, and look forward to coming here again. read more