It's not very good at Sorrento Pizza. The only thing that resembles pizza is the box. Which tastes a lot better than what the box contains. I've lived in Mendham for years and keep hoping Sorrento was better. But it isn't. I've tried. read more

I love this thin no flop sourdough pizza! It's so thin yet so flavorful! I loved the fried chicken sandwhich too it's sooo crispy and fried in beef tallow!! No seed oils!! read more

See all

Excellent -the Pizzi sourdough crust, sauce and fresh toppings. Have recommended this place to everyone

Great sourdough pizza with quick service. They also have a chicken parm pizza I think it's called a pizzetta or something similar?? My husband LOVED it. We will go back. read more

THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!!!!! I went with my friends out later in the day and he guys gave us free soda on the house for a good review!!! what a goat!!! please come here and support local business! AMAZING! read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Free soda they gave us on the house! - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

Very impressed with service. Allowed me to order for pick up 5 minutes before they closed on a holiday. I ordered penne vodka and wings. Great food and the new environment was very cool. No complaints. read more

Must be new owners. Great pizza. The "pizzi" pie is incredible. We also had the crispy chicken sandwich based on a recommendation and it did not disappoint. read more

Admittedly, the Mendham/Far Hills/Bernardsville pizza scene is kind of weak. Some places are ok, some are awful, but none are really stellar. One of the better ones is Sorrento's in Mendham. The Sicilian is a typical thick-crust pie, good sauce and quality cheese, even though they missed a spot on this one . The Pizza Fina (thin crust) isn't thin like Star or Pete and Elda's or any of the other places that have bar pies, but it is thinner than their regular cheese pie. Folks are nice, which is always a plus. read more

See all

Edited review - after a rough first experience, I gave this place another shot and I'm glad I did. The customer service has really improved and the pizza is still delicious. -------- If I could write a review of just that Penne Ala Vodka pizza, this would be a whole lot easier. 5 stars easy. I'm not usually a fan of pasta on pizza either - too dry. But this was just perfect. Unfortunately the experience did not consist solely of eating the pizza. I needed to pick up the pizza, and that is where the trouble started. The first thing the owner said when I said I was picking up my GrubHub order was "you paid the wrong price." Of course, I have no control of the prices reflected on GrubHub, but he didn't seem to agree and he was pretty angry about it. Two important notes: (1) this is new ownership at a neighborhood place (not a good start) and (2) we were talking about $1.50 on an ~$30 order. In other food news, the chicken piccata had an excellent sauce, but was way too small of a portion for the price. The side Caesar salad which my wife was excited for ended up as a garden salad. Oh, but that pizza. read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Penne Ala vodka pizza - delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

See all

I don't know what all the negative reviews were about... They had a lot of pizzas to choose from: white, Sicilian, pepperoni etc... This place has been here forever too (though I believe it has changed ownership a couple times). The pizza was good, straight, standard New York style. Meets the benchmark. read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

I ordered through Doordash the "FRESH MOZZARELLA WITH ARUGULA SUB With house-made roasted peppers" (copied directly from their website) and was given a sub with chicken, tomatoes, lettuce, and mayo. I called Sorrento's and was told they were sorry and would send their delivery driver out with the correct sandwich. They then called me back 15 minutes later and said the sandwich I ordered "comes with chicken" and they were unable to provide me with a refund or a new sandwich. It wasn't even close to the correct sandwich. read more

A good pizza does not always require a trip to the city, there's a find here in Mendham too... the new owner has improved quality, no longer dependant on frozen dough, and... is building lifetime customers with his cordial manner. Highly recommend. read more

Been coming here for years. Under new ownership!!!!!! The owner came and introduced himself and even asked what we thought of the food. Felt very warm. Will definitely be back. DEFINITELY RECOMMEND!!!! read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Yum yum - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

Sausage pizza was raw and worked refused to refund for it. Unfortunate customer service. read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Sausage pizza not cooked - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

This is a great in-town pizza place. In the surrounding towns there aren't many better NY Style pizzas. Worth a try if you are in Chester or Randolph area as well. read more

Ok. We're done ordering from here. They messed up our order and most of the food was so salty that it was inedible. I'm so sorry that I cannot support a local business but they have to fire the cook and own up to their shortcomings. read more

I ordered from this place because the picture of the Sicilian pie looked decent. The reviews on doordash were 4.8 stars. I got my food and I have plenty of options in the area that shatter this. So it's my first and last time. I'll continue to try all the places in the area but it hasn't been very positive. read more

I ordered from Sorrento's for the first time through DoorDash, although they did not use a Dasher, but their own delivery person. They're located 11 minutes away via care and I am sorry to say that delivery was horribly slow. I ordered a Grandma's Pizza with extra cheese and a salad. The salad was nice, but the pizza without extra cheese and because it was cold, we heated it up in the oven and it still didn't make the grade of "pizza snob." read more

The buffalo wings is great, lick my fingers. Come here all the time on the weekend, always get the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. It's the best pizza in town. Definitely recommend it. read more

See all

Quarantine take out order was wrong. Chicken parm instead of eggplant. Called & they made eggplant gratis but too hungry to wait so ate chicken, which was 2 large flat pcs overcooked on top of each other with mediocre tomato sauce & plain mozz melted over just top one. Nothing on one underneath. Ample portion of pasta done nicely. Other dinner was penne w/broccoli & chic. Broccoli was frozen small pcs and chicken was grilled breast, sliced & placed on top. Side order of broc rabe was tiny for price & over garliced. Even salad that came with parm dish had creamy dressing already on top - with sauce dishes, should be vinaigrette and served on side. Had eggplant next day & again poor - only sauce & mozz melted over top piece - rest was dry. They have steep competition in Mendham with 4 other Italian rest. serving great food with loyal fans. Been living here 30 yrs & never had such a poor Italian meal. Better step up their game- we will NEVER go back. read more

Everything you want in a good pizza experience and more! A lot has changed at Sorrento's - and for the better! They have remodeled the inside... fresh paint, new seating design, counter with stools. Very pleasant to eat there now. They are adding new pizza selections regularly. Delicious! Also try their eggplant! Best around. read more

Excellent customer service and food is always so good! Delivery is always punctual and fast!

Sorrentos pizza under the new ownership is absolutely fantastic! Great good and great service! Everyone is super friendly and the food is amazing. There is a lot more dinners and salads to choose from and they are delicious. I am very happy the new sorrentos is here! read more

Sorrento's Pizza - This salad was amazing from sorrentos! - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

Amazing pizza and even better service! I would highly recommend the chicken parm sandwich. Will definitely be back soon! read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana Sub - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

We're pizza snobs and this is our go to for quick bites. Pizza is good, delivery is quick. Rolls are delicious!!

Worst sandwich ever. Ordered a tuna sub with LTO and vinegar. They delivered this. No L, no T and 3 tiny onion pieces. How could anyone running a business let this go out the door!?! read more

Sorrento's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mendham, New Jersey

$10.95 listed on online menu. At checkout charged $15.95 for same meal. On top of that now a 3% credit card usage fee! Decent food but we are done with this place. This has become price gouging and says everything about the management. Many other options in town. read more

Pizza is so fresh and delicious. Very safe neighborhood:) Good service!!! Definitely I will be back again read more

Food might have gotten 2 stars but the dishonesty forced the lowest possible review. I was handed a menu and told a price price for toppings. When the total came up I questioned it. I was told "We raised our prices but we're waiting for new menus." To me that is fraud, you charge what you say you will. You want to charge more you update the register and the menu at the same time. Both items I ordered were more expensive expected but I was in a hurry and didn't want to find a new place. The bathroom made gas station bathrooms look fabulous and when the food came out was extraordinarily greasy and didn't even taste good. I will NOT be back. read more

Overpriced and soggy pizza. I work down the road from Sorrento and I've never been happy with the pizza from here. Two pepperoni slices and a soda cost me about $10. Save your money and go to New York Pizza in Chester. read more

Consistently great food and great delivery. Pizza is never soggy or undercooked. Good mozzarella sticks. Delicious pasta dishes.

Rude. Liars. On doordash and didn't cancel their participation. Yelled at me over the phone. Hung up 3 times. This is beyond horrible customer service. I would avoid and advise all to do the same. Their pizza was average before but with this new owner, must be even worse read more

They are so frustrating. Service was poor. I hate this place. So my thoughts you can try another best place for pizzaa read more

There was an issue with our GrubHub order. The restaurant quickly fixed the problem. Delicious pizza!

I've only had the pizza the few times I been here and I think it tastes great. The price coincides with the area so if your not from the area then you may think it's a little pricey. read more

This place has good old style pizza. It tastes fresh and they have a variety of other foods too. Including sandwiches subs and soup. I really like this place! read more

The worst customer service mixed with average food makes for an extremely poor experience. The owner is abrasive and rude. He apparently has an issue with Slice, but takes it out on the customer. Never ordering from them again and I suggest others follow suit if stress over ordering pizza is not what one is looking to experience. read more

One of my favorite places for takeout! Great pizza and sandwiches! Relatively fast service with super friendly staff! Love the Good Goat Salad! read more

We stopped here for the first time for some slices on a weekday evening around 8pm. The unhappy server was vacuuming a hallway floor then came behind counter to take our order. He didnt wash hands but did use a spatula on slices. After warming up some old looking slices and serving them, he began vacuuming around all the tables where we ate. This place looks dated and feels dirty. A real dump. read more

I decided to stop in to this place to grab a slice of pizza after finishing with a hair appt. and I was starving. I read the reviews on Yelp and although the reviews weren't great, I decided to try it. As soon as I walked in, I almost wanted to walk back out but my stomach was growling so I decided to order. First, it's a small place but it looks very run down. The "ready to go" pizza looked like it had been sitting there for a very long time. I couldn't even tell what some of the toppings were. I decided to get a buffalo chicken and a pepperoni to go. As I went to pay, I noticed a sign that read "$10 minimum on credit/debit"....thank goodness I had cash on me. Although they do have an ATM machine there, it was out of order that day. The soda machine next to to the register was absolutely filthy and it kind of grossed me out thinking about eating the pizza. Still I thought, maybe this a diamond in the rough type of place. WRONG....the pizza was horrible. The slices were soggy and lacked flavor. Worst pizza I ever tasted. read more