They say they're open at 11 I walked in at 11:10 and was told I'd have to wait 20 minutes to get two slices of pizza because there wasn't any ready. They just opened up first of all if you're in the business to serve the public and you advertise that you're open at 11 o'clock everyone and everything should be ready to serve the public. You don't turn people away from the door and tell them to come back in 20 minutes because you're not ready at 11 o'clock if that's the case then change your hours. I'll never go back there again.!!! read more

Best pizza in Morris County and not even close. Not feeling pizza? Their subs and pasta are quite good as well.

I grew up in Randolph and really appreciate the pizza at Pizza Palace. Went there last night and it was as good as always. However, one thing that bugged me just a little was that they automatically added a10% tip for a takeout order. Has anyone else noticed this? Thanks. read more

Yelp should delete reviews from over 10 years ago. This pizza place has been a stable family business for the 28 years I have lived here and that should tell people something. The pizza is very good. You may encounter a wait time if you order Friday or Saturday night but it's worth the wait. read more

Pizza Palace reminds me of one of those old fashioned pizza places where there's not a lot of frills, but the pizza is excellent. At lunchtime, you can see that a lot of the locals stop in here for a slice or a sandwich. It has that nice vibe that makes you feel comfortable. I went for a slice of buffalo chicken with a can of root beer. Price was right on and the pizza was great! Plenty of parking and seats. The guys behind the counter were very friendly. Just keep the conversation to pizza and sports! read more

Pizza Palace - First time here! - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Fantastic Pizza..plus great eggplant parmigiana sub...extensive take out menu on line. Thin crust pizza, perfectly made...we pick up..never get delivery. All the types of pizza you would ever desire plus toppings. Third generation owners...a Randolph tradition. I went with my young children in the 1980's - 2000. Now we order for their kids ! Our grandchildren- every time they visit and want " Palace Pizza". Good quality...good prices. I recommend Maureen & Steve Haller read more

Whether it's nostalgia raising my kids when they were little or if this tiny restaurant in Randolph has truly the best salad pizza I've ever had, no one will know except for me. We moved away 15 years ago and visited one other time 9 years ago. We finally made it back today! Vito, whom I recognized was so sweet. They joked with us, see you in another 15 years! read more

See all

The boys over at Pizza Palace just get it. The sauce has just the right balance to make all their pies truly stand out. As a Morristown resident right up Sussex Avenue from this establishment, I've been a regular customer for nearly 20 years now. They're pies taste just as consistently good as they did in 2005. The absolute best of the best when it comes to Jersey pizza. Thanks for everything you do guys! read more

Pizza Palace - Buffalo chicken and Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Anyone else having trouble getting through to Pizza Palace? I like that they are busy but every time I've called in the last month or so their lines are always busy so I keep trying. Eventually they do answer but tonight they answered and as I started to order they said "sorry you're going to have to call back"? Very rude tone, not sure what's going on there? read more

Unfortunately we were very unhappy with the food that we had ordered for delivery. The pizza was gross. Had a strong taste of parm. It was thin crust and didn't seem fresh. The chicken parm sub was tasteless. My husband tried to fix it to taste better so that my son would eat it. No luck. We typically like the food, and I feel bad for writing this review, but when you spend $50 on an order and most of it is inedible, it's upsetting. Contacted the restaurant via the website and didn't hear back. read more

I grew up going to this place while at Randolph High in the 90's and went to school with Vito. I left the area for college in the late 90's and have lived in Maryland since. This is still the greatest Italian food I've ever had, there's nothing like it's simplistic yet perfect sauce, taste, dough texture of the pizza. There is a nostalgic flavor of growing up with this food that I cannot find anywhere outside of New Jersey, it just doesn't exist. If you're local to Pizza Palace, do not overlook how great their food is. read more

Pizza is fantastic and owner is very nice. I told the owner i make pizza at home and he was more than happy to give me some tips & tricks on how to make better pizza and i really appreciated that read more

I can't tell you enough how i love their cheese pie pizza reminds me of the good old days when I was a kid and pizza was done right! Only wish they had wings but honesty one of the best pizzas around! read more

Stopped at this place on a main road and ordered a grilled chicken sandwich. The sandwich was average but came as ordered. One of my biggest pet peeves is being overcharged and I was charged $3 more than the price on the menu. read more

Great pizza joint, excellent pizza,excellent sandwiches, very good meals, great value, fast service, no extra frills just good service

I always order Eggplant & Mushroom Roll/Stromboli. I am not a vegetarian but this combination is so GOOD! I always order here when I am in the area! read more

I don't know what their secret is but their sauce is delicious! Fully enjoyed just the basic cheese pizza.

It's my Monday spot when Mama's is.closed, but he, let's keep it in the family shall we.

I rated this a 1 star previously and then another yelper told me to give it another try. The pizza is good in a pinch and great drunk food pizza. I have had New Haven CT pizza for years and while I know nothing can top New Haven style this pizza is still rated on that scale. 2 stars for pizza in the north east. 3 stars for pizza in Randolph NJ read more

Watched my friend down a whole pie at 15 years old in about 5 minutes, after we biked there. Still wasn't enthralled by (any) pizza but I always thought they had the best I had ever had at that age (1980). Miss them more than I can say. I wish I lived closer or they decide to ship :( read more

Always great pizza. Sometimes they have no delivery available (very understandable as it was only during this pandemic), and we had to order from another local pizza place. Our kids are never fooled, and get upset that we didn't just drive to Pizza Palace.... hard to argue with them honestly. read more

Been going here for over 30 years, the pizza is fantastic and the meatballs are great too. I remember when a slice cost $0.85, not that it matters. read more

I have been here a few times I only had pizza and the chicken stromboli. No complaints regarding either. This is what you would expect of any pizzeria. It is not fancy inside and quite honestly the tables could probably be update. Hey, the tables don't affect the quality or taste of the food. This is a good go to spot if you are in the area and need a quick slice. read more

Went here today for lunch. Close to the job I'm on. Me and my helper both got chicken parm sandwiches. Not bad, lots of cheese. Good amount of chicken, the roll was not toasted. Kinda threw it off but it wasn't bad. The people seemed nice. I will definitely give it another try. The pizza looked good. read more

This pizza place was my staple growing up and therefore, every pizza slice I've had gets compared to this pizza. I think because their base is done perfectly and consistently - the right amount of garlic, sauce, & cheese - it translates well with toppings and it's not over the top greasy. Meatball and sausage is done very well here as is the margherita pizza (and any white pizza here for that matter). The buffalo chicken pizza is very good as well. Also - try the meatball sub or Stromboli when you're not in the mood for a slice. read more

I had a couple of slices while killing time. Crispy thin crust. White pie had nice big dollops of ricotta. The Margarita was good. I'd be back. A little chaotic in the door with the order. Being new to the place the flow was confusing as the place was full of people waiting for takeout. That the place was so packed was a good sign to me, locals were definitely enjoin their favorite local slice. read more

I absolutely love pizza palace, we stop in everytime we visit my in laws in Randolph. I can always count on them to have the best variety of slices on the spot. I loveeee their margarita, meatballs, and white slices, he always goes for their ziti and pepperoni. The crust has the perfect crunch and it's overall just delightfully delicious . If we didn't live 35 minutes away this would be our go to for delivery. When they start delivering by drone... you'll have our business for sure ! read more

Blast from the past. I remember riding my bicycle here as a kid. Went again recently and little has changed. Solid pizza, typical pizza parlor, convenient location. The pizza has a thinner crust, which I like. Pricing is a bit on the higher side for what it is. read more

I know they have great chicken rolls but I was feeling vegetarian today so I it in a special request for a mushroom and eggplant roll. OMG! It was so, so, so DELICIOUS!!!! Enough said, you have to try It' read more

After living in Manhattan for over 7 years, with access to some of the best pizza in the country, I have to say I still boast about my hometown pizza joint. Growing up on such deliciousness has spoiled me rotten and set the bar high... and a trip home to see the parents always includes a palace pie. xoxo read more

Ordered a pizza tonight with spinach on it. The spinach looked bad. Older dudes that work there are seriously unfriendly and dour.

Ordered pizza for takeout as a quick lunch when we were moving. Unfortunately the pizza itself was not very good - neither I nor my family enjoyed the margarita pie. However the order was ready on time, and the staff was very friendly and provided us with extra cups, plates, and napkins as we didn't have anything stocked in the new house yet. While it's not the fanciest or most up to date looking restaurant, it is in a convenient location right off of Sussex turnpike. read more

A staple in Randolph!! Consistently delicious. Last week I called in a panic- 25-30 people coming over and I'd done nothing about food... I called Pizza Palace. No problem. My needs were quickly assessed- delivery set for the NEXT day... yes- I procrastinate. Right on time the next day- brought into the house HOT set in trays and off we were!! I got so many compliments on the food!! Best Cesar salad EVER! Penne was perfect as was the chicken francaise!! They totally came through and it was amazingly good!! read more

Great pizza and Calzone! This was my first time here. I am definitely coming back!

Solid and reliable local business with a personal touch to delivery and in-house pizza.

Barely ok, small slice & over priced pizza. Not overly friendly either. No reason to go back. Small selection of slices. I could get a slice twice the size, twice as good for the same price in Manhattan. Too bad. read more

Yummy crispy thin slices! Best Pizza I have had in the Randolph area! Friendly customer service.

I can't believe I just paid $53 for this garbage. The only fresh pizza I got was the one that had veggies. The other two looked and tasted like day old stale Pizza. The "Margherita" pizza was stale cheese, sauce and garlic. I asked if they at least some fresh basil....now it's summer so that should be expected but all they had was frozen. If can't keep basil for a pizza don't have the pizza on the menu. The staff was rude and I will never go here again. I would like a refund. The first two photos are the nasty Pizza Palace slices, the other photos are what they should have looked like. Hopefully this will help set standards for this company. read more

See all

Pizza was pretty good. The crust was nice and overall not a bad pizza. Friendly staff and service was fast. I would return and try again.

I have been to many different pizza places in my life and this one is my favorite. The food is fantastic I love the thin crust and the pizza is never undercooked or burned. I love the chicken roll and I highly recommend it. So food is great to take out but do not plan on eating in because the place is small, dirty, and outdated and the scenery is just not that good. read more