I've been here about 10 times and it's time to write a review. Best pizza in the area and by far the most consistent pizza too! And fantastic customer service is the cherry on the top! read more

Mama's Roxbury - Bee Sting - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

We've never been to Mama's before. There was a sign out front, rib-eye cheese steaks and we figured we'd give it a try. You can pick whatever you want to add so we went with hot cherry peppers and provolone. We also felt like wings and went with the traditional hot wing sauce. Everything was made to order so it took a bit of time which was fine. The place was super busy, lots of to go orders and pick ups. The staff were very energetic and happy. When they weren't taking orders, they were stocking sodas and cleaning. There was oldies music playing and a general happy vibe. As far as the food goes, the wings were ok. There were generous with the blue cheese, but the wings were a little tough for $15. The sub was with the cherry peppers, and not enough meat which was sort of greasy. It came with fries, but they were cold and soggy. Again $15. I'd go back for pizza since it was everyone else was picking up and taking home. read more

Mama's Roxbury - Rib Eye Cheese Steak - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

See all

Past review, first time ordering from Mama's. Had their delivery service, not a happy customer as it was not up to par...no receipt and he forgot the soda I ordered. The food was good ...I had ordered a sausage pie (nice crust) and cheesesteak Maybe I'll try again and they can redeem themselves. read more

The absolutely best bee sting pizza you will find in NJ! I love their Sicilian slices, the dough is amazing. My husband likes to get the buffalo chicken pizza and he says it's amazing. Love the decor and the feel of a real pizzeria. read more

Did you call your Mama lately? well I'll tell you one thing, if your Mama could make amazingly delicious Pizza like this place, I'd be calling her up every damn day Lol!! Seriously though you cannot go wrong with anything off this outstanding menu which features some of the Best local Pizza A-round!! This business is owned and operated by two guys from Brooklyn and I gotta say that this one-of-a kind style Pizzeria is a much welcomed addition to this part of Jerzey.   So far I've tried their "Buffalo Chicken Pizza" which was loaded with Tender Juicy Tangy Chicken with just the perfect amount of spice to it and even was topped with Blue Cheese Dressing. For those who might not know It's like biting into Buffalo Wings and Pizza simultaneously. Also I enjoyed their "Bee Sting" Square Slice which was just as awesome with it's Crispy Pepperoni cups that were slathered and filled with Hot Honey = YUMMMMMMERS!!    Plus, here they feed you just like your Mama would so yeahh. Oh I almost forgot, is there any chance I could get your Mama's phone number? Lol. Ahh you know what, nevermind I'll just give this place a call whenever I get the urge to chow down on some Incredibly Delicious World Class Pizza!! Come And Get Your Mama Munch On!! read more

See all

Ordered takeout Brooklyn MVP on thin crust with sausage and pepperoni which was delicious! It was the perfect size and had just enough of everything. The crust wasnt as thin as I expected but it had a good crunch nonetheless. I will be making this my go to pizza spot now. The price is a little on the expensive side since each topping added was another $5 each so my total was $38 for the one pizza. The gentleman at the counter offered me extra plates to take home too which was nice. They had my pizza ready in a timely manner as well. read more

Absolutely delicious! We've dined in, ordered for pick up and had delivery and never had something I didn't like or enjoy. Everything is delicious!! We usually go for a quick bite after soccer practice and order a variety of slices and they knock it out of the park with every speciality slice they offer. Staff is always super friendly. Love it here, they are my go to pizzeria, the best in the area! read more

There's been a few different owners at this pizzeria over the years, but I think we finally have the right one. I stopped in today to pick up a pie for lunch and we all thought it was very good. It's a thin crust with a delicious sauce. Just the right spice in the sauce! Another thing I like is that they had some great looking slices on the counter. You need choices when you're just having a slice. It's not a large place, but there are tables for dining in. Parking in front. Prices range from average to slightly above, but if you're getting high quality, that's fine. This is a welcome addition to the Roxbury pizza scene! read more

See all

I was in this area and craved pizza. Stopped in for lunch. A very small place with only two booths and an upright rail with some seating. I ordered one slice of The Bee Sting, which was a Sicilian style slice with pepperoni. This slice must have honey or something because it was a little sweet which was awesome! The second slice was the same Sicilian style with pesto on the cheese. Also excellent. In the future I'll plan my visits to the area around lunch time to stop in again! Great place and the staff were very friendly. read more

Mama's Roxbury - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

Love their pizza most authentic in Delaware to NYC ! The owner is from Italy and his daughter helps to operate the restaurant keeping it authentic read more

Stopped in to this new pizza place and though it was good, I really wished for more. I would truly give this place a 3.5 if I could. For strengths, this place has a good location off the highway and kind, friendly staff. Everyone made sure we were taken care of for our little lunch stop. Food variety is great, menu is both exciting and has all the things you want from a pizza joint. For pizza slices we tried the grandmas, bee sting, and upside down. All pretty great! Seems like high quality ingredients and fresh take for pizza. I think the traditional and modern mix of things here is a great asset. My biggest critique is for when we tried one of the large rice balls and were not happy it seemed microwaved. The outside coating was rubbery and the thing was extremely hot inside but not in a good way. Surprised happily there were no peas inside (as I don't prefer them, though they are mostly traditional). I hope to order from here soon and get a full pie. I know they are just starting out, so I'm going to give them another go - just wanted to share these thoughts! read more

See all

It was my first time trying Mama's pizzeria yesterday. We've been looking for years to find a go-to pizza place in the Lake Hopatcong area and nothing has stood out as an absolute must have...Until now! When we walked in we immediately saw people eating 2 pizzas in the one other booth and they looked amazing! They highly recommended them so we had to copy their pizza order. The 7 of us shared the Brooklyn MVP and Mama's Special Roasted Garlic Square Pizza as well as garlic knots, and a chicken parm hero. While we were waiting for the pizzas we indulged in their large garlic knots drenched in oily garlicky goodness with crispy bottoms. We also really got to dive into the sauces with their garlic knots because they generously gave us big cups of their vodka and marinara sauces with them. The chicken parm was really good but we really came to try the pizzas. Both pizzas were Brooklyn Sicilian style square pizzas. The crusts were thick, light, and airy with a crispness on the outside, all 3 sauces were flavorful and very plentiful on top of the Brooklyn MVP. The roasted garlic pizza was delicious but you've got to be a garlic lover. There are tons of huge pieces of roasted garlic. We also then had to try a couple slices of their upside square, which did not disappoint. For me personally the Brooklyn MVP was legitimately the MVP. I will have a hard time not ordering it every time I'm there. The other MVPs were Tatiana and her dad! They really gave it that authentic Brooklyn feel and were so welcoming that you left feeling like friends. Overall it was a definite 5 stars. My wife and I try pizzas all over the NJ area and honestly this might be the best pizza we've had in NJ. Next time i will have to try the round pizzas to see how it stacks up with the squares. My only criticism would be that they need a bigger place with more seating! read more

Mama's Roxbury - Brooklyn MVP - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

Spectacular pizza. Exceptionally nice and welcoming owner. Great crust, whether ordering Thin Crust or Sicilian. Zesty sauce. What could be bad. I want to head back for the sandwiches this week! read more

Best pizza in western New Jersey. Tried the regular Sicilian and Grandma and both were excellent. Smells like a NY pizza place.

Now this is delicious pizza! We like to try new places but like to have a go to staple and mamas is it. Very friendly inside and always fresh. The pizzas are all absolutely delicious and they have such an interesting variety of slices. I really love the traditional triangle slices and the square ones too and the pizza and crust itself is phenomenal! Will be returning over and over again:) read more

Mama's Roxbury - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

See all

Amazing dough! honestly the best pizza flavor and texture in at least a 15 mile radius, at least that's how far we came for this pizza on Christmas eve. There's music playing and the atmosphere feels like you stepped into a Brooklyn, Italian restaurant. The food came really quick and our server dropped off the salad within minutes of us sitting down. We also ordered the chicken parm but with vodka sauce and damn was that pasta perfectly al dente. The sauce was the perfect balance of creaminess and umami. Sprinkle a little crushed red pepper and you have the best vodka sauce on this side of jersey. We will definitely be coming back for more pizza, pasta, pizza, and more pizza. read more

Mama's Roxbury - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

Over the top friendliness and quality. Recommend the mama pie, might be grandmas pie, I can't remember. Bathroom was small but clean. Eating area was small but clean. It was amazing how much business this place did while we were there. Parkings a little tight too. read more

It's @BigDudesBigFoods first time at @MamasPizzeria_NJ Time to support another small business. We stopped for some Friday slices , which were Dee-licious!!! Joe had a stuffed meat and a pepperoni with hot honey . I had a spinach/artichoke and a mango habernero . Yum! It's literally a stone's throw away from work. We will definitely be back!!! The crew and owner were friendly and helpful. It's a cleaned up version of what was there in the past with a couple of booths to sit in. I love the wall of pics of celebrities eating pizza. #BigDudesBigFoods #SupportSmallBusiness #BDBFCertified #BDBF read more

See all

Excellent pizza, by far best in the area. A large pizza is like an XL. You absolutely get what you pay for. Very delicious ingredients and it truly tastes like Brooklyn style pizza. Wonderful and very generous owner. Wish them nothing but the best. read more

Delicious grandma's slices! The owner and staff are very friendly, great service! Will be going back for sure.

I went for the first time today and got a grilled chicken Caesar wrap and a slice of grandma pizza. The grandma slice was made perfectly (crust, sauce, and cheese all) and it was authentic Brooklyn style. I inhaled the slice! The Caesar wrap was also perfect all around. I could tell the chicken was high quality and was cooked fresh and not reheated. As a bonus the owner and the staff were extremely friendly! I will be going back. read more

Best pizza around !!! Friendly workers , cute place . Go try it you won't be disappointed.

5 star excellent, great quality. We can't wait to go back. Thank you yummy .salad perfect, eggplant delicious. Large portions and fresh read more

Is it good? Yes. But the prices they charge for pizza are much higher than anyplace around here and I don't think it's worth it. I got three pizzas and it cost over $70. And btw if you order online, they charge a 7 percent online convenience fee so call it in I guess. read more

Amazing Pizza from Mama's. Plain Cheese was cooked to perfection. Sauce, Cheese, and Crust are top notch. A 9.6 in my book! The Bee Sting is amazing as well. Thank god they are local but I would drive an hour away for this pizza. read more

Mama's Roxbury - Mama's Pizza with homemade sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Pecorino Romano Cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Succasunna, New Jersey

Real good pizza. I've gotten a few different pies and enjoyed them all. Brought a drunken pie to Cornhole and the boys loved it. Best in Roxbury. read more

Friendly service amazing food. Always greeted pleasantly. I've tried a lot so far. They do not disappoint. Garlic knots are the best around. My favorite slice is the buffalo chicken. read more

This place has the absolute best pizza I have ever had. Forget the ambiance, it's a pizzeria, very clean and nice. Excellent service, friendly atmosphere. I come weekly. read more

Nice people, great food! Love this place. Definitely the best pizza in this area and everything else is yummy too!

Tried their pizza for the 1st time and it was pretty good. Definitely we will be ordering again. read more

See all

normally the food is good but today eggplant parm dinner had hardly any eggplant and a ton of uncooked spaghetti. Hardly any sauce and sauce did not taste good same with the chicken parm. read more

Dined in for a Mama's Specialty Square 16" special order. Peppers, onions, and sausage. Thin square pizza! Absolutely an excellent Brooklyn experience right here in NJ!! Owner is a Brooklyn native and delivers an excellent selection of pizzas. read more

See all

We recently did a review of Mama's pizzeria giving it great marks but had to do another review today. As usual, we stopped and picked up a variety of slices to enjoy a couple of our favorites and try some different things. One of the new slices they had was a Chicken Caesar Salad slice. We've had this at other pizzerias and enjoyed it, but this one was absolutely outstanding. So if you're in the area and looking for the best salad and pizza combo, you'll probably have anywhere around, give it a try. J & E - Landing read more

Best real Pizza around 10 out of 10 real cheese real sauce real crust real dough so happy they brought Brooklyn ingredients to this town read more

See all

The Brooklyn MVP pizza is awesome! Also have had the Bada Bing hero and it's delicious, lots of broccoli rabe.

Great food. I had meatball parm sandwich. Plenty of meatball. Husband had sausage w/ peppers &onions. Plenty of all. Pizza is always great too. read more

Great Brooklyn style pizza! Their mvp pizza and upside down pizza are not like anything in the area. The owner is friendly and always says hello no matter how busy they are. read more

My daughter and I came here for dinner on Mother's Day! I think the Pizza is among the best I've had in years!! The atmosphere is friendly and the people are super friendly!! 5 stars easy for Mamma's !! read more

We had a plain and a sausage pie they are the best pies in our area cooked perfectly. Can't wait to try some of their specialty pies.

Plain guy was so good and I don't normally order plain but wanted to try the place first. I devoured it and will def go back. Owners are from NY so I think they know a little bit about pizza read more

See all