Standing by itself surrounded by an immense parking area, Casa is housed in an historic building which goes back decades. Inside it is a different time: exposed beams harken back to another age. Service is very friendly without being overbearing, and the food is superb. We ordered mussels marinara -- remarkably large and tasty . Our entrees were delicious and large portions. The food is traditional but not boring, combining the well known with a modern twist. Clearly many people there were repeat customers, and it is easy to understand why. Definitely a place to return to. Recommended. read more

Casa De Pasta - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Came here on Saturday for a nice dinner, very surprised my wife never ate here before despite passing it for most of her life. Food: we ended up going with a Bavarian pretzel as an appetizer which was an awesome decision, but super filling. I ordered the stuffed shells and my wife got an eggplant dish which were both superb. Aesthetic: deceivingly nice, both small looking but seats a lot of people, and cool bar set up. Service: even though we were thrown in the side room, our waitress was quick to help us out once she realized that we were seated back there. Really good teamwork between all of the waitresses. read more

See all

We enjoy this restaurant often. On our most recent visit the food was superb and the service was amazing. The ambiance caused my score to lower based on the bullet hole in the window where our table was located... while I didn't expect a drive by shooting, it did make me feel uneasy. read more

Nice food, large portions, friendly service, nice selection of drinks. The place is old style restaurant read more

See all

I have lived in the area for almost my entire life, and for whatever reason, this was my first time dining at Casa de Pasta! And now I regret not going sooner. The eggplant alla casa is a dish I would definitely order again. It was eggplant rollantinni style, but the eggplant was stuffed with sausage, spinach and cheese. The servers were all very nice, especially the hostess, and I loved the cozy feel. read more

Casa De Pasta - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

As others have said, it's a quaint place that has not been updated probably since it's been open in 1983 but that's what gives it its charm. Multiple waitress waited on our table. I liked the team effort. 4% credit card fee. Extra charge for blue cheese dressing. Food was decent. We got mozzarella sticks as an appetizer, they're not homemade but are of the higher end of brought mozzarella sticks. Chicken parm was two big pieces of chicken, just wish there was more cheese. Side of penne vodka was good and my husband enjoyed his tortellini Alfredo. read more

See all

The following describes a first-hand experience as a customer of the business as per Yelp's Content Guidelines: My friends and I went to the Greek Festival in Randolph this weekend--a packed community event full of families, kids, and locals just trying to enjoy themselves. Parking was tight, as expected. After seeing a steady flow of people crossing from Casa de Pasta, we figured that must be the overflow spot and parked there like everyone else. We had no idea we were walking into a setup. As my friends and I quickly walked along the shoulder of a busy road--unaware that officers were having to actively guide pedestrians who had fallen victim to what we later learned was Casa de Pasta's parking scam--a man standing in the restaurant's lot began yelling at us while we were inches from high-speed traffic. One of the officers was calling out to us, actively trying to stop traffic and reduce the danger that the Casa de Pasta employee was making worse with his behavior. It was clear the officer was doing everything he could to keep us safe--something the man yelling at us clearly wasn't concerned with. We didn't see any signs and had no idea there was a fee. Just a guy screaming at pedestrians for not paying a charge we didn't even know existed. This wasn't just pathetic--it was dangerous. That man knowingly created a traffic hazard over pocket change. My friends and I could've been seriously hurt. Other festival-goers told us this happens every year--it's a full-on scam, especially considering the church lot had free parking available all along. Let me be clear: it's a free country--charging for parking is their right. But when that matters more than public safety, it says everything. Casa de Pasta seemed more focused on making a quick buck than offering good food or a good experience. As a former customer, I will never give business to this establishment, and I strongly encourage others to think twice before supporting a business that prioritizes $10 or $15 over human safety. read more

We love Casa de Pasta! We've been going there for years. The food is always delicious and the service is consistently great. A nice welcoming place to eat. Highly recommend! read more

I brought the family here last weekend and definitely enjoyed our experience. We were greeted promptly and seated. Our waitress was attentive snd worked hard for us. The inside is rustic and cozy but clean and organized. Everyone including our kids were happy with our meal. I got the chicken parm with vodka penne on the side. Both very good. This was our second time here and would return. The bartender even came over to see if I liked my drink! read more

Casa De Pasta - Variation on the espresso martini - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Hands down my favorite place to get vodka sauce! I tried to recreate the sauce and tried so many other places and nothing beats their sauce! Rigatoni zingara is also a must! One of my favorites. Other favorites: Zuppa do clams, eggplant rolatini, chicken Marsala, any of the veal or chicken parm subs! read more

See all

It's been a few years since we ate at Casa De Pasta and nothing has really changed. That's not a bad thing though, this is a cozy little restaurant that's been in Randolph since 1983. The decor is rustic with a nice bar that unfortunately can't be used in these Covid-19 days. The food is NJ solid Italian, not spectacular but no complaints. I went with the Eggplant alla Casa which is similar to rollatini but stuffed with spinach and sausage. My wife had Veal Francese and my stepson had Shrimp Scampi. The meals were served with a side salad and pasta. My wife thought the veal should have had a vegetable with it and it probably should have. All in all, this was a nice meal at a friendly, local place! read more

Casa De Pasta - Randolph classic! - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

I have been coming here for years it's great local Italian for me. The food is really good

Great place with good food. Treat yourself to a good Italian dinner. Life's short !!!

Food is good. Service is great very friendly atmosphere but you can't depend on this place to be open. When his dad was alive it was open 6 days a week. Now it only open Thursday thru Sunday and they close on Sundays at least twice a month supposedly because of a shortage of help. Who would want to work at a place that's only open 4 hours a night 3 or 4 days a week. How can anyone live on that? read more

See all

This place is fantastic. The ambiance is rustic tavern with amazing original wood beams. The eggplant rollitini was delicious and everyone else agreed theirs was delicious too. Service was great with Celia giving great attention to our every need. Highly recommend it! read more

Greta homey feel for some classic American Italian dishes. I went here growing up and it is super nostalgic for me. Service and food are consistently good. Nice family place read more

All of my experiences here have been decent but tonight was extremely disappointing. I called and placed a pick up order for one item at 6:30. I was told it would take about 30 minutes and arrived at 7 PM. When I asked for my food, I was told the order was never put in and that they were "short staffed." Even if you don't have enough staff, how does that affect submitting a meal? I needed to wait another 15 minutes. Rather than comp the meal, I was given 10 percent off (less than $3) with an apology. That was my last trip here. Very disappointing. read more

Casa De Pasta - Cavatelli with Broccoli with shrimp - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

This place looks more like a tavern than an italian place. They have a bar, booths, and a back dining room. Be careful because if you drive too fast you will miss it. It was empty on a saturday around lunch time but we came. I knew when I walked in I knew I wasn't going to have 5 star food but I held out hope for something close. We started with the calamari and it tasted like any other calamari I have had. The marinara sauce that came with it had some flavor but not my favorite sauce. The salt content seemed to be the common theme at this restaurant. Either there was too much of it or not enough. I tried the chicken sorrentino which had too much salt. I felt very bloated after. The eggplant rollatini had way too much ricotta in it so it was overwhelming and drowned out the flavor of the eggplant. The service was good and the staff overall seemed very nice. In the end, they gave it a shot but I put it at 3 stars. read more

See all

Most reviews about this establishment are written from the perspective of a long-time townie/local. I'll offer something different. From the outside, the quaint architecture and name suggest a low-key and friendly dining experience. On these points they deliver. Unfortunately, there's little else I was able to recommend during my dining experience. We decided to spend a considerable amount of our COVID risk budget on eating out here, and the first thing we noticed was a prominently posted sign announcing management will openly and flagrantly disregard any and all institutionally-recommended COVID precautions. They even cite the popular social media conspiracy theory of not being able to to ask you about your health conditions because of HIPAA, which is irrelevant because they're a restaurant and not a Covered Entity under that law. It was all we could do not to turn around immediately, but with two small children, we felt committed and the area has a high vaccination rate. Onto the dining experience. Another sign openly warns diners to set their expectations low due to a shortage of labor. While we didn't experience any dearth of service, the perpetual help wanted sign out front suggests they're unwilling to confront the reality of increased wages. One sign among many (including significantly reduced operating hours) that the restaurant is run by those whose heart isn't in it anymore. The food's quality is precisely one notch above Olive Garden. The proportion of sauce to noodle in my linguini primavera left it a swimming pool. Flavor on the bland side, but I've had worse. Any number of other locally owned New Jersey Italian places would deliver a better plate. Decor hasn't been updated in 30 years. Old enough to convey neglect but not old enough to pass back into retro chic. The lighting is strongly tinted and poor quality. You'll feel like you're a Batman villain's hideout. All that being said, they staff were friendly and accommodating, even with our small children. At the end of the day, this place needs to be put out of its misery and the owners need to retire to Florida. read more

Wow!!! I can't even express how DELICIOUS this food was--- The food was just absolutely AMAZING!!! I was craving for some pasta so my boyfriend told me about " Casa De Pasta " since he delivers to them. We drove an hour and 15 min to eat there!! Let me tell you that it def was up to my expectations!! I would drive to Casa De Pasta everyday if I had to, just to eat there--That's how GREAT it was!! The service was great! I honestly forgot our servers name but she was good And very nice! Thanks Matt for a great experience!! We will be back soon! read more

Casa De Pasta - Bruschetta - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Yesterday my family ate at casa de pasta and the food was okay. Our server was very nice and the place looks like a tavern that serves Italian food. Each meal comes with a salad and bread. read more

My family came here for my 30th wedding anniversary because we wanted to try a different casual Italian place and the reviews were decent. We got a late start because my poor wife had a root canal and we had to wait until the numbness was gone. They advertised being open until 11, but when we got there at 9:15 the hostess had to check if the kitchen was still serving. Honestly, I'm not sure why anyone gave it a rave review because it needs work on every level. First, the decor is old and the booth cushions were worn out, so sitting was uncomfortable. The trim around the booth was dirty and I felt like I didn't want to touch anything. We sat about 10 minutes before the less-than-enthusiastic waitress even came over with our menus, but gladly the bread was served immediately. Their selection was old school NJ Italian, which is fine. We ordered spaghetti with meatballs, sausage, Caesar salad, stuffed shells, chicken francese, and the dinners came with dinner salad and a penne with marinara. Some things were good, the blue cheese salad dressing, sausage and the chicken. The marinara was fine. The salads were very small and blah. The pasta was ok. The loaves of bread were hit or miss as a few were stale or overbaked. My wife found a fairly large piece of bone in the meatball which was probably just the meat supplier's fault. We basically felt rushed and that the food was not commensurate with the high prices. There are places closer to us for less and a more enjoyable experience. For closer locals, it might be more worth it. read more

food is amazing!! Shame the staff is so rude!!!!!!! only four stars for the food because the blonde bartender is rude!!!!!!!!!!! Horrible customer service! read more

Ahhh. Casa. I cannot day enough positive things about this place. I've never had a bad meal, bad service, or bad atmosphere. It's a family owned Italian restaurant where everything tastes homemade, even if it isn't. It's one of those places that has it's share of regulars who are like family, but also welcomes newbies with ease. I've lived in town for 30 years and have probably come here specifically for my birthday since we first discovered in almost 30 years ago. Family favorite. Recommend the Rigatoni Zingara, Shrimp Scampi, Zuppa de Clams, and Tiramisu read more

I popped in here on a whim with my friend and I am so glad that I did! GORGEOUS building. The moment you walk in it feels so homey. The food is so tasty! The calamari and the antipasto are both delicious. And the pasta reminds me of my mother's. But my favorite thing by far is the cheesecake. When we went they had a Valentine's day special: Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Cheesecake. Y'all...it was incredible. The lightest, fluffiest little piece of heaven on a plate you've ever had. Our lovely waitress told us that sometimes people actually call ahead to make sure that they have the cheesecake available. After trying it, I don't doubt it for a second. Lovely place, lovely place, lovely food. What more could you ask for? read more

A favorite from day 1 Great dishes and a nice ambiance. Bar area is great with really good snacks! read more

Run don't walk to this restaurant! Been here before and I want to tell that the food still great! The interior is rustic with hand made wooden beams across the ceiling. We had the rolled eggplant stuffed with sausage smothered with melted mozzarella and rigatoni zangarra with mushrooms hot cherry peppers, prosciutto with lots of fresh sliced garlic! YUM! We will be back again! read more

Casa De Pasta - The sausage stuffed eggplant! - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

This place just cares about there money. Puts out coupons that say dine in only. When asked to use for take out they say no. There's no dine in here for quite a while if they stay in business. Stuck with the coupon I paid $15 for. Food is average at best. Better places to eat in the area. I'll throw out the coupon before spending $100 or more here. read more

Came here for diner with some friends. Plenty of parking and a bit small inside, but cozy! We all had a great time here. Our waitress was so kind and great to interact with. We ordered mozzarella sticks and calamari as an appetizer. Sticks were excellent, but not a fan of calamari; never was. I ordered chicken francese as my meal over cappellini. The chicken was a little bit dry but the sauce really made the dish. They make a great lemon sauce. read more

You wouldn't think it from the outside, but this place is so cute and rustic inside! I had the eggplant rollatini with the crumbled sausage and spinach ricotta stuffing, it was delicious! We had the pumpkin walnut cheesecake for dessert...amazing! The Chanti wine and pasta side dish were just ok. The waitress was ok; did not offer to read us the specials or even state her name (rude, especially since I overheard her telling the next table the specials). Overall though a good experience. Nice atmosphere really good food. Would come back. read more

See all

I have been going there for over 20 years, but haven't been there in the last couple of years.. What a disappointment!! They are short staffed and took an hour for us to get our dinner.. The food was cold and WAY over priced, and it was cold inside.. Its not that cozy atmosphere with the great food anymore.. Too bad, I used to love that place.. read more

A most wonderful place to eat & drink!! They have all kinds of Italian specialties, Shrimp Matteo, veal Patricia, Lobster Franchese . Old favourites egg plant Parma , what ever you desire! The staff works very hard to please!! read more

Casa De Pasta - Took @ my birthday party:)) - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

I will give it a 2 star because I tried the restaurant for the first time and they served my family with respect,but I will not recommend it to my friends or family. On Saturday they had a nice crowd,so obviously people like going there to eat. Rosie's Trattoria really have great Italian food.I am sorry for the bad review. read more

I have been coming to Casa for well over 30 years. They have updated the decor yet still maintains its ambiance. My dad always ordered the Capellini DiAngelo. It was his favorite meal. I am thrilled to see it on the menu after all these years. My two favorites are the Country Chicken and the Veal Patricia. I waffle between the two when I visit. Wine is poured in full glasses which is a plus. The food is delicious and fresh. It is a small place but that adds to its ambiance. read more

Really, really good hearty Italian. We have been looking for another local spot to get our grub on and this place aced it. We had an app and two separate dishes with sausage and meatballs in the side. Everything was phenomenal. We liked that the marinara was not the same in every dish as it sometimes is at other spots. The service was very friendly and attentive. I had gone here many years ago with friends and liked it, so finally remembered it when we were having the usual "no you pick the restaurant" debate. It was just really good. Thankfully I didn't read the recent reviews or I may not have gone. However, something might have changed in past 5 months since the less than stellar reviews were left. Oh and the bill was a nice surprise, less than $50. That is very unusual for us to have an app and two meals and walk out paying less than $60! read more

Just moved into the area 6 months ago. I've been there 3x. Sat at bar all 3 times and had dinner twice. Barmaid Denise was friendly and attentive. It's an older crowd which matches the decor. The place could be spuced up a bit. The food is average at best. What shocked me was when I got home, I looked at my itemized receipt and noticed that a Tito's Martini cost $13.50..... that's not all, they charge $1 extra for EACH Blue Cheese stuffed olive!! Are you kidding? There are many more places to go nearby that are much more high end with better food and martinis are the same price or less. Other places won't change you $1 per olive! It's so petty and insulting considering the shape of Casa de Pasta.... I'm outta here. read more

Have lived in Roxybury for awhile and finally went! Good food, nice dining area and friendly staff. They also have a bar with a couple TVs not sure why we waited so long! read more

Food was pretty bland. I ordered vodka sauce, I was not expecting mushrooms in the sauce which was weird. Lacked that creamy smooth taste which I'm use too. I would try this place again and hopefully remember to say no mushrooms since everything had them read more

We went to Casa De Pasta last night, and it was A-OK. First off, the parking is massive, you can park 10 - 18-wheelers there without issue. It is almost formatted like a "Roadhouse". The place was packed, hmm... must be why they have such a large parking lot. We waited for a bit (as they do not allow reservations), and then got a seat at the bar. Tony (behind the bar) was super busy maintaining the patrons, and he did get our orders and drinks quick enough, and we ended up having a good time just sitting at the bar. The food is good, very home style, and they customize it how you want it. I had the chicken francaise with angel hair pasta. It was very good, and the portions large. It was done just right. I think the things that are not working for this place is that it is extremely full, and that business (although it does not take away from quality) adds to the wait time to get things. Sometimes just getting the attention of staff is difficult - but don't take it personally - they are just very busy. I would recommend this place again, and I give it 3 stars. read more

We needed to cater for my mom's birthday and so I called Casa. Very glad I did full tray of eggplant rolatini full tray sausage and peppers. Half tray of stuffed mushrooms and half tray of stuffed shells. And a full tray of salad. Food was great. Everyone was happy. Thank you for helping to make it a great day read more