Our neighbors raved about Pizza Pub so we decided to try them out and have done so a handful of times. Unfortunately every single time since the first time had been a disappointment. First time I ordered pasta fagioli, and it was good. I eat meat and veg and it seemed to lean veg and was white. No meat in it. I also ordered the eggplant rollatini app and it was good, no complaints. Second time we ordered (like, two days later maybe?) I ordered the soup again and it was completely different with tons of smoked bacon in it and was tomato based. Whoever my husband spoke to over the phone denied the soup was different. Garlic knots are disappointing because they're made with granulated garlic instead of actual minced fresh garlic. Anyway, last night we ordered and I ordered the pasta primavera with light marinara and they gave me bland cream sauce instead. Shame on me, but we're done ordering here. read more

The Pizza Pub is a fabulous bar & restaurant . The food is delicious, best pizza, and the menu is huge, many more options than just Italian. Portions are large & the desserts are spectacular. Full super friendly bar reminiscent of "Cheers" where everyone knows your name. Very child friendly, take out can include beer & wine. Well lit parking lot, large outside dining weather permitting, handicap ramp, first floor bathrooms! Very reasonable. My favorite place! Go and enjoy!!! read more

I am officially done with this place. We used to go there ALL the time for at least 15 years "back in the day." It was comfortable, friendly, decent food and prices. That was years ago when the kids were young. We had a lousy experience with the food about a year ago but figured let's give it another shot for old times' sake. MISTAKE. 1- Ordered a large pie 1/2 meatball and 1/2 plain- What we got was all meatball. 2- Ordered fried calamari for, I believe, $14. It was worth $0 and we threw it in the garbage where it belonged. The calamari was barely cooked and obviously barely warm. A rip off!!! 3- Placed the order on the phone and was told it would be ready at 6. Foolishly, I arrived at 6 and ended up standing around until 6:15 plus. And the dining room had 2-3 tables occupied and maybe 2 people came in after me- meaning they were not very busy (rightfully so). Simply tell me my order would be ready at "whatever" time. All in all there are a plethora of pizza places in Randolph from which to choose and zero reason to get ripped off with lousy calamari and a wrong order. read more

Great dinner with family tonight! No wonder it was so busy here. The Christmas cookie martini was so yummy and festive! read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Christmas Cookie Martini - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

I placed a pick up order and came at the time it was supposed to be ready. I still had to wait a long time but after getting my food I realized it took so long because they had to make sure it was PERFECT. Absolutely delicious every time I go. There's a reason they're so busy! read more

Causal pizza restaurant but not like your typical pizzeria. It's located in an old house. Friendly staff. Pizza is some of the best in the area! The fettuccine carbonara is also one of their best pasta dishes! Also able to get packaged goods to go. Full bar as well. read more

See all

I went today with care giver the food was good after two years I didn't came there . The owner is very nice and friendly maybe I will stop by again. Bring you more customers. Hopefully you liked this review. Thank you to Serve me today. You were nice. Maybe seeing more In the summer. read more

Go to the Pizza; Pub! JP has anything that you want covered. I eat here multiple times a week and feel I couldn't do better. If I were rich, I would eat at Pizza Pub every single day. read more

Stopped here between Denville and Long Valley for a pizza and beer. The Pizza Pub was a welcome surprise! Cozy welcoming bar with full menu, great service and good company. The Country Pizza was a win-- the (well done as requested) crust stood up to the sauteed onions and peppers, thinly sliced sausage and pepperoni, and mushrooms. We returned a couple weeks later and enjoyed Round 2 of the same. Will definitely patronize them going forward! read more

It was a great surprise the experience we had at Pizza Pub. We were looking for a place to have a bite and decided to give a try to Pizza Pub. Honestly, given the reviews, I wasn't expecting much. But, thankfully, I was wrong! We had a great experience from the minute we stepped in. The waitress was super nice, doing a lot of things at the same time (taking orders, drinks, serving food) always with a smile on her face and super fast. My husband and I had a personal pizza each and it was great. The dough was super crispy and delicious. It's well served but depending on how hungry you are, you can share. I'd definitely recommend this place!!! read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Personal Pizza - pepperoni, meatballs and onions - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

I had dinner with my family tonight for the last time. The service was ridiculously slow,Mind you the waitress had one other table and the place was empty. The food was tasteless in addition to relieving undercooked chicken wings. The waitress never checked on us to ask if everything was OK. Everything about the experience was a bust. Do not recommend!! read more

Five months into this pandemic, with still no indoor seating, we've been trying to order from as many different local restaurants as possible. Last night, we ordered from Pizza Pub for the first time. Our dinners were very good. My wife ordered the Veal Milanese Salad and I had the Rigatoni Abruzzi dinner. Both were very tasty and delivered nice and hot! It's been a few years since we ate at the restaurant. When we did, they gave complimentary zeppoles. That was the only thing missing from this dinner. read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Rigatoni Abruzzi! - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

See all

Many Thanks to Chef‍ Mike G @the_pizza_pub_in_randolph for creating this giant #HolyStromboli for #BigDudesBigFoods Unlike some of our other posts, the "Holy Stromboli" is ON the menu. They are "overstuffed" and meant to be shared but not today. Its about the size of you arm, not MY arm but YOUR arm. You can't go wrong when they will stuff it with whatever you want, if they have it. Don't forget the sauce to dip in #OnTheSide We finished this one ! #WeWillBeBack #shenanigans read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - The "HolyStromboli" @PizzaPub in Ironia,NJ - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

Margarita pizza was excellent, nice thin crust and very crispy! Great place to go, would highly recommend.

Was here last night and the food was terrible. We started with the fried ravioli that tasted like they just came out of the freezer. I ordered the baked stuffed shells. The dish came out luke warm and the melted mozz on top was like cutting through plastic. I think my dish was sitting out on a shelf somewhere for a few hours. My friend ordered a chicken dish, I think it was marsala. Well they served it in a bowl and was really hard to eat and the sauce was really dark and unappetizing looking. His side of pasta, that he had to pay extra for was all clumped together in a really thick tomato sauce. It was like eating a blob of glue. The service on the other hand was good and our waiter was very accommodating. I give the food a zero and the waiter an 8. read more

Nice causual eatery for pizza and other dishes. A lot of locals and families great place for a mellow dinner. Food has always been good. Nice small bar too if your looking for a drink read more

Ordered a calzone and garlic shrimp thru slice. Calzone was well cooked, crispy and tasty. The spicy garlic shrimp was also very good. Will definitely order again. The seafood pizza looked good read more

Had lunch here today, our normal crowd of 6. Service was great. two of us had the corned beef lunch special, it was terrible dry and tasteless. I would not recommend this dish to anyone Side note under previous owners this used to be such a great dish we would come 2-3 x the week before st patty's day just for this meal Everyone else was satisfied with their meals Just stay away from corned beef dinner read more

I cannot rave enough about this restaurant! My husband and 5-yo twin girls came here today and had such a wonderful experience! We were greeted by Gino, who, btw, is just the NICEST. PERSON. EVER. He provided such prompt and personal service. The food was great! Our pizza was tasty and well received by our girls, two very picky divas. The calamari we ordered was crispy and fresh, and our garlic knots were out of this world! I would highly recommend this place to families and pizza lovers. We will definitely come back! read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Small dining area which sits about 50 people. Intimate, yet spacious. - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

First time to the pizza pub. I ordered the penne with the vodka sauce prosciutto and shrimp. It was tasty however, it was overloaded with the sauce. My husband got the chicken Parm. And it was good old fashion, pizzeria, chicken Parm. The staff was very nice. read more

Pleasantly surprised how good the seafood pizza was. I was skeptical but it worked real well. Want again fer shure!! read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

See all

I attended a party yesterday that was catered by The Pizza Pub. The food was wonderful. The service was exceptional. We had a guest that required a special diet (they were unaware of this prior to the party) and they were extremely accommodating. The variety offered was appreciated by all. (although some of us tried it all). We were very impressed. read more

Great local place--seemed to be some regulars. First time there today. Yummy buffalo wings and the grandma's margherita pizza was super delicious. Matisse was our server and she was a sweetheart. I think we met the new owner and he seemed like a nice guy. We might become regulars too. read more

I ordered pizza for take out here several times. There is a restaurant, bar and take out area. The pizza come out good. No complaints for what I would expect from a local pizzeria. read more

Gonna take a pass moving forward. It's under new management. Young people who have a difficult time with guest management & out right manners. It's this generation. Yeah, nah, uh uh, etc, etc. Sure do miss Gino & the former Barn owners. My family wants to love this place but cannot any longer. read more

They have nice food and great customer service. The variety of pizza on offer is great

We had our soccer party here last night. The waiters were very helpful. The service was excellent and the pizza was delicious. I have never been to this place before and I will definitely come back. read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

Meh. I was in the neighborhood and wanted to grab a quick bite. Service took forever, I think the guy taking orders and serving may have been the owner (he was also working the bar). I ordered the Tuscan panini and it was ok, nothing to write home about. Although when I started on the second half of my sandwich I ended up putting it down and not eating it because the texture of the chicken was really off. It was kind of rubbery, not what you expect chicken to taste like. Prices were fine, service was less than stellar (and this was on a Saturday afternoon) and food wasn't great. This is a one and done for me. read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - The Tuscan panini - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

So for a long time my wife has been wanting me to taste this pizza but it just never happened as it's close to her work but not to where we live or I usually am. I'm hindsight that is great as I won't ever go back as I need gluten free pizza so they made me a nice gluten free pizza and then put breaded eggplant on it which defeats the purpose of having a gf pizza and will nicely make me sick. Not going back and stay with our local pizza places who understand the concept gluten free read more

We just recently moved to the area and this has fast become our pizza spot. We even brag about having the best pizza right down the road from us and keep telling friends and family they have to try it. It's hard to describe exactly why it's so good, but I'd definitely start with saying it's the dough. We often order the specialty pies and they are just the best. All of them full of flavor. read more

Today's order of 2 pizzas, penne vodka and mozzarella sticks was awful! The pizza was doughy and flavorless, the Penne had practically no Vodka sauce, and the mozzarella sticks were just OK. Considering we paid extra to have Door Dash bring the food direct to our location we were surprised the food was ice cold. I know when the Dasher left and I know the Dasher was onsite waiting. Pizza Pub did something that made the food was sit around. I can excuse the food being cold to a certain extent, but the quality was just atrocious. I have had good food from this place too, but anytime you order on a Friday the food just plain sucks. This is the last time I order from this place. What a waste of $$$. read more

Ordered from them last night, pizza and eggplant parm. Both were very good and nice and hot when I picked up.

took 1 hour and 30 minutes to get our food. the chefs were talking and not making our food. the food was served cold and was being tried to hid by microwaving it. read more

We love this place. I take my 2 young kids there before the lunch crowd. The best waitress Mastisse always takes care of us and is so sweet and nice to the kids. My kids love this pizza and always ask for me to take them here. Also they have ice cream and beer/wine to go in the front. read more

Food is very good and very reasonable. I had the antipasto salad and bruschetta. The only issue was the bruschetta was served with pizza dough bread rather than toasted Italian bread and you had to attempt to construct your bruschetta yourself read more

Happy to say the new operators have cleaned the place up! Nice job and keep up the good work awesome turn around!! n read more

Food is very good. I was able to receive delivery to Mendham Boro through a delivery app and will definitely order from them again.

The pizza was very good. Definitely New York style with a sweeter sauce. I enjoyed it. Also ordered the chicken parmigiana sub. Again it was very good. They also have a large selection of beer and wine available which isn't the norm with the Jersey liquor licenses. The chef spent a minute talking with me and was very friendly. Food came out quick. I highly recommend. read more

The Pizza Pub Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Ironia, New Jersey

Great place to go for a fabulous casual Italian meal without a fabulous price tag. The owner is friendly, extremely accommodating. You don't want fries with your fish and chips? You can have the sauteed spinach you want instead. Never had a bad meal, but have some fav's there- the fish and chips, the eggplant rollatini, (to die for), and all the soups and sides of sauteed spinach, etc., are awesome, there is actually tons of roasted garlic in there. The fra diavolo is incredible, more seafood than you can eat at once, and it's all good. The zuppa de pesce is my hubby's fav, loves it. He is also really into the eggplant parm, which I also love. And they have whole wheat pasta, so I don't feel so guilty. Not only is the food quality, it is quantity. DH and I always have a lunch or so from our leftovers. DH says we need to order extra dinners as we leave for days we can't/don't want to cook, but no worries. the Pizza Pub allows you to order online and pick up or have it delivered. I do take advantage of this service more than I care to admit to. The garlic knots are awesome, need to steal the recipe. The specials I have tried have always been fabulous, and the kitchen never has an issue with my food issues (allergies & veg). I sometimes have lunch delivered to our home office, and I make special requests. I am every restaurant owners nightmare- allergies, no salt, extra lettuce/tomatoes/peppers/cucumbers on sandwiches/salads. Never an issue, Gino the owner is awesome. Not enough good things I can say about the Pizza Pub, other than keep up the great job, and we'll keep coming! Or ordering delivery. read more

Definitely a mom & pop type feel to this restaurant. I ordered a sausage, mushroom, and pepperoni pizza and it was decent - being from the New Jersey/New York area finding that 'to die for' pizza can be hard. We also ordered baked ziti and I personally did not like how it tasted. It was almost a little too salty. The pizza was large enough to share though, perfect for family or friendly outings. They also serve alcohol! read more