Stopped in for a quick slice of pizza. Had no clue it would be so amazing. I highly recommend the natural gourmet! Fresh, hot and delicious pizza. Fast service! read more

Pretty good! The best beach pizza that I've had in a while. Lots of great by the slice options. Perfect for an indecisive group! Friendly staff. We were here in the off season and it was still pretty busy. Bonus points for perfectly clean bathrooms! If I had one complaint... they had soccer and women's volleyball on the two televisions on an autumn Sunday Funday. Where's the football?! read more

Just discovered this spot. The natural gourmet pizza is now my favorite pizza of all time! Thin flavorful crust, fresh mozzarella and basil and an awesome tomato sauce! I would eat there every day! read more

These people are rude as hell. Pizza is pretty meh, though what you would expect. Mall quality.

My fiancé and I were having trouble finding places to eat in Nags Head, but we came across this little joint. We come from a beach town ourselves, so we try to avoid all touristy restaurants. However, this felt so genuine and laid back. The service was prompt, and the pizza was amazing! Between the two of us, we got three pizza slices and a salad. It was all well-worth the value! The only complaint I have is the little amount of seating space available. However, they still try to accommodate this by providing seating outside. Overall, it was a great experience and we'll be back! read more

Pizza was ready when they said it would be for carry out. 1 medium cheese and 1 medium pepperoni. Both had slightly burned crust :(. Went to pay and they didn't accept American Express as a form of payment. Had to dig through my wallet and find my business check card that luckily I had with me. I won't be back as they don't except the main form of payment I carry also the pizza was not the best. read more

I moved down here from NJ and finding good pizza was hard to come by. We tried a few places in the area and they were okay, but nothing special, until we tried Slice. I love the variety of pizzas to choose from and their sauce is on point. The grandma pie is one of my favorites, but to be honest, there is anything I've tried that I didn't like. By far the best pizza we've found! read more

Excellent Chicago deep dish!! Great tea (Gold Peak) for being mixed in a machine. Delicious crust and cheese!

Their Margherita pizza with tomato basil and fresh mozzarella is Amazing!! wow, I still can hardly believe it. Their Chicago pizzas are also very, very good. Both were ordered by the slice. Their crusts are so light and crispy. Very decent prices for the area, and well worth it. read more

Really good pizza by the slice or whole pie.

Man! This place right here has AMAZING pizza. Lots of different pizzas to choose from. Great price and fast service. Love it

All I have to say is if you like New York style pizza go here! The hoagies are also great. Everything is good to eat at this place.. Also, they have $1 slice Mondays :) read more

Chicago style pepperoni is excellent. Tastes a bit like Pizza Hut however. Nice outdoor eating space for a strip mall.

Still searching for great pizza delivery in the OBX! We just hate to order chain pizza while vacationing, so we tried Slice Pizzeria because of it's yelp rating. This pizza was just okay. It wasn't the worst I've ever had, but certainly not the best and definitely not traditional New York style pizza. The flavors were good, but the crust was too chewy...sort of like cardboard. The delivery was timely, although the driver was clearly in a huge hurry as he peeled out of our driveway and squealed his tires down the road. We'll keep looking for our favorite beach pizza. read more

We have been here a few times now & it's pretty much our favorite pizza! I only wish the inside seating area was larger. Good beer too!

Visiting OBX with the family and decided on pizza for dinner. They have a nice variety and the taste is great. Being used to NY pizza, we are always nervous about what we might get while traveling. We were pleasantly surprised. Additionally, service was very good, everyone was friendly and helpful. The pizza was ready fast and the price was reasonable for a tourist area. Would definitely return. read more

Excellent Supreme pizza. small dining area so dining in may be hard. However, don't let that stop you from getting one of the best in OBX.

Pros: good crust and sauce Cons: $7 ceaser salad was more of a personal side salad. Would it hurt them to add some extra lettuce? Based on the price i expected it to be an entree salad (especially since a ceaser doesnt really have any toppings), but it wasnt even shareable among two as a side. Pizza toppings are not fresh - frozen spinach, canned mushrooms, large unripe tomatoes Garlic knots are more like airy dinner rolls topped with garlic. They tasted decent, but doesnt match the description. Most of these reviews are saying the food is overpriced. I wouldnt have thought so if the ingredients were actually fresh, but given the quality - I would definitely agree. Overall, i was so disappointed with my experience here that wish i could get a refund. read more

This is not the all-time best pizza I've ever had, but it was very good. Has a good selection of specialty pies with some I hadn't heard of before. Baked ziti or baked spaghetti pizza were two of those. Stone oven, too. They also have a deep dish pizza, but we only tried the regular. Has all the traditional toppings and a few less-typical ones. I was surprised to find that broccoli and eggplant were standard toppings. They have some premium toppings like fresh basil, too. I wouldn't hesitate to go back. read more

I can't lie I'm impressed with this little joint. I was expecting the run of the mill pizza instead I was gifted with a great slice of heaven. Lol I got the Chicago style pepperoni and it was great. The crust was thick and buttery, there wasn't too much sauce and it had just the right amount of pepperoni. Friendly service with a smile. read more

Popped in to get a few slices to take back to the room. Small dining area the place was packed, but the service was fast and friendly. The pizza was great! read more

Very good pizza. New York style thin crust. The garlic knots and marinara sauce is excellent too!

At the pizzeria today...great pizza, incredible bargain , super friendly staff! Highly recommend!! Mary read more

Pizza wasn't that bad. Apparently we came on a bad day for the staff. We were greeting at the door by a loud "shut the door" as our family of 7 worked their way in. The 2 employees seemed overwhelmed by our family along with another group of 10 that walked in at the same time. Hopefully the customer service improves to at least the quality of the food. read more

Came in tonight 1/16/20 around 6:30. Havent even gotten to the cottage to eat the food but I'm LIVID that my boyfriend and I were just accused of stealing a freaking 2 liter sprite. My boyfriend and I ordered out food and after we realized that we didnt have drinks in our airbnb so he got back in the line and ordered a second order, only a 2 liter sprite. When our food came out my boyfriend went to the register to get our sprite we had ordered. The same boy who rang my boyfriend up BOTH TIMES swore we didnt order the sprite and they werent going to give it to us because they supposedly couldnt find the receipt on the register. I asked the kid if he remembered talking to my boyfriend the second time and he said yeah but he didnt remember the sprite. The lady obviously running the shift just gave us the sprite. The guy didnt even charge my boyfriend the right menu price for the sprite, on the menu its 2.50, change wouldve been 2.50. My boyfriend only got charged for 2.00 so 3 dollars change. When he came up to the register to get the sprite the boy told him the total would be 2.70 so he gave him the menu price. LOL I work in restaurant management and if i didnt know any better about slick employees Id say he pocketed an easy 5 dollar from a cash order and gave us our change. Someone needs to check the cameras because it was also very embarrassing being called a liar when I watched my boyfriend buy the drink. Dont know how the food will be but just ask for a receipt if you ever order food. read more

Friendly staff. Great prices most slices $3ish. Clean bathrooms too. I followed other yelper's tip to try the Natural Gourmet and was very happy! read more

Quick service. Good pizza. Crispy crust. Great choice for families to get a lot of different pizza choices. Will be back to try the Chicago deep dish style next time. read more

Our favorite pizza at OBX. margarita pizza is fantastic. Great crust always a stop on our yearly trips

Stopped here the other day for a quick bite before a movie. Great food and great service. I had the natural pizza and my boyfriend had the sausage. We will definitely be going back. read more

Good pizza! Skimpy salads. Delivery takes a very very long time. Ours arrived cold. We prefer warm pizza! As we ordered delivery to a hotel, one would hope that restaurant management or delivery professional would be thoughtful enough to provide plastic forks for the salad we ordered or paper plates for pizza, or even napkins. Nope. I tried to call to give feedback to the manager, in hopes that other customers would benefit from changes, but I was put on hold ...and eventually gave up. read more

Best pizza in the OBX! And they deliver! I'd recommend the Natural Gourmet pizza - fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, and a perfect crust - simple, but so good! The Stuffed Meat pizza is great as well - a little pricey for a whole pie, but it could feed an army - you'll have leftovers for days! Definitely will be a repeat customer :) read more

Don't let the reviews fool you, Pizza is nothing special. Bland crust and sauce

Very much enjoyed the margherita pizza slices that I had there, and the grape Fanta (having good drinks is the sign of a quality establishment). Marked down to 4 stars because it is so very small, and because one of the wait-staff was a little slow on the up-take and seemed confused by me wanting to sit at their counter and have two slices of pizza. Is it real NY style? Eh, who cares? I imagine people say it is because it has pre-made pizzas sitting there that they rewarm for you on request. But the crust didn't seem NY-ish to this Pittsburgher. I didn't care because it was delicious either way. read more

Lots of choices and if you have the picky eater with you, They should be able to find something that they like too. If not its their own fault. I got the stuffed meat pie, and it was full of every type of meat you can think of. The downfall I wasn't expecting onion (not a fan) and this had its share. Still enjoyed the pie, just would have been better without the O's. The other pizza was cheese and supreme which both of the others with me had no problem eating. Small area to eat inside and a slightly larger area outside. 2 of us wanted to eat in, and 1 out, however no tables on the inside so we ate outside. Them temp was close to 95 so not exactly the best setting, but food was enjoyable. Normal temps in a OBX evening, and it would be a lot of fun to sit outside and enjoy the food. Prices were fair, staff was polite. Will return and maybe consider takeout. read more

First time and place is pretty good. Well, just OK..Very friendly staff and right next to my other vice..donuts. Scored the deep dish of course and it's pretty darn good. Had 1.5 slices and I'm stuffed.. read more

Delicious pizza heated when you order it! The pepperoni is greasy, but let's be honest, that's the best way to enjoy pizza. Prices are really reasonable too for such high quality pizza. read more

Quick. Tasty. Everything you would hope for. Very limited seating. But it's in and out so it doesn't really matter.

Nice place, got the Chicago deep dish, hot and fresh, pizza was good, light on the sauce, and the mushrooms were canned, not fresh, I would go back but would try something else. read more

We come here like clockwork when visiting our home in the OBX. The staff are efficient and friendly. The pizza is better than good and is the best in the OBX by far. read more

Excellent pizza with quick service. It's a small place with limited seating. The Pizza was excellent. We went several time during our stay and it was a good the last time as it was the first. I highly recommend it. read more