Excellent! Loved the scallops and shrimp pizza! We ordered 5 pies and garlic knots. Everyone loved…read moreall of the different pizzas we ordered.

Traveling through Nags Head, NC with kids, my youngest--who has probably eaten every kind of…read moreMargherita pizza known to mankind--was seriously craving pizza. Village Pizza turned out to be a great choice. The staff was incredibly attentive and kind, and the ambiance was welcoming and relaxed. We ordered a Margherita pizza to go, but couldn't wait and ended up starting it in the car. That's usually a good sign. The crust was almost perfect, with just the right balance of crisp and chew. The tomato sauce tasted fresh, and the mozzarella had that just-made flavor you hope for. The basil, however, didn't add much flavor, which was a small letdown. Overall, it was a very good pizza, and we'll most likely return next time we're in Nags Head. A bit on the pricey side, perhaps--but the taste made up for it

This is some of the best pizza I've had ANYWHERE. It's DELICIOUS. The ingredients are fresh. They…read morefollowed the takeout order instructions to the T. The crust is perfection, there's a DELIGHTFUL pillowy doughiness, a light crisp. I can't even tell you how wonderful this pizza is. I'll dream of it. I recommend extra mozzarella cheese -- the Milky Way + tomatoes + extra mozarella is everything you could ever want in a white pizza. Get this pizza immediately!

Had the hulk smash pizza and it was not cooked enough. Ingredients were average. We make better…read morepizza at home. Won't be returning

We got takeout. Brussels sprouts (without the bacon) were delicious. Also got a mushroom pizza…read morewhich was very flavorful and good though I expected it would have more mushrooms. Would order again and probably try the margherita pizza next time.

Let's start with the positives:…read more Love that it's in Manteo and the place has a nice vibe to it. Would've like to try the Weeping Radish Beers but kids were with me so I passed. The Pretzel was good, no doubt about that. All of the breads were very fresh. Unfortunately, everything got worse after the appetizer pretzel at our table. The hot honey on the New Yorker Down South functioned more like a sticky grease. But if not for the honey, I don't think I would've tasted anything at all. The service wasn't good either. Our waitress appeared to be getting frustrated just by those at our table asking questions. The only time she lit up was when she bragged about the two smash burger ideas she came up with that made the menu. She wasn't terrible, but maybe I'm just being nice considering I felt us being there was an inconvenience to her. When someone at our table asked to add lettuce and tomato to their burger, she replied that this isn't a build your own burger place and that she works at the Lost Colony where you can do that...but not here. It was odd. My family has gluten allergies which sucks...but when we asked if any desserts were gluten free she said the tart was the only one she was aware of. It might have been, but saying "aware of" led me to believe there could possibly be others but she didn't know and wasn't asking. Ok, I convinced myself, the service was bad. In fact, the place was practically empty and they stuck all 7 of us in a booth. My daughter who is extremely gluten sensitive has to cut off a piece of her pizza because the waitress bumped it against mine when she put it on the table. In her defense, we had no room for it. When the waitress brought back my youngest daughters Smash Burger (because they didn't put cheese or mayo on it) she could only fit half the plate on the table. So my 8 year old ate off a plate with half the plate dangling off the side...bizarre. I'm giving 2 stars because I believe the meal could've been better. Living in a family with gluten allergies and having none...I get how it can be frustrating (apologies to those gluten free...I get that it's way more frustrating for you). I'd probably stick with a pretzel, order a standard smash burger & do the beer sampler. If you're driving over 15 minutes to get here, probably safest to try somewhere else.

Ordered delivery from here last night. Pretty easy experience. Site is a bit odd but we made it…read morethrough. Just looks a bit dated but hey my pizza showed up so who cares! I got an 18 inch cheese pizza with light sauce, well done, meatballs, arugula, feta, half black and half Kalamata olives and it was fan-frigin-tastic! Never had this combo before and I appreciate them bringing it to life and it tasting sooo good!

this is a fun little pizza spot, definitely not fancy and very casual but has a nice chill beachy…read morevibe to it. the waiter was very nice and we all enjoyed the salads/garlic knots. we ordered two pies, and one came out about 20 minutes before the other. my grandparents got a little impatient with this and asked the staff what was going on, to which they let us know that they'd made a pizza wrong so they had to remake the whole thing. this ended up prolonging the wait, and I do wish they'd given us the heads up about it, as it wouldve given my grandparents a chance to be more patient. other than that, the pizza was delicious and we really enjoyed!

I really enjoyed Slice to satisfy my pizza craving. The service is spot on and the pizza is…read moredelicious. It was a beautiful day so I opted to sit outside. I love that the pizza is saucy, hot and fresh. They have pizza by the slice ready when you walk in. I hope they continue to do well in the Outer Banks.

Proper NY Pizza! By far the BEST pizza in the OBX. We got the slices of cheese, margarita, deep…read moredish, and a couple specialties. Prices are about normal for what the pizza economy is. The restaurant is fun and great outdoor seating! Highly recommend if you're in search of good pizza. It's a kind of pizza you'd be happy with eating once a week. The boneless wings were very good, crispy, and tangy. Great size too. Service is very attentive and fast. Great service. This is the spot to grab OBX pizza!

"Sandwiches and pizza in Food Lion/ Fresh Market shopping center in Nags Head"…read more Came here for a takeout lunch on a midsummer Friday. We ordered in the restaurant-- I got a chicken cheesesteak sandwich, and my dining partner got a calzone. The restaurant was rather surprisingly dark, but that was fine to just wait for food. The order took a bit longer than I may have expected-- maybe 20 minutes. Everything was packaged well so it was warm when we got back to our place. The chicken cheesesteak was good albeit SUPER messy-- which is how it should be. Lots of chicken chunks, cheese, peppers, onions, etc. The calzone was just OK-- more hollow than one might expect, thereby lacking in fillings. My dining partner said he wouldn't especially recommend it. Service was friendly. And price was fair. One plus is location-- 2 doors over from Duck Donuts! Overall, an OK option, but not something to necessarily seek out.

We've been using yellow submarine for years every Friday/Saturday the first day we are down there…read more The food is always good and prices aren't bad at all. The service is very good and they are always very friendly. When we had to pick up the food the one time we were out of delivery range, I came in carrying my half awake 3 year old the crew carried our pizzas out to the car for me. It was very clean and relaxing atmosphere inside.

I found this place when looking for a new spot to try. I had the Lobster & shrimp ravioli and a…read moreglass of red wine, which was a lovely dinner, I decided to try the cannoli for dessert which was so tasty! The ambience is clean and simple and the service was great. I will definitely come back the next time I am down in the OBX.

This spot was fantastico! The service was awesome and friend. The food was great and came in good…read moretime. We had the chicken parm and shrimp fra diavolo. The atmosphere is calm and peaceful with light Italian music playing. They have indoor and outdoor seating as well as takeaway. The prices are fair and the portions are healthy.

Perfect pizza everytime. Got a to go pie after leaving martin st. Will definitely be back.read more

Very good pizza, very friendly service, and our pickup order was ready even before the 15 minutes…read morethey estimated despite it being a busy pickup spot with many other orders being put out. Definitely worth getting g takeout or dine in if you're staying anywhere nearby They have a gluten free small that was quite tasty. Opt for the cheese sticks over the breadsticks.

Maddisons pizza has the best wings on the outerbanks great service affordable prices.read more

Thank you to the review that said this was the best pizza in Nags Head, you were correct!! It's…read moreclear how much quality and originality matter to the owner. Always happy to support a small business, but this pizza was exceptional! I'm halfway through my pizza and I've already sent their link to 3 people!