Ordered delivery from here last night. Pretty easy experience. Site is a bit odd but we made it through. Just looks a bit dated but hey my pizza showed up so who cares! I got an 18 inch cheese pizza with light sauce, well done, meatballs, arugula, feta, half black and half Kalamata olives and it was fan-frigin-tastic! Never had this combo before and I appreciate them bringing it to life and it tasting sooo good! read more

this is a fun little pizza spot, definitely not fancy and very casual but has a nice chill beachy vibe to it. the waiter was very nice and we all enjoyed the salads/garlic knots. we ordered two pies, and one came out about 20 minutes before the other. my grandparents got a little impatient with this and asked the staff what was going on, to which they let us know that they'd made a pizza wrong so they had to remake the whole thing. this ended up prolonging the wait, and I do wish they'd given us the heads up about it, as it wouldve given my grandparents a chance to be more patient. other than that, the pizza was delicious and we really enjoyed! read more

We ordered carry out and the pizza was excellent. The dough was a pleasant and the toppings were fresh. It is in a nondescript strip shopping center and the lack of ambiance is more than made up for with the quality of the food. It was our last night at our rental house and we wanted a change of pace from seafood. The only complaint is that they were very busy and their estimate on when the pizza would be ready was 45 minutes optimistic. read more

Best pizza in the OBX. Closest I've found to authentic NY City pizza. I've never eaten in but get it to go. So I can't speak into the experience inside. Highly recommend regardless. read more

Definitely recommend on throwing to sales New York Pizza.It was delicious and cases very familiar To the new york style

Got a Margarita pizza tonight takeout. It was over the top. One of the best and I have had. Don't miss out on this gem in Kill Devils Hill. Enjoy. Service was great read more

We picked pizza here for dinner. We ordered large cheese pizza and garlic bread. It took them about 20 mins, which is understandable. Staff was friendly. There isn't too much space if you want to dine in. Garlic bread was great. Pizza was decent as well. read more

ALL THESE PEOPLE SAYING THERE'S SOMETHING WRONG WITH THIS PLACE ARE DEAD WRONG!! The people there were lovely, although my family can get a bit rowdy; the decor was typical of your usual restaurant, and I've been craving the food there ever since I left. Please ship some of that cheesecake and cheesy garlic bread to PA. I need it. Also, the photos do NOT do them justice. Go see this lovely business for yourself and keep it open so I can go when I pass by. read more

Absolutely outstanding pizza. We got the several large pizzas and they were very good. I highly recommend the deluxe pizza, it is absolutely loaded (everything except fish and fruit). read more

Wonderful food, great service. Everything we have eaten there has been good. Even when they have been busy they have managed to serve great food in a reasonable time. read more

Stopped in Sal's and ordered a mushroom pie and a margherita pie. Usually I go for a pepperoni or sausage but I decided the change would be good. I was not disappointed, the basil was fresh and very aromatic which enhanced the experience even more. The crust was thin and crispy like it should be. The sauce was unbelievable, someone's mom is in the kitchen with her secret sauce for sure. The waitress was great, seated us as soon as she cleared the table. The place is small with only a few tables but I suspect they do a lot of take out because of where they are at. Definitely a New York feel in the best way possible. If you are in KDH you should give them a try. read more

Great NY style pizza! Order was ready when they said it would be. I placed an online order and they even called me to double check what I wanted. Great service. read more

Had margarita pizza and garlic knots. Love the homemade mozzarella cheese. Garlic knots were good. We sat at the bar and service was great

So tonight we tried Sals pizza for the first time we have dined here before and love this place. I am incredibly happy tosay I have found the BEST PIZZA in the OBX! PERFECT CRUST , by the far the best pizza I have since we moved here! It's a must stop for any of their meals. I am now a total fan of this place. read more

Told they were closing early this past Friday night due to "running out of cheese"! What kind of pizza joint runs out of cheese?!

A Friday evening stroll from the resort led us here. Thankfully we were able to sit at the bar. We ordered and it took about 30 minutes for our pizza to come out. They were fairly busy the entire evening. Food worth waiting for... the pizza slices were large and the Supreme toppings were really good. read more

Sal's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

I'm from NY and this pizza was terrible. The crust was soggy and flavorless. We felt like the entire thing was not seasoned whatsoever. The pizza was super greasy and they charge a lot for each topping you add. Also, if you order after a certain time they have a menu that is limited to pizza or wings only which they don't disclose on their website. Expensive and disappointing. read more

Recently wanted to get pizza, but our "regular" places were closed so thought we'd give Sal's a try. What a find! This is a classic joint, which is exactly what you'd find in NY - and this is a good thing. The pizza did not disappoint. The crust had a great chew to it, thin and crispy, and generous toppings. We saw others there that got the lasagna or baked spaghetti and based on their reactions it was as good as it looked. The only disappointment is that we didn't try Sal's before now. It is now part of our "regular" places. read more

We ate at Sal's tonight. They do not have a lot of seating space but accommodated our group for our son's 16th birthday with no hesitation. I was so impressed with their professionalism as they answered phone orders and walk ins with estimated wait times. It is a Sunday and a huge cottage turnover day - pizza and subs are no brainers for tourists and they non-apologetically gave honest answers. I loved this! The atmosphere made me so happy with tons of Frank Sinatra music. We ordered wings, garlic knots, a 18 inch pepperoni pizza and a deluxe. Everyone was pleased with the tastes. The wait staff was kind and attentive. I highly recommend this establishment. read more

Pizza was fantastic, rivaling central jersey pies. Fresh mozzarella, basil was very tasty. Make your own pasta with meatballs was excellent as well. The use of good ingredients shines. Beer on tap is a welcome addition to our visit. Service and ambiance was welcoming with soft music in background. Small dining area. Will be sure to visit again read more

Sal's New York Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Wasn't a fan. For starters, the online ordering system is a joke. While they did accept our order over the phone, it wasn't the same. We were told 40 minutes. Which ended up being 70. The pizza was...meh. Yeah, it's pizza. But, it's not pizza you'd purposefully order again with other options available. Sauce had a weird taste, and all toppings were basically melted with the cheese. Just wasn't good. read more

On a soggy night, Fat Man Reviews stopped into Sal's New York Pizza in Kill Devil Hills, NC. Sal's is New York style pizza joint serving pies, beer and pasta dishes. We started with the Specialty Topped Tots - classic. This comes with bacon, cheese, House made ranch, and we added jalapeños. The tots are out of a bag, but they were cooked and seasoned perfectly. The bacon is crispy and chewy and adds texture. The melted cheese was great, and the jalapeños added a kick of spice. The ranch was creamy, thick and great with this dish. We ordered a half Pepperoni and half Sausage pizza. This has a hand tossed crust, it 2as thin and crispy, and I believe cooked in a wood-fire or brick oven. The pepperoni was high quality, thin and had a nice flavor. The sausage was ground with a light fennel flavor that wasn't overpowering. My one issue is I would have like a few more toppings per slice, especially the sausage. The sauce was traditional tasting marinara that was flavorful but subtle and the cheese was melted well. I think the crust to sauce and cheese ratio was about spot on. Sal's makes their pizza dough in house, and they also offer beer and wine. They have a large menu that includes salads, sandwiches and desserts. The staff is very friendly and helpful. The Fat Man says that Sal's New York Pizza is Fat Man Approved with 2 chins. read more

Sal's New York Pizza - Specialty Topped Tots - classic - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Fantastic service, delicious pizzas... absolutely worth visiting when in OBX... we also did a take out order!

The best NYC style pizza in Kill Devil Hills! Every visit to the outer banks we go here. Trust me on this one! Check em out!!! read more

See all

I was very surprised to find quite an abundance of NY Style pizzerias in the area. NY style is a favorite of mine and had to try at least 1 pizzeria while visiting the area. So it was a rainy and windy evening and I figured why go out in the messy weather and they deliver to my location so I placed a order for delivery. So the reviews indicated their chicken parmigiana grinder and caprese salad was really good. So I had to order them, as well as a Margherita pizza and a Italian sausage/mushrooms pizza. Food arrived as promised in the estimated time frame. Caprese salad was really good The chicken parmigiana grinder was a huge disappointment. The chicken was pounded or sliced so thin that the bread crumb coating was pretty much what you really get to bite down on besides the bread itself. The chicken it self was the thickness of a slice of cheese on a sandwich. But the pizza is what really matters to me and the 2 pies I ordered was on the money. I'm so surprised that the pie it self weighted nothing In the box and I ordered the large pie. And you almost think they forgot the pie inside the box. But 3 slices in I'm getting full and the 4th slice was a fight to the end. All said and done, I still think this pizzeria is solid and will order again. read more

Sal's New York Pizza - Margherita pie - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

My husband and I both really enjoyed our delivery order from Sal's. I got a caprese salad, and was amazed at how big it was. A bed of soft greens and halved grape tomatoes was topped with shingled slices of fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, accompanied by balsamic dressing. The dressing was very good, and the salad itself was big enough to be a whole meal. We also got a large pizza. We were impressed by how cheesy the pizza was! The crust and sauce were good, but the star was the cheese. We ate pizza leftovers the next day driving home from vacation, and it was great eaten cold out of the box too! We'll definitely order from Sal's again. . read more

Food was delicious. We ordered the meatball appetizer. The order comes with 3 meatballs covered in red sauce with melted mozzarella... yum! To make it even better it came with soft white bread and your choice of butter or oil and parsley. Then we had a NY style pizza...cooked perfectly with ooey gooey cheese and a crisp, chewy crust. The table next to us ordered a chicken Cesar salad that looked fantastic... huge with thinly slice chicken breast on top... I wish we had ordered it!! The wait staff was friendly and helpful. The restaurant has a decent size bar, ample seating, they also have desserts, sandwiches, entrees and sell pizza by the slice. We have eaten at many places in Kill Devil Hills that have been ok but Sal's is delish and we recommend eating here!! Plus they were playing music from the 80's... The Cure, nice people, great food... it was perfect. read more

We got a pizza for takeout. I prefer a good wood fired pizza, but couldn't find any place serving one. We decided to grab a pizza here just to change from the seafood we've been eating all week. It was okay but I wouldn't want another one. read more

Owner was extremely rude, coming outside and yelling at me and my friends saying we could not park here without coming in when we were planning on coming into his restaurant. Because of this we got into our cars and drove across the street to another restaurant. read more

The house pizza was thin crust, but not too thin, sauce was delicious and it was cooked just right. We ordered take out, they even called us when it was ready! read more

We decided to order delivery the evening we arrived. As promised, our food was delivered piping hot and on time. Pizzas, garlic herb wings and garlic bread were all tasty, but it was something extremely special about the marinara sauce. If it were bottled, I'd definitely buy it! read more

See all

CANT BELIEVE I HAVE TO GIVE THIS HELL HOLE A ONE!!!!! Pizza was trash no favor anywhere ! customer service (what's that?!?) matched the tasteless food and they over charged my card $20 when my total was $40 ! I would go and RUN somewhere else with my money and family #trashy #NOcustomerservice #NOTfamilyfriendly #whatChef read more

We've had their pizza before and decided to try their dinner menu. I had the penne vodka and my wife had the eggplant parmigiana. Excellent.

We showed up here because of a mishap at slice with the manager actually getting a huge attitude with us over food we never got. So we popped across the street to Sal's and they had JUST opened. We enjoyed two beers and two slices of HOT fresh pizza before we headed out of OBX. I mean it was done in a couple of mins! One of the employees talked to us in between phone call orders coming in. They were BUSY with call-ins for sure (the Saturday of Memorial Day Weekend) but still made us feel VERY welcome and a priority. Can't say the same for slice (to be fair we've never felt that way at slice). So Sal's it is for all of our pizza and sandwich needs from here on out for us. Can't wait to come back and visit and take a pie back to our rental. They have a great sizable beer selection! read more

Pizza is fantastic!! I'm from NJ and we are very picky about our pizza. Good enough for "One bite everyone knows the rules" if he hasn't already been there! Everyone was very nice. The only negative is average decor and lack of enough seating. Highly recommend! read more

This was our first visit to Sal's after the change in ownership. We liked the old product enough to try again although it needed a little work. It still needs a little work. This was takeout, so as has been true with Dare Devil's and Max's, the pizzas are not baked enough to keep the crust from getting soggy on our short drive (~ one mile) home. The cheese also does not get browned. The cheese on pizzas needs to be baked a little brown, not just melted. It's not nachos. The browning adds a richer, nuttier flavor to the mild cheese. We are Italian sausage fans and always order it. Sal's is link style, sliced. It is weak on the fennel as Ms T could not detect it and I only could by picking a piece of the sausage off and eating it separately. We liked the sauce. It was not sweet and also was not tomato paste. We order either calamata or green olives to add the briny saltiness that they bring. Sal's offers neither. So for us, this is a semi D-I-Y pizza. We bring it home, add calamata olives, broil the cheese and crisp the crust on a griddle. After all that, we still don't have great sausage. I won't say we won't do this again, but there are still a couple of places to try; New York and Pizzazz (not holding much hope, they both look so commercial). We have already ruled out Max's, Slice, Cosmo's and Lucky 12. We may have to forego pizza while staying here, or we might have try Sal's or Dare Devil if we get hungry enough for it. read more

Sal's New York Pizza - Sausage Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Sal's was really great Italian food and as vegetarians we found several options. I would highly recommend this place, the food was fresh, flavorful and the service was very friendly and awesome! read more

Sal's New York Pizza - Eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Pizza is ok not an hour and a half wait ok. The atmosphere Rude AF they were short and rude everyone as you would try to order or pickup if they let you order at some moments they would say closed to new orders never heard that ever. Then close at 930-10 lights off read more

They made a mistake and left something out of our order and went above and beyond to make it right. Excellent customer service. Also, the meatballs in the red sauce were delicious. Highly recommended! read more

We were visiting the area and wanted something different than seafood. It looked good online and so we went. It was a cool little pizza joint. Sal is, and never was, there. Pizza was great, service was too! read more