Pizza is mediocre but the service is terrible the guys a compete jerk. The only positive I can throw out is that he's at least an equal opportunity jerk. Go look at his replies to customers on facebook, google and other platforms, it's borderline comical that he's such a miserable person. He treats locals like dirt so imagine how he treats visitors.. it's as if this guy never learned anything about manners or just general common business sense very unprofessional and the product isn't worth the attitude. read more

Thank you to the review that said this was the best pizza in Nags Head, you were correct!! It's clear how much quality and originality matter to the owner. Always happy to support a small business, but this pizza was exceptional! I'm halfway through my pizza and I've already sent their link to 3 people! read more

Madisons Pizza - Margarita pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

I saw the reviews and pictures online and waited three days for it to open back up. Madison's did not disappoint. Amazing pizza and wings. Only one individual working, but he provided great service and everything was ready in the time he specified when we ordered over the phone. I look forward to visiting again on my next vacation. read more

Maddisons pizza has the best wings on the outerbanks great service affordable prices.

The best pizza we've had in OBX or pretty much anywhere. Note that Madison's is take-out only, and one guy does everything, so know what you want when you call in. You won't be dissappointed! read more

We live local and had a great first experience at Madison's. They have a great story and the pizza hit the spot!

THIS. THIS is the best pizza in Nags head. Super fresh ingredients, toppings were very generous, crispy crust!! The owner was running it by himself. His dedication is shown in the quality of the food. Much respect! We have high standards for pizza and this was...THE JAM! Looking forward to trying the cheesesteak next time! read more

the Google reviews on this pizza place and I knew I had to try it. I'd liked the responses from the owner seemed like a down to earth place and it was just that this is a one-man operation so he really doesn't have time for shenanigans taking orders. And it was just as expected, and I loved it. The owner was the only one working. My order was done on time. It was fresh and good reviews to the restaurant but the pizza and wings are bringing me back. Keep doing what you're doing. You clearly know how to run your business. read more

See all

Had some amazing wings from Madison's last night!! The owner was a cool guy and gave us great service even though we came a little late. Will definitely be back the next time I'm in OBX!! read more

Absolute horrid pizza and subs. First day of vacation the whole house was sick with stomach trouble. 3 pizzas and 3 subs waisted. The guy running the place is rude and ignorant. Hard pass on this place. read more

Quick and friendly service! Ordered garlic bread, hot honey wings, & a L half margherita/half meat lovers! Best wings I've had in awhile! Pizza sauce to topping ratio is superb! Highly recommend coming down to Madisons on your next obx trip! read more

The pizza was fabulous. It was Done exactly like my husband likes it. It was ready right when I requested. The owner was there and was very pleasant and appreciative of our business. Definitely the best pizza we've had in a while. We will be back!! read more

The bad reviews here are crazy. Best pizza on the island and I'm not sure it's close. Crispy under carriage but not burnt. Fresh toppings. I just ordered a supreme and it may have been the best pizza I've ever had. The owner is super chill. The people complaining are probably dealing with the summer rush when things are crazy. Not sure if the oven he's using but it cooks the pizza perfectly. Fresh ingredients... delicious! read more

I ordered 3 large pizzas from Madison's for 7 hungry teenagers who are very picky about their pizza. They loved it! Delicious! We'll definitely order again. read more

Decent pizza (crust on the thin side) but it's literally a one man operation. If he gets more than a few orders at a time (on our night, it was thrown off by walk in traffic) you can expect to wait an hour or more. And he's not all that friendly about explaining it. Take out only. Not for dine in. read more

Now that you've amused yourself by reading all these crazy reviews, just order the pizza. This is a one man show and he doesn't have or make time for anyone thinking they should be treated like they're extra special or to wait for you while you figure out what the heck you're doing. He's got pizza to make! Read the menu. Know what you want. Order it. You might have to let it ring for a bit because he's making pizza. Then go pick up the best pizza on the Outer Banks (or anywhere else I've had pizza, for that matter). I've never had a bad pizza from Madison's, it's always been on time, hot and delicious. And I've never been treated rudely or disrespectfully because I've never treated him that way either.This place is the real deal. read more

Good pizza, excellent service, closes at 9pm. The owner accommodated our request for a thin crust pizza a few minutes before closing! read more

Madisons Pizza - New menu as of May 2023 - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

This was our first time visiting and it exceeded every expectation we had. After having pizza at many places in the OBX over the years, I think I can say this is the best so far. The pizza was great, especially the high-quality toppings. Even if the pizza wasn't so good, I would go there just for the chicken wings. I've had mixed results ordering wings from pizza places, but these were delicious. The owner was honest and conscientious about his product and seemed to take pride in what he was doing. We'll be back and we'll be hungry! read more

The owner is quite rude and refuses to hire any help. Honestly, I don't know how anyone could even work with him. The first couple times we went the pizzas were incredible but the last few times were enough to make it not worth putting up with his 'personality.' read more

It is kind of hard to find this place, even with the gps it's hard to find the actual store within the plaza! Overall the food is amazing and the store is like a pizza factory! The host was able to explain the pizza ingredients and steps to me! read more

Madisons Pizza - Garlic Spinach Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

I came here because of the bad reviews and the hilarious responses from the owner. The pizza and wings are amazing I will keep coming back.

Worst pizza in North Carolina. Period. Low quality and tastes like feces. Someone shut this place down

I'm in town from Buffalo. We love Pizza and Wings in Buffalo. Is this the best pizza I've ever had? No. Is it really great pizza for North Carolina, you betcha. Heck, it's better than most out of state pizza I've had. One thing that absolutely ASTONISHED me was how CLEAN this man's pizza shop was. I've never seen anything rival it. I worked in a pizza shop that took cleaning pretty serious but I've honestly never seen hoods, counters, fryers etc that were so spotless they looked brand new. I mentioned it and he pointed to a paper he had on the wall which showed he had a 100 score from the health inspector. Nice guy, super reasonable prices. Good pizza. For the rest of our trip and if we ever come back, I won't order from anywhere other than Madisons. read more

Terrible service and even worse manners. Make sure you check out the Google reviews before you go. The way he responds to customers calling him out about his terrible interpersonal skills is ridiculously disrespectful. Please do not patronize this business. I absolutely have no idea how this person stays in business the way he treats people. And he calls people entitled..you sir are the epitome of entitled. And thank goodness there are way better pizza places in the OBX. Save your hard earned money and go to one of them instead! read more

Horrible ownership that prides himself on making a bad pizza look perfectly circular.

Make sure to voice your order fast or the owner will tell you to hurry up then cancel your order, and hang up on you. read more

Madisons Pizza - Terrible customer service from the owner!! His response to my Facebook review speaks for itself. Tourists beware, he is not a fan. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

Great pizza and wings. Local dude and no he doesn't try to become friends; but does that really matter? He is like every other small business owner trying to make a living against big chain. He doesn't have enough staff and he doesn't have time to shoot the bull on the phone. Figure out what you want, call and order. I'll keep going back. How many times do you goto Pizza Hut or papa John's and it sucks, the workers just dropped your food on the floor, smoked, or took the trash out before making your food or even handled it afterwards? But yet you keep ordering from them. Madison has good food and it's clean, made to order, and you're supporting local business. Be patient and ready to order when you call. read more

Great pizza, wings, and subs! We've been ordering from Madison's for a few years now, and the food is consistently good. Bryan is a one-man show; he does it all! Owner, chef, cashier, etc. He does an outstanding job balance everything. Check out the menu online before calling, he's a busy guy. Then order and enjoy! Be sure to check out the dry rub wings. read more

Great chicken wings! Wasn't alot of choices for wings in the area at the end of December but this place had a great place and good wings!

The pizza was pretty good. A bit greasy (just absorb it with napkins). The location is a bit hard to find so you have to look carefully. After you pull into the shopping center, you will see Super Wings in front of you. Madison's Pizza is on the left side about half way down the strip. read more

Madisons Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

BEWARE! If you seek good customer service, with a side of humility along with your food, this is not the place to be. I was passing through the area and decided on pizza for lunch and called up this place to ask about price of their cheese pizza. To my surprise the person on the phone immediately informed me "That's the only one question I am answering!" and hung up. I thought it was some sort of joke and called back to order. At the store for pickup, I figured there would be an employee with a weird sense of humor, but instead, the only person there was the owner, who remembered me from the phone and went into a tirade about how he doesn't have time answer questions and does not care if he looses customers and assessed that I must be some corporate type who does not say what I mean, but he does. He went on for a while more, berating his customers, while I stood there in awe of the degree of negativity spewing from him, completely unprovoked. I never met the guy before. As I was exiting, he then arrogantly yells "Please leave me a negative review!!". Never before in all the countries , states, cities and towns I have visited, have I encountered a business owner who is as unprofessional and self sabotaging as this guy. Based on his reviews, I can see others have called him out on his rudeness and I have seen him respond with even more unprofessionalism. I fully expect him to exhibit the same in response, instead of looking inwards. Surely there must be other restaurant proprietors in the area who actually understand that its customers is its lifeblood. read more

First time I have tried this relatively new pizza place here in Nags Head. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza in mid-afternoon over the phone. I was told the pizza would be ready in 15 minutes. I arrived one minute early and he had just boxed the pizza - great timing. Left a nice tip for that! The pizza was simply outstanding. The crust (which I rarely comment on) was cooked perfectly. Too often pizza's are soggy or overcooked. This pizza crust was perfection at its best. And the crust tasted great. For toppings, there was plenty of pepperoni, no need to order double pepperoni. The cheese was cooked great - not burnt brown like some other places. Sauce was good and the right quantity for a pizza. Highly recommend trying Madison's Pizza if you are on the Outer Banks and want pizza. Five stars! read more

Called to order 4 pizzas while driving. I asked two questions about their food and he says "call back when you're ready to order" and hangs up. I used to work in a busy pizzeria and that was just unnecessary and rude. Get over yourself or don't answer the phone. read more

Wow. My new favorite pizza on the beach. Fresh ingredients, especially fresh bacon, whole pieces not the bacon bits like most shops. Order this pizza. The wings were great as well! read more

Madisons Pizza - Small Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

Try Madison's ! My wife and I stoped by and will be returning! The owner made our pizza and while I awaited we discussed OBX history,really enjoyed sharing stories with a local guy. Good prices,flavor,crust! read more

HORRIBLE customer service!! I have never been talked so harshly by a man in my life! All we wanted to do was place a large order and support a small business. But after being told to find somewhere else to eat and hung up on we placed our order somewhere else. I would never spend a dime to support this small business after the way we were treated.... especially knowing that it was the owner that was so rude! read more

Fresh pizza and friendly owner. The toppings were fresh, not frozen. One of the best pizzas we've had in a while read more

Madisons Pizza - Half Hawaiian and half supreme - Chicken Wings Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

We were super hungry, walked in and ordered two large pizzas they were ready in 20 minutes and they were delicious! Owner was nice and friendly. Forgot to take a picture of the pizza because we were so hungry but it was beautiful. read more

This has become our go-to pizza place. The crust perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crispiness. The sauce is tangy and the pepperoni is spicy. My kids love the veggie pizza. Their wings are meaty and I especially like their dry rub wings. Different that what you get at most places. Even the ones with sauces are still crispy. I admire the work ethic of the owner. He seems to always be there and does everything. Answers calls, cooks, rings you up. Sometimes there is a wait but it is worth it. read more

What great pizza. The owner is great also posting young students art on the wall by the entrance. Pizza is amazing! read more