We found Slice on our first day at the beach. I had two slices of the margherita and my daughter had a slice of pepperoni. A little expensive but tasty. She went back for more slices later in the week. Seating inside but a bit small. It got crowded but no one seemed to mind. We didn't. There is also outdoor seating on a side patio. I'd definitely eat here again, probably on a day when they're offering specials. read more

Every year that my family vacations here we try to find a pizza place and usually leave disappointed but Slice changed our minds! Five of us stopped by for dinner, sat outside and ordered five house salads, garlic knots and their Endless Summer pizza. The salads were OK. A bit watery and the ranch dressing was kinda bland. The garlic knots were delicious but the pizza was the star of this meal. The endless summer is a 16' pizza with five toppings of your choice. With five grown adults eating, we still took a slice or two home with us. The crust was hand tossed and was perfectly cooked. it wasn't greasy like you get at some other places. Another plus to this place is that everything is fresh and handmade in the store! The only downside was the cost. For our meal it was around $60. but then again, when you are on vacation you are allowed to splurge, right? read more

I am giving 5 stars because its at the beach... and typically food is kinda "meh" at beach pizza places... In the words of Lee Corso... Not so fast my friend!! Double not so fast!!! This place would get 5 stars anywhere in my book! Great prices, awesome food, family owned... clean - air conditioned... and the selection is phenomenal. Every time i go to OBX - i stop here. you should too - if you want good pizza... in fact theres a donut shop next door.. show up early - eat donuts while you wait for them to open! You wont be dissapointed... it can get crowded - but ladies and gentlemen... this place is a treat at the beach. I am Tater LoneStar read more

We had delivery to our rental beach house one night from Slice. They quoted an hour and a half delivery time so I was pleasantly surprised when the pizza arrived 45 minutes later. First, let me say I'm a really picky pizza eater of the New York persuasion. I like my pizza a little more thinner and not so doughy and saucy but this was hot and tasty nontheless. A solid 3 1/2 stars. The wings and greek salad were good too. My favorite pizzeria in the OBX is Cosmos so this didn't quite measure up but it was good. read more

Pizza is great. Service is not. I understand they were extremely busy but hurrying customers to decisions and asking them to step aside so person behind them can order while we were asking questions about food is not a good customer service practice. If we come back it will definitely only be to order out. read more

I've been coming to the Outer Banks for over 25 years and have had pizza from Corolla to Ocracoke, and this is the best I've ever had ! The other pizzas I've tried taste like ketchup on cardboard compared to Slice ! Love the sauce, the toppings are very generous, and the staff there, especially the delivery guys, is friendly, helpful, and polite. Yes, it is a bit more expensive than the other places, but I'd prefer to pay 10-20% more and LOVE what I'm eating rather than taking the cheaper route and ending up with what tastes like a frozen Tony's pizza ! Wish I could give more than five stars !!! read more

Damn good pizza! This is a great addition to the area. Lot's of yummy items on the menu. Our pizza had perfect crust, fresh vegetables and supper yummy italian sausage. Can't wait to try a calzone. read more

Fantastic Pizza! Pizza is not my go to food item of choice, however when traveling with a ten year old, it is easy. We were told by the hotel staff to check out Slice, and what a great recommendation. The dough was perfect, sauce was moderate an the toppings were deliciously fresh. I will stop back for sure, but that is because Slice is in the same plaza as Duck Doughnuts and Try my Nuts.... read more

We own a home very close to this pizza place and have been coming the outer banks for 39 years. Slice pizzeria is the closest thing to New York pizza in the entire outer banks. A classic no friils pizza slice joint. We were there for Monday madness this past week and had cheese slices for $1 each. The kids start talking about slice when we cross the bridge. read more

We ordered 3 pizzas for 80$! We Made sure we Requested For Thin Crusted Pizza and they said NO Problem! If they cannot make that they should Say they don't make them like that! Also the Pizza was just Bland! Sucked Actually! For 80$ it should Be Great! They think they know Pizza but to be honest They really Don't! Then they advertise Best on the Beach! They must give pizza's to Homeless People that put reviews on the site! The pizza Sucks read more

Couldn't have asked for a better experience! We did a to-go here. The staff was super friendly and made sure we had everything we asked for. In fact, they went a step ahead and offered us cutlery and other items as we had told them we were going to drive back to Raleigh from there. The pizza here tastes just amazing! Would strongly recommend this place to everyone visiting the Outer Banks. read more

I liked the pizza at Pizza Stop more --- less crust and cheaper. But all and all, good solid NY style pizza. Sauce and cheese were good. Spinach roll was meh -- wouldn't order it again. Wings were good -- decent size, mild was actually mild. read more

Friendly and fast service. Pizza was great, I recommend the "Natural Gourmet." Seating is limited inside, but there is some bar/counter seating and lots of seating on the patio outside. Perfect for eating with your kids, you can order by the slice (huge slices) and then everyone is happy. Slice Pizzeria is also very clean, including the restrooms. They are Ravens fans too! read more

We always go to Slice pizza when in town. The pizza is great especially when you order a whole pie, noticed when you ordered from the pre made not as delicious as when made to order. Staff is friendly and takes care of us each time we are there... Best pizza on OBX.... read more

Probably the best in the area to me personally I got a large pie with white cheese, ricotta cheese, chicken, and broccoli With Alfredo Sauce as the base read more

Ordered Slice for carry out. There was some issue with their phone, so it took like 3 calls to place the order. Otherwise, the service was great! I would recommend this decent pizza for anyone who wants a quick carry out dinner. read more

Slice has some of the Best Pizza on the OBX. They also have good specials on occasion. read more

Awesome pizza . Just loved the flavors. Never thought east coast had so much too offer. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Absolutely delicious! We ordered half spinach and half margherita. It's the best I've had so far. Wait was not too long as there was not a long line when we got in. I definitely recommend this joint. Looking forward to try other pizza's from their menu. read more

Big pies. Good sauce and plentiful toppings on the pizzas. Staff was wearing masks which I appreciated.

Just tried this the other night and it's the BEST PIZZA in the OBX!! The pizzas are delicious and they offer a variety of toppings. We will definitely be ordering pizza from Slice Pizzeria from now on!! read more

This was once a terrific pizza place. Authentic northeast pizza with good ingredients and an excellent crust. They are now super busy and the quality has regressed. Ingredients not as good. I suspect the owner thinks no one will notice but many have. read more

The second we crossed the NC state line, my boyfriend started talking about "beach pizza." Beach pizza? "You know," he said. "Pizza just tastes better at the beach." I didn't know that, actually... So we stopped at Slice and we had a few beers and a few slices and one of their big sausage-y things (they're like baby calzones). And it all tasted pretty great. I don't know if it was the beach-proximity or if it was just good pizza, but either way, it's worth stopping. read more

Very good pizza. Quite a few vegetarian options, but be warned if you're vegetarian (or allergic to fish), some of the red sauces have anchovies! We got a couple of pizzas to go and they were quite good. Very good cheeses and fresh ingredients. read more

It was good , we got a few different types. Nice clean place and the people were pleasant.

Coming from New York I want expecting a slice as good as I got here. Would definitely stop again on my next trip down. Oh the Beer was nice and cold also read more

Great pizza and cute restaurant! But last night, the pizza maker went from emptying trash, to taking orders, to making pizza, to cleaning dishes. ALL WITHOUT WASHING HANDS! Not to mention the owner was fairly rude to us after we accidentally spilt a water and he tried to clean it up with a broom lollll! read more

Simply great pizza. They won't insult you by calling it "NY style," but between you and me, it's some of the best pizza I've had outside of NY: thin crust with good flavor, high quality toppings, not too saucy... And in a strip mall in lil' ol' North Carolina! Who ever would have guessed?! read more

OMG.....Slice my Slice....oh my dear dear Slice...where have you been all my life and why why why are you not in the DC area (which has absolutely CRAPPY pizza places!!!). This has to be the best damn pizza I have EVER had in my life!!!! No more 'floppy' pizza slices No more skimpy toppings No rude customer service BUT YOU MUST EXPAND AND GET A BIGGER PLACE......the storefront is small so a small crowd is out the door! If you go to OBX, DO NOT PASS THIS PLACE UP!!!! read more

Folks...I'm from the metro NY and Boston area and a pizza aficionado. This is THE best NY style pizza on OBX and I've had them all. If you're looking for atmosphere, please keep driving.This is a mom/pop deli-style bistro. However, if you have kids, this is the eat-in place. Home made hand tossed crust melts in your mouth.The Gourmet Pizza is superb! read more

The pizza was great and the staff was super friendly. We were here 3 times in 4 days. Can't wait to come back.

All their pizza is good but get the Grandma Pie. Trust me...it's what you want. IT'S AMAZING!!! This is my must have when I'm on the OBX. The only reason I gave 4 instead of 5 stars is because they don't have Grandma Pie year round. The service is fast and friendly, the space clean and inviting, and the pizza is always fresh and tasty. Wish they would come to Greenville! read more

You know those lazy evenings after the beach or pool when you don't feel like going out to dinner? Those are the days you are thankful for great pizza delivered right to your door. This was our first time ordering from Slice Pizzeria and it was some of the best pizza we have had. Highly recommended. read more

Good, not great. Their virtue is that you can order pizza by the slice, selecting from one of the pies on display. You pay, get your drink, and sit down in the very small dining area and wait for your slices to be delivered. The wait isn't long. They have thick Chicago-style pies, as well as thin crust, which is what we had. The pizza is good, but not earth-shaking. It's better than most beach pizza -- I'm beginning to despair about really good beach food. There are several tables outside, which are probably better options than having people waiting to order hovering by your inside table. read more

I can't speak much to the NY style pizza as I will probably NEVER agree that anyone makes a NY pizza as good as a true NY pizzeria. I will say that those of you complaining that the pizza is "too greasy", have obviously NEVER had a true NY slice. Those from NYC, blot slices or hold them down to "drain" the oil off of them. That said, I truly enjoyed, Slice Pizzeria on our family's recent vacation to the OBX this past weekend. Our family used the wonderful Yelp friends we have to choose our dinner on our first night in KDH. We opted for dining in and, luckily for us, there was a table that sat four right near the pizza display. We ordered a caesar salad, large Chicago style pizza, 1/2 cheese, 1/2 pepperoni, onion and jalapeño, two drinks and two kid's drinks which came in a souvenir cup. The service was courteous and efficient. The caesar salad was your typical fare, but if it were bad I would've remembered so I wasn't disappointed. I doubt you would be either. The cook came out to ask us if we'd like it cut to accommodate our family which I truly appreciated. The Chicago style pizza was great! The crust was was crisp on the bottom and cooked all the way through. We ALL really enjoyed the pizza and dinner as a whole. The food aside, the music was really rocking. I had a hard time managing my table manners and not singing along. The place was clean, the food was great, relatively inexpensive. What more could you ask for? read more

Order by the slice but be prepared to wait. We stopped in at one in the afternoon and the line was long, and never seemed to get shorter. We finally ordered and then waited a fair bit to get our pizza- it was being warmed. This location has a small selection of tables and we sat by the door- the fan over top of the door kept going on every time Someone walked in or out- it was not super pleasant. The pizza itself was ok, there was a good selection to choose from including these bun type things stuffed with spinach, cheese, etc. Just ok. Will probably try a local pizza parlor next time we are in the mood for pizza. read more

Pizza is delicious and they rarely turn you away because they are to busy !! Definitely a good business to support and enjoy!!

This is pretty good for beach pizza. Now York style pizza at a decent price. It's not the best I've ever had, but far from the worst. It's not really a sit down restaurants, it's more like take out and counter service with a small bar. If the weather is nice their patio has a few extra seats. My only real complaint is they refused my AMEX. read more

Who comes to the beach to eat pizza?! This gal when it's this place! Oh so good!! We absolutely love the deep dish and have to visit at least once during every trip. Perfect customer service and not one time have we been disappointed with the food. read more

This is how good Slice Pizzeria is. While out earlier in the day shopping we got 3 incredible recommendations from various people to go to Slice, 2 from locals and 1 from an out of towner all in the span of 5 mins maybe. So how could we not try this place after that? I'm so happy we did. We get to Slice and each decided to try a couple of slices apiece and from the first bite, we were in heaven. Everything from the toppings to the cheese to the melt in your mouth crust was to die for! We enjoyed Slice so much that we bragged about it all night long to the other members of our vacation party and the next night ordered 2 whole pies for dinner. Everyone was in agreement on our choice with Slice being the best pizza on the OBX. We love Slice so much we even purchased t-shirts from them as well! read more