Okay, what did I do wrong people? I am going against the grain... I didn't like the pizza... Is there a secret to ordering here? I had to go El Boro with a regular pepperoni and mushroom pizza to please the masses. Should I have ordered something else? I admit, I do like Chicago style, deep dish the best, but I've had my share of thin crust that I've dug. Now, everyone's really going to hate me... the pizza crust was like cardboard, the cheese was rubbery and there was hardly any sauce on it. There, I said it. Sorry! So is there something else I should be getting here or did I just come on an off day? I'm open to suggestions... this place is in my hood and rocks so many of your worlds, what's the secret!? read more

Believe the hype: Slice is really, really good. It's the real deal. Being married to a former New Yorker who treats a good pizza shop like a temple, I can say that this shop is as close to a New York pizzeria as we get in the 'Burgh. Slices on display in a case at the register, cooler full of pop (including really yummy root beer) on the wall when you walk in, pies of a million different varieties to order for take-out or dine-in. The crust is nice and thin. The slices are huge. There's just the right amount of grease and crispiness to the pizza, and a healthy dose of cheese and toppings. It's basically what a perfect by-the-slice slice looks like. (They also have a hearty stock of pepper flakes, Parmesan cheese, and some little jar at the front labeled 'magic garlic stuff' that is really pretty magical.) Also, since the downstairs seating is itty bitty, there is a second floor seating area as well. Just place your order at the counter and they'll bring it up. The staff is super nice (which, okay, maybe disqualifies it as a *real* New York pizzeria), and they're patient with you if you take ten years trying to pick what slice you want (sorry about that, too many choices!). Yes, it's a bit out of the way for us cityfolk (the South Hills? But don't we have to cross a RIVER and use a TUNNEL to get there??), but it's absolutely worth going out for. It's right off the T line, and we had no trouble finding street parking on a Saturday night, even though the shop was packed. We may not make the trip to the South Hills very often, but I have a feeling that any journey we make out that way will include a route that passes by Slice. read more

Great spot for a family to eat before the pirates game. Had pre game special. Easy access to the ballpark. They don't serve beer once the gates are open but you can bring in from the stadium. This will be our go to stop since atrias closed. read more

Let's face it. Pizza is always pretty good no matter where you get it from. However, every time I get a SLICE at SLICE on Broadway, it tastes better and better and better!! And the price can't be beat for the quantity and quality. The restaurant is bright, nicely decorated, and clean and has a few tables/seats so that you can enjoy your food there, or take it to go. They also have delivery service on the weekends if you prefer to have your food brought to you. I'm a big fan of their hand crumbled spicy sausage for the toppings, and the specialty margherita pizza!! I am really happy to have a great business run by good people in my neighborhood like this and look forward to enjoying a Slice on Broadway for many years to come! read more

Visited Pittsburgh on Sunday to shop at Ikea. Asked Google what the best pizza in the 'burgh was and the Slice was listed among many others. I crave New York style pizza with a passion, and Cleveland just doesn't have any I would consider good "New York" style. Man, am I glad that we went here. The pizza was awesome. Thin crust and crispy, just the way it is supposed to be. I had the pepperoni, while my wife had the margarita. We both loved it. Now about the atmosphere. It's a simple hole in the wall. But the music is great, and the cooks were singing along with the Italian music that was playing. We simply loved it. The best part was, while getting a box for the leftovers, I added another large slice and a Coke Zero for the ride back to the 'Land, and the manager added it for no charge. Free, in other words. Awesome! Highest recommendation. Can't wait to go back to the 'Burgh for some more great pizza. read more

I work at a diner but my Co workers and I wanted pizza, first we thought we would just have pizza Hut deliver, but I suggested how about I pick us up slice on Broadway, and everyone said yes!!! And wow were we glad we did!!!! Everyone loved the pizza, the person that made the pizza was steven very polite and nice. The chef at the diner is from new York and not from the area, he said that is one of the best pizzas he's had since he's been in Pittsburgh, said it taste like new York pizza, I'm so glad we ordered there, even though it was just extra cheese and pepperoni and half supremo, still delicious, I took menus we'll be trying other items for sure!!!!! read more

Decent pizza, but certainly not the best in Pittsburgh. When a place is called "slice," you'd think the slices would be something special. Instead, they have pre-made plain pizza, add whatever toppings you want, and stick it back in the oven. I think I would like Slice more if people would stop calling it the best pizza in town. read more

Slice On Broadway is a relatively new pizza joint but they have already carved a pretty solid reputation. I have eaten their pizza a bunch of times now and I can attest to the fact that the pizza is very consistent and you can expect that it will be made the same every time (probably because they have the same pizzaman working there every single time I have been in, he must pull 60 hours a week at least). They have a little dining room on the main floor and I think there may be a dining room upstairs too but I can't imagine it gets much use. I ordered a large cheese, which is 16 inches and less than $12 which is a solid price for the quality of ingredient, but truthfully I would have rather paid an extra dollar to not have gotten such a skimpy pie. The pizzas are made the traditional way of sliding the pies straight onto a brick oven, the pizzaman is very good at keeping the pies nice a round too. They do use a bit too much corn meal on the dough and it ends up a bit on the sandy side, also you get some charred black dust remains on the bottom of your pie because they don't clean the oven enough as they go. The pie was well done and crispy with a nice dark brown color. This pizza is close to being really good but unfortunately they are a little too skimpy on the everything and what you end up with is a really really dry pizza. I'm talking Jesus' bones dry. If you are one of those fat assholes who dips everything in ranch dressing than this pizza very well may be perfect for you but I am having a bit of trouble raw dogging it. The dough is pretty plain but it tastes fine. It doesn't have too much of a distinguishing taste aside from a slight salty breadyness. They are stretching it pretty thin so it is hard to gauge it but it seems like a medium density, slight airiness, a few healthy bubbles in the dough and no doughiness. The salt in the dough combined with the saltiness of the cheese and the general lack of other flavors ends up making the whole pie a bit too salty. The dough is a bit on the dry side, which may not have been a bad thing if the rest of the pie didn't follow suit. Despite being really thin it actually help up very well, you could hold the slices straight without them drooping. I feel like it would not have help up as well if the rest of the pizza hadn't been so lite in the pants. The sauce is actually really delicious but they are so brutally skimpy with it that you don't get to taste it at all. I tried to order it with extra sauce once and instead of putting extra sauce on the pie they just made it as normal and then pooped 2 or 3 odd dollops of sauce oddly in the middle on the top of everything else. The sauce has a really nice garlic sweetness with nice pieces of high quality tomato. Unfortunately they do the bullseye sauce distribution pattern like most shops around here. I guess since we are in western PA their thought is that God will distribute the sauce while the pie is cooking. Keep praying fellas! They are using high quality mozzarella with some provolone in the mix too, its a nice blend. The cheese coverage is pretty much perfect too. They use the most appropriate amount of cheese of any pizza shop in Pittsburgh and it would be awesome if they weren't so stingy about the sauce. All in all this place is still better than most of the shops in Pittsburgh just based on how consistent they are. I wish they would just put enough of their delicious sauce on the pizza. I hope the 10 cents per pie they are saving on the sauce is worth having such dry pizza, I really do. I hope that there is a guy in the Bahamas right now just swimming Scrooge McDuck style in all of the tomatoes that didn't end up on my pizza. 6/10 read more

Used to be my favorite pizza shop. Now everytime I order the crust is overcooked. Also there is a young snooty biatch who works there who i believe is related to ownership, not friendly, also took 40 minutes for 4 slices of pizza for eat in the one time i went. I didnt get a sorry for the wait etc. I swear people dont have good customer service let alone common sense any more. This is the world we live in today:) read more

We have been eating pizza from SLICE on Broadway for years. We loved it. All I can do now is say, "What happened?" We ordered our usual large mushroom and pepperoni and were terribly disappointed. The crust seemed to be the same wonderful crust, but the cheese was horrible at best. It tasted like the cheap cheese that the cheap pizza stores are known for. It was chewy and without flavor. Please go back to your original recipe......raise the price if need be...but don't ruin your business! read more

I love their pizza -- especially a red sauce with fresh basil and fresh ricotta plus veggies. I've never gotten an order in less than an hour, but that's a good sign in my book: they take their time and the pizza is hot when it gets here. Plus, the managers and staff are great and it's locally owned. read more

If you are nearby you have to try Slice on Broadway. One of the best pizza joints around town. They might take a little longer than the other surrounding pizza places, but that's because the pizza is out of this world. Well worth the wait!!!! Never disappointed!!! They know how to make a mouth watering pizza and the the staff is trained to handle any situation that comes their way. read more

Decent pizza however I am walking distance to this place and every time I have ordered it takes over and hour and a half and the pizza arrives cold. So if you would like a pizza in a few hours that you heat up in the oven this is the place for you. read more

Never mind the fact that we live right across the street... but the pizza is amazing. The Fancy Pants is by far one of my all-time favorite ever. Spicy thinly sliced prosciutto, goat cheese, and spinich... Mmmmmm! Funny enough, my second favorite is plain cheese! The guys that work there really are the finishing touch on a tasty pizza place. Always nice, friendly, making suggestions, busing tables (even though they really dont have to!) They always remember us, and even bring out "nice" glasses when we show up with a bottle of wine. They are true Beechview supporters too, which is what makes Beechview the special "hidden gem" neighborhood that it is. The newly renovated upstairs makes it a much more spacious place: Sit downstairs for a quick "slice," Or go upstairs with your family for a nice sit down. In the summer, they put a couple tables out on the sidewalk. Hop right on the T when you're done, or wave to it going by! read more

Fantastic crispy, yet chewy crust, fantastic sauce and all fresh ingredients... Best pizza in Pittsburgh. read more

I once ate slice on Broadway two days in a row and didn't even feel guilty about it. This place is hands down the best pizza in Pittsburgh. The crust is thin and crispy and the sauce is perfectly zesty. I always order a standard pepperoni pizza and I have never been let down- quality is consistent and honestly for the price (~$20 for an XL) you can NOT beat it. Each time I've called to order delivery their staff has always been friendly even in times where I assume they are extremely busy. I never feel rushed by them to place my order and you have the option to pay over the phone with a credit card which is extremely convenient. The ONLY downside is their delivery seems to always take about an hour or so, which has me impatiently hawking at my door awaiting the arrival of the delivery man. However, I assume that's because they are making everything fresh, which takes time, so I can't knock them for that. Id eat this pizza hot, cold, luke warm- whatever temperature, anywhere, any day, anytime- it's seriously that good. I love you slice on Broadway, never change. read more

One of the best pizza places I've ever had. When I lived in Beechview I ordered from them constantly. Now that I've moved I'm sad that I can't order from them anymore. Their pizza has won numerous awards, and for good reason! read more

Anyone that has given this place less than 5 stars has no clue what good pizza is supposed to be like. Slice is consistently great, timely, always friendly, and one of my favorite pizza places of all time. Crunchy crust, thin pizza but not so thin it falls apart, perfect cheese to sauce ratio, not overly greasy, sauce is there but not overly present, cheese is the perfect blend of saltiness, gooey delicious perfection. It's like the pizza from the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cartoon from the late 80s/early 90s came alive and tastes just as amazing as you thought it would when Michelangelo downed like 8 slices in 3 bites. Try it, you will love it. And if you don't, go back to Chicago you thick crust loving freak. read more

First time customer,ordered a salad ,regular pie w a few toppings and the Fancy Pants pie...all were excellent ...a must,especially if you like thin crust..the salad was all fresh greens with lots of veggies read more

Slice on Broadway - Fancy Pants pie - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Pretty good pizza but they didn't have as crispy and crust as promised. This could be because the veggies sogged it down (and there were a great load of veggies!) but still just wasn't outstanding. Expect 45+mins for delivery. read more

Kind of disappointed after reading the rave reviews. Pizza (plain/cheese) was slightly above average. A little dry. I was expecting a challenge to Aiello's in Squirrel Hill, but to no avail. Garden salad was pretty good. But in the end I can't see myself returning any time real soon. Best of all though were the employees. Super nice! Give it a try at least once, maybe I'm wrong. read more

We have a range of pizza preferences in our family. Husband likes Mineos, Mother in law likes Pizza Perfecta and Father in law loves Vincent's. I don't claim allegiance to one place but I am always looking for a pizza place that has decent prices and reminds me of the array of pizza styles that I grew up with, being from Northeastern PA. So we decided to check out Slice on Broadway and I'm so glad that we did. We had our 4 year old and 2 year old in tow and we were blown away by their service and hospitality. We ordered the super larger pizza with half bacon, half mushroom. The mushrooms were fresh and the bacon was generously sprinkled. The pizza came out in 15 minutes, piping hot. We also ordered a grilled chicken salad and it was also fresh and a really generous portion. Along with great food, we had the whole first floor to ourselves, including the TV. The gentleman who served us told our four year old daughter that she could change the channel to something that she wanted to watch, and so we ended up watching NCAA gymnastics. The folks making the pizza probably wanted to see the college basketball games, but they didn't seem to mind us. In fact, when our kids started getting fussy, they brought out some extra waters to help resolve a toddler fight. Even as we were getting into our car, the same guy who served us ran out of the pizza place and returned a toy car that our son had left at the table. Basically, this place is awesome and I will definitely be back to dine-in and enjoy some pizza with the family. Thanks! read more

Called slice last night 4 different times 2 of the times they kept acting like they didn't hear what I was saying then after I repeated myself five times they got all nasty like they were high or drunk then they didn't let me tell them I wanted extra sauce I'll never call them again fioris and betos all the way .....!! read more

I was a fan of this place from the day they opened but just recently they drastically raised their prices which is problem number one. problem number two is I ordered a pizza and was not told of the price increase and they had not sent out flyers reflecting the price increase so I thought I was paying a lower price. I talked to two managers who would not let me talk to the owner who would also not call me back and who refuses to even give me a small credit for my confusion and for the benefit of the doubt. I was rudely hung up on and told that nobody there really cared what I thought. The pizza there is better than average but it is definitely not on the level of Mineo's or Fiori's and places like that. I'm extremely disappointed needless to say I will not ever patronize this place again. read more

My first time at this location and it was great! Service: The staff went above and beyond what a normal pizza shop usually does. They made sure to attend to every need and we're happy. Food: The vegetarian pizza was amazing, the veggies all mashed to create a yummy salad like topping on the pizza. The veggies were a plenty, but not overloaded. I really want to try the green monster pizza next time I come. Price: the price was average to low, definitely worth the value of the pizza and drinks. Overall: This place is great with a selection of sodas, beer, and pizza. Eat upstairs for a classic feel. read more

My favorite pizza place. One of the best I've tasted and it feels like home. The guy's at work here rock ! Always keep me coming back for more. The price is great too. Keep up the good work read more

Slice on Broadway - Buffalo chicken half and big Lou half - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped here while doing some heavy laundry at Sip& Spin. Walking distance, which made eating pizza guilt free! Really good, nice atmosphere and beer selection. read more

Ordered a pizza off their online site. ETA was 60min... at 90 min I called the store asking if it was on the way. The girl that answered did the best she could asking, whom I can only assume is a manager, about the pizza and it's location, before handing the phone over to them. All I heard were excuses about me ordering the pizza online and them "losing the ticket." Completely unacceptable. I wish I could say this is the first time this has happened, but consistent wait times of 60+ minutes for a shop that is not even 3 miles from my house, appalling. Do not order from this shop, they will not try to make it right... read more

Terrible service, under staffed. Ordered 2 salads took 1 hour and 45 minutes and were wrong. Manager blamed new staff. Steak Salad was dry and mostly large leafs of romaine. Steak was dried out cardboard like pieces. "House balsamic" was gross sludge. Their pizza is fine, but better pick-up if you want before bedtime. read more

If I could give negative stars, then MAYBE I could give an honest review. We ordered two salads at 5pm and were told there was a 45 minute delivery time. At 6:50 pm, our salads arrived, and....they were wrong. I asked for no onions or green peppers and instead got heaping piles of them. I wanted balsamic dressing, but I guess they wanted me to have ranch instead. Although after seeing the sludge they call "balsamic dressing", I may have lucked out. My boyfriend's salad had this dark grey meat that was allegedly "steak" and unfortunately he had the sludge-y balsamic dressing. We did call the restaurant and were given some pathetic excuse about a "new guy in the kitchen". The manager offered 20% off of our next order, but....there won't be one. Thanks anyway Slice. There are many other decent pizza/salad/sandwich places that deliver, and in under two hours too! read more

This was a great pizza for a great price. It was a thinnish pizza but the flavors of the crust were really prominent. They also have great ranch. read more

Outstanding pizza was cooked perfectly. Guys that work there couldn't do enough for you. You'll be seeing me again. Thanks. Bob F.

Terrible, terrible, terrible, the worst place I've ever been, they completely don't care about customers. I will never come again!!!

What can I say about this place. I stopped at the beech view location a few years ago when it first opened for a couple cuts, and I've been hooked ever since. These guys put much passion into their pizza and it shows in the food quality. The crust is thin and chewy but with a perfect crisp on the bottom. The sauce is exactly how it should be, loaded with fresh basil and fresh tomato flavor. Of course the cheese is the real deal. This is my favorite pizza in town, even better than Fiori's . TRY THE NEW THICK CRUST PIZZA! It's effing unreal. The best pizza ever!!! read more

I LOVE slice on Broadway! They always make the pizzas perfectly and the topping are so delicious! The hoagies are amazing as well! I love all the different options they have too. They do take a while to deliver but it's worth the wait! read more

Great customer service and even better pizza. We had 2 specialty pies, the slaughterhouse and the buffalo chicken... Amazing Everyone needs to support a local business like this, we will be back again. read more

We have always liked Slice and have supported it since it opened. The hoagies are very good (especially the Luca and the gonzo). The salad is wonderful. All of the pizzas are delicious (the big Lou and the Athena). We enjoy mixing and matching and have a few favorites. It is so nice to see good toppings, even premium toppings, at a reasonable price. Recently, however, I am wondering if their popularity has made them have growing pains. There is now expanded seating and you can get beer by the bottle. You can take out beer as well. They are always busy and there seem to be an increased number of employees helping to cook and deliver and serve. Sometimes it is just very hectic there. Last week, I tried to get a take-out order and ordered it as I walked up to the cash register. I kept waiting and waiting and people who were after me got served first with their order. Finally, I guess as I was looking a little bewildered, someone asked me if I was being helped. When I explained that I already had put in my order and it paid for it and have been waiting for it, they checked and it was not even started yet. I had to wait a long time and eventually receive the order. To compensate for their air, they did give me a little bit extra. Fine. I went back the very next day and called in order on the telephone. I doublecheck to make sure that they got the order right. When I got there, I still had to wait longer than they promised. I took the order, paid for it, asked the man at the checkout register if it was the right order. He said it was. When I got home, and opened the box, the order was wrong. It was red pizza instead of white pizza even though the toppings were right. All of this is just to say that, Slice is a good place. I will continue to go there. Just please doublecheck your order, be patient, and don't leave without making sure the order is correct. read more

I'm not sure why I keep giving this place a chance. I'd give the food a 7 on a scale from 1 - 10 even though they seem to use decent ingredients. The crust of their pizza is chewy, and the bottom of the pizza is hard. Their prices are too high (probably to cover ther cost of the ingredients). They NEVER quote a correct delivery time. It's always the standard "45 minutes to an hour." The past three times I've ordered, the average delivery time has been an hour and 25 minutes, which is totally unacceptable. I think this place has finally been removed from my order-in list. read more

I haven't had too much pizza in Pittsburgh since I over here from New Orleans, but it's pretty damn good compared to what I have had in my life.. Pizza in New Orleans is terrible but I have had pizza in New York and this pizza definitely holds it's own.. It's never soggy or over sauced you get a very generous amount of topping and all for a decent price.. The staff is extremely nice as well.. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in a long while. Crust was perfect - not too thick or thin, great sauce - perfect amount, right amount of cheese... just about perfect. Guys working there all friendly and accommodating. Small space and very hot on a summer day but worth it. read more