I'm not sure why I keep giving this place a chance. I'd give the food a 7 on a scale from 1 - 10 even though they seem to use decent ingredients. The crust of their pizza is chewy, and the bottom of the pizza is hard. Their prices are too high (probably to cover ther cost of the ingredients). They NEVER quote a correct delivery time. It's always the standard "45 minutes to an hour." The past three times I've ordered, the average delivery time has been an hour and 25 minutes, which is totally unacceptable. I think this place has finally been removed from my order-in list. read more

I haven't had too much pizza in Pittsburgh since I over here from New Orleans, but it's pretty damn good compared to what I have had in my life.. Pizza in New Orleans is terrible but I have had pizza in New York and this pizza definitely holds it's own.. It's never soggy or over sauced you get a very generous amount of topping and all for a decent price.. The staff is extremely nice as well.. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in a long while. Crust was perfect - not too thick or thin, great sauce - perfect amount, right amount of cheese... just about perfect. Guys working there all friendly and accommodating. Small space and very hot on a summer day but worth it. read more

Loved the pesto sauce Green Monster pizza. Also like the pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom. Great service.

Becoming a Friday Evening Tradition .. Great Pizza .. Good People .. Consistent quality .. Flavor .. Chewy Crust .. All you need is a bottle of red wine .. some Italian music .. Good company .. and a few hours to relax .. read more

Best pizza. Worst hoagies. Pizza is delicious thin crust, although occasionally burnt. Hoagies are overpriced at 8 bucks each. Buffalo chicken so small that the bread touched on both sides. Italian sub meat burnt to a crisp even on the second sub they brought as a replacement! read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in the Burgh. Great selection of specialty pizza. The hoagies are delicious. Staff is always friendly.

Slice has the best Margherita pizza, and the staff is always super friendly. This is our favorite pizza spot in town!

Worst pizza I've ever had. And if the owner blames it on the people working that night it's still his fault for hiring them. For as thin as it is how could it ever be under cooked. read more

This is literally our only go to Pizza place. We absolutely love their food & we've never had one bad experience with them. We order from here At least 3-4 times a month. Great quality food in the heart of Beechview. read more

Darren ordered some of their pizza for us on moving day and it was excellent!!!! Keep in mind I don't usually order pizza, but this was good. read more

Absolutely horrible service and the pizza was NOT in my top 10 in South Hills let alone the top in Pittsburgh. Asked for something specific. When delivered, it was wrong. When we called, the person who took the call was rude. HORRIBLE. read more

Honestly one of the best pizzas and hoagies in town.one of my favorite pizza spots. Employees are extremely helpful

Slice you did it again! Friendly service, fast delivery, and delicious food! PLUS they offer cheesecake now! We ordered the chocolate mousse cheesecake. It was probably one of the best I've ever had. For our entrees we got two ultra mega chicken hoagies. They are grilled chicken, onions, banana peppers, bacon, provolone cheese, and spicy ranch all on a freshly baked hoagie roll. Their bread comes from a local bakery, so it's always nice and fresh tasting!Huge portions too! read more

The pizza is good, when it's on time. I've placed so many orders that just don't show up. When I call, they eventually send the order but it's not uncommon to be 2 hours or more from the time of order. read more

I've loved Slice since it opened and am really happy for all of their success. I think I've had every type of pizza. The supremo and big Lou might be my favorites but that's a hard decision. All are so good. Their breadsticks and salads are also quite tasty. Their customer service is great too. I wish I could order there weekly (which is what I used to do) but the healthy diet doesn't jive with that so now it's only a special, much-enjoyed, occasional treat. read more

I am sorry to say that this place has fallen in my esteem from best pizza to eh pizza. We got the regular pie with half meatballs and half pineapple. There were several pieces that had neither topping on it at all! The pineapple was canned and the meatballs were tiny pieces of ground beef with minimal seasoning. There was hardly any cheese at all. I will say that the crust is still well done and the sauce is still good, but this place has been going downhill for a few years now and I sadly think this will be the last time we order. Sad days in a pizza lover's heart. read more

Spectacular! The folks that took care of us (we ate upstairs) were more concerned about our business than most high end restaurants we've been to. Then the pizza was delicious as well. Great Job! read more

Today, Sunday, March 22nd, in the year of our Lord 2015, we visited what too much time on Yelp has led us to believe is the last pizza place anyone in Pittsburgh need ever visit. We visited SLICE on Broadway. We were immediately faced with a choice here, and I hoped that we would not falter. 'Should we get one of their specialty pizzas everyone raves about or go the route of a standard pizza with some Italian meat on it?' Entire seconds passed as we agonized over this most important decision of the day. We chose the latter. Specifically, we ordered a small hot soppressata pizza to split, as well as a pepperoni roll and a steak and onion roll. We appeared to be the only people dining in at the moment but we headed upstairs to check it out anyway. What can I say other than that it's really obvious how that location used to be a house and how oddly endearing that is. Our rolls were brought to us very quickly. They were better than expected. They set expectations for the pizza crust very high. Most pepperoni rolls I've had have had too much dough and not enough payoff. These were essentially perfectly balanced to the point where the sauce and ranch we got for dipping were nearly redundant. I will say that the steak and onion roll was amazing and noticeably better than the pepperoni. I would absolutely order a few of those again. Our pizza was not far behind it, coming up the stairs for us probably only 10 minutes after we sat down. It looked beautiful, the meat atop it most of all. And who can say no to the little pockets that sometimes rise from a pizza, announcing their home slices as prime eating. My first impression of the pizza was that I was impressed by the sturdiness of it. They make them pretty thin here, but the slices hold up very well en route to face. The next thing I noticed was that each element of the pizza worked together so well that it was a full unit. It became difficult, in a good way, to differentiate between sauce, cheese, and toppings. It was like eating a Professionally Manufactured Pizza Product - this too is a compliment. The crust tasted to me like it was very light on flour and perhaps heavy on cornmeal. Is that a thing? I don't know, I'm not a Professional Pizza Manufacturer. Either way, my mouth was telling me that it was tasting corn and my mouth has no reason to lie to me. PAULA did not agree with this analysis, so your results may vary. It was only a couple of hours ago that I ate this pizza, but I am struggling to tell you anything about the sauce or the cheese. They were both perfectly adequate but did not excite me. The soppressata was the only non-crust highlight. And honestly, while the crust was remarkable, it wasn't my favorite either. Bottom Line: I enjoyed the pizza at SLICE. It did not change my perception of pizza as a whole or convince me that I need to return for more. I am willing to accept that ordering a specialty like the Fancy Pants may have been a wiser move, but I like to order pretty similarly across each pizza place for the purpose of comparison unless there is a specific style or topping that a shop is known for. Like 'you may as well not even go to X place if you don't get their sicilian'. From reading reviews, I did not get the impression that I needed to go that route at SLICE, but my lack of enthusiasm for their soppressata pizza may prove that their specialties are the way to go, at least for me. read more

This is our go to pizza place in the city! Awesome pizza made by a family. They keep the family business going. Good customer service for mistakes they may make and totally worth the price! read more

Pizza was decent, nothing special but very little sauce. Breadsticks super thin and rubber-like when eating. Ordered a buffalo chicken hoagie, for $9.50 it's not even that big. Hoagie bun was super crunchy and rock hard. read more

We ordered some pizza for a quick dinner after arriving back into town. They deliver, which was a huge and welcome surprise! No charge for delivery! We tried the green monster that I had read about. The large pizza is definitely large! There wasn't much pesto, but I really enjoyed the pizza! The artichokes were yummy and plenty of peppers and feta! It was a winner. My fiance got a pepperoni pizza and said it was good. Not the best ever, but he enjoyed it. The pizza crust was my favorite part! Nice crisp and chewy! read more

We were looking for a place to get some lunch and this place had great reviews. Their great reviews are definitely for good reason. We were warmly greeted upon arrival, and everybody was extremely friendly. We ordered a large sausage pizza which was outstanding, a anti-pasta salad which was gigantic fresh and delicious, and a really top notch toasted Italian sub. I am pretty sure that the guy helping us was the owner, which was really great to see him working on New Year's Day. Even the delivery guy asked me if everything was all right with my meal as he walked past. That kind of service and friendliness is what makes this place a five star rating. Highly recommended. Oh yeah, and the little pizza rolls they sell are killer, I could make a whole meal just out of those... read more

Good, solid pizza place. Its now my picky significant other's new favorite pizza place. Their pizza is good. It a thin crust and very crisp. So crisp, that when you take a slice there's no fear of ripping a delicate piece it because it just snaps. The sauce is bright and sweet. Their sauce to cheese ratio is heavy on the cheese and light on the sauce. Good quality cheese and overall good quality of toppings. read more

I'm not sure what happened to this place. I haven't ordered for awhile and I did tonight. The food took 1 hour and 50 min. The expectation was about an hour, hour and 15 min. We got the Italian hoagies and pizza. Everything was cold. The lettuce soggy. Not worth the price. Should have stuck with my usual. read more

Best Margherita outside of Italy. You must taste to believe :) Mamma mia! read more

I heard a lot about this location, and the pizza was good, but I had much higher expectations for the number of Top 10 lists Slice was listed on. read more

The best delivery in the city, hands down. Not as sloppy as Milano's, not as basic as Pizza Parma, lots of varieties, salads are full and good, and sandwiches are great. read more

Your marketing people should be fired, if you have any. You advertise in the Pirates booklet that is handed out at every game and offer 15% off. This 15% is not honored on the days the Pirates in town....I'm sure you are very busy on game days despite this.... I am a season ticket holder and will never taste what you say is delicious pizza. I will take my business to Atria's who also advertises in the same booklet and doesn't have fine print like you do. They are using their advertising dollar wisely. read more

Slice on Broadway is one of my favorite pizza places around! Living in Dormont, there are so many delicious pizza option but so many places do not deliver. Slice is one of the few places that will bring a decent pie to my doorstep. I have tried so many different pies and they are all good. The Frisky Billy goat is one of my favorites with meatballs, goat cheese and roasted red peppers. I also really like their hoagies. Both the Gonzo and the Luca are really top notch. The only complaint, if you can even call it that, is that I wish they made their specials of the day known. Ocassionally I will see something on instagram but I think it would be helpful for the consumer to post them on their website. Although, really, I couldn't care less. It is good pizza and that is really what matters. read more

Yum, yum and more yum! Amazing pizza and they deliver :) Nice thick & crispy crust, plentiful toppings & just the right amount of pizza sauce & cheese. Kudos to Slice!! We will most certainly be back. read more

Great Pizza and Hoagies.... best in the city. Also very friendly staff. The sauces are awesome and hoagies are huge. If you are in the beechview area, you need to order here. it's a must. Grab a SLICE. read more

Great brick oven-like pizza! Tasty, thin crust with super fresh toppings! Locally owned.

Not a super huge fan of thin crust but I find Slice to be pretty tasty anyway. My favorite is just plain pepperoni or a delicious Hawaiian (add bacon, duh). We've ordered from here a few times even though we don't live in Beechview (the in laws do and order from Slice all of the time). Agreed on another review that they should add more of that delicious sauce; sharing is caring after all. Also slightly disappointing that the pineapple on the Hawaiian isn't fresh. Still, we'll definitely continue to order an occasional Slice. read more

I dined at the location at PNC Park Friday night, 15 April 2016. There is not enough seating. One must arrive when the gates open to be assured of securing a table and the only tables have high chairs onto which one must climb: not for everyone. Although it is thinner than I prefer, the pizza was good; it looks delicious and it is. The sauce, crust, and cheese combine nicely, and are good quality. The only facet of the pizza that was poor was the "steak" topping; it resembled and tasted like "Steakum" frozen product. I object to the presence of a tip jar for counter service for a $24 pizza. I should not have to provide a subsidy to an employer that does not wish to compensate its employees adequately. read more

The pizza is really good. The wait for delivery though is a bit too long. They said 45 minutes and I got it an hour and a half later. This has happened on two separate occasions so now I just pick up instead read more

This is some of the best Pizza and hoagies I have ever had. Stopped back in the old neighborhood an found this amazing place. I now drive more than 30 minutes for pizza... Ya it's that good. I've had the Guido, veggie, and the cheese Steak pizzas and the Caprese hoagie. All fantastic. I usually don't get excited about pizza but I have eaten pizza all over and this is some of the best anywhere. Go to slice if you like pizza! read more

Yesterday I had the BBLT. It was quite delicious! They also have a menu that you can get just a slice or two! They are big slices and very reasonably priced. I eat here a lot as they are just down from my business. If your looking for some good pizza shop fare in the neighborhood, I recommend Slice! read more

Definitely our favorite pizza place in Pittsburgh. The ingredients are very fresh and their specialty pizzas are delicious. Their salads and hoagies are great too. I highly recommend! read more

Just okay, given how great I'd always heard it was. I had two slices and a soda at the Slice in East Liberty this week. It cost $9, and I gave the guy a dollar. It isn't bad pizza. It just isn't great pizza, especially at the price. The slices are large, at least. Next time, I'll probably just have one. read more