Pizza!!!!! It's been a while since we have had Slice and it did not disappoint! Got a large red/white sauce pizza with garlic and the Italian stallion calzone. So good! The pizza has such a great flavor and while I don't personally like ricotta ( just not my thing) everyone else loved the calzone - the flavor was delectable!!! Will definitely be back ... read more

See all

Just moved to the area. Found this spot on my walk and decided to order. It was so good!! Everything was flavorful and exactly as I ordered it. Staff was also super friendly and nice. I'm surprised why this isn't more highly rated. On my first night here I did try another "local highly rated spot" and THAT was disappointing. So glad I found a closer and better pizza spot :) will returning! read more

Pizza is decent (and that's saying a lot coming from a New Yorker). Service is solid, prices run a little high for pizza, but I still grab a slice whenever I'm in the area taking my dog to the park. Easy, convenient stop if you're nearby read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Slice on Broadway is an excellent pizza joint. Great tasting pizza; good sauce, good crust, and good toppings. Reasonable prices. One of my favorite pizza places in the south hills. If you want a good pizza, you can't go wrong here. read more

Potentially the worst pizza I've ever had. Ordered a large Rico's Favorite, the pizza came sitting on top of a pool of grease. I understand pizza is going to be greasy and there's plenty of pizza shops that you have to dab with a paper towel on top. 3/4 of the under carriage was saturated in grease. It was soggy and greasy and each of us had one slice and threw it out. I don't like blasting small businesses like this, but if I was the owner and someone game me a pizza like this, I would be ashamed. Everyone has bad days and maybe this was just a bad day but wow was this a tough first time trying Slice on Broadway. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Let me start by saying Slice USED to be a staple in our household...by used to I mean we will no longer support or order from this business again. The quality over the last year has gone wayyyyy down hill. Sauce is now flavorless, crust is super thin (see attached picture), and they barely include toppings as if to encourage customers to spend more just to have an adequate amount of topping (see in picture). We asked for pepperoni and mushrooms and barely any came on the pizza. Might as well have just ordered a plain pizza with how little came on it. Slice is likely trying to cut corners to save costs but unfortunately they just lost a loyal customer. This pizza was TRASH!!!!!!!! For $40, save your money people!! I mean damn, even Pizza Hut stays consistent lol read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

We live right behind Slice and are big fans. The employees are wonderful, as is the food!

Great slices. It lives up to the hype. Fast and cordial. And it was pretty cheap. That's about it. God bless

Another great pizza option in Pittsburgh. Thin crust, great sweet sauce (in my opinion), typical pizza cheese blend. Quick prompt service, great resourceful Togo packaging. Clean pickup. Would order again. read more

Slice on Broadway - 16" Large half pepperoni/half olive - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The pizza is excellent but I must say that all of the employees at this shop are top notch people. They really care about their customers. And I have seen this consistently each time I pass through Pittsburgh and have the time to stop for an excellent pie. read more

I honestly don't know how this place isn't rated higher. I see older reviews dragging the rating down, but we order delivery here regularly and I think it deserves a better rating. The pizza here is great. It's more floppy thin crust, but the flavor is so good. There are exactly zero other pizza places that I can order delivery and say it's good (in my area). The sauce, cheese, toppings and crust are always tasty. Now, sometimes the pizza arrives avid it looks like it got knocked around a bit and the cheese is a little shifted, but that's going to happen with delivery. I can think of a couple of times that the pizza wasn't great, crust burnt, but I've been ordering from this place for nearly as long as they've been delivering and I'd say that's a pretty solid record of great orders over that math years (it's got to be more than 10yrs). The ginormous pizza feeds us for DAYS (two people). It's a thrill haha The sandwiches, I've rarely deviated from the spicy Italian. SO GOOD. The only complaint I have is that I'm pretty sure it's gotten smaller for the price over the years (shrinkflation?) Sometimes the bread is a little more toasted than I'd like, but it's never bad or inedible. I can't bring myself to order any other Sammie's because I love this one too much. We didn't order the sandwich on our last delivery, but I have included pics of the pizza. Can't wait to order again. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Pizza was amazing great flavor! And amazing services everyone was very welcoming !!! Great location definitely recommend read more

Slice on Broadway - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Tasty pizza and steak rolls, garlic knots. One of the go-to spots in Beechview/Dormont

We've ordered delivery from Slice on several occasions and have never been disappointed! The pizza is always hot and delicious when it's delivered! Today we got the Alotta Ricotta and my god it's my new favorite! The crispy prosciutto, fresh basil, and ricotta sauce was perfection! read more

Slice on Broadway - Alotta Ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Everything! Pizza crust was cardboard! Calzone was about a 1/4 inch high. Crust also like cardboard. Hoagie came on what looked like a French baguette. It's like they didn't use water when making the dough. Better off putting ketchup on an Amazon box and throwing my money out on the street. read more

Staff very cool. Im not a NY style pizza guy but this is incredible pie no matter what kind of pizza you prefer. Def a must try

I was put on hold three times before I placed the order and also the cheese did not even go out to the edge of the crust or near it. It seemed like when you get the Tuesday special they get Cincy with the cheese other than that it was good. It was OK read more

Good food for decent price. We were regulars when we lived close and always loved their pizza

Asked for no olives, pizza was received with a ton of olives. The entire pizza was soggy. Worst experience yet.

Delicious slices, red sauce super flavorful. Awesome service. Would highly recommend and go back when we visit again. Outside tables on a nice day were perfect. read more

I am mad that I believed the reviews and awards. WTH!! I just spend $60 and my 3 yr old won't even eat it. Pizza was hard borderline stale tasting crust, with what tasted like American cheese both cheese and sauce were skimpy, The salad greens were wilted beyond recognition. My chicken parm was the worst! cubes of processed rubbery chicken with no breading on top of a mound of overcooked starchy noodles, Inedible! I am eating rice cake crisps for dinner while I type this. read more

Place is going downhill ordered pizza for delivery crust was burned and not edible. Will need to find a new place for pizza read more

Slice on Broadway - $20 burnt pizza crust - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I am sorry. Ordered a small Athens pizza with extra toppings and small salad. Thank god weather is cold. The pizza came here ice cold with hardly feta cheese at all. I am heating up it up my oven right and happened to some mozzarella that I added. I am sorry. I never do this but my order was at least. $45.00 and left a 20% tip plus the driver some cash. It just was not good after waiting two hours to get it. read more

Tonight was my first time trying Slice on Broadway after hearing great things, and I quite possibly had the best experience out of any of the pizza shops I've been to. I ordered my pizza (accidentally) 20 minutes before closing, and the guys on the other end of the phone didn't even hint at being upset. My pizza was ready as soon as I got there, and it was my favorite pizza in all of Pittsburgh, but that isn't what made my experience so great. When I called, I asked be guys if the salad was big enough for two people and the guy on the receiving end said not really, but he could do his best for me since they were getting ready to close. When I picked up my pizza it was dark out, and the guy who already went out of his way to give me a little bigger of a salad then walked me to my car to ensure my safety. You don't find quality like that too often. I will absolutely be returning! read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I can't rave enough about this place!!!!! Just amazing. We ate in and brought our own beer. It is BYOB. For a six pack, it was a $5 fee. Not bad at all! One of the guys working gave us frozen beer glasses to keep our beers cold! Very thoughtful. We had a bunch of different pizzas at our table. They were all delicious! We had a thicker crust red sauce pizza with bacon and sliced steak, thin crust red sauce half cheese & pepp bacon and banana peppers, a margarita pizza, and a thin crust white sauce bacon and prosciutto pizza!! All were soooo good. Not chunky sauce. The crusts on all the pizzas were cooked perfectly. We are all extremely picky about pizza and were a little skeptical at first when arriving, but it was great!! We can't wait to come back again. The service was great. Staff was all very friendly. One of the staff even walked one of the ladies home that had a cane. Overall, wonderful customer service. Willing to go above and beyond. read more

See all

I ordered delivery. Was delivered piping hot faster than they had promised. The pizza was great -even cold the next day.

Great legit NY pizza with the freshest of ingredients. Made the way pizza should be made. This place reminds me of a pizzeria I worked at as a kid. Great food and awesome atmosphere. Thanks guys! read more

Really good pizza. Slice will probably become one of the pizza places in our regular rotation of pizza shops. The crust is thinner with some crispness but not to hard. The sauce is really nice with some of the Italian spice and good tomato flavor. We also had the little guy salad and we were able to add a couple of extra veggies at no extra cost. read more

We've always had great pics from here. We tried the stuffed pepper pizza this time and everyone loved it (even the kids).

I ordered delivery. I got a large Garden Pie, which was loaded with delicious toppings, much more variety than your typical "veggie lovers pizza" at any other pizza place. My friends thought the pizza was a bit too thin, and fell apart due to so many toppings, but I didn't mind it much. But this was kind of more than a knife-and-fork pizza! The big guy salad was fresh and delicious. They included more than one ranch dressing for the salad, which I appreciate because i split it with my friend. Slice, in my opinion, has superior, unique, quality ingredients. They have a smaller menu than typical shops, because what they do, they do it very well! Every time I get Slice, I wonder why I get pizza anywhere else! I would highly recommend them for a change from your run of the mill pizza experience. It's no wonder why their locations have popped up all over the south hills. Support small business! Especially for pizza night! read more

Absolutely delicious pizza! Came to the shop from 30 minutes away because it is that good. Waited a bit longer than was told for pick-up but they have a note in the store warning that they may be possible. Friendly staff kept me notified while I was waiting as to the status of my order. read more

This is probably the best pizza I have had in Pittsburgh. It's a shame that other places can't seem to get it right. I have only ever gotten slices from here. I am sure a whole pie would be good too. The crust was crisp without the whole dough being over cooked. The sauce had a sweetness to it. The cheese was solid. Simple ingredients but put together and cooked the right way can make all the difference. The parking around the place can be busy so off hours may be better times to go. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Excellent pizza. Perfect undercarriage. Great tasting cheese and sauce. Sauce is the perfect amount of sweetness. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio. Also their ranch is delicious. 10/10!! read more

This place is in my top 5 favorite pizza places in Pittsburgh. Whether it's been slices or whole pies, their pizza is fantastic. I tried the steak & onion roll today & it wasn't good. Very little steak & I didn't even taste onion. It's mostly bread. read more

Great pizza if you are a fan of very thin slices. The ingredients are definitely fresh which makes for a great flavor. Also, the pizza is cooked perfectly with just the right amount of crisp. They also have a great house made ranch which goes well with the pizza. I also had the breadsticks and a buffalo chicken roll. Neither of these were very good, so I will stick to just the pizza when I come back. On top of the good food, the service here was great for a pizza shop. Every worker was extremely friendly with the customers including myself. They check to make sure your order is right and also made sure to hold the exit door as people walked out with their food. read more

excellent pizza and a menu with a lot of variety. I personally recommend the pesto and chicken pizza, it was delicious and had a fair balance of oil. the service was fast. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pesto Chicken Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Dylan had that shit hot and ready, I made it home by puck drop at a 6:35 order time. 5 stars Dylan needs a raise! Great experience 10/10 read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Very good thin crust pizza. I prefer it to Mineos and Aiellos. It is out of the way, and a pretty rough hole in the wall, but worth checking out for yourself at least once as part of your Pittsburgh Pizza journey. read more

The best pizza I've had in Pittsburgh. Perfect crust, really good sauce and perfect ratio of cheese. Better ingredients than most pizza joints use. read more

Out of all of the pizza joints in the Pittsburgh area I've tried, Slice takes the cake every time. Their pizza is by far the best! I live closest to their Broadway location and am never disappointed! read more