This is my favorite and go to pizza and sub spot in Carnegie. The thin and crispy crust is great, even better, they don't flood the pie with sauce like so many other places. The toppings and ingredients are always fresh and super flavorful. Try the green pesto sauce instead of the red, it really adds a whole different level of flavor. Aside from the pies, their sub and roll selections are amazing. The Luca is a must try. read more

I used to love Slice's pizza, but it's definitely not anywhere near as good as it used to be. The last few times I've ordered, it's been over cooked and dry, and way too light on the sauce & cheese. I tried the pepperoni stuffed breadsticks last night and they're pretty awful- not actually breadsticks but pepperoni folded btwn tasteless pizza crust. The hoagies are small. Not sure I'll try again. read more

They have the best veggie hoagie I've ever tasted, and their mushroom pizza is also top notch (fresh mushrooms).

Quick, fresh delivery to my hotel, and the pizza was great! Had a pepperoni roll to start and followed up with a tasty New York style pizza. Not the absolute best pizza I've ever eaten, but I've had a wide variety of pizza and this was definitely high on my list. Great local spot! read more

Some of the best Pizza I've had in a very long time! Tried a sandwich here the first time (about a year ago) and it was OK, but then had Pizzaa few days ago... Wow! As good as I remember from a local Pizza place in Colorado from many years past. There are so many Pizza places around Pittsburgh to try, but Slice will be my fall back and, since I now live here in Carnegie, my home town favorite. Priced right too! Try it... you'll like it I'm sure. read more

Some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh! The slices are HUGE and the price is right. I order Slice at least once a week and have never been disappointed - delivery, pick up, eat in....you name it. MUST TRY: buffalo chicken pie read more

I love their salads. They always use the freshest ingredients, definitely worth it.

It seems like they have a lot of time management problems here. My order was estimated to be ready in 40 minutes. I showed in after 50 minutes. This allots turn plenty of time. They rudely tell me at the counter that it will be another 30 minutes with apology. This is unacceptable behavior from a long time established business. Get it together guys. read more

Favorite pizza place!! Great pizza and bigger better portions than the chain pizza places. And cost less!

Pretty good pizza, definitely a top 3 option when you're looking for a quick lunch in Carnegie. I ordered a slice of white pizza and a meatball/banana pepper roll for lunch. It was ready a few minutes after ordering which is always a plus. The white pizza had spinach and tomatoes, very thin crust (I'm usually not a fan but it worked well here) and the meatball /banana pepper roll was excellent. Very clean looking restaurant and the staff was very polite. read more

This is the best NY style pizza I've had in Pittsburgh no joke. The bottom was actually crispy too, we only got sausage and pepperoni but I'm really glad we stopped here. Everyone working there was cool to talk too as well. I will be back soon for sure. read more

Slice On Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

I had this pizza for the first time at my 10th birthday in July 2010. For the next 10 years, Slice on Broadway has remained my family's go-to pizza and has never disappointed. Now, literally 10 years later, I'm about to turn 20 and I'm sure we'll be having slice again! My boyfriend and I have been getting Slice at least once a month (often more) since we started dating a few years ago. Love this pizza, absolutely my favorite! read more

Love Slice specialty pies and they deliver! Great pizza and they have great salads, even the side salad is excellent (think it's the homemade croutons and dressing). Only once did I ever have any issue, just kid working with bit of attitude. Who knows maybe it was closing time? read more

Best pizza in Pittsburgh!!! Thin New York style nice crunch in the crust and great flavor in sauce, cheese and toppings!!! Definitely worth the trip, I also had a pepperoni roll and buffalo chicken rolls in the past that we're awesome. I like a lot of the places in South Hills Area but this is my favorite...give it a shot!!! Support local during these times!!! read more

Today I ordered their Veggie Pie which is a combination of fresh baby spinach, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, black olives, green peppers, roasted red peppers, and sliced red onions. Vegetable pizza is almost sac religious for some but this was absolutely AMAZING. The crusts even stayed very crispy which is usually a problem when you order lots of veggies on a pizza. I would think their other pizza options are just as fantastic. SOB is my new pizza delivery go to. read more

Discovered Slice after we moved into our new house. I can't get enough. Everything about their pizza is heaven. The cheese, the crust, the sauces, & the ratio are all superb. They do a New York style pizza and they do it well. Also have tried their breadsticks and they are super yummy. I've gotten take out and delivery. Both ways have been. Great. Delivery has always been quicker than they said, except for one Sunday BUT it was a Sunday and the Steelers were playing so I don't hold that against them. The prices a slightly higher than some other pizza places, but I personally think that it's worth it for the quality of the pizza you get. Dang. Now I want Slice pizza immediately. read more

GO HERE!!! I live in DC but drive to Pitt once a month to visit family. Slice on Broadway is DELICIOUS!! I've had Mineos, A'pizza Badamo, Fiori's (my 2nd fav), Beto's, Aiello's, and Spak Bros.....Slice on Broadway is number one. Thin, crispy, sauce not to sweet...and tasty. IMO - to determine the best pizza place..try the plain no frills cheese pizza. If that holds up against others...that's your winner. Also, Slice just knows how to run a business - floors, tabletops, and bathrooms were spotless...uber clean and not something I expected from a pizza joint. The cleanliness is a bonus...the pizza itself earned 5 stars on it's own. Pic here is my personal fav - extra cheese. read more

Slice On Broadway - Extra Cheese - Slice on Broadway (Carnegie/Pittsburgh) - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

They are unable to take an order and get it correct. Every single time I order there is an error in the order. When the delivery person arrived I asked him where the missing food was. He told me there was none and was insistent about it almost to the point of indignant and then asked for his tip which was already on the receipt. The manager, Tara, acted like she was doing me a favor by refunding me for the food NOT delivered. I contacted them the next day and she stated that I needed to contact them as soon as the order was delivered. I was getting ready to serve 13 guests. Who had time to contact her once again about errors that are continuous? The website always shows that our address is non-deliverable but when I call they always deliver. They have yet to fix the website. Plus I have numerous reward points to be used but again when I call the person taking the order does NOT know how to apply them to the check. read more

We ordered the basil pesto chicken pizza. Flavor wise it was okay. The main turn off how how greasy the base was. My hands were coated with grease and afterwards my mouth felt all greasy. read more

My relationship with Slice started off very rocky. We waited 2 hours for our pizza, turns out they got that wrong and said they'd give us a credit but never honored it. Having said that I decided to give them another try and their sandwiches have made up for their poor outing the first time. These sandwiches aren't the typical pizza shop sandwiches, they change it up for the better and leave the customer satisfied with a new idea of what a pizza shop sandwiches should be. read more

Overview: We were passing through on our way to Chicago and stopped to see a few sights. We asked a local where the best pizza was and he sent us to Slice on Broadway, and are we glad he did. I couldn't stop thinking about the crust, the pizza was cooked perfectly and they seem to pride themselves on high quality ingredients. Pizza Shop: Great shop, very clean and welcoming feel to it. I like that the kitchen is mostly open to the dinning area. Unique "vault," from when this place was a bank, creates a special private room for a family of 4 or 5 to dine. The kids loved it. I also always check out bathrooms, because if a place wants to cut corners the bathroom is a good place because not many guests see it. These were spotless! Service: The staff was second to none. Our order was taken promptly and all food came out accurate. They were very friendly and attentive all while giving us space to enjoy our great meal. Pizza: I like that you can get pizza by the slice here and that was one thing the local pointed out when sending us here. That way each of the kids could get their own topping and the slice would be ready for a quick grab and go. We were so charmed by the staff and setting that we decided to eat in house. Crust: awesome, made the biggest impression on me, perfectly crispy without being over cooked or too well done. It was some of the best crust I have tasted and I still think about it. Sauce: Good flavor, could tell that it was likely homemade. Cheese: nice blend of mozzarella and provolone. Perfect amount. Toppings: Pineapple was standard, then again, who the heck puts pineapple on a pizza! Sausage was good. I prefer sliced over the crumbed but the benefit of how this place does it (crumbed/clumped) was that you had a good sausage flavor in every bite. Salad: Above average pizza place salad, no iceberg lettuce, good veggies Usually I have something negative to say, but this was such an overall positive experience that nothing stands as negative. This would definitely be my pizza shop if I was a local and is also a great stop for anyone passing through that wants to grab a slice! read more

Wasn't impressed with this pizza at all.. barely any cheese and little taste. Also got a steak hoagie, for the price it was small and tasteless as well. Both the pizza and hoagie bun were extremely hard to chew. Might as well chew on cardboard. read more

The pizza was not very good. In my opinion the best pizza is in New Jersey and New York. This pizza was sloppily thrown together and messy. The toppings were uneven and the flavor was not good. I will not order from there again. read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch, knowing ahead of time that it had good reviews. We were pleased that huge slices were available along with rolls. We both got pepperoni slices and agreed the crust was very good. Nice thin but doughy body and a handle that was crisp on the outside but soft inside. The cheese was high quality and the right amount. The red sauce was on the thinner side but flavorful and definitely noticed on the slice. We tried a meatball and pepperoni roll, each served with a side of sauce. Both were tasty snacks. Will definitely be back here or to Beechview. read more

I love Slice so much, and I wish I lived closer to any of their locations. I get a whole pie with just hot soppressata. Simple and perfect. Ready for pick up in 10-15 minutes at lunch time. read more

Good pizza , these guys usually come through with great food but last night we ordered a caprese hoagie and couldn't believe how small the portion was ..very disappointing! read more

Amazing pizza!! I've been going to The Slice now for almost two years I believe and it is considerably the best pizza in Pittsburgh. If you like pizza with a thinner crust then you will thoroughly enjoy the pizza here. All of the toppings are tasty with my favorite being peperoni and sausage. Their hoagies are also very good here, though they are slightly on the smaller side of a typical hoagie. Lastly the staff at The Slice is always very friendly and great at doing their jobs. Consistently good food and great service! read more

Great pizza, slices are always ready and fresh ...plus service is always quick/friendly

Rico makes the best pizza in town. I used to work for him as well, great boss and never cuts corners when it comes to quality. When I crave pizza I order from Slice :) read more

Had their cheese and their pepperoni slices definitely good pizza nice flavor good size slices for a couple bucks you can't beat it. Definitely worth coming back to read more

Changing to one star due to the terrible customer service. They are rude and condescending. There are too many good pizza places in the area to be treated poorly here. read more

I'm really, really confused how this place has such high ratings. I've been here twice, and neither experience was particularly good. The first time, I had two slices with toppings. They were ok. Not awful, but nothing to write home about. I never judge a pizza place on slices alone, however, because they just can't compare to a whole pie. On my more recent visit, my husband and I got a large cheese pizza. This, to me, is the true test of a pizzeria. As soon as the pizza came to the table, I noticed it smelled EXACTLY like tomato soup. After a few bites, I could confirm that the sauce indeed tastes basically like tomato soup: bland, sweetish, with almost no spice, texture, or flavor. It didn't even taste very much like tomato, just so bland. The crust was very good. I loved how it was thin without turning soggy or floppy, and it had an excellent crispness. Now, I don't mind a lightly cheesed pizza, but this cheese again had very little flavor. We had to dress the pizza up with way more crushed pepper, oregano, and parmesan than normal to give it any flavor. Normally when my husband and I order a large, were assuming we'll take home about half for lunch (or, let's be real, cold breakfast). This pie was so thin and light we polished the whole thing off, and were legitimately peckish a few hours later. So while $14 isn't exorbitant, it can certainly buy you more, better pizza elsewhere. I will say, the service was excellent. All the staff was super friendly, and seemed happy to be at work, which goes a long way. I'm giving 3 stars because of the great service and because the gourmet pies with toppings look like they'd be good. read more

Was told that this is like NY pizza but I'm not too convinced. Slices are huge and a little floppy. Pizza tasted better the second day, but this isn't my favorite slice in Pittsburgh. read more

They don't deliver to the DoubleTree hotel. The shop was easy to find and clean. The pizza and sandwiches were amazing!

Delicious NY style pizza. Plain cheese or a one-topping mushroom pie hits the mark. Their supremo was a bit salty and the thin onions did not look appealing; looked like worms to be honest. Advice to them is to cut onions into diced cubes or bigger rings. read more

I'm such a sucker for a NY style thin crust pizza and Slice definitely does it right. It is the one pizza place in Pittsburgh my husband and I both agree on and we've certainly tried them all - Fiori's, Campiti's, Mineo's, Beto's, but I think hands down, Slice has them all beat. But, again, I'm partial to a thin crust which is why I love it. Before they opened their Carnegie location, we frequently drove to their original location on Broadway. If we stop during the week and I need a healthier option, their salads are also great. I know what you're thinking, why would you come here for the salad? But, I just love their house-made balsamic dressing and their spinach salad. And if I'm really still craving the pizza, they have perfect little pepperoni rolls that are delicious, as well. They have a lot of variety for a pizza shop and use all fresh ingredients. There are alos specialty pizzas and sandwiches and they deliver in the Carnegie area. And, now I'm craving Slice after writing this review... :) read more

Unfortunately, I never got to try the pizza, because my order never arrived. I ordered food for a department meeting at work, and when it was never delivered, I called and was told that the order was received "with a bunch of other orders" and that it got missed. I asked for a refund as well as a confirmation email that proved the refund (I used a company card and needed receipts), but was never emailed a confirmation, nor was I called back (I was told someone would call me to try to rectify the situation). Needless to say, we won't be ordering from here again. read more

I am stingy with 5 star reviews but this pizza earned it. Im from an area that is highly critical of pizza. Perfectly done crust. Great selection of toppings. Allowed you to do half and half specialty pies. We did margarita pizza and whatever the meat selection was (the guys wanted that). The have a nice selection of rolls with different things in them. Hot peppers, cheese steak, pepperoni. With side of ranch and tomato sauces for dipping. Very good. The music on in the restaurant reminded me of the 80's it was a nice throwback for me. Come here for pizza and you will not regret. read more

Pizza was excellent sauce and the crust was delicious Best thin pizza I have had in while Moderate prize but well worth for the taste read more

Excellent food and service. I own a paintball field locally and we use them regularly!