I was craving some bar food so I ordered takeout from Presutti's. Online ordering was quick and easy. I ordered 5 buffalo ranch wings and 5 seasoned wings. I also ordered their freshly cut curly friends and a side of cheese sauce. My order was ready in about 20 minutes. There is limited parking so I was glad to find parking in their parking lot. The bartender/cashier was so kind and helpful. The place itself was clean but it's your typically Pittsburgh bar/restaurant. The food itself was delicious. I enjoyed every single bite! I will definitely order food from here again. I'm happy to find a new (to me) place! read more

See all

Tried Presutti's for the first time. I noticed the signs for their fish fry and decided to order lunch last Friday afternoon. I ordered a fried fish sandwich with two sides to-go. The fish was very lightly breaded and crispy. The coleslaw was mayo based and I liked the addition of purple cabbage. The hush puppies were absolutely delicious. Spot on with the crispy and soft texture of the corn meal with their seasoning blend. read more

See all

We stopped by Presutti's yesterday for food and trivia at 6:30. You can sit down and order food to your table via QR code. We got a steak and ranch pizza, Italian hoagie dip, and fresh cut curly fries. The pizza was pretty good and had 12 slices. The hoagie dip was different and we also enjoyed it. We thought the fries were just okay - while the basket we got of them was huge, some of them were overcooked and they weren't seasoned at all, not even with salt. The space is pretty small with a small bar, three high tops, and a few other small tables made for 2-4 people. There's not a lot of room to move around so I wouldn't bring a small group there. This definitely a place where you go for food and drink specials and not for the vibe. They do have a small parking lot but it was full when we got there so we did street parking and just hoped we didn't get towed. read more

See all

Love this place. I've eaten here a few times so far. I've had the sausage calzone, chicken calzone and wings. All very good and would recommend! read more

Wonderful pizza wings and curly fries! Try it for your next Carnegie pizza fix, you will be pleased! read more

Presutti's - A slice of Devine pie! Ask for some ranch on the side! - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

See all

Jeff makes amazing specialty pies and he goes above beyond for the experience of his clientele. I appreciate the relaxed ambiance and it is some of the best pizza in the south hills. The hoagies and wing night are worth your time EVERY week! read more

Presutti's - Dining Area - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

I really wanted to love this place being that it's local to my hometown, but very disappointed. I ordered a large 12 cut pizza with pepperoni and green peppers, and 10 buffalo wings for pick up. I ordered the day before and was told the total was $25. It was $38!! The pizza was delicious, but the wings were missing a lot of sauce and although I ordered well done, eh just ok. Apparently, the price per topping was $3.19, and so that added almost $7. She mentioned that was bc it was for take out? No, just no. Those prices for pizza and wings are ridiculous. Again, not worth it. read more

Presutti's - 10 buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped by for a quick late lunch and just wanted a slice. The place is very new and clean. Only took few minutes to get my order. The waitress was so friendly. The pizza is very good and has nice thinner crust. Learn that Presutti's make there own dough and sauce with San Marzano tomato's. Will have to stop back and try the wings or a hoagie. read more

Excellent service and by far the best tasting pizza I have ate in a very long time live the new pizza sauce

New place in town. I kept seeing their pizza on Facebook & decided it was time to stop. You walk in & place your order at the desk & then your order is brought to you. There is a self-service fountain pop machine. We chose to sit at the bar ourselves. Ashley & Kayla were amazing. We had the pepperoni rolls which were quite good. The ranch dressing is homemade & amazing. I did get a salad & it was so fresh & tasted great. Hubby ordered the wings & is a wing snob, he said they were good. We really enjoyed ourselves & will be back to try other items from the menu. read more

See all

We ordered a steak hoagie, an Italian hoagie, veggie pizza, fries, and desserts. All I can say is it was embarrassing how bad it was. 2 slices of meat in the Italian hoagie, no seasoning on the steak with white tomatoes, burnt fries, undercooked pizza with sauce that's worse than what u can get at the grocery store. I feel sorry for anyone who works there or thinks this garbage is acceptable. I'll never order from this place again. Alll the desserts were frozen solid but I'm hoping that's a good sign that they were made elsewhere. read more

My husband and I have always loved your noblestown location and have been patrons since you opened. Everything has always been really good...until....6/11/24 when we came in for dinner and the place smelled like grease so bad that we both had a couple drinks and burnt onion rings and mushrooms while we waited to get our food to take home. The wings were over cooked! Turn your fryer down!!! Your smoking out your business!!!! As I went to check out, I was shocked to see the price of my 2 small drinks. First, I had 2 mixed drinks of Grey goose and oj. The oj was not even oj, it was apple, grape and oj by Apple and Eve. The real shocker was when I asked for my check and realized not only was I charged $19.00 for 2 Grey goose vodka and oj, but I was also charged separately for the oj! Now I got upset when I asked about the charge and my bartender told me, that's just the way they charge for a screw driver. Ok, come on.....it's happy hour and I'm paying $20 for 2 small screw drivers? Not to mention the greasy smelling air I had to breathe? I'm done! I've always purchased Grey goose and oj from you and been charged $6.75 a drink. You got me this time. Just don't think others don't look at their check as well! Bye bye! read more

Presutti's - Here's my receipt from my purchase 6/11/24. - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

First time ordering here. At first I tried calling (several times) but could not get through. I had questions about the ingredients of the honey bbq sauce and fries. I decided to order online and ask later. When we walked in to pick up our food, I asked the server (Jess) if there was any dairy in the wing sauce or fries and told her I have a severe milk allergy. She said there was no dairy in either. But she'd tell them in the back as well. After waiting 30 minutes we get our food. I check my wings in the car. They're a light orange color. I smell them and immediately know they are buffalo wings. I take them back in to tell her she gave me the wrong wings. She argued that she did not. That all their wing flavors have buffalo (which makes zero sense). I reminded her that I have a severe dairy allergy (that would include butter). So she either lied about giving me the incorrect wings or she lied that the wings didn't contain dairy. I'm going with the former because there was NO honey barbecue sauce in that container. Even without that incident, I still wouldn't go back. My husband said the pizza was just ok. read more

Just stopped in for the first time and am definitely happy! Todays Wednesday and I was in the mood for wings, and have been wanting to try Presutti's for quite some time. They have a great deal for wings on Wednesdays where you got 10 wings for $10, can't beat that! I ordered the hot wings, and they were very good. Nice and crispy just the way I like them, and a good amount of sauce. They weren't too spicy to the point of burning your mouth off, just the right spice. The pepperoni rolls were great as well! I was thinking that $10.49 for an order of pepperoni rolls was a little expensive, but we got 8 fair sized pepperoni rolls which were more than enough. I will definitely be coming back for wings on certain Wednesday's, and look forward to trying their pizza as well next time! (The lady at the counter was really nice too:) read more

Take out was good! Pepperoni pizza. Be care full pulling in and out of the place. Clean and service was good.

Stopped in for happy hour on a Tuesday and there is plenty of great deals. Also great music and trivia too! Got two pieces of sausage pizza and they were served in 5 minutes. Delicious too! Was told everything is home made and ingredients for the sauce are imported. I definitely recommend stopping by. read more

Presutti's - On the bars and tables - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

Everyone was very friendly. I like the sit down and order from the table or order at the register. The pizza came very hot and fresh. Was so delicious!! read more

See all

Excellent Pizza, I had delivered, obviously pizza is generally better when you sit down at the restaurant, so I don't know the atmosphere other than delivery, but it was excellent! read more

Gave it a chance because it was under new ownership and we eat from our local pizza places 3x a week. The food we were served was terrible. We ordered a cheese pizza and bread sticks. The pizza was under cooked and the sauce tasted like spaghetti sauce with added spices. It was bad. The worst is the bread sticks. Do not get these. They were burnt and inedible. I am still waiting for the owner to call back and as of today its been 5 days. In 5 days he couldn't get back to his customer regarding a complaint, that's rediculous considering the owner (Jeff)is the only one who can authorize it. The girl on the phone said the breadstick are new and they use the same dough as the pizza and it doesnt rise. She said they havent really had anyone order them before. How is thay possible! I normally dont leave negative reviews but im blow away at the lack of responsiveness from the owner. It made me sad since they posted in our community page asking for feedback and I wanted to support them like I do all the other places in our community, but unfortunately I am checking this place off our list and wont be giving it a second try. read more

The pizza is fresh and delicious. The wings are perfectly cooked slightly crispy on the outside but juicy on the inside. Delicious steak and Italian hoagies. Great service and always aiming to please. Maddie and Steve are wonderful! read more

Food is average. Looks like an ok simple pizza place with a little bar that could be fun BUT... Having a beer I ordered from the bartender. I was asked to leave by another bartender with the comment that the place had a private party going on and I had to leave now. So Very Weird!!! I will think hard to go back again. And only if I get a sincere apology on this thing... CIAO read more

Great pizza and service! My group eats there all the time! The large hoagies aren't like anything you have have seen or eaten. Delicious all around. read more

Me and my friend Went there on Thursday for lunch for the 1st time. Everything was delicious and fresh and homemade! I got a slice of pepperoni pizza and a slice of mushroom, and jalapeno poppers. My friend got 2 pepperoni slices and a small caesar salad which was pretty big. Both of us loved all our food! The place is clean, great atmosphere and staff , service. Will definitely be back! Highly recommend!! read more

My new favorite pizza, wing, and curly fry place. I tried it a while ago shortly after opening and can't get enough.

First: Very good food. Pizza and onion rings. Crust crisp, rings hot and crunchy. Only complaint: For the price, a little stingy on the rings and pizza toppings. Will be back. read more

Food took an hour and half to get to me was extremely cold. We spent over 100 dollars and it was gross. Fries tasted like mush like they dipped them in cold oil and threw in a brown bag. I try to go to local businesses but this place was just awful. read more

My favorite pizza in the Carnegie area. Great cheese, delicious sauce, perfect crust/flop. The only pizza shop I've found that delivers CRISPY wings. If only they had a cheesesteak with wiz. read more

Called twice to make an order for delivery and got hung up on each time. Will never order from here.

I placed an order online for delivery thru toast. I was given an approximate delivery time of 45 minutes. After an hour I called about my order and was told if I had called the restaurant directly I would have gotten a more accurate time for delivery, but the driver was out with my order. Two more calls to the restaurant and over an hour later I was told I would get a call from the Manger for refund..my order arrived a very cold pizza and no hoagie.. I was given a refund. read more

Ordered food on their app at 5:45. Received an email that it would be delivered at 6:30. At 7:00 got a text that it was ready. I called at 7:20 and they said they just got through there dinner rush and it would be on the way soon. I called back at 8 and the person that answered the phone said the same thing. It is now going on 8:15 still no food. Highly doubtful that I will order delivery from them again. read more

It is so hard to find places that use all fresh ingredients and at Presutti's everything was super fresh and delicious !!! I love everything I have tried so far. I can't wait to go back and eat more!!!! read more