History of Present Indulgence: 32 yo M presents having discovered small pizza establishment on an unassuming 14th St and Florida Ave corner. Multiple visits reported with consistently positive outcomes. Physical Exam: Food - This is hands down the best pizza slice in DC. Period. Eating it fresh, I'll take Slice & Pie over Andy's Pizza any day. Though delivered, I actually would take Andy's. The slice that's a collab with Federalist Pig is my absolute favorite - I it's got Federalist Pig's brisket, smoked mozzarella, and dollops of garlic cream sauce. It's insanity. Their classic slices are all top-notch, but this creation is something special. When I judge pizza, I look at a few factors. The crust, the sauce-cheese ratio, the sauce flavor, the toppings selection and quality. The pizza at Slice & Pie hit all the checkmarks. A crispy exterior, but when you bite in, the center is still soft and doughy. No flop when you hold it up. The sauce-to-cheese ratio is nice, and the sauce itself is perfectly balanced. Not overly acidic or awfully sweet. Service It's a slice shop. You walk up to the counter, you order, you get your slice. That's pretty much it. Nothing to complain about, nothing particularly noteworthy either. Ambiance There's not much seating. It's a small corner spot. You're probably eating your slice standing at one of the standing tables or outside the storefront. Wasn't here for ambiance tbh. Assessment It's the best slice in DC when eaten at the restaurant. It's still a 9 out of 10 when delivered. Surprisngly not that many people know it exists, and I'm on a mission to spread the word. Plan - Will be coming again and again until every slice has been tried - Order for delivery again to see if the floppiness was a fluke or a consistent quality problem - Convince other DC people that there's more to our pizza scene than just Andy's read more

Gluten Free Friends. This is it, this is the holy grail of gluten free pizza. This is what pizza tastes like! I know it's been years, and we have accepted card board pizza crust and convinced ourselves over all these years that it tastes good....... But today, my friend... You will taste what real pizza is again! I need them to open up a new location, right next to my house, so I can eat there everyday. My only, slight complaint, is the tomato sauce is tangy... I'm not a big fan... but... it's worth it! They use the small pepperoni cups, that crisp on the edges, and hold on to just the right amount of grease. Even glutenous eaters will be happy, their square Detroit deep dish is pretty good as well! You can easily order online, and have it ready to go.... I do plan to come back! read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

Dare I say it was better the morning after? As far as cold pizza goes, the pepperoni was good! It is your standard American pizza - but go pick it up if you can because delivery was a nightmare. The staff was so kind, attentive, and eager to help when the situation was explained. Would try again! read more

I passed by this place so many times during my walks and wanted to fall in love with the pizza so bad, so I'd have something to reward myself with on my takeout days. While the pizza was okay, it didn't knock my socks off. I went on a really hot day and it was pretty hot in there. Not sure if that's how it typically is but I mostly felt bad that the employees had to endure that type of heat along with the running ovens. I got a slice of the Detroit pepperoni. It was fine, just didn't really taste very fresh, which I get to an extent since it is from the slice section. Also got the famous burrata slice but it was too soupy for me. Garlic knot was solid though. I'm still giving this place a high rating because they have a versatile menu, the food is solid, and it's a good price point. read more

See all

Came here just to grab a slice of pizza to tide myself before dinner. It's small inside with minimal seating. Staff was courteous when I placed a slice of the Federalist Pig. The pizza is thin crust and the brisket was tender. A delicious snack! read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

Always happy a slice shop is in the area. I'm from NJ so I have a deep passion for pizza. It's pretty good overall and most definitely a pickup spot (there are a few tables). The grandma slices remind me a lot of L&B Spumoni Gardens which is great. Sandwiches were fine. I prefer the pizza. We got our food super fast which is a huge plus if you're stopping by for a quick lunch. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Came in on a Thursday around lunch the place only had one other customer. The lady at the register was not friendly. No hello or how're you just what can I get you? She was pretty blunt with other customers and not friendly with the others in the kitchen. They do have gluten free pizza but it is not advertised on their menu. After we had waited for 10-15 minutes and watched 4 other people get food that came after us I heard her ask the kitchen, "do you have the gluten free in?" They said no. So we waited another 10-15 minutes. Once we finally received the pizza, the gluten free pizza was burnt and also undercooked... the worst combo for a pizza. It was also very hot in the restaurant so not a pleasant spot to eat at, they also have very limited seating. Don't think I would come back. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pepperoni 12" Gluten Free - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Absolutely blown away by the gluten-free pizza here! Hands down one of the best I've ever had. The crust was so perfectly crisp, soft, and chewy that I had to triple-check the label to make sure it was actually gluten-free--it was that good. Topped with fresh, flavorful sauce, cheese, and basil, every bite was perfection. The staff was very friendly, and it was nice to have a few seats available to sit and eat. I'm looking forward to my next trip to DC so I can return for more! Highly recommend to anyone, gluten-free or not! read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - burrata gluten free - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Great spot! Inside was nice... definitely just the vibes of a small to-go pizza spot. I really liked their fun neon pink color scheme. It was clean too. I got the burrata pie which was delicious... crispy and flavorful and a solid NY slice. It came out pretty fast. No complaints! read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Burrata Pie - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Will not be going back for pizza at Slice & Pie Pizza. I ordered online and there was a point of sale surcharge - yeah, no thanks. I ordered to pick up at 5:15. I arrived at 5:15 to pick up for a birthday party and they hadn't even started the pizza. The large garlic knots were basically three small dinner rolls with garlic salt and cheap Parmesan cheese - for $7.00. Overall spent $55.00 with tip for Wawa quality pizza that was cold and greasy by the time I got it home 5 mins away, and joke of garlic knots. Why does all DC pizza have to be this bad?!? read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Overpriced garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

We were craving pizza and noticed that Slice of Pie Pizza offers gluten free options. I called the restaurant to confirm that they take the necessary precautions to avoid cross-contamination, and they reassured me that they clean and bake everything separately. My husband really enjoyed the Hawaiian pizza, and I must say, the GF Hawaiian pizza was pretty good. The dough was amazing--it wasn't overcooked and was soft and delicious. I do wish my pizza had a bit more cheese. Next time my sister's in town, we're definitely going to dine in. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Hawaiian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

We ordered a bunch of pizza from Slice & Pie for a party and everyone enjoyed them. I think we had a Burrata Pie, Hawaiian Pie, Meat Lovers Pie, and Federalist Pig Pie. I think my favorite was the Federalist Pig Pie, with White garlic base, mozzarella, Federalist Pig Smoked Brisket, caramelized onions, pickled onions, pickled jalapeno, potato, and sticky garlic sauce. This was just such a unique pizza flavor. The brisket was really tender. One warning - their Hawaiian pie comes with jalapenos, so you might want to tell them to remove those at the get go. My niece was sadly surprised by the spiciness of her Hawaiian pizza. read more

We had Slice & Pie pizza for my daughter's birthday and it was great! Her birthday celebration was going to be at midday on a Sunday so they were really helpful and let me order in advance to just pick it up and they had it ready in time, which I greatly appreciated! We had a Burrata Pie, a Hawaiian Pie, Meat lover's pie, a Federalist Pig, and a vegetarian pizza, and they were all SPECTACULAR! I would definitely recommend! They are good quality ingredients and good combinations. read more

Visited the NOMA/Union Market location This location has a good selection of pies including: Burrata, BBQ Brisket, Mushroom, Pepperoni, and meat lovers. The pies are out fresh! The crust is thin and lightly charred for a slight chewiness. The garlic knots are solid and taste like fresh wheat rolls. (Not super garlicky) and comes with a side of sauce Solid choice for Union Market read more

See all

This was my first visit, I'd dropped in for a quick bite because it was in the right spot on my way home, & the sign piqued my curiosity. I was hoping to see a pie / slice with a little bit of green - veg on it, but since they didn't have any of that I was waffling between the burrata and what turned out to be the Sicilian. The guy at the front was giving "manager who resented having to fill in at the front due to a call out." Just a hunch. Maybe he was in foreclosure or his dog died, idk. He seemed impatient and completely disinterested in me or other guests. He never noticed, never asked, nor seemed to care that it might be my first time there... or that people return and recommend businesses to others when they have a good experience. I was visually perusing and reading everything and looking inquisitive as one often does on a first visit, in addition to asking questions based on the poor /nonexistent signage. I pointed & asked what ingredients were in one pie & he said "you want the Sicilian?" rather abruptly. There was no language barrier. So it was awkward having to ask him *again* what was in the pizza. He provided no explanations or recommendations, just silence and watching me vacantly while I struggled to make a choice... again, because the pizzas weren't labeled or apparent on the awkwardly positioned menu screens high up on the ceiling directly above the pizza. I didn't notice the menu screen until just after I asked for the pizza I pointed to but couldn't name -since there were neither labels nor words coming from his mouth. When I started to read the menu directly above me, "croquettes" caught my eye. And I said "oh I didn't notice those up there right above my head." Yet another awkward moment of silence while I waited for the way too quickly wiping menu screen to reappear so I could catch a split second glimpse of the price and description. The screen flashed away so quickly I only caught a glance of the croquette description - something about potato and maybe sausage... I've been craving croquettes so I switched my order to that. Still no recommendation from the guy waiting on me to order. Clearly, the guy was not interested in explaining, introducing, or upselling me anything so I decided not to ask about beverages and just got for a bottle of water. The croquettes, aka glorified tater tots, had a decent flavor, and a nice little crisp on the outside, but the inside was kind of liquid like cream of wheat. At least they looked and tasted like sweet potato tater tots. The white dipping sauce, which was a mystery since there are no descriptions on their yelp menu, tasted really good. The ambience was clean, fine , up-to-date, adequate, functional . read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - croquettes -probably sweet potato. No idea what the dipping sauce is it was good though - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Slice & Pie is 2nd place for "best pizza slice in the U.S.", so I had high expectations, but had a very underwhelming experience. Staff were not very friendly or welcoming either. We ordered the burrata slice (Cali tomato sauce, mozzarella, fresh burrata, basil, Parmesan) mushroom slice (Parmesan cream, mozzarella, mushroom, garlic, truffle oil, parsley), Detroit style slice (tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, hot honey, pepperoni), and truffle fries. I appreciated how thin and crispy the burrata and mushroom slices were. The slice of burrata pizza was a bit too salty, and could've used more tomato sauce. The slice of mushroom pizza was quite unflavorful, which was disappointing. The Detroit style slice was also underwhelming, and the slices of pepperoni weren't even crispy. Each slice was $5.50. The truffle fries were also very mid, they weren't even crispy and didn't even taste like truffle. The fries honestly tasted like cafeteria fries. Overall, pretty disappointing experience with the pizza and service. The space inside is very small, but has eclectic decor. Given our experience, I'm not too inclined to come back. I think Andy's Pizza is superior in terms of taste, menu options, and service. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

I was nervous to try this place but I liked it! The garlic knots and Brussels sprouts are amazing. I can't comment on the actual pizza but these items were delicious! read more

Food: good for what it is, they did not have most of their sides available at my visit, only had "garlic knots" Service: guy was nice however there was a long line of people waiting for their food and people getting annoyed at longer than wait time promised - unsure of what exactly was backing things up Vibe: chill, casual spot, limited seating Parking: very limited paid street parking Pricing: fair for market price read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

I was so excited to finally get a good slice in the city, but that didn't happen. Pizza was barely heated up and it was very bland. The perfect cheesy deliciousness one would expect was not apparent. Even the garlic knot was boring. Neither one of us could finish our order. This is yet another place that is only good after a night out. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

Second only to Andy's for NY style pizza in DC. Love that it is actually set up and looks like a standard NY pizzeria. Quick and to the point counter service as well. Prices for a slice are way above that of a regular slice in NYC, however, but supply meet demand I guess. Last time I was there I ordered a cheese pie for takeout and even looking at it, you can tell they're doing a good job with the style! I should note they also make solid Detroit style pizza, which you won't see attempted in NYC. The good news is you can get a slice instead of a pie of it, so you don't have to spend $19 on a pie at Red Light several blocks down 14th. Only downside aside from kinda high prices is I do wish they kept it a bit cleaner in there, as other reviewers have also noted. Also, that recent article that called this the second best slice in the entire world are out of their minds, but I won't hold it against the establishment--they make fine slices after all! read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Just ok. Nothing to rave about. Better than a jumbo slice flavor wise. The staff is alright and service was quick.

This place has really good pizza and garlic knots! The service was relaxed yet prompt. However the cleanliness of the place is slightly questionable for me. There were flies everywhere. The cooks had aprons/rags that wasn't the cleanest. They don't have a lot of space so it's most ideal for pick up's and they're open late which is super convenient for a late night bite. Overall, it's a good place for late night and you're hungry. But would suggest a better cleaning protocol for the cooks, kitchen, and where the pizzas are displayed. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Hawaiian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

I felt like I was back in NY when I walked into slice and pie. They have lots of options and I like that there is such a variety of pizza here. The prices are great as well, it's no surprise they are ranked as high as they are! The Hawaiian slice was really delicious, tons of flavor and just the right ratio of sauce to cheese. Their garlic knots were good too, staff raved about them which is always a good sign! I wish there were more searing options, but I also understand the demand for space in the area. Looking forward to coming back soon. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Garlic Knots & Hawaiian Slce - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Really good gluten free pizza. I did grubhub and was curious if they put a sticker on the box and was really happy they did - so it felt safe. It had an airy crust and was light and thin, but not the crunchy thin we gf folks often get. Got the pepperoni and the meat lovers - no complaints! read more

See all

Decided to check this place out as it was voted #2 best pizza however we were a little disappointed it did not live up to the hype. It was a solid pizza and nice for quick bite around the area but we were spoiled with lindustrie pizza in NYC. Also prince st pizza still stands its ground for the pepperoni squares in our personal opinion. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

We keep our pies simple. Cheese, pepperoni, basil (if we're feeling adventurous). If the pizza maker uses quality ingredients, toppings are unnecessary. S&P gets this, delivering a quality pie crust, sauce, and cheese. Bonus, the cupped pepperoni was delish. Yes, they check all the boxes and we enjoyed our "boring" pizza very much. And garlic knots for the win! read more

See all

Pretty decent for a grab and go pizza. They have a decent variety and they're all pretty good for premade pizza. Tried the pepperoni which is loaded with pepperoni and the Bianca which was really creamy and good. Service was nice too! It's a small place so not idea to sit for a long time but late night especially is a good spot! read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

I lived right next door to this place, so it's safe to say it was my go-to spot after a night out! For those who have had Pizza My Heart, it feels so similar in quality! I will say that the flavors can be slightly bland, so I will try to add hot honey at home and it just makes it *chefs kiss*! Just a quick and easy grab on the way home from the bars, or if you are just looking for a mid-day pick me up! read more

My fiancés been dying to try this place out so we stopped on our night out. Really small spot, very similar to NYC vibes, with NY slices and Detroit slices (and 4 subs too). They serve wine and beer too I think which is nice. Prices were fair and the Hawaiian slice was one of the best I've had in years. The pepperoni slices were nice too, with crispy pepperoni. The garlic knot was good but would love it to be a bit more buttery. Service and staff were super friendly! read more

Named the country's second-best slice shop, Slice & Pie, a tiny pizzeria along 14th Street NW, is worth a visit. From an Italian pizza master, they sell New York and Detroit-style pizzas by the slice or pie and other items like garlic knots and meatballs. For dinner, I ordered two garlic knots (it comes with pizza sauce on the side) and a slice of the Meat Lover. Both were very tasty, but the winner was my friend's Detroit Pepperoni. It's square and very light and tasty. Slices are between $4.50 and $5.50. They sell a variety of drinks, including wine! The Sauvignon Blanc was refreshing. read more

YUM! This NJ girl has a high bar for pizza, but I actually really liked the slices I tried from Slice & Pie for a Friday late night slice! We tried the truffle slice, the pepperoni Detroit style slice, the Hawaiian slice & the pesto slice. Nice thick crust & good flavor. The Detroit slice came with pepperoni and hot honey which is one of my favorite combos! I usually get Red Light pizza if I'm going for a Detroit slice, but I throughly enjoyed this one too! The truffle slice was my favorite. read more

See all

Grabbed a slice during a long day of shopping and sightseeing. Service and pricing were reasonable, and the pizza itself was good. A little greasy but overall great NY style pizza. read more

I decided to try this casual pizza place since I was in the area. I got the meat lover slice and it was fast warming it up. The cheese and toppings were good. My problem was with the crust since it was nothing special. So I would say the pizza is like 7.2/10. It is a nice place to get a quick cheap slice around the area so if I was hungry again nearby I would probably get a slice again. read more

Yesterday was my first time visiting Slice & Pie Pizza. I ordered a slice of Sicilian pizza and a Hawaiian slice. Between the two, I really enjoyed the Hawaiian slice. It had the perfect balance of sauce and toppings. However, I wasn't a fan of the Sicilian slice, as the cheese was very dry and tasted as though it had been sitting out for hours. The ambiance was pretty cool, although seating was limited. The staff on the other hand, wasn't very polite. They were pushy and curt in their responses. Despite there being no line, I felt rushed when placing my order and didn't get a chance to look at all the options available. read more

Flies on all slices not safe to eat here unless you order the pizza fresh. But overall good pizza read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Love this fun new corner pizza spot. They've got all different types of NY style pizza slices available. Slices are pretty big and really good! Not too much indoor seating - more of a grab and go. But the service was quick and friendly - I would love to go back! read more

See all

Oh the wonderful pizzaplaces in DC I love gourmet pizza and I love their pizza sauce and their Detroit crust my new favorite Detroit style pizza place but This is a $55 pizza restaurant And you will want the whole pizza ! My favorite Detroit pizza is meatball garlic oil basil burata , sausage hot honey pepperoni is diabolically delicious read more

The ONLY bad thing I can say is that you can no longer order by the slice through delivery! Now that that is outta the way...OMG!!! Not sure if this is a fair review because I got their mushroom and truffle pie ONCE and have been stuck on that one ever since! I've gotten a good 5+ times and haven't ventured anywhere else on the menu! Why?? Because guess what! That MUSHROOM and TRUFFLE IS TO DIEEEEEE! Yum! GET IT and you're welcome!! read more

Was in the mood for pizza and garlic knots. Found this places on DoorDash. It was pretty decent. I found the quality of the pizza be solid and the food flavorful. I probably would order again from here. read more

Slice & Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

The quality of the pizza has been downhill since they first opened. Pizza is very doughy and lacks any firmness. It's like eating a big dough roll with pizza sauce & cheese. Mozzarella also has no taste but unfortunately this what the state of New York style pizza in DC minus Slice Joint & sometimes Grazie Grazie. DC - get your shit together! read more