I recently tried Slap's Fish Market and sampled a little bit of everything--lobster roll, burrito, cheesecake, and their lobster deviled eggs--and overall it was a really memorable experience. The service was very helpful deciding what to order. The setting was fun down town indanopolis feel. The lobster roll was definitely the standout. It was packed with fresh, flavorful lobster and had a nice balance of buttery richness without feeling too heavy. You can tell the seafood is high quality, which makes a huge difference. The lobster deviled eggs were super unique and honestly one of my favorite bites. Creamy, slightly tangy, and topped with lobster--it's not something you see everywhere, and they executed it really well. My husband tried the shrimp burrito, which was great for a seafood spot. It was hearty, well-seasoned, and filled generously. It didn't feel like an afterthought on the menu. To finish, the cheesecake was a great choice it was from the cheesecake factory is what the offered for my birthday smooth, rich, and just the right level of sweetness with a strawberry topping to end the meal without being overwhelming. Overall, Slap's Fish Market delivers on both creativity and quality. It's a great spot if you want fresh seafood with a few fun, unexpected twists. I'd definitely come back to try more of the menu. read more

See all

Not gonna lie, my work group really likes coming here when we have lunch outings. My only problem? I very much dislike seafood to any capacity. Yet, I still eat here just fine. I feel like most seafood places will have vegetarian options by way of removing the fish from pasta dishes or salad, but it's also nice to know that you can get chicken as a substitute on most of these kinds of dishes, too. Granted, it's just like chicken tenders, but still good nonetheless. I really like their firecracker pasta, which is moderately spicy in my opinion. There's no particular fishy smell here, which is always a good sign that the seafood they serve here is freshly prepared. Our food always comes out quickly for lunch and we've been a group as large as 8 or 9. I do believe that ordering is mostly done online in their mass Ave location, though. I don't really seek out a place like Slapfish on my own (no offense at all, just not a seafood girlie!!), but I would assume that it's a rather popular establishment as they recently opened a fifth location in the greater Indy area. If I did like fish and such more, I'd probably be here on a more regular rotation. read more

Finally had a chance to try the restaurant that was recommended by so many people, and it did not disappoint! From the moment we walked in (just after opening on a Sunday), we received a friendly greeting and music to make our toes tap. We received menus and took a seat to think through the options. After some back and forth, I ordered the sandwich that prompted the visit - the lobster roll. I opted for the "simple salad" as my side. My husband ordered the fish and chips, which also came with coleslaw. Our food arrived quickly and looked delicious. The lobster on the lobster roll was very buttery (yum!) and tender. The salad had mixed lettuces (nice and crisp), carrots, radishes, cucumber, tomatoes, and a delicious house-made vinaigrette. My husband enjoyed his fish and chips. He also said the slaw was delicious. I snuck a fry and it was crisp outside and fluffy inside. They mentioned that they also have a whole line of house-made sauces. Something to try next time! :) read more

Slapfish - Fish and chips with slaw - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is a very nice clean simple establishment. You order at the counter and they bring you the food. The service was brief but good. The food was good, but honestly not sure if I'll be back as our bill was $63 for 2 drinks, a lobster roll and shrimp roll and 2 sweet potato fries. Good but to me not with it. For that I would expect a more in ambiance, service, etc. But again it wasn't a bad experience or food. read more

Slapfish - Traditional Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Everything was super yummy and fresh! Staff was great and patient. Took the time to explain certain items on menu since it was our first time there read more

See all

AMAZING!!! That's my take on my visit!! The food was prepared perfectly with out of this world flavor. We were greeted by a friendly staff and fast service. This is a must stop in Indy!!! read more

See all

I ordered to have delivered about 3 days ago. The tuna steak (app) was good, fries and coleslaw. The "fish-n-chips" was just awful. The fish was very poor quality and it was cooked WAY too long. It had no taste. If I had of been in the restaurant it would have been sent back. I will be more careful in the future if I order again. read more

Visited after work around 4:30. We were the only patrons but the food was still hot and good at this hour. Employees were friendly. The petite lobster roll looked small initially but there's more meat hiding than you originally think. All in all a good experience and I'll be back. read more

See all

I just had to look Slapfish up after it was recommended to me by the hotel receptionist at the hotel I stayed at while in the city of Indianapolis. I was pleased to find that it was only .2 miles in distance from the hotel. And its 4.7 star rating out of 1,500+ on Uber Eats was the assurance I needed that I would have a quality experience next to the recommendation by the receptionist. Looking through the menu, I took interest in items like the lobster deviled eggs, clobster grilled cheese, fish 'n chips, lobster tots, reel fish sandwich, grilled fish bowl, slapfish burger, grilled cheese, and the mac n cheese. Out of all that caught my eye on their extensive menu, I ended up ordering their grilled fish bowl because of what it consisted of. Whether it be Grubhub or Uber Eats, I love ordering online because it is convenient. Most of the time my orders are completed upon my arrival or near complete. By the time I arrived at Slapfish my order was waiting behind the counter during this ordering experience. Picking up was just confirming my name, order, and I was well on my way back to my hotel. I am grateful to have had a smooth online ordering experience because the likelihood of me ordering online again is very high. "Noooo!" After opening the brown paper bag with my grilled fish bowl inside, I received everything I had ordered, except utensils, but thankfully I was able to retrieve utensils from the hotel I stayed at. Now the rice was the first thing my tastebuds tasted! The rice was seasoned with herb rice sauce, hand-picked lettuce, and honey lime vinaigrette which gave it a taste that I just could not get enough of. And once I paired it with the fried cod, I was on cloud 9 and in love with this meal. I highly recommend the grilled fish bowl if you are looking for a pescatarian option that will surely leave you satisfied taste wise. In closing, I had a great ordering experience as I have indicated in this review of Slapfish. And as it was introduced to me by the hotel receptionist, I share my endorsement of it as well with you all on yelp. Service: 4 | Ambiance: 4 | Food: 5 ~ Good vibes coming your way ~ Thomas G read more

See all

Found this place on Yelp called Slapfish since we were looking for seafood. I was 15 min walking distant from our hotel. Food very good. Service also good and the ambiance laidback. Would I come back and eat at this place again, I would. Try Slapfish if you love seafood. read more

Slapfish - Colobster Grilled Cheese & Power Bowl - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We came here on a Friday early evening and were able to be seated right away (the host let us pick where we wanted to sit as well). We were given the menus and advised we could go to the counter to order or order via the QR code and ToastTab. We went with the phone option and it worked perfectly. We ordered the Lobster Deviled Eggs and they were amazing - I'd come back just for that single item!!! For entrees, we got the Oyster Roll and the Hawaiian Bowl. I loved mine and my husband thought his was fantastic too. We wrapped it up with the Key Lime pie. He loved it but I thought it was ok. The filling was perfect but I didn't love the crust (not bad, I have just had better). Service was fast and really friendly. We loved our first visit and I'm looking forward to our next one. Thanks Slapfish team!!! read more

See all

Great fish & chip shop in downtown Indianapolis. Good prices, great food and relaxed vide. Definitely worth a visit read more

See all

Really great food. Big portions and fish and oysters were pretty fresh. Love that there are healthy options. Full cocktail bar available. Counter or table side order via the web. They'll bring the food to your table. Food for 3 adults and 2 kids was $120. read more

See all

The food here is terrific. It is a great menu, so many good options. I had the Reel Fish Sandwich and Lobster Tots. Well cooked and delicious. It's a casual setup and the foot comes out quick and exceptionally well presented. I will definitely come again when in town. read more

Slapfish - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We needed a quick late night dinner and popped into Slapfish. The space is very inviting and has a fun atmosphere. The counter associate was super friendly and helped us make decisions. He suggested a couple of options that we ordered and really enjoyed. We shared the lobster deviled eggs. Really interesting presentation and very delicious. We also had the lobster tots. Similar to a hush puppy with a slightly spicy Sauce. We also shared the shrimp roll with fries and coleslaw. The worker suggested that we get the fried version and he was not wrong. Tons of shrimp with a buttery roll, crispy fries, and their coleslaw is quite good. Not the cheapest meal you'll have, but the portion sizes are good as this was plenty for the two of us to share. I live on the opposite end of Mass Ave and I forget this is such a great find as you get closer to the city. read more

See all

One of my favorite seafood places in the USA. Staff was very friendly and helpful with deciding what to order. The lobster roll is one of the best I have had. Buttered roll, loaded with warm lobster that's cooked perfectly and the lemon adds a nice layer of flavor to it. Coming back to this place next time I'm in Indianapolis! read more

Slapfish - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Been here couple of times and it's still enjoyable. Ordering is more steamlined now using QR code. Pictures on the menu are helpful. Started with shrimp ceviche, taste was great but serving size was small. Clobster was our 2nd starter and enjoyed it as well, serving size was good. Our main were the traditional lobster roll and lobster boil. The former, you just can't go wrong, the bread is amazing and it was very filling. Latter was also great, lobster meat was already extracted so you don't have to crack and break the shell (but that's the fun part). The lobster tots it came has more filler than lobster meat, and lastly, it came with clam chowder, which was also good, love that creamy and crunchy texture. Overall, food was enjoyable and somewhat filling. Parking is alao great and cheap next to this place. Definitely will come back. Place looks different now and has more seating for bigger groups. read more

See all

Stopped by SlapFish on Mass Ave and had a great experience! It wasn't busy at all when I went, which was a nice surprise. The service was fast and the food did not disappoint. I had the Clobster Grilled Cheese with fries and it was so good! Perfectly cheesy with just the right amount of seafood. The ambience is super cute too. I always love a good neon sign, it adds a fun touch! Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area and craving something tasty and a little different. read more

Slapfish - Clobster Grilled Cheese - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food was hit and miss. They're chowder fried are bomb 8.5/10. The Sweet potato fries were some of the best so far in indy 9/10. The burgers both surf and normal were slacking and tops 6/10 not worth it at all. The lobster roll was decent but wouldn't get it again from this place, they skim on the lobster compared to others priced the same but still was a solid 8 in flavor. However I got a good amount in the grill cheese which was amazing 9/10 flavor bomb just like the Mac cheese but the Mac had two bits of lobster which again tasted good but not good enough to match the price they sold it at so it's pass next time for us on the Mac value. Overall there were things worth it to go back and get and some never again and some maybe if we are craving must haves. Priceing to portions gets a 6/10 Taste overall is a 8/10 Customer services were 10/10 friendly I'll be back for the grill cheese mainly. read more

I have to admit. I was somewhat hesitant coming here. Growing up on the southeast coast, I've had my share of fresh seafood and fish. It's hard for me to pass up peel-n-eat and a blackened grouper sandwich, but this in Indianapolis, not Savannah, Ga. I will say, Slapfish did not disappoint in any way. Even though the shrimp were chilled, they were really good. Tasty with a nice snap to them. Just the way they're supposed to be. And the blackened grouper Sammy - again, just like the shrimp - how it should be. Really, really good. Not too salty, fresh and tasty with the Jersey sauce. Yum! And we had the Lobster deviled eggs to share too. We were very pleased and will back. Give this place a try for sure. It's the real deal. read more

We came in around 12:30 on a Sunday and we ordered at the counter - no server (honestly it's kinda nice to just serve yourself sometimes in this expensive area) but there was a call button on at the tables! Food came quick. Wish they had more oyster variety, they had their standard ($3) plus one other rotation for $3.50. Poke bowl was evenly portioned with plenty of ahi tuna, multiple sauce options provided. The lobster Mac and cheese and was cooked really well with a unique creamy bake flavor and the tots were huge, really well fried. Hats off for a quality seafood counter on Mass Ave!! They have a little bit of everything. read more

See all

Parking is a challenge as you have to pay during the week to park on the street or pay for parking in the lot next door. It has a nice casual ambience. You take a menu but you go to the counter to order. If busy you can log on through a bar code and place your order. The fish and chips are what you'd expect. The Cole slaw is also what you'd expect. The lobster grinder was a treat with a bit of heat. Not unpleasant. I loved the mix as well as the buttery roll. I would order it again and again. The salad dressing was a nice complement to the salad. I ordered a shrimp ceviche to take back to the hotel. We'll be set for the rest of the day read more

Slapfish - Fish 'N Chips - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I live a few blocks away so Slapfish + Raw Bar (RIP) have been one of my go-to's when I don't know what to eat. The power bowl is actually an incredible value and always hits the spot! Service as of late 2024 is quite low touch with counter tablet ordering but I enjoy the value proposition and convenience. read more

Chef Joseph here. Ate lunch at Slapfish today because I wanted raw oysters. The oysters were good but small, two small for the $50 I paid for a dozen. The oysters were just big enough to be sold. When people eat oysters they want them as big as your hand, size you get in New Jersey, New York, Boston. read more

See all

I arrived just has they opened at 11 o'clock. I had intended on eating in the restaurant but there was a strong odor of sewer gas they did open the doors and it dissipated rather quickly but it turned me off and I wanted to take the order to go so I ordered the fish and chips the slaw was very good one piece of fish actually had fish in it the other piece was more breading than fish there were other options on the menu that I thought of trying but did not I will return just to see if this was a one off and to try other options on the menuI was glad to read about the counter ordering service or I might have been tempted to just sit down at a booth read more

Slapfish - breading was light but in this one piece of fish there was no fish just the breading the other piece did have fish and was tasty - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The proper location for ours is 11505 Illinois street. Carmel,In. This place has no wait staff you order from the register area and they bring it to your table. There were 5of us and each of us had something different and it was all good. It is a little expensive. Good and quiet read more

My husband and I walked into the downtown Indy location of Slapfish and were hit by a HORRID smell. I mean putrid. It smelled like raw sewage. My husband doesn't even have a very good sense of smell (unlike me), and even he was so disgusted he said he wouldn't eat there. Buyer beware--they are NOT taking care of something the way they should. No. Thank. You. read more

Had a great time! So the inside was different than I thought, you order at the counter and then they bring your food out to you. They do have a button at the table in case you need anything which I SO appreciate and wish all restaurants did this! Everybody was nice and service was quick! The bathrooms were clean when we went. We ordered the fish sandwich and tacos and also got the linguine dish and instead of the shrimp subbed with salmon and it was perfect for it! The sandwich came with TWO pieces of fish and the salmon went great with the lemon sauce of the pasta. It's on mass ave in the beginning, so you know what that means with parking. read more

See all

Oh wow! Great New Location we just checked out! Slapfish on 116th in Carmel is FABULOUS! The staff is OUTSTANDING! The ambience kept our party of 4 for way too long! If you are looking for an affordable special dinner with friends and enjoy fish- this is THE BEST place in town! ENJOY! read more

I stopped by Slapfish to grab a bite to eat for dinner after work. It wasn't busy and I was able to order my food immediately. Parking is located outside at the meter. Inside, Slapfish has a very nice ambiance. I ordered food at the bar. They have two sides to the restaurant. The oppose side appears to be more family friendly, while the side with the bar would be perfect for date night or a night out with the girls. I ordered the lobster roll with a side salad and cup of clam chowder for myself, and my son had the fried grouper sandwich with a side of fries. I've had Slapfish before and everything was super fresh, but this time, the roll was on the hard side, but the lobster was plentiful. The clam chowder was good as well. The salad dressing that came on the side reminded me of poppyseed dressing. My son's sandwich looked decent, but the fries didn't seem to be fresh. While I did make this a to go order, I feel the food could have been better. I'll still return, but I think the food may be better if I dine in. read more

See all

Service was super friendly. It's walk up-order-seat yourself vibe. They have a full bar, there is no bar seating. Food is good. Drinks were also good. read more

See all

We had our team Christmas lunch here last week. A couple of people who are not fond of fish managed to try something new and everyone enjoyed the various choices of dishes. We had boiled shrimp, tuna and fish cakes to start them some had lobster, ahi tuna and poke bowls as well as fish and chips. The service was great, the food was great and the location was great too. read more

Last night was a Carb Load! Grilled Cheese with Lobster Claws and Fries in Clam Chowder (never had this, but wow!) Good grief there was no way that I could finish all it, but it was delicious! read more

Slapfish - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Saw this place and never thought about going in until I was invited. I've been missing out. I was a little skeptical of the portion size to the price, but was pleasantly surprised. It is definitely worth it and I left full. I tried the shrimp roll with fries and it was delish. The bread is soo buttery. And the service was great as well. I'll be back sooner than later. read more

I wish I had taken photos, but we were hungry and dug right in. I had the Power Bowl, hubby had fish and chips. The Power Bowl was fantastic! Grilled mahi mahi, salmon and shrimp. Under that was brown rice and grilled veggies. The fish and chips came with plenty of fries, a big serve of Cole slaw and the fish was a lovely golden brown. The tartar sauce was delicious! Lighter and smoother than the usual. Love the clean, simple decor and the staff is friendly and efficient. read more

See all

The fresh looking dishes hooked us online. As visitors from out of state, we look for non chain unique dining. Slapfish had some delicious food. We got Lobster tots, Lobster Deviled eggs, a bowl of Clam Chowder, and a Lobster Grilled Cheese sandwich. Everything was beautifully presented, fast and satisfying. I would definitely come back. read more

See all

This place slaps!!! It's a great lunch spot but also a great dinner spot. They have the best clam chowder in the game but what I like getting is the poke bowl. It's fresh and a bunch of food and a mix of beautiful flavors. Other people I come here with like the lobster burrito and they love it but it looks kinda messy to me (sauce on the outside of the tortilla). They have recently done up the bar area and it looks cool. The service is also top notch and friendly. read more

See all

I have only gotten Slapfish to-go, so this review is based solely on the food. I have tried both the Grinder and the Lobster Roll and both are equally tasty. While no place can beat the generosity that Maine shows with their rolls, Slapfish does provide a fair amount of filling to bun ratio. It is on a nicely toasted butter brioche bun that holds together nicely and isn't too rich. Sides are your pick and I have gotten both the side salad and slaw. Both were a generous amount and I liked having the refreshing veggies with such a rich sandwich. I hope to be able to dine in the next time I'm craving something from Slapfish. read more

Slapfish - Traditional Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Super friendly staff and food came out quickly. The presentation was gorgeous and so delicious. Love having this option in Indiana. Recommend to all my seafood lovers! read more

Slapfish - Clobster Grilled Cheese - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Four of us came for lunch after a show. The place is counter service but we were greeted by a hostess with menus and sat down to review. They also have a button at your table and someone will come if you have questions. We went to the counter and placed orders and food and drinks arrived quickly. We ordered Lobster tots and Lobster stuffed deviled eggs. Both were good but I wish the eggs were warm, they were served cold. I ordered fish and chips as well as a friend but I asked for mine blackened. It had a strong fishy flavor but the fried did not. The fries and slaw that came with it were both good. The slaw was unique with pickled onions and shaved carrots and radishes. The tacos were a hit as well as the fish sandwich. They recently remodeled the inside with ship lap and the decor fit the theme. Next time I'm ordering the Lobster roll, I really wanted to order it but recently had dental surgery and stuck to soft foods. read more

See all