We are regular customers. Food will never let you down. Everytime we call in a order, it's done before we get there. I'm 52, and have been going there with my father since the 70s. Catfish sandwiches rivals any in town read more

I haven't had a lobster roll since Caplingers closed the location north of Zionsville. I wanted a lobster roll today so I drove over to the east side. This location is 1/4 or smaller the size the one was up north. It really could use a facelift and a deep cleaning of the floors and walls. They were busy since I arrived toward the end of lunch time. Sorry to say staff not overly welcoming or friendly. I ordered and waited. The Pepsi machine was out of co2 so I opted for tea. I was happy they had sweet and non sweet tea available. Got my Lobster Roll, it looked nothing like what I've got in the past. Much much more filler than lobster. Tasted like a mass produced lobster salad. Fries were ok, not waffle fries but crinkle cut chips. Over all just kinda disappointed. Just didn't have the same flavor I came to expect from Caplingers and a 30$ meal. read more

See all

All the food is bursting with flavor. I love fried okra. The only comment is I like the coating on the outside a little thicker. I dunked my okra in the Chipotle aoli sauce and that was a treat. The greens are seasoned perfectly made with turkey which always gets a high score from me! The salmon came with a sauce of my choice but but the salmon was seasoned and cooked so good it would be disrespectful to put anything on it! The salmon was a little more fishy than I usually notice with store bought or other restaurants but maybe it's because it's so fresh? I pre-ordered and paid online so it would be ready when I got there which is convenient. It took about 5 mins after I got there to receive but since it's prepared fresh and orders are first come first serve you can't really make a specific time;however it's still faster than placing order when you arrive. There are small tables on the ordering side and several larger tables on the other side of the counter but still not alot of space...FYI if you have a large group. You can buy fresh fish at this location along with some dips and assorted "fish accessories" like sauces and cornmeal ect... The young man serving behind the counter was very attentive and helpful kept everything running smoothly. The price is pretty good too especially for fresh hot quality seafood. read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Lemon pepper Salmon, fried okra, greens with turkey meat, Chipotle aoli sauce - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Had a late lunch at Caplinger's. I had the fried lake perch and my wife jhad the coconut shrimp. Bith were excellent. We couldn't believe how quickly it came out. We had to wait to eat because it was too hot. Will definitely come back again. read more

Today I felt like a treat, so I ordered the lobster roll and a side of hush puppies! Yum YUm and YUM! Everything about how they season the lobster roll appeals to me. The hush puppies are cooked just right for me.-crunchy outside & filled with delicious are a pleasant change from french fries or onion rings. Service was quick! I arrived before their evening rush that begins about 5:30 pm on weekdays. The ambiance is pleasant and friendly with an efficient "take out" vibe. Although, there are 5 tables in a separate section along with tables in the ordering area. It is also a fish market and sells seafood items in their refrigerated cases. read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Lobster Roll Sandwich, Hushpuppies and Pepsi - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I enjoyed the flavors of the breaded shrimp dinner. I had the hush puppies and baked beans for sides and both were really tasty. For sauces I tried the pina colada dipping sauce and was surprised how delicious it was. Paired well with shrimp. My only complaint is the cocktail sauce. It's in a prepackaged dipping cup and was so thick it wouldn't even stick to the shrimp. I'd expected homemade sauce from a place that emphasizes freshness. But won't keep me away! read more

Caplinger's is both a fish market and a restaurant. For the restaurant, you order at the counter and they bring your food to the table. It is a very casual dining experience. We ordered the Caplinger Dinner. The menu indicates it's their number one seller. The dinner is served with two pieces of Basa fish, two sides, two hush puppies and tartar sauce. The cost is $18.89. The dinner was enough for us to split. It came with two large pieces of fried fish. For sides we got the fried okra and waffle fries. Both were very good. We really like the tartar sauce. It is very different than normal tartar sauce. It has a very creamy and smooth texture. More on a sweeter side. The dinners are a little pricey. However, as mentioned above, one dinner is enough for two individuals to split. We really like Caplinger's and will return. read more

See all

I carried out from Caplinger's Fresh Catch last night. Being land locked in Indiana, it's hard to find fresh fish. Caplinger's is the exception. In addition to having a full menu of seafood, they also offer a well stocked inventory of fish in their market. I got the Fish N' Chips - 5 pieces of haddock filets battered and fried served with fries, 2 hush puppies and a side ( I chose red beans and rice). The meal satisfied my fish craving. All of the staff in the restaurant were friendly and helpful. We'll be back soon. read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Fish N' Chips, fries and hush puppies - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We got there at a not so busy time. Staff gave us plenty of time to review the menu. I picked out the grouper dinner with fried okra and waffle chips. Service was very friendly and great as we ordered at the counter. In about 10 minutes we dinner was served to my wife and I. The grouper I was tasting was awesome! So flaky and lightly buttered. The tartar sauce was also good which I used lightly on each piece. Just FYI malt vinegar packets are also available along with ketchup packets. Highly recommend this place for some of the best fish in town. One of the best things about this location is that it has plenty of seating and I would also recommend eating it there while it's fresh. read more

See all

We love Caplinger's!! Food is amazing and always consistent. The hush puppies? So good.

You go up to the counter order your food and pay - so everything is cooked to order and fresh, went with the 1lb order of fried oysters and they were big seasoned very well almost like they add a hot sauce to the batter it had a lil bit of a kick but nothing crazy it was just there and i really enjoyed it. In the past i have ordered the fried fish sandwich, fish and chips, and alligator bites (a few years ago when they first opened I didn't look to check if they still had) and have been pleased with everything. There isnt servers here you order and pay at the counter and grab your food when it is called ,, the staff working and taking your orders both at the restaurant/food side as well as the fresh uncooked seafood side are super friendly and attentive. The variety of fresh seafood in the cases looked very good and clean will definitely be back to try other things on the menu read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Fried Oysters - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

After a morning of craft/hobby browsing at Lawrence Central High School, I had worked up a little appetite. I didn't want to go anywhere that would take too long, but my options between Lawrence Central and my house were kind of slim. Suddenly, I was driving up Shadeland Ave and I remembered Caplinger's Fresh Catch. My mind told me I'd be having a fried grouper sandwich. However, once my tastebuds sampled the smoked tuna salad, plans changed. I know it might not sound good, but I'm thinking a tub of it with some buttery crackers would be an excellent way to start your Thanksgiving FEASTivities! I still WILL have that fried grouper sandwich. Some day. #Getlostindiana read more

See all

Caplinger's is forever that girl! If you're looking for fresh, yummy, well seasond seafood - Caplinger's is the place to be! Tucked on Indy's northeast side, it's perfectly positioned for visitors to the local hospital or Castleton Square mall. The foodnis perfectly prepared and always SO good. Even the sides make themselves lnown as stars of the show. I appreciate the generous portions and that food is served HOT. Caplinger's is a must try! read more

Good: We were greeted with friendly staff and felt welcomed. The menu is easy to navigate and the staff at the front offered help if we needed it. Bad: I ordered a crab cake dinner. With 2 sides. I was given catfish with 2 sides. I told the young lady I ordered crabcakes. She goes oh you wanted a crabcake that's a different price you'll have to come pay the difference. I feel like I was treated like I changed my mind and wanted something different and I didn't. Maybe she misheard what I said when I ordered. When I went to the front to pay the difference the man asked me if I didn't hear her when she repeated the order to me. The order was never repeated. Eventually, the man at the front did not make me pay the difference which was nice, but my experience was already ruined. Food: The crab cakes were okay. I didn't expect them to come with 3. So it was a very nice serving. I did not like the Mac and cheese or the red beans and rice. My husband had a side of fried okra! So good! 10/10. Well seasoned! Delicious! Ambiance: it was extremely hot on the side of the restaurant where you place your order. We went and sat on the opposite side of the restaurant and it was so much better. read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Crab cakes, Mac and cheese, red beans rice - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food, service, and atmosphere is authentic and welcoming. Food is always fresh a little pricey especially in this economy but if you not broke like me go for it! Customer service needs work but usually the cooks and the men are nice to me. So I don't write them off. read more

The last time I had, this, I went to the one on Shadeland it was horrible and I hate to say that because I always loved this particular location their sides have never been great. I just wish they would have regular french fries sometimes these waffle fires everybody don't like, but yeah, my fish was not good. it wasn't very good at all. read more

Friendly knowledgeable staff, swift service, quiet atmosphere yet well lit and open, tho dining area is small and may not serve well for a large party, is a great place to dine in and have a working lunch or call ahead to carry out! The food was so hot, I had so sit on my hand before digging in and it was well worth the wait! read more

See all

Your service on Shadeland Ave "SUCKS". I placed my order online for pickup at 7:05 and I had to wait 25 minutes. Total confusion amongst the workers in regards to service. It seems like no one has enough experience to handle the amount of customers, eating in, take-out and door dash. I paid $30.00 for a mediocre meal. It will be a long time before I return to this location. You need to send in the "Undercover Boss", definitely room for lots of improvement. Front staff lack professionalism and have no regard for customer service. read more

Incredible seafood! The oyster po boy, crab cakes, and clam chowder were all perfect fresh, flavorful, and perfectly served. Amazing market and top notch service!" read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I really can't believe I just made my way to Caplingers. I pass by there a million times and just never stopped. A coupon came in the mail and to be honest that is what prompted my visit. Upon pulling up, the parking lot is busy but I was able to find a spot right in front which is good. I went on a Friday around 3:30 and it was busy, seemed like people were coming out with to go orders. When I went inside, I had no idea there is actually seating inside. I don't know why I thought it was just to go orders. When you walk in there is a cabinet of fresh fish that you can buy, or you can have it prepared for you. I ordered a Grouper Sandwich, and a side of fries. Fries do NOT come with the sandwich so just beware of that. You order and then they will bring the food to your table when it is ready should you decide to dine in. The food was really good, I mean really good. It tasted very fresh and not greasy like some fish places. It was clean inside and the staff were very nice. Now that I know I can go and get seafood and not just any seafood but good seafood I'll be back for sure. Oh and pricing is reasonable, the Grouper sandwich I think was about $16. read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best Fish Market and well cooked to order!!! Business was busy YET, order takers were timely and pleasant!!! Small interior, tables to sit at while waiting!! read more

The food was really good, we ordered the catfish and the grouper. The catfish was perfect. The fried okra was perfect. The hush puppies were good, though I could handle a few more onions and jalapeños in them. The macaroni was just ok. We ordered oysters on the half shell, but these were way too large to eat in this manner. They had a good flavor, and they would be delicious fried or some other way, but not really for the style that we were thinking. read more

See all

Amazing!!! I had the Caplinger special and it was so good!!! I want to go again!!!! We sat down to eat our food and it was so good!!!

We usually stop at the Pendleton Pike location where we take away our order...hot and delicious every time

Had an amazing dinner experience today and want to shout it out to everyone! We knew this place gets busy so we arrived a little early (5:15pm) and there was already a bit of a line. We waited and were so happy because it was worth the wait. Fresh seafood, has grilled salmon and grilled Tilapia. You get two sides plus hush puppies. We got the Mac and Cheese, baked beans and corn bread. Everything was absolutely delicious and fresh The service was very kind. The space is tight , so a lot of people take it to go, but we ate in and were lucky to get comfortable seats. As a side note, I think if you're going to order to go, it seems like ordering in advance is a good idea based on my observation. We were here a few years ago and the wait was overwhelming but decided to give them a try again and so happy we did. We will definitely return again and again Thanks so much! read more

Caplinger's is now renowned for fresh seafood and a great selection every day. Central Indiana is gaining more seafood options and you can be assured that Caplinger's has the kind of turnaround on their fish that it will be first class. Be forewarned that there are several items on the menu that can get pricey, i.e. the fried grouper but it's worth it. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. After ordering at the counter, be prepared for a bit of a wait even if they don't look that busy. read more

Everytime we go the fish is hot and delicious! The people are friendly and usually there is plenty of parking. read more

Bought sea scallops for a special occasion, and the quality exceeded expectations. Thank you!

The catfish nugget dinner was great; the nuggets were fresh and well-seasoned. My wife enjoyed her crab cake sandwich too. We also had red beans and rice, Mac and cheese, and hushpuppies. The rice and mac were both a little under seasoned and the hushpuppies weren't very fresh but we would get those pups again, no doubt-- they had great texture and flavor. read more

Fresh seafood, with more different types of fish than you'd expect. I ordered a haddock sandwich, that came with 3 pieces of fish, which didn't fit on the bun. So much fish, that I gave up on eating the bun and just ate the haddock. Great fried okra as a side, love that stuff. Wealth took home a tub of smoked tuna salad, which was also amazing. read more

The fish sandwich is my go to here. Always hot and delicious. The staff there is very patient and helpful.

Food hands down the best fried fish and best coconut shrimp I have had ever! It's so fresh and so tasteful!! Made my hubby drive over an hour twice to eat here. The restaurant is small but they keep it pretty clean. Service was amazing, Phil, the chef, came out to greet us and made sure everything was to perfection! Highly recommend! read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Grouper Dinner - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

SO good, everything! I think this is the first time having it for me. Where have you been hiding haha Hush puppies are good, crab is good, Mac and cheese, green beans, fish & shrimp. Next time I'm gonna have to get the gator bites and frog legs. Try the lobster and clam strips too. Unfortunately they were out of corn & yams yet they had corn BREAD We ordered online so can't say how the service was, but like I said I will defo order again read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Soft Shell Crab - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Order before you sit down and they bring it to you. Quiet inside as most people we noticed ordered to go. We ordered fried jumbo shrimp, clams & fried cod with fried orca and mac n cheese. Overall pretty good...but Not our favorite. You should definitely check them out though...you never know until you try it! read more

This is a great place that I have visited many times, really any chance or excuse I have to be on the NE corner of Indy! Last night was the IHSAA Sectional Football game at LNHS vs Cathedral. My Walleye Dinner was as good as always, both the fresh & flaky fish as well as the corn bread & beans & rice sides. Was in & out in 15mins and took it to go to make the game. You can order ahead but I am never that organized. And there were no lines given it was 6:15 on a Friday night. But there is normally a line, especially at lunch time, so plan accordingly! read more

It I'd difficult to find excellent fish in Indiana. But when you ear here, you swear you are eating at a fine restaurant on the Coast. The Walleye is cooked to order and seasoned perfectly. It absolutely melts in your mouth. This is the best seafood I have eaten anywhere in the Mid-West. The staff are the best. Every detail is important You really feel like a welcomed guest!! read more

Haven't been back for a long long time. The price increased around 1-2 dollars. The portion for sides seems to be decreased. Quality and taste still as good. Will always be back for seafood dishes read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Cod Fillet Dinner - Lemon & Pepper Crab Cake - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We had not been in since change of management at this location.All went really well! Our visit started with Yulinia, whom was very helpful and quick at the register! When our grouper meals ( 2 for 1 thru VIP Club)..were ready,Charles kindly brought them to our table! It was quite quick-( just a short wait) so their cook sure has hustle! The grouper was done to perfection- so soft and tender! Very flavorful with the garlic/ parm topping! The sides were all nice and warm and ready to consume! There were plenty of places to wait for your order and to sit & eat with good conversation too They have a great team - ready to serve you WELLl at this Shadeland & 75th location!!! Thanks! read more

Very good food! Great selection! You get ALOT of food for the money! They also have cases of both fresh fish/seafood and frozen fish/seafood! They even have crawfish and alligator!! read more

Good, quality food but a bit pricey. The seafood is fresh, which is a feat for a landlocked area. Went a couple times and the cooked food was good. Definitely want to buy some fresh seafood but the prices are a bit steep for me. I lived by the ocean so these prices are more than I'm used to. But for the quality and freshness it's alright. read more

Caplinger's Fresh Catch - Yummy banana pudding - Seafood Markets Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all