My friend invited me out so she chose. Never had been so figured I should go. Very busy place and glad we got our name in before some guy took over...he was very disoriented and had no idea what was going on. Gladly when it was our turn the young lady that took my name down remembered because he was totally calling out a whole different name, could have been missed had she not been up there or if I wasn't paying attention. Got seated. Our server was very nice and helpful since it was my first time. Chloe did an excellent job by explaining how the boil works and flavoring etc. we ordered lemon drop martinis. Unfortunately they missed the mark. They definitely were not prepared properly which is fine but I guess it's my fault considering it's not known for their drinks. No hard feelings I drank mine. I ordered hush puppies to start...definitely need some more of these! Flavorful and the sauces it came with were delicious. I ended to dipping mine in my boil bag and let me just say that was AMAZING. I ordered the scallops and shrimp and added the boiled eggs for an extra charge of $2.95. Very delicious very tasty and the garlic lemon Cajun mild was a great choice. Everything was cooked exactly right and the seasoning was on point it wasn't overly salty or spicy and yet wasn't even an ounce of bland. I of course took my half home and glad she wrapped it up good so nothing leaked out. Needless to say the bag boil was very good and definitely would go back. As far as ambiance goes it was very busy and lots of people enjoying their food. Lighting was a bit soft but it wasn't bad. (Pics aren't loading, I'll add when internet isn't acting up) read more

See all

Service was absolutely horrible. The only time we saw the server was when she took our order and dropped off our food over an hour later. The crab cakes were still cold, the crab was unbelievably dry and cold when we got it, the broccoli and cauliflower was still hard. You would think when you spend over $200 you would get good service and good food. read more

This seafood was possibly some of the best I've ever had. we as a group had red bomb. it had some of the best sauce I've ever tasted. I was basically licking my plate. That is how good it was. I definitely will be back at some point. read more

Never been before. The ambience is nice, staff is friendly. All the food i got was really good. Despite how busy they were, we got our food pretty quick read more

See all

My grandkids love this place. The food is wood and we have not had any issues with food or service X 3 visits.

My favorite place to go ever! Amazing quality, clean atmosphere, and friendly staff. Our favorite waiter, Jacob, is the absolute best! And ofc the food is the best. 10/10 read more

See all

If I could give it more than js yes I would they are sooo nice and the food is amazing and the service is great

This place is incredible -- truly amazing food! The seafood is outstanding, and every flavor is spot-on. We loved everything. But... you've got to fix the ranch. The ranch is key! The kids need it for their tenders, and honestly, you need it for the wings too. A good ranch just brings everything together. And one more thing: you need a biscuit, roll, or even a hush puppy to soak up all those amazing juices in the bags. That would take the experience to a whole new level. There's nothing negative here -- the food is phenomenal -- but these small fixes would make an astronomical difference. read more

My dad actually picked this place since he came into town. I had no idea about it since I lived closer to downtown. The seafood was surprisingly delicious. I'm from Virginia so I'm a little picky about the seafood I eat however the muscles, the crawfish, the crab, the potato everything was seasoned well it was fresh. It was delicious. I have no complaints. I will definitely be back. They have weekly specials. The drink I had was called the something tiger. I don't remember the full name and then I also had a few tequila sunrises, and between just the superior weight staff and just the general vibe and ambience of the restaurant I'll definitely be back whether it be with my dad again or just by myself. I'm glad to have discovered this little Jim outside of downtown. read more

See all

DO NOT EAT HERE This was one of the most UNPROFESSIONAL and RIDICULOUS experiences I've ever had at a restaurant. We are REGULAR customers who come here 1-2 times a MONTH. We spend a good amount of money here. We ordered our food NO SPICE -- very clearly. The food came out SPICY anyway. When we explained the issue, instead of remaking it properly, we were told they could just wash the seafood off and put no spice on it. That does NOT work, and they know it. Once the seasoning is in, it's in. We've had this happen before. We refused to accept food we couldn't eat, and instead of handling it like adults or managers, staff THREATENED to call the police on us. Over a WRONG order. Let that sink in. We weren't yelling, we weren't scamming, and we weren't asking for free food. We simply didn't want to eat food that could cause STOMACH issues because the kitchen messed up. Threatening customers with COPS over a mistake YOU made is insane behavior. This place is NOT cheap, and customers deserve RESPECT -- especially loyal ones. If this is how you treat people when something goes wrong, don't be surprised when business drops. Completely unacceptable. We will NOT be returning. read more

Server was in attentive. Couldn't wait to take our order and go back to her booth and get on her phone. My wife and I ordered two salads and a dozen oysters to share. I ordered Thousand Island dressing and she brought Italian. My wife opened one of the containers of dressing and put her finger in it to see what it was. When I told her server I ordered Thousand Island she informed me they didn't have that. I asked what do you have and rattled off 4 kinds. My wife said do you have honey mustard and she said yes!! Then she took the two containers of Italian and i assume returned them to the kitchen. Salads were very wilty, leafy, and barely edible. Oysters were so so and didn't taste fresh. Other than that it was great. We will not go back. read more

Day #3 Indianapolis Addition I'm not sure where to begin with this review. The Juicy Seafood is a seafood spot with several locations around the Indianapolis area and came recommended by a local. Their aim is to provide fresh seafood free of additives to preserve its original flavor and taste. This was a hit or miss. Since we had a long day of competition judge and facilitating which brought us to this fine city, we decided to place our order online for pickup. The online ordering was pretty easy and straight forward, except for the fact that you CANNOT pay online! So you order gets placed to the restaurant and you pay when you get there. Naturally, we waited 20 minutes before heading over so that we would arrive close to the time the seafood should have been ready. When we arrived, the staff for very kind and polite. Unfortunately, our order was not ready. As a matter of fact, they hadn't even BEGUN to prepare it! Although you can order online, they do not prepare your order until you have arrived at the restaurant and paid for your order. WHAT'S THE POINT!! This was super frustrating because we placed our order at 7:11pm, but did not receive our order until 8:47pm! You might as well order at the restaurant, since AHEAD has somewhat of a different meaning. Moving on to the food. My Chef de Cuisine order Onion Rings and his favorite Clam Chowder. Well, the Clam Chowder was too thin and quit bland. Almost as if water was added to the batch to stretch out one order on a pot that was almost gone. The Onion Rings were crunchy and pretty good, but Cold! Now that's a feat within itself. Typically, if something Battered and fried is cold, it becomes soggy. So, that's something. Your Seafood Executive Chef had the Mr. Caption! 1/2lb Shrimp, 1 Snow Crab cluster, 1/2 lb of sausage, 2 potatos, 2 Eggs, and 1 Corn in the Juicy Sauce which is a combination of their 4 choices of sauce, and medium heat. I am very happy to say, it was really good! The sauce had just the right amount of heat. The sausage was really food and the crablegs were sweet! The shrimp was slightly overcooked, but other than that, a win! Needless to say, You'll save yourself some time, by just going to the restaurant and placing your order. Stick to the basics. Seafood boils! Check It Out? read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Onion Rings - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Took my son on his birthday, waitress was good attentive took our order and had our drinks out quickly and our appetizer's . Was fairly busy was and they was cleaning up and bringing them as quick as they was moving out food is good and lil better than expected as fast as they was moving gm read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Food is amazing , servers all 3 times have been nice and gave us drinks when needed. The food is always amazing , I get a variation of combos but I always use the juicy special sauce in medium heat. Delish! The restraint itself is clean and easy to spot when driving to it. read more

See all

Service was really fast and professional. Good portion sizes. Food was delicious. No complaint.

Gotta luv the sauce! Juicy seafood brings the food and flavor!! Lobsters, shrimp, sausage, corn and boiled eggs!! Sweeeeet tea! Great fun and good food! read more

Food is a little pricey but we took 14 people last night for a special occasion. Our waiter, Timothy, was exceptional. Never an empty glass and was very accommodating. Even helped us take a family photo before we left. If you go, request Timothy, you won't be disappointed..... read more

So! This location has gone through some turnover, despite a central location on a busy intersection. First thing I noticed: wow, they really cleaned the place up and made it shiny and appealing! On entering, it's decorated nautical-kitsch, which is kind of fun. Our server was trading bartending duties with her coworker -- with the clean new ambience, I wasn't expecting her to be wearing shredded jeans, but it didn't bug me. She was FAST and efficient, and very pleasant. Looked at the menu: surprise! This is a Cajun-style crawfish boil place. This means: 1) you choose what critters you want boiled, 2) you choose what sauces/spices/spice level you want, and 3) your order arrives in a tin pan covered in a garbage bag, which the server shakes vigorously, then opens the bag to let you at the noms. Bibs, gloves, kitchen shears (instead of crab crackers) and wet wipes are provided, and *you will need them*. (Get a drink with a straw -- better yet, bring your own reusable straw. Drinks are standard bar fare -- nothing fancy.) Hubby and I ordered a special for two: it included two lobster tails, two bunches of crab legs, and a pile o' black mussels. We chose garlic butter, as I didn't want to bury the flavor of the lobster. Paid $69 for this -- flavor was drowned anyways, as there was SOME spice in there. And GIANT PILES OF SALT. I love salt. I crave salty foods. THIS WAS TOO SALTY FOR ME. (Those with high blood pressure: do not eat here.) Was it worth the cost? Nope. Was it tasty? Yep. They serve flash-frozen/thawed raw oysters, which apparently have appealed to some guests (I wasn't brave enough to try, being from the seashore, myself). read more

See all

i did not like the way the girl with the blonde hair treated the young lady she was training she was very rude and nasty with her the young lady that was being trained was very respectful polite and treated me very well and got my order correct and the blonde hair girl came up front and was being very disrespectful for no reason they need new management and new trainers because its not a reason why the new trainers dont get her tip and for it to get snatched from her after i paid her a tip personally is not right the new traine taqiyyah was so pleasant and nice even when the manager and the trainer where being disrespectful please give her a big thumbs up she went above and beyond i wouldn't even know that she was new she handle my order so well TAQIYYAH I LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU MORE YOU MADE OUR EXPERIENCE REALLY NICE AND YOUR CUSTOMER SERVICE AND COMMUNICATION AND ACKNOWLEDGING ALL OUT NEEDS NEEDS AN REWARD MY HUSBAND RICHARD SAID YOU ROCK AS WELL read more

1. Girlfriend ordered Snow crab and sausage with garlic seasoning no spice, came as Cajun Spicy with extra things she did not order, (server did not write anything down and we had a 4 person table) wouldn't have been a problem but server said she could take it back if girlfriend removed crab legs she had touched. Said if she kept the meal we would have to pay for it and we said we would not pay for their mistake. Server then said if we did not pay then it would come out of her pay. Called manager over. Manager had gf remove extra items we did not want and offered to take meal back. (Manager said that they would just give it to the kitchen staff, mind you my girlfriend had now touched everything with bare hands removing extra stuff) We sent the whole thing back, manager did not ask for the correct order and came back with another wrong order. Dealt with the second wrong order. 2. Forgot to bring out a side of Coleslaw 3. Catfish was very bland and mushy 4. I would be more understanding of getting the order wrong if the place was absolutely packed. But we were 1 of maybe 5 tables. I get everyone makes mistakes and it happens but to make a mistake and then be rude/ argumentative to customers is not a good experience for either party. read more

Atmosphere is fun. You cannot tell that used to be Ponderosa. The service was OK but it was only her 2nf shift of her own. The displays and fanfare around getting your meal was very cool. The apps were so so. The clam chowder wasn't good. The crab cake had veggies in it. I wasn't a big fan of those but my husband liked it. We got corn and potatoes in the bag. Oh my goodness that was so good! Next time we will do that instead of getting a bunch of appetizers. You definitely want to do the thing they are known for. Just skip the appetizers there's plenty of food in those bags. I didn't want to mess with peeling my shrimp. But friend said it wasn't that bad. I don't mind working for crab legs but that wasn't what I was wanting that day. The margaritas are on special one night a week. They were delicious! read more

See all

I've tried the location in Castleton and it was good. This place was just as great and half the drive distance as well. The food was ordered for carryout and it was on time and delicious lots of shrimp and crayfish also crab and lobster. Got the all juicy all the above option with extra sauce. Also ordered some hush puppies everything was hot fresh and juicy as described I will definitely be back again. I prefer to take it home To go so I can relax and enjoy and not worry about having the tools to open or if they are which is always being able to flag down staff lol. If so I'd eat in but I'm happy to eat at home since the food is done so fresh and packed so well it is literally like it came to your table as well. So kudos to the amazing service at the counter and friendly staff. For creating such a great experience. read more

See all

We always have a good time at juicy! The staff is friendly and the food is amazing. I love the Cajun garlic butter! The restaurant has been clean upon every visit! I will definitely be back. read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Me and my hubs love this place Always a good experience I highly recommend trying it you can't go wrong read more

Having a seafood boil for the first time, I was skeptical going in but WOW I was amazed. Food was amazing, service good and all around a good experience. Food is a little more on the pricey side but I say it's worth it. read more

Great and friendly service. Got seated right away on New Year's Day at the height of dinner time. Food was great. We got the hush puppies. They seemed homemade and piping hot. My husband got a lobster tail, crab legs and shrimp combo. The lobster tail was pretty decent size and was cooked to perfection. I got the crab legs and shrimp combo and had more than enough food. Everything tasted delicious and we will be back. read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Crab legs, shrimp, potatoes and corn. - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Fantastic food and service every time. Everything is delicious ! I am obsessed with the crab and shrimp combo with the juicy special med or hot ! read more

We've had Juicy a few times, but this was the first time we dined in and it was a great experience. My party of 4 was seated within just a few minutes of arriving. Our waitress Courtney stopped by pretty promptly to let us know she'd be right with us. Sometimes you get seated-your waitress takes a while, but she was prompt. We we're going to order take out, so we already knew what we wanted to order when our waitress came back to us. We gave her our order at about 7:07p and our food was out by like 7:22p!!! 15 minutes is amazing! Typically I'm leary when food comes out too fast. When that happens either the food is undercooked or the order is wrong-we did NOT have either issue. Everything hot and fresh-seasoned and delicious! We were all full by the end and satisfied. I love the vibe. It wasn't chaotic. It was calm and chill. Typically that happens when it not busy- but they were busy and on it. I'd come back and dine in. Kudos. read more

I've ordered from them around three times for takeout. I'm always left feeling that the seafood is just below average freshness. I always go for the green mussels, shrimp, with heads on, and snow crab legs in the juicy seafood sauce mix. Flavor wise they have nailed it, but without super fresh seafood, it can only be average. read more

Crab shells that actually crack!? Amazaballs! Service was spot-on! And ambiance was relaxed and not ruahed.

Tried Juicy Seafood for the first time tonight. I wasn't that hungry, so my husband and I split a meal. We got the red bomb special with crawfish added. The food was really good. The crab legs were very big and full of crab meat unlike some other places. The lobster tail had tons of meat too. The reason I am giving only 4 stars is because I had to ask three times for a crab leg cracker. I was told they're "hard to come by" at first and was only given the little plastic tool. I asked how I was supposed to crack the hard crab claws and she just said "I don't know." Finally after asking two more times she was able to rustle up one from somewhere. For $45/person and with it being a seafood place, you'd think they'd have more crab leg crackers available. read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Crawfish - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I wanted to try Juicy Seafood because I was craving a seafood boil & I was not disappointed! I got the build your own seafood combo because you can do 1/2lbs of a few items to get a little bit of everything for a good price & you also get a couple potatoes and piece of corn. Today I got black mussels, shrimp, and a snow crab cluster with Cajun & garlic butter seasoning. It was delicious and very filling! They gave me a scissor multitool, gloves, a wet napkin, a bib, and a bucket for all the shells/garbage which all came in handy (the bib was much needed despite how ridiculous I felt putting it on at first lol). The restaurant is casual and pretty big. They have a lot of tables/booths specifically for large groups. We got seated quickly around 7pm and by the time we left at 8, it was pretty packed. Service was quick as well. They're located at the intersection of Emerson & E Thompson Rd so it was easy to find and they have a parking lot around the restaurant read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Seafood combo: black mussels, shrimp, snow crab cluster - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We had ordered drinks, one Long Island Ice Tea and a Bloody Mary. They were top notch drinks from the bar, good enough to order round two. As an appetizer we went with the hush puppies and they were good. We both had ordered the Red Bomb which has a lobster tail, a cluster of snow crab legs, shrimp, potatoes and corn. We both had the butter garlic flavor and med spice.When you come here and you want the best customer service, ask for Yue. She is also a bartender our drinks were (once again) top notch and out of this world. The food was absolutely amazing, I could sit here all day and eat. You want a different experience in seafood, come to Juicy. read more

See all

AWESOME food, great atmosphere, excellent service and price. I will be back! We DESTROYED the boil lol. read more

Juicy Seafood - Beech Grove - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We visited here the other evening for a group birthday dinner. We had a reservation so we were seated right away by a kind host. Our server was awesome-super friendly and responsive. I ordered some appetizers for the table including fried calamari and hush puppies. The apps were served super fast and were tasty. For my entree I ordered the 2 clusters of snow crabs which came with a side of small corn cob and roasted potatoes. Since the meal is messy you do get a bib, gloves, scissors and hand wipes. The crab was delicious and it was a very filling portion. Overall we had a great dinner and the service was excellent. read more

I've had juicy seafood for takeout before but never dined in! I avoided dining in because the building use to be Ponderosa (aka Pondegrossa) but they put in major work to make this building over. The outside of the building doesn't have much personality but the inside is packed with sea decor. My husband made a reservation for our party of 8 and we were seated right away. Our server, Brooke, was with us right away and killed it getting drinks and appetizers to us quickly. I ordered the two crab legs that come with potato and corn piece. I got it in the garlic butter sauce and no spice. The food is very filling and tasty. They give you bibs, gloves, wet napkins, paper towel, scissors and forks. It's seafood so it's a bit higher in price but so worth it to me. Messy but soooooo delicious. I had a great experience with my family and was surprisingly happy it wasn't too busy for a Friday- we made our reservation for 6pm. I would recommend coming here for sure! read more

See all

Good Food, good service shrimp is fantastic, crab legs and lobster tails delicious. This is my Wife and I special occasion place. They have never let us down. read more

Very delicious Good chef Service 10 star Ambiance wonderful Told the manager very delicious food read more

It's not the management it's the store owner that is unfair to workers. Will fire most men out of spite because "a host job is a woman's job." They reuse seafood and tell you, you're not supposed to leave them bad reviews for up to two months. Also they do not do you taxes correctly, checks consistently messed up. Waitresses and cooks are amazing and always willing to help. But prices are unfair for what you get. And a great example an order sat out all night and was more than likely reused the next morning. read more

Food was good and not over the top expensive. Would definitely return. Be careful of the Cajun fries because they were a bit too spicy for me. read more